Gladiator vs Guy Gardner

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



victorymaker
I saw this thread posted on Comic Vine, so I want to post it here as well to see what the KMC community thinks. I have already seen what the Comic Vine community thinks. Guy Gardner vs. Gladiator. Who wins and why?

"Id"
Guy gets trashed by Lobo, why would it be any different with Gladiator?

victorymaker
Originally posted by "Id"
Guy gets trashed by Lobo, why would it be any different with Gladiator?

That is a good point. A lot of the arguments presented were "Guy can make a shield to defend against Superman." If Superman can break the shield, why can't Gladiator at full confidence? It makes no sense.

iceman24567
Gladz for the the vast majority

Slaanesh
Guy isn't a great Lantern like Hal or Kyle..so he'll lose..

victorymaker
Here is the battle that was made on Comic Vine.

http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/gladiator-vs-guy-gardner/565201/

cdtm
Originally posted by "Id"
Guy gets trashed by Lobo, why would it be any different with Gladiator?

Guy got trashed by Lobo once.

He also fought fairly evenly with Lobo in an earlier JLA story, and had the upper hand in his solo series with the Sinestro ring, only having problems due to his power randomly shorting out.

I pick Gladiator though, since his upper level feats are closer to pre crisis Superman clone stuff then post crisis, imo..

Cubey
Their responses were lol.

Divine Spawn is also hella wanked there.

cdtm
Originally posted by Slaanesh
Guy isn't a great Lantern like Hal or Kyle..so he'll lose..

Ever since Rebirth, he's been pretty awesome. Inspired the entire Corp in Recharged, came up with the idea of using the yellow battery as a cosmic bomb against Anti Monitor, and thought up the trawling net in Blackest Night.

And he has Kyles respect, which says a lot. Even John softened up on him.. (and frankly he has no business looking down on anyone considering some of his history..)

D_Dude1210
Comcvine posters don't seem to read a lot of Marvel... :-/

victorymaker
Originally posted by D_Dude1210
Comcvine posters don't seem to read a lot of Marvel... :-/

I have to agree. I do see a lot of "Pro-DC" posters there quite often.

amnesia
Originally posted by D_Dude1210
Comcvine posters can't read. :-/


fixed it for you.

Prep-Man
Glads.

victorymaker
Originally posted by amnesia
fixed it for you.

LOL. You hate Comic Vine?

amnesia
Originally posted by victorymaker
LOL. You hate Comic Vine?

kinda, prepman is sort of DC biased, but he is still a bro.


I love babs if that counts for anything.

Prep-Man
Originally posted by amnesia
kinda, prepman is sort of DC biased, but he is still a bro.


I love babs if that counts for anything.

thumb up

Warlord
Glads and yes ComicVine is shit

axelraptor
Gladiator

Lord Feron
Originally posted by iceman24567
Gladz for the the vast majority

D_Dude1210
Comicvine sucks for the vast majority! smile

-Pr-
Originally posted by cdtm
Ever since Rebirth, he's been pretty awesome. Inspired the entire Corp in Recharged, came up with the idea of using the yellow battery as a cosmic bomb against Anti Monitor, and thought up the trawling net in Blackest Night.

And he has Kyles respect, which says a lot. Even John softened up on him.. (and frankly he has no business looking down on anyone considering some of his history..)

Tholian web.

Gladiator imo, though Guy can and will take a few off of him.

r0nm0n88
make it hal and we have a fight lol

vansonbee
Originally posted by r0nm0n88
make it hal and we have a fight lol I believe Guy was better in 1 vs 1 confrontations.

Hal is awesome in team fights though.

iceman24567
Nah Hal is better in a 1 on 1 confrontation too he's just overall better than Guy. Guy was having trouble with a Alpha Lantern Hal dropped the same lantern without his ring eek!

r0nm0n88
hal is the man!! The best lantern out there!

Stoic
Gladitor takes it, but Guy could surprise him a couple times.

BattleMage
Comic Vine is a dc fanboy site i really do feel that way. But any way Glads 10/10 And he would beat Hal too. IMO

victorymaker
Originally posted by BattleMage
Comic Vine is a dc fanboy site i really do feel that way. But any way Glads 10/10 And he would beat Hal too. IMO

I agree 100% that it is a DC fanboy site.

Badabing
Is this a joke thread? sneer

Do you people even KNOW who Guy Gardner is!? uhuh

Guy Gardner for the wtfstompflawlessvictorypimpsmack! biscuits

victorymaker
Originally posted by Badabing
Is this a joke thread? sneer

Do you people even KNOW who Guy Gardner is!? uhuh

Guy Gardner for the wtfstompflawlessvictorypimpsmack! biscuits

Why?

rotiart
Well I think it was the blackest night when Gardner went ballistic and was rocking black lanterns when he was red ring wearer...

-Pr-
with a red ring i'd give him the win here.

rotiart
Well do you really thing it was the red ring that made him that good...I mean how do we know it just wasn't a regular guy Gardner "bloodlusted"
Guess it would be hard to tell

-Pr-
Originally posted by rotiart
Well do you really thing it was the red ring that made him that good...I mean how do we know it just wasn't a regular guy Gardner "bloodlusted"
Guess it would be hard to tell

it's a combination.

The Nuul
Originally posted by Badabing
Is this a joke thread? sneer

Do you people even KNOW who Guy Gardner is!? uhuh

Guy Gardner for the wtfstompflawlessvictorypimpsmack! biscuits

Originally posted by victorymaker
Why?

Dont pay attention to that guy, PR is the cooler mod.

Badabing
Originally posted by victorymaker
Why? Because, Guy Gardner is badassness incarnate!

Also, my post wasn't 100% serious. laughing out loud

Mshinu
Glads headbutts Guy until he can`t remember if the ring is on his finger or this toes.

Lord_Talron
glads -.-

vansonbee
Originally posted by iceman24567
Nah Hal is better in a 1 on 1 confrontation too he's just overall better than Guy. Guy was having trouble with a Alpha Lantern Hal dropped the same lantern without his ring eek! Which comic this from?

Hal dropping an Alpha w/o his ring?

cdtm
Originally posted by iceman24567
Nah Hal is better in a 1 on 1 confrontation too he's just overall better than Guy. Guy was having trouble with a Alpha Lantern Hal dropped the same lantern without his ring eek!

If Johns put Hal against Superboy Prime, and editorial mandate demanded a winner, would his head explode? big grin

The Alpha Lantern thing is clearly PIS, but I'd agree Hal is a step above Guy.

The upcoming Emerald Warriors may change that though, since Guy looks set to clash with Hal, and Tomasi is as much a fan of Guy as Johns is of Jordan..

iceman24567
Originally posted by vansonbee
Which comic this from?

Hal dropping an Alpha w/o his ring? Final crisis 6 i was just reading it and it made me giggle. Hal punches out the Alpha lantern then the Guardians tell him he has 24 hours to save the universe the ultimate wankage laughing

BattleMage
Glads

Spire
Gladiator.

h1a8
Glads

Omega Vision
Who wins?

thanos-prime
gladiator

King Castle
bn done. http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12909952

now it can be closed

-Pr-
merging. kudos for the link-finding.

Lunacyde
All depends on Gladiator's confidence level I would suppose, and how particularly good Guy was that day, but Glads should take the majority.

carver9
Gladiator rips him in half.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.