Cross Genre Nominations #7

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Omega Vision
Here are the rules:

(1) All nominations must be between one character primarily identified as a comic book character and a character of another medium outside of comics.

(2) No spite nominations.

(3) In order to receive official consideration once the poll thread is made ANOTHER person must communicate their support for the nomination other than the person who proposed it.

(4) Try not to spam nominations, consider them carefully and then post them in this thread.

(5) Explain the scenario and why you think the matchup would be a good one and provide documentation for the character(s) proposed so that others can understand what they're dealing with.

(6) When nodding state which would win in your opinion.

Characters off limits:
Kain (until 8th thread)
Spider-Man (until 8th thread)

Trackz
Samus vs. X-force (Wolverine, Archangel, Deadpool, Psylocke, and Fantomex)

X-force are skilled and hunters in their own fashion, against Samus's power output.

Afro Samurai vs. Elektra or Wolverine
Afro is one of anime's best warriors (in my opinion) against either elektra or wolverine who both have comparable skill.

byrdgang21
Originally posted by byrdgang21
Deadpool vs Raiden(MGS4)

Blade vs Vamp(MGS4)

Moondragon vs Starkiller the Apprentice(SW Force Unleashed)

Apocalypse vs Mumm-Ra The Ever Living

Hercules vs Beowulf

Wolverine & black panther vs Lion-0 & Panthro (Thundercats)

Deathstroke vs Terminator(Arnold)

What do you all think?

I posted this in the last thread by mistake.

chomperx9
beast vs blanka. no electricity for blanka

punisher vs terminator




kain marco or kain from Robocop ?

Gecko4lif
I nod herc vs beowulf if there are correct stipulations

McNasty996
Dethstroke vs Albert wesker for reasons previously stated
Fight takes place in mall
Firearms are optional for either character but prefered for deathstroke

Black bolt z
Void vs. Fat buu

XanatosForever
Originally posted by chomperx9
beast vs blanka. no electricity for blanka

punisher vs terminator




kain marco or kain from Robocop ?
'
Kain from Legacy of Kain.

marwash22
why is there a 7th nomination thread when we haven't even done the 6th poll yet? Or is that coming soon?

EDIT: nvm. it was burried. didn't know it had been made.

Trackz
Not to deadpool vs raiden and blade vs. vamp

chomperx9
Originally posted by XanatosForever
'
Kain from Legacy of Kain. oh

XanatosForever
Robocop Versus Bullseye

Both participants are put at a gun range and tasked to tag every target accurately in the designated point from so far away. Who ever gets the most hits and greatest accuracy wins.

Round 1: Shotguns to the abdomen at 10 yards.

Round 2: Pistols to the heart at 20 yards.

Round 3: Automatics to the torso at 25 yards.

Round 4: Rifles to the head at 100 yards.

Round 5 (Special): Participants can use their most familiar item to tag the previous targets with different target points: head, left shoulder, right thigh, and left index fingernail.

Colossus-Big C
Kratos vs Drax the destroyer

this fight is guaranteed to be badass
i'll pay to see this

Etna
Originally posted by McNasty996
Dethstroke vs Albert wesker for reasons previously stated
Fight takes place in mall
Firearms are optional for either character but prefered for deathstroke

nod

nicamarvin
Hancock vs movie Hulk.... smokin'

jalek moye
umm thats not cross genre. make that in the movie vs

marwash22
erm

how is that not a cross genre match?

Hulk is a comic character.
Hancock is a movie character.

The Nuul
No, thats movie vs movie. It has to be Comic Hulk vs Hancock.

chomperx9
optimus prime vs mastermold

illadelph12
The Avengers Vs. He-Man & The Masters of the Universe

Black bolt z
Originally posted by Black bolt z
Void vs. Fat buu This


And I nod wesker vs. Slade.

Hellspawn28
Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
Kratos vs Drax the destroyer

this fight is guaranteed to be badass
i'll pay to see this

Which version of Drax are you talking about? Classic Drax would own Kratos in one punch.

The Scenario
Originally posted by Trackz
Samus vs. X-force (Wolverine, Archangel, Deadpool, Psylocke, and Fantomex)

X-force are skilled and hunters in their own fashion, against Samus's power output.



Sure, why not. Nodded.

As per rule 6, I'll say Samus.

chomperx9
batman vs liu kang

Trackz
Originally posted by Trackz
Not to deadpool vs raiden and blade vs. vamp oh i didn't see rule #6, raiden and torn about fight 2

Black bolt z
Fat buu vs. void?This is the last time i'll say this for this nominations thread.

psycho gundam
Originally posted by chomperx9
batman vs liu kang how bout you stop spamming the gheyest threads imaginable

chomperx9
hancock vs wonder woman

Trackz
Originally posted by Black bolt z
Fat buu vs. void?This is the last time i'll say this for this nominations thread. does void have enough feats?

chomperx9
T-1000 vs Wolverine

liquid metal vs Adamantium metal

Hellspawn28
Originally posted by Black bolt z
Fat buu vs. void?This is the last time i'll say this for this nominations thread.

What about Android 18 vs Wonder Woman?

marwash22
Originally posted by illadelph12
The Avengers Vs. He-Man & The Masters of the Universe He-Man is super haxx... he solos the entire team.

-Pr-
Originally posted by chomperx9
hancock vs wonder woman

she'd kill him.

illadelph12
Originally posted by marwash22
He-Man is super haxx... he solos the entire team.

You think He-Man could solo Thor, Ironman, Ms. Marvel, Wolverine, Spider-Man, etc?

He-Man vs Thor alone would be epic.

Lord_Talron
nod to Herc vs Beowulf



oliver warbucks (annie the musical) vs kingpin

kingpin is using his influence to pass a federal law. warbucks decides that hes going to stop that law from being passed

-warbucks influence would translate to the modern world

warbucks was a billionaire during the depression who had so much money and influence that he bought the mona lisa to only decide that he didnt like it, had favors he could call in to almost any influential person from Rockefeller to having president roosevelt pull an all-nighter with him JUST to find out if a couple who claimed annie was their kid were for real or not.


to put his money in perspective, for every billion dollars he had in 1936:

marwash22
Originally posted by illadelph12
You think He-Man could solo Thor, Ironman, Ms. Marvel, Wolverine, Spider-Man, etc?

He-Man vs Thor alone would be epic. yeah. His power is damn near limitless. the guy busted a planet with a rock... lulz. He makes PC Superman look like a chump.

Omega Vision
Originally posted by marwash22
yeah. His power is limitless. the guy busted a planet with a rock... lulz. He makes PC Superman look like a chump.
IIRC when they met in a crossover PC Superman was the clear superior.

Lord_Talron
Originally posted by Omega Vision
IIRC when they met in a crossover PC Superman was the clear superior. how does cannon work for that crossover? iirc it was cannon for the he-man universe but not for dc

marwash22
I'm not familiar with that occurrence. Fact stands, He-Man is ridiculous.

Lord_Talron
yea, but hows his durability vs adamantium or a godblast?

Omega Vision
Originally posted by marwash22
I'm not familiar with that occurrence. Fact stands, He-Man is ridiculous.
Okay, but to say he makes PC Superman look like a chump is off base.

marwash22
Originally posted by Omega Vision
Okay, but to say he makes PC Superman look like a chump is off base. point taken, Mr. Critical.

marwash22
Grimmjow Jeagerjaques, from 'Bleach' vs. Cheetah (Barb)

fight takes place in football stadium

byrdgang21
This is to help support my nominations of:

1)Raiden(MGS4) vs Deadpool

2)Vamp(MGS4) vs Blade


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R61cCBUWNQM


http://www.youtube.com/watch#!v=eW1yezdwt4w&feature=related

Hellspawn28
I nod to the Vamp vs. Blade idea.

chomperx9
Originally posted by byrdgang21
This is to help support my nominations of:

1)Raiden(MGS4) vs Deadpool

2)Vamp(MGS4) vs Blade


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R61cCBUWNQM


http://www.youtube.com/watch#!v=eW1yezdwt4w&feature=related raiden would distroy Deadpool

"Id"
Solid Snake vs Punisher or Depowered Cable

byrdgang21
Originally posted by chomperx9
raiden would distroy Deadpool

is that a nod?

marwash22
Yulaw ('The One') vs. Cap(Steve) & Batman(Bruce)

-fight takes place in the Thunderdome.
-no shield for Cap, no gadgets for Bruce.

byrdgang21
Iron Fist vs. Kenshiro (Fist of the North Star)

Wei Phoenix
Originally posted by byrdgang21
Iron Fist vs. Kenshiro (Fist of the North Star)

Sure.

jalek moye
no Kenshiro would win easily.

Etna
Iron fist vs Kenshiro? I smell spite thread

chomperx9
Originally posted by Etna
Iron fist vs Kenshiro? I smell spite thread i almost thought i was seing things when i saw the eye blink in your sig and av lol

Wei Phoenix
Originally posted by chomperx9
i almost thought i was seing things when i saw the eye blink in your sig and av lol

You are.

AthenasTrgrFngr
Originally posted by marwash22
Grimmjow Jeagerjaques, from 'Bleach' vs. Cheetah (Barb)

fight takes place in football stadium

i nod this

Mrblonde
Hajime Saito from Rurouni Kenshin vs Batman in a sword fight.

Black bolt z
Originally posted by Hellspawn28
What about Android 18 vs Wonder Woman? Wonder woman easilyOriginally posted by chomperx9
T-1000 vs Wolverine

liquid metal vs Adamantium metal I'll nod this.It really wouldn't be intresting but it would be a fight....

Black bolt z
Mr incredible vs. The thing

Omega Vision
Silver Surfer vs all active Z fighters circa Buu saga. 131

ScreamPaste
Originally posted by Omega Vision
Silver Surfer vs all active Z fighters circa Buu saga. 131 Trolltastic. I nod.

marwash22
Originally posted by Omega Vision
Silver Surfer vs all active Z fighters circa Buu saga. 131 http://i616.photobucket.com/albums/tt248/cgutta2790/qzlmhu.gif

spizite.

Black bolt z
Originally posted by Omega Vision
Silver Surfer vs all active Z fighters circa Buu saga. 131 Circa?You mean all in them.Well the only ones that matter are the super sayians.

But I think and SS3,Three SS2s,and 2 SS1s can do it

Hellspawn28
What about Younger Toguro at 100% from Yu Yu Hakusho vs. The Thing?

marwash22
Originally posted by Hellspawn28
What about Younger Toguro at 100% from Yu Yu Hakusho vs. The Thing? Toguro would rape. finger bullets, ftw.

"Id"
The Tick vs Colossus

Black bolt z
Popeye with spinach vs. Base hulk but hulk can get stronger.

Popeye has 30 cans of spinach.

No BFR

illadelph12
Popeye would win by punching Hulk and turning him into Ed Norton rocking a pair of Hulk Hands.

Ronin Warriors Vs. Fantastic Four.

marwash22
Clubber lang and Drago vs. Wildcat (Ted)

bare-knuckle boxing match, inside a UFC Octagon.

Black bolt z
Lizard(from MK)vs. The lizard

Etna
Originally posted by illadelph12

Ronin Warriors Vs. Fantastic Four.

I havn't seen ronin warriors in a very long time...but i liked it
I trust you that this isn't Spite

So I nod

Wei Phoenix
Originally posted by Etna
I havn't seen ronin warriors in a very long time...but i liked it
I trust you that this isn't Spite

So I nod

Delph isn't one to spite someone. At least intentionally.

psycho gundam
http://img27.imageshack.us/img27/9568/81082676.jpg


vs

http://img256.imageshack.us/img256/8585/31767695.jpg

marwash22
Akatsuki rapes.

psycho gundam
well, what about those two vs some other mid-meta and down duo (w/ known appearances together) from comics?

- storm and yukio

- wolverine and colossus/nightcrawler/psylocke/etc

- hawk and dove

you get the picture

marwash22
they would be a bad match for anyone who's blood can be drawn.

Omega Vision
Originally posted by Black bolt z
Circa?You mean all in them.Well the only ones that matter are the super sayians.

But I think and SS3,Three SS2s,and 2 SS1s can do it
Is that a nod?

psycho gundam
Originally posted by marwash22
they would be a bad match for anyone who's blood can be drawn. that's a little too pessimistic don't you think?

naruto, kakashi, shikamaru's blood can be drawn and well....

marwash22
huh?

Naruto... never fought Hidan
Shikamaru... tricked Hidan into thinking his blood had been acquired
Kakashi... evaded well enough not to get his blood drawn because he knew what would happen if it did occur.

Unless you wanna make one of the stipulations that whoever Hidan fights, knows about his ritual (which would be gimping on a massive scale), anyone who's blood can be had is a bad matchup. But then, most of the people who can't be cut are out of Hidan's league.

That's a tough one.

Wei Phoenix
Originally posted by marwash22
huh?

Naruto... never fought Hidan
Shikamaru... tricked Hidan into thinking his blood had been acquired
Kakashi... evaded well enough not to get his blood drawn because he knew what would happen if it did occur.

Unless you wanna make one of the stipulations that whoever Hidan fights, knows about his ritual (which would be gimping on a massive scale), anyone who's blood can be had is a bad matchup. But then, most of the people who can't be cut are out of Hidan's league.

That's a tough one.

Hulk can be cut, Magento can have his blood drawn, so can Thor.

marwash22
Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Hulk can be cut, Magento can have his blood drawn, so can Thor.

^ all are out of Hidan's league. Well, he's fast enough to get Hulk, bu the other two, he'd never get the chance.

psycho gundam
Originally posted by marwash22
huh?

Naruto... never fought Hidan
Shikamaru... tricked Hidan into thinking his blood had been acquired
Kakashi... evaded well enough not to get his blood drawn because he knew what would happen if it did occur.

Unless you wanna make one of the stipulations that whoever Hidan fights, knows about his ritual (which would be gimping on a massive scale), anyone who's blood can be had is a bad matchup. But then, most of the people who can't be cut are out of Hidan's league.

That's a tough one. that's what makes it fun....

geez, what a wet blanket


most of these cross-genra fights have been too safe anyway

Wei Phoenix
Originally posted by marwash22
^ all are out of Hidan's league. Well, he's fast enough to get Hulk, bu the other two, he'd never get the chance.

So anyone who's blood can be drawn is not necessarily a stomp in his favor?

psycho gundam
^ see, that's the x factor that makes a fight with them interesting

marwash22
Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
So anyone who's blood can be drawn is not necessarily a stomp in his favor? correct.

He first needs to draw their blood, then he has to ingest it, then he has to make a symbol on the ground and stand inside it. After that, any damage he does to himself or gets done to him, will result in that damage being done to his opponent... and since he is immortal, it's an easy win.

Magneto can be cut, but he'd never get close enough to do it.

marwash22
Someone like Grundy would be a good match because he's already dead so i don't think the ritual would work.

psycho gundam
Originally posted by marwash22
Magneto can be cut, but he'd never get close enough to do it. that's what kakuzu is for.

magneto is too high on the totem pole anyway, bad example. he'd just use the scythe and dice up the whole team

marwash22
Oh, here's an idea...

just make whoever Hidan's and Kakuzu's opponents are, the Zombie versions from "Marvel Zombies".

psycho gundam
have to ask why

Wei Phoenix
Originally posted by marwash22
Oh, here's an idea...

just make whoever Hidan's and Kakuzu's opponents are, the Zombie versions from "Marvel Zombies".

The ones who had the Power Cosmic?

marwash22
Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
The ones who had the Power Cosmic? nah, just zombie versions of the character. regular powers, but zombified.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
have to ask why Zombies are dead, so even if Hidan get's their blood, his ritual wont work.

The Scenario
What about someone like Iron Man or Samus?

psycho gundam
Originally posted by marwash22
Zombies are dead, so even if Hidan get's their blood, his ritual wont work. i know that, but what's the point of trying to negate his powers?

it's like saying cyclops vs daredevil is cheap cause dd can die from an optic blast, so it's best he only go up against opponents wearing cameron hodge's ruby quartz cover all suit.

marwash22
Originally posted by psycho gundam
i know that, but what's the point of trying to negate his powers?

it's like saying cyclops vs daredevil is cheap cause dd can die from an optic blast, so it's best he only go up against opponents wearing cameron hodge's ruby quartz cover all suit. Oh. Well, i just figure it'll eventually come down to (WHEN) Hidan gets his opponents blood. But i get your point.

Lord_Talron
ill nod the popeye vs hulk one. anyone whos actually seen classic popeye knows hes got incredible strength/speed feats (even without spinach).


id suggest a galbatorix vs classic strange or something, but ole galby lacks the feats erm

marwash22
i had no idea popeye was THAT strong.

The Scenario
Originally posted by Lord_Talron


id suggest a galbatorix vs classic strange or something, but ole galby lacks the feats erm

Then just use Murtagh or Eragon, they're basically the same.

XanatosForever
Mojo Jojo Versus M.O.D.O.K.

Which of these big brains can outdo the other?

Mojo has access to his lab and all his gadgets.

M.O.D.O.K. has his resources from A.I.M.

marwash22
Originally posted by byrdgang21
Deadpool vs Raiden(MGS4) nod.

Match-ups with nods (number of nods)

Hercules vs Beowulf (2)
Deadpool vs Raiden, from "Metal Gear" (2)
Blade vs Vamp, from "Metal Gear" (2)
Deathstroke vs Albert Wesker, from "Resident Evil" (2)
Wolverine, Archangel, Deadpool, Psylocke, and Fantomex vs Samus (1)
Grimmjow, from "Bleach" vs Cheetah Minerva (1)
T-1000 vs Wolverine (1)
Ronin Warriors vs Fantastic 4 (1)
Popeye vs Hulk (1)

Etna
who would make a good match up against the giant mecha Megas + Coop controlling it and Kiva as support

from the cartoon show Megas XLR

Omega Vision
Originally posted by Lord_Talron
ill nod the popeye vs hulk one. anyone whos actually seen classic popeye knows hes got incredible strength/speed feats (even without spinach).


id suggest a galbatorix vs classic strange or something, but ole galby lacks the feats erm
I really don't think anyone in Eragon, feats or otherwise can even come close to matching Classic Strange. The greatest spells in Eragon aren't even Herald level IIRC and Classic Strange was Trans-Skyfather.

Lord_Talron
Originally posted by The Scenario
Then just use Murtagh or Eragon, they're basically the same. no not even close. hes ridiculously more powerful, thanks to the hundreds of dragon souls hes collected, each of which boost his power greatly. its possible he could tell classic strange to simply die in the ancient language and have enough power to actually pull it off without dying himself. but theres no proof

Lord_Talron
Originally posted by Omega Vision
I really don't think anyone in Eragon, feats or otherwise can even come close to matching Classic Strange. The greatest spells in Eragon aren't even Herald level IIRC and Classic Strange was Trans-Skyfather. the spells in eragon are as powerful as the lifeforce behind them. you could destroy the entire universe by saying so in the ancient language if you had enough lifeforce to do so

XanatosForever
Originally posted by Etna
who would make a good match up against the giant mecha Megas + Coop controlling it and Kiva as support

from the cartoon show Megas XLR

Etna, you're reading my mind. laughing I was just thinking of using Megas in a CG match. wink

illadelph12
Megas XLR was dope. I wish they'd have kept it on Cartoon Network longer.

Maybe against War Machine.

Omega Vision
Originally posted by illadelph12
Megas XLR was dope. I wish they'd have kept it on Cartoon Network longer.

Maybe against War Machine.
Fin Fang Foom maybe?

Blair Wind
Originally posted by marwash22
nod.

Match-ups with nods (number of nods)

Hercules vs Beowulf (2)
Deadpool vs Raiden, from "Metal Gear" (2)
Blade vs Vamp, from "Metal Gear" (2)
Deathstroke vs Albert Wesker, from "Resident Evil" (2)
Wolverine, Archangel, Deadpool, Psylocke, and Fantomex vs Samus (1)
Grimmjow, from "Bleach" vs Cheetah Minerva (1)
T-1000 vs Wolverine (1)
Ronin Warriors vs Fantastic 4 (1)
Popeye vs Hulk (1)

Ronin Warriors vs Fantastic Four thumb up

illadelph12
I'll nod Popeye Vs. Hulk, though I think it's unfair to Hulk given Popeye's magical matter manipulation via punching.

Originally posted by marwash22
i had no idea popeye was THAT strong.

Without spinach Popeye has lifted buildings, houses, tanks, juggled cars effortlessly, and jumped up and punched the moon in the eye. With spinach he's hammer tossed sperm whales into the horizon, punched out a Martian Armada, transmuted a locomotive into pipe organ and wood burning stove, and turned a psuedo King Kong into the three Hear No Evil, See No Evil, Speak No Evil monkeys.

Popeye ain't nuthin to f*ck wit.

Lord_Talron
Originally posted by illadelph12
I'll nod Popeye Vs. Hulk, though I think it's unfair to Hulk given Popeye's magical matter manipulation via punching.



Without spinach Popeye has lifted buildings, houses, tanks, juggled cars effortlessly, and jumped up and punched the moon in the eye. With spinach he's hammer tossed sperm whales into the horizon, punched out a Martian Armada, transmuted a locomotive into pipe organ and wood burning stove, and turned a psuedo King Kong into the three Hear No Evil, See No Evil, Speak No Evil monkeys.

Popeye ain't nuthin to f*ck wit. and dont forget his insane speed too. he was able to toss stuff out a 5 story window and run to the bottom and catch it before it hit the ground, used his pipe to make a boat go super fast or to fly and can punch really fast too.

glad someone else understands how f*cking insane popeye is smile

marwash22
Jeebus! I'm gonna nod that Popeye vs. Hulk matchup. And i'm gonna go watch some Popeye cartoons cool

Lord_Talron
i have a huge collection here + netflix and my disposal. prepare for hulk to no longer be the 'strongest there is' jr_shakefist

BlackZero30x
Originally posted by marwash22
Jeebus! I'm gonna nod that Popeye vs. Hulk matchup.

The Scenario
Originally posted by Lord_Talron
no not even close. hes ridiculously more powerful, thanks to the hundreds of dragon souls hes collected, each of which boost his power greatly. its possible he could tell classic strange to simply die in the ancient language and have enough power to actually pull it off without dying himself. but theres no proof

Yeah, the only difference between them is the amount of life force they have. Anyone using the Ancient Language can do pretty much the same thing as anyone else using it. Other than the amount of power behind it, all Eragon spellcasters are the same.

who would make a good match up against the giant mecha Megas + Coop controlling it and Kiva as support

from the cartoon show Megas XLR

I'm not sure. Megas is pretty powerful.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Megas_XLR#Equipment

psycho gundam
popeye is a toon, nobody can beat a toon cause of their inate invincibility and seeming ability to accomplish any task they want to do, no matter how improbable.

toons are able to pull objects out of thin air: nukes, acme bombs, spinach cans, bear traps, spot holes, paint cans w/ a brush, spring shoes, anvils, giant shears, sowing needles, etc.

popeye vs mxtzlptlk is more fair

Creshosk
Originally posted by psycho gundam
popeye is a toon, nobody can beat a toon. Dip

illadelph12
Popeye would punk Mxy if he could catch him. He can punch through magic bolts (and that's actually canon). Mxy's overall far more powerful though. Popeye could try and pull an SBP on him.

Popeye vs. Hulk would be educational.

Lord_Talron
Originally posted by psycho gundam
popeye is a toon, nobody can beat a toon cause of their inate invincibility and seeming ability to accomplish any task they want to do, no matter how improbable.

toons are able to pull objects out of thin air: nukes, acme bombs, spinach cans, bear traps, spot holes, paint cans w/ a brush, spring shoes, anvils, giant shears, sowing needles, etc.

popeye vs mxtzlptlk is more fair popeye carries spinach in his shirt wtf

psycho gundam
only thing that i see can give the hulk, or anyone for that matter a shot at beating him is they can completely separate him from his last can of spinach while he's in dire need of it.

bluto almost beat his ass in the desert this one time and i know hulk is billions of time stronger than him.

edit...

holy F, i found it:

ClpwuQabuzI

i have the tape of this at home, it still plays after hundreds of viewings.

popeye turns into a tank tread *facepalm*

Lord_Talron
bluto has some pretty impressive strength feats too, including hanging (shortly) with popeye on spinach on more than one occasion

illadelph12
Popeye is a beast, he's just in a comedic medium. I don't see anything out of the ordinary with his abilities when compared with a comic character. He's got shape-shifting, super human strength and speed, propelled flight (via use of his pipe), high end durability, and tactile matter-manipulation via punching. If he was a Super Skrull rather than a foul mouthed sailor with mutated forearms and a speech impediment no one would have issue with him.

Creshosk
Originally posted by illadelph12
Popeye is a beast, he's just in a comedic medium. I don't see anything out of the ordinary with his abilities when compared with a comic character. He's got shape-shifting, super human strength and speed, propelled flight (via use of his pipe), high end durability, and tactile matter-manipulation via punching. If he was a Super Skrull rather than a foul mouthed sailor with mutated forearms and a speech impediment no one would have issue with him. I'd say its more than just mater manipulation. He's got reality altering punches. What with things like punching a giant gorilla into three smaller ones.

psycho gundam
Originally posted by illadelph12
Popeye is a beast, he's just in a comedic medium. I don't see anything out of the ordinary with his abilities when compared with a comic character. He's got shape-shifting, super human strength and speed, propelled flight (via use of his pipe), high end durability, and tactile matter-manipulation via punching. If he was a Super Skrull rather than a foul mouthed sailor with mutated forearms and a speech impediment no one would have issue with him. ^ you can justify anything with that train of thought.

i guess popeye storing his costco sized can of spinach in his tessract inner pocket is fair play.

illadelph12
Batman carries a lot of stuff in his belt, and Hulk has a near ton of additional mass held in an alternate dimension until he gets pissed. One large can of spinach inside of a shirt is small potatoes.

Besides, maybe he has an unseen holster or something in there. whistling1

Creshosk
Originally posted by illadelph12
Batman carries a lot of stuff in his belt, and Hulk has a near ton of additional mass held in an alternate dimension until he gets pissed. One large can of spinach inside of a shirt is small potatoes.

Besides, maybe he has an unseen holster or something in there. whistling1 I'm just going to go with hammerspace.

psycho gundam
Originally posted by illadelph12
Batman carries a lot of stuff in his belt, and Hulk has a near ton of additional mass held in an alternate dimension until he gets pissed. One large can of spinach inside of a shirt is small potatoes.

Besides, maybe he has an unseen holster or something in there. whistling1 okay cool, but this begs the question: does hulk have even a slight chance of winning?

we already know toons are broken, on object lesson of it is kinda pointless

Lord_Talron
lets please save this for a potential thread before it gets locked again.

marwash22
Xena vs Captain America

-Cap gets his shield
-Xena gets her Chakram
-Fight takes place in the Gladiator Arena, as seen in "Gladiator"
-There are 4 Bengal tigers that will randomly attack both competitors

Lord_Talron
xena warrior princess?

anyways, ill nod it at least for the creative setting. i like it

marwash22
Yep, Xena...

she has abilities akin to those of someone who has taken the Super-Soldier Serum; and they both have indestructible throwing weapons.

psycho gundam
Originally posted by marwash22
Xena vs Captain America

-Cap gets his shield
-Xena gets her Chakram
-Fight takes place in the Gladiator Arena, as seen in "Gladiator"
-There are 4 Bengal tigers that will randomly attack both competitors nod

marwash22
you nod it without the tiger stipulation? Eh, that's cool... people would probably argue about who would get caught by a tiger instead of debating the actual fight.

Wei Phoenix
Or debating about who oneshots the most tigers.

psycho gundam
Originally posted by marwash22
you nod it without the tiger stipulation? Eh, that's cool... people would probably argue about who would get caught by a tiger instead of debating the actual fight. captain america has been said to run on pis, so a fight with xena is almost a perfect counter for all of that since she's definitely influenced by pis

the pis argument gets negated

marwash22
Who'd be a good Matchup for Brock Samson?

psycho gundam
savage dragon

punisher

wildcat

the goon

marwash22
Brock Samson vs. Punisher

-Fight takes place on the Conveyor map, from Unreal Tournament.
-They start out on the lower level, both unarmed.
-First to 10 frags is the victor.
-map --> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8SnLr5Bp-as

cool

Omega Vision
Originally posted by marwash22
Brock Samson vs. Punisher

-Fight takes place on the Conveyor map, from Unreal Tournament.
-They start out on the lower level, both unarmed.
-First to 10 frags is the victor.
-map --> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8SnLr5Bp-as

cool
Punisher gets punished.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
savage dragon

punisher

wildcat

the goon
I don't know about Savage Dragon or the Goon but Brock would tear Wildcat or Punisher apart. He's not a Top Tier MA but he makes up for it by having damage soak to put the Punisher to shame and strength arguably beyond peak level. He did tear apart a muscle car with his bare hands.

Etna
Originally posted by XanatosForever
Etna, you're reading my mind. laughing I was just thinking of using Megas in a CG match. wink

Cool! that would be awesome
this show was funny

marwash22
Yeah, Brock has some sort of Beserker mode, ala Wolverine.

Lord_Talron
brock is insane xD

psycho gundam
Originally posted by Omega Vision
Punisher gets punished.


I don't know about Savage Dragon or the Goon but Brock would tear Wildcat or Punisher apart. He's not a Top Tier MA but he makes up for it by having damage soak to put the Punisher to shame and strength arguably beyond peak level. He did tear apart a muscle car with his bare hands. brock vs marv then

yes that would be epic

marwash22
Originally posted by psycho gundam
Brock Samson vs Marv (Sin City)
nod. nod. nod. nod. nod. nod. nod.

Lord_Talron
nod!

marwash22
Match-ups with nods (number of nods)

Hercules vs Beowulf (2)
Deadpool vs Raiden, from "Metal Gear" (2)
Blade vs Vamp, from "Metal Gear" (2)
Deathstroke vs Albert Wesker, from "Resident Evil" (2)
Wolverine, Archangel, Deadpool, Psylocke, and Fantomex vs Samus (1)
Grimmjow, from "Bleach" vs Cheetah Minerva (1)
T-1000 vs Wolverine (1)
Ronin Warriors vs Fantastic 4 (2)
Popeye vs Hulk (4)
Xena, Warrior Princess vs Captain America (2)
Brock Samson vs Marv, from "Sin City" (2)

RE: Blaxican
I'm going to nod Deadstroke vs. Wesker, because they both have easily acceptable feats.

xmarksthespot
I want to see Xena fight Captain America.

byrdgang21
Originally posted by psycho gundam
popeye is a toon, nobody can beat a toon cause of their inate invincibility and seeming ability to accomplish any task they want to do, no matter how improbable.

toons are able to pull objects out of thin air: nukes, acme bombs, spinach cans, bear traps, spot holes, paint cans w/ a brush, spring shoes, anvils, giant shears, sowing needles, etc.

popeye vs mxtzlptlk is more fair

I agree that Popeye has an advantage in being a toon,even tho I do kinda like the idea of Popeye vs. Hulk. I just think that you would have to give Hulk "The Mask" to even the playing field, but that wouldnt be anything near a cannon Hulk, would it? So Im torn on the idea of this fight.

Lord_Talron
i dont see why him being a "toon" matters. just go by feats

The Scenario
It could be argued that Brock is also a toon.

marwash22
Brock, who? Samson? He's not THAT kinda toon... not like a Wile E Coyote, Popeye or the Mask... Brock doesn't do crazy shit like pull bazookas out of his back pocket. If you watch "Venture Bros.", you realize that he's pretty much a Punisher type character.

<< THERE IS MORE FROM THIS THREAD HERE >>