Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Battle site is Jedi Temple

Force
Lightsaber
All Out

1. Luke
2. Luke
3. Luke

1. Luke
2. Mace
3. Luke - if he can keep Mace at a distance via superior Force usage. However, if Mace is able to force an all-out saber duel (i.e. his battle w/ Sidious), Luke is in trouble.

Luke beats Mace in lightsaber combat more often than not.

A few points why you can't use the Mace-Sidious fight as an example for Mace's lightsaber victory. Luke knows shatterpoint just as Mace does. Sidious has way more anger, darkness to be turned against himself than Luke. These were the two main reasons why Mace beat Sidious.

Luke just hit a triple

Mace is an amazing duelest, but he is not in NJO Luke's league. Mace defeated, which itself is arguable, Sidious due to Vaapad's superconducting loop, however he will not have this advantage against Luke. Luke, however, managed to defeat DE Sidious through his own skill/power. A far more impressive feat.

Intresting fact, Luke may have created a new version of Vaapad in TUF. While Luceno has never stated it was Vaapad, he said he made is sound like Luke was using Vaapad on purpose.

If Mace murdered Mara and then confronted Luke, he might have some Dark Side to feed off of. But as it is...

Luke takes all three. He is pretty much what Anakin could have become.

Luke definitely wins all 3. Force and all out I dont think there is any argument. For sabers, remember that Luke cut down THOUSANDS of Vong during just the attack on the Citadel. Thats pretty beast. Mace cant compete.