Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

No board. No Mjolnir. No energy attacks.

Just slugging it out between these two Marvel icons.

Who remains standing at the end?

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0/981/87139-107507-silver-surfer.jpg vs http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0/40/150353-55190-thor.jpg

Thor....surfer really doesn't brawl.I never recall him brawling.He will not win a slugfest against thor.At all.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Thor....surfer really doesn't brawl.I never recall him brawling.He will not win a slugfest against thor.At all. he doesn't usually brawl...but I think he's done so competently in the past when the occasion called for fisticuffs

he did kinda decent againts Rhino in brawling

surfer, slightly stronger, more durable

Probably Thor. But Surfer is doing really well in H2H these days he was easily able to hurt BRB with his punch making him bleed and all.... and he defeated Skaar in h2h when he had the old power. That and his ability to tank physical damage are extraordinary.

Good fight I say...But Thor most likely wins in the end a lot more experience in h2h and possibly physically stronger.

Physical: Thor>surfer
Durable: Surfer>Thor

Thor due to being a bit more skilled.

Surfer, more durable (by a big margin, imo) and just as strong, if not stronger.

Durak proved surfer is not more durable

What strength feats does surfer have that compare to thor?I never recall readign anything of the sort but I haven't read any post-annihilation surfer.

three punch downing BRB, tackling GreenScar & the Warbound, without much trouble. taking on Skaar, chumping Abomination...

basically, he's durable and powerful enough to engage T&A, at length... he's powerful enough to take Thor's best and return with better.

Thor

Yea, Thor.

Thor.

Originally posted by Gecko4lif
Durak proved surfer is not more durable

Thor

Originally posted by kgkg


His probably referring to the number of punches it took to take out Surfer in comparison to Thor.

Surfer's durability is kind of weird at times but I think either Superman or Thor would take a punch better than him on average.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
His probably referring to the number of punches it took to take out Surfer in comparison to Thor.

Surfer's durability is kind of weird at times but I think either Superman or Thor would take a punch better than him on average. I wouldn't say that.IMO surfer has a little bit higher durability but not quite as much punching power to close the gap to beat either.At least not from what i've read.

I still think either Thor or Superman would take a punch better than him. They're just tougher in general from what I've seen. His skin might not be prone to damage as theirs, but as we know, lack of wear and tear on his body doesn't prove much.

Most feats between the both of them can be found in the main Thor vs. Silver Surfer thread.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t292293.html

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
His probably referring to the number of punches it took to take out Surfer in comparison to Thor.
The fight were Durok pretty much killed Thor and Surfer had to save him? Hey at least Surfer K.O'ed Durok...counting punches now that's reaching if I recall correctly Surfer was never K.O in that fight while Thor was... Don't see how that helps Thor's case.

Surfer durability is pretty much the best in the top tiers.

And I degree Superman and Surfer are clearly more durable than Thor....While Thor has a firepower advantage over them.

Originally posted by kgkg
The fight were Durok pretty much killed Thor and Surfer had to save him? Hey at least Surfer K.O'ed Durok...counting punches now that's reaching if I recall correctly Surfer was never K.O in that fight while Thor was... Don't see how that helps Thor's case.

Surfer durability is pretty much the best in the top tiers.

And I degree Superman and Surfer are clearly more durable than Thor....While Thor has a firepower advantage over them. I agree to the last line.

They are more durable(if only slightly)but that damned hammer....

Originally posted by kgkg
The fight were Durok pretty much killed Thor and Surfer had to save him? Hey at least Surfer K.O'ed Durok...counting punches now that's reaching if I recall correctly Surfer was never K.O in that fight while Thor was... Don't see how that helps Thor's case.

Why does everybody forget that Thor was holding his own until Durok resorted to using the electricity from the city? He knocked out Durok by using Time Travel, which apparently has some type of effect on Durok. Thor however has actually overpowered and beaten him straight up when pushed.

Is it not the point of this thread to discover who wins in a slug fest, and in turn, who can take a punch better? How does it make counting punches reaching?

He wasn't knocked out, but he was put on his ass, and was lying on his board as if he couldn't walk I believe. It really rocked him.

Originally posted by kgkg
Surfer durability is pretty much the best in the top tiers.

And I degree Superman and Surfer are clearly more durable than Thor....

Nah. I'd place invulnerable mode Juggernaut as above him. Still, he is a contender for the runner up spot.

I think it's harder to injure either Superman or Surfer than Thor on average. I never argued otherwise.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
I think it's harder to injure either Superman or Surfer than Thor on average. I never argued otherwise.


Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
I still think either Thor or Superman would take a punch better than him. They're just tougher in general from what I've seen.

Thor

considering that Thor has won every battle against SS as far aas i know off

H2H SS goes down Thor strength feats are way beyond Surfer Durability can go either way. H2H skill Surfer has nopthing on Thor Unless someone want s to count Hitting BRB in the Back of the head as owning BRB

SS wins this.
Now if this was h2h then Thor would probably slightly edge him. But this is a slugfest, skill doesn't count.

SS is easily more durable than Thor and possibly around the same strength (based on SS's punching feats against beings of Thor level).

Originally posted by h1a8
SS wins this.
Now if this was h2h then Thor would probably slightly edge him. But this is a slugfest, skill doesn't count.


WOW just wow so the fact this is a Melee fight and it is stated that it is H2H only and you think a slug fest is different

Originally posted by h1a8
SS wins this.
Now if this was h2h then Thor would probably slightly edge him. But this is a slugfest, skill doesn't count.


Unless they're just taking turns hitting each other, skill DOES count.

Originally posted by Tron
Unless they're just taking turns hitting each other, skill DOES count. Isn't that is what a slugfest is, taking turns? And not putting up a defense?

Originally posted by h1a8
Isn't that is what a slugfest is, taking turns? And not putting up a defense?

That's what I thought . . .

thor

Strength wise, Thor > Surfer
Durability wise, Surfer > Thor
IMO, their respective advantages cancels out the others and it all comes down to skill. and Thor has more skill showings that Surfer.
So, Thor for the majority, maybe 7/10

Originally posted by gogogadgetgo
Strength wise, Thor > Surfer
Durability wise, Surfer > Thor
IMO, their respective advantages cancels out the others and it all comes down to skill. and Thor has more skill showings that Surfer.
So, Thor for the majority, maybe 7/10 I'll go with this.

Originally posted by gogogadgetgo
Strength wise, Thor > Surfer
Durability wise, Surfer > Thor
IMO, their respective advantages cancels out the others and it all comes down to skill. and Thor has more skill showings that Surfer.
So, Thor for the majority, maybe 7/10 Not bad.

Thor via Judo Chop!!!

Originally posted by h1a8
Isn't that is what a slugfest is, taking turns? And not putting up a defense? it just means any type of non sanctioned fistfight, imo with not so skilled/professional fighters (like a bar fight)

a hockey fight is synonymous for a slugfest

---------------------------------

i still see no reason not to give this to thor, surfer simply lacks the feats to bolster any confidense he can win with JUST fisticuffs agaist someone in the elite high herald class (thor, supes, etc) that are sitting on hundreds of feats knocking people around using physical force.

when surfer needs to bulk up he cn, but he just lacks a definite set of feats that guage what kind of sheer physical power he's packing. knocking green scar and the warbound was okay and all, but it's still not enough to say he beats thor in that area of combat.

Just to add. Surfer's durability HAS fluctuated based on the amount of amping he gives his durability. Like I've said before, in some panels he's tanking an entire fleet focus firing him with everything they've got without so much as flinching and, in the same issue several panels later, gets knocked off his board by a single laser battery (while he was distracted).

There should be no question that when Surfer amps his durability, he is entire levels above Thor.

Base durability, tho. I see Thor as having the better damage soak but Surfer having far better damage resistance.

Originally posted by D_Dude1210
Just to add. Surfer's durability HAS fluctuated based on the amount of amping he gives his durability. Like I've said before, in some panels he's tanking an entire fleet focus firing him with everything they've got without so much as flinching and, in the same issue several panels later, gets knocked off his board by a single laser battery (while he was distracted).

There should be no question that when Surfer amps his durability, he is entire levels above Thor.

Base durability, tho. I see Thor as having the better damage soak but Surfer having far better damage resistance.

Agreed. And you make a very good point. The reason why Surfer is variable is because he is an amper. The more energy hes absorb the stronger he is. So for Surfer we should take averages instead of his highs since the OP may not want Surfer to be at a high amped level. Depends on the OP though.

Thor beats his *ss.

Thor dominates

The one possessing the highest level of superhuman strength wins biscuits