Zom vs Shuma-Gorath

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



CortSether
Oh yes. I went there.

753
tentacle rape for the win

guy222
zom

zopzop
Zom.

CortSether
Nah, Zom loses. In fact, Strange even says that he's never felt such power when confronted by Shuma's manifestation with the Ancient One's mind. Nevermind the fact that Zom never actually did anything big grin

zopzop
Nah Zom wins.

Zom was never defeated by Strange. So irregardless of how much power Strange said Shuma had, Strange repeatedly defeated Shuma. He defeated Shuma in his own seat of power, then again on Earth.

Crom (or nameless Neanderthal Shaman depending on whether handbooks count) defeated and imprisoned Shuma.

CortSether
Originally posted by zopzop
Nah Zom wins.

Zom was never defeated by Strange. So irregardless of how much power Strange said Shuma had, Strange repeatedly defeated Shuma. He defeated Shuma in his own seat of power, then again on Earth.

Crom (or nameless Neanderthal Shaman depending on whether handbooks count) defeated and imprisoned Shuma.

It was already explained to you countless times that being defeated by something made to stop you (plot-device weapon) does not equal a low showing. And all that did was banish Shuma.

Again, Strange never, not once, defeated Shuma-Gorath. It wasn't "Strange" as we know him that defeated Shuma-Gorath in its realm, he had already turned into a separate Shuma-Gorath within Shuma's realm, which is what enabled him to wield Shuma's energy at all.

Every other encounter (such as when in the Ancient One's mind) he needed to use plot devices to win (like killing the Ancient One so as to collapse the gateway to earth, preventing Shuma from fully manifesting). Strange has never combated Shuma directly and won without some kind of plot device aid.

Meanwhile a Strange who was not even Sorceror Supreme at the time was stalemating Zom.

Also consider the fact that Strange even says he's never faced such power when referencing Shuma.

zopzop
Bro give it up. Strange owned Shuma AND his "all powerful" lieutenant in their own realms! Strange has owned Shuma on Earth.

Why doesn't this sink in?

Strange AND Ancient One, then later Strange with Ancient One's powers, never owned a shackled Zom. The LT later shows up and saves the day.

CortSether
Originally posted by zopzop
Bro give it up. Strange owned Shuma AND his "all powerful" lieutenant in their own realms! Strange has owned Shuma on Earth.

Why doesn't this sink in?

Strange AND Ancient One, then later Strange with Ancient One's powers, never owned a shackled Zom. The LT later shows up and saves the day.

You're the only one that doesn't see the absorption of Arioch as plot device. When has Strange ever before or after that been able to force someone to merge with him? Hell, if that was a part of his normal powerset he could have done that to every Shuma-Gorath servant before that and saved himself a lot of trouble.

And again, it wasn't 'Strange' who owned Shuma. There was a slight bit of Strange's consciousness left in him when in Shuma's realm but that was it, he even says that Strange is no more. When he had started to turn into Shuma-Gorath that's when he was finally able to wield Shuma's energy and hurl it back at it. It was the same energy that would have destroyed galaxies just by being in the vicinity (since it was Shuma's energy that means Shuma could have as well).

So? The fact that a shackle and crown of thorns restricted Zom's powers so much that he couldn't even kill a Strange/Ancient One just shows how overrated Zom is. And the Ancient One comparison doesn't even mean much since the Ancient One knew from the start that he was doomed once it was clear Shuma-Gorath was coming for Earth.

I'm curious as to why you think Zom is so powerful besides the vague hyperbole coming from Umar. It's never even said that Zom and Eternity actually battled you know. Eternity would roflstomp Zom in a head on confrontation. Shuma's shown more durability than Zom ever has regarding tangling with high powers.

Lestov16
Originally posted by 753
tentacle rape for the win

Feats proving this?

Lestov16
Originally posted by zopzop

Why doesn't this sink in?



Because, like Onslaught, people read the wikipedia page which says they are uber-unstoppable, not reading the comics to see that this so-called uber-power was never displayed, ever

King Kandy
Eternity beats Shuma.

CortSether
Originally posted by King Kandy
Eternity beats Shuma.

He also beats Zom...so?

This is Zom vs Shuma-Gorath, not Eternity vs Shuma-Gorath.

CortSether
Originally posted by Lestov16
Because, like Onslaught, people read the wikipedia page which says they are uber-unstoppable, not reading the comics to see that this so-called uber-power was never displayed, ever

Actually in terms of the comics Shuma-Gorath showed far more power than Zom ever had :/

Colossus-Big C
Originally posted by King Kandy
Eternity beats Shuma. outside shumas universe maybe, but shuma merged/devovered the eternity of his universe

King Kandy
Originally posted by CortSether
He also beats Zom...so?
Actually, he doesn't. He needed help.

zopzop
Originally posted by CortSether
You're the only one that doesn't see the absorption of Arioch as plot device. When has Strange ever before or after that been able to force someone to merge with him? Hell, if that was a part of his normal powerset he could have done that to every Shuma-Gorath servant before that and saved himself a lot of trouble.

And again, it wasn't 'Strange' who owned Shuma. There was a slight bit of Strange's consciousness left in him when in Shuma's realm but that was it, he even says that Strange is no more. When he had started to turn into Shuma-Gorath that's when he was finally able to wield Shuma's energy and hurl it back at it. It was the same energy that would have destroyed galaxies just by being in the vicinity (since it was Shuma's energy that means Shuma could have as well).

So? The fact that a shackle and crown of thorns restricted Zom's powers so much that he couldn't even kill a Strange/Ancient One just shows how overrated Zom is. And the Ancient One comparison doesn't even mean much since the Ancient One knew from the start that he was doomed once it was clear Shuma-Gorath was coming for Earth.

I'm curious as to why you think Zom is so powerful besides the vague hyperbole coming from Umar. It's never even said that Zom and Eternity actually battled you know. Eternity would roflstomp Zom in a head on confrontation. Shuma's shown more durability than Zom ever has regarding tangling with high powers.

I'll repeat this till it sinks in so you understand Cort :

Strange NEVER beat Zom. Strange with Ancient One's power never beat Zom.

Strange beat Gorath and his "all powerful" lieutenant in their own realms where they were supposedly omnipotent.

Strange beat Gorath on Earth at Stonehenge

Crom, a stone age God, beat Gorath OR (depending on source) unnamed neanderthal shaman beat Gorath. Pick whichever is least embarrassing for your boy.

Zom's hands were shackled by Dormammu with the Chains of Living Bondage, no one knows how. Dormammu couldn't or wouldn't finish the job and Eternity stepped in and put on the Crown of Blindness and imprisoned him in an amphora outside all space/time.

The LT shows up and annihilates Zom, but Zom lives in diminished form and can reach full power should he ever gain enough mystic energy.

Gorath's list of enemies : Dr. Strange, Ancient One, nameless caveman shaman, forgotten Stone Age God Crom

Zom's list of enemies : Dormammu, Dr. Strange, Ancient One, the Living Tribunal, Eternity, Umar

It's kinda all right there.

And speaking of hyperbole, you got scans of Gorath destroying a planet, let alone a galaxy?

CortSether
Originally posted by King Kandy
Actually, he doesn't. He needed help.

Actually, he does. Nowhere is it said Eternity needed help, ever. It's not even said they actually battled. But we do know that Dormammu put Zom in the Chains of Living Bondage without Eternity, and then Eternity imprisoned him. It had nothing to do with how powerful Zom was or that Eternity couldn't defeat him. Why did he decide to imprison Zom instead of destroy him? Who knows, possibly for the same reason the Living Tribunal decided to banish Zom instead of just destroy him right there on the spot like we all know he could.

Or are you now going to start saying that he's able to rival the Living Tribunal? big grin

Zom's hands were shackled by Dormammu with the Chains of Living Bondage, no one knows how.

The fact that Dormammu was able to shackle Zom at all speaks volumes that he's not near Shuma-Gorath in power.

The LT shows up and annihilates Zom, but Zom lives in diminished form and can reach full power should he ever gain enough mystic energy.

And this is special in some way? Shuma-Gorath was apparently destroyed and reassembled just fine. It's also stated in the Thanos Imperative #6 that Shuma-Gorath along with the rest of the Many-Angled Ones cannot die.

Gorath's list of enemies : Dr. Strange, Ancient One, nameless caveman shaman, forgotten Stone Age God Crom

You're forgetting: The Vishanti and Sise-Neg, the former who failed to defeat Shuma-Gorath and the latter who outright stated he didn't want to attempt to destroy it (wasn't even sure if he could), and this is when he was almost at the completion of his journey in absorbing everything in Marvel.

Again you're bringing up "nameless Shaman"? Wow. You're just choosing to ignore things. He used the 'Iron Bound Books of Shuma-Gorath' to banish Shuma. It was Shuma's own personal plot-device, which AGAIN I'll tell you is not a low showing if you're defeated by your own plot device. Or shall we say that Mad Jim Jaspers is a weakling because his own plot-device, The Fury, was able to defeat him? Or now Superman is a weak pos because of his Kryptonite weakness? Or Spectre because of the Spear of Destiny? And in the case of Crom, he's never even battled Shuma, just used the plot-device weapon to banish him.

{B]I'll repeat this till it sinks in so you understand Cort :

That's fine, but you just look like an ass because you've clearly only skimmed through wiki pages and not even read any of Shuma's appearances.


Strange NEVER beat Zom. Strange with Ancient One's power never beat Zom.

The fact that Zom couldn't even kill a regular Doctor Strange even before the Ancient One imbued him with his power shows he's nowhere near Eternity's level.

Strange beat Gorath and his "all powerful" lieutenant in their own realms where they were supposedly omnipotent.

As already said, it's only you who cannot smell the plot device with Arioch. In his realm Arioch was as powerful as he could conceive, Strange didn't disagree which is why he forced the merging. But when before or after has Strange ever forced a merging with those significantly more powerful than him, or significantly weaker? Never. That's why it's PIS, because Strange has never displayed that ability before or after that point. And it wasn't a normal Doctor Strange that defeated Shuma-Gorath. It was Strange/Arioch who had turned into Shuma-Gorath in the realm. It was basically Shuma-Gorath defeating itself. Not "Strange". Keep lying, it's fun telling you you're wrong every time.

Strange beat Gorath on Earth at Stonehenge

You mean, a severly weakened and hungry Shuma who was collapsing over itself almost killed Doctor Strange. And that was just in Strange leading the battle to Stonehenge to use the historical site's powers to open a dimensional warp. That encounter was not even comparable. Or should I say the time Doctor Strange downed a starving Galactus with the Images of Ikkon equates to Galactus being a weakling in all instances?

Crom, a stone age God, beat Gorath OR (depending on source) unnamed neanderthal shaman beat Gorath. Pick whichever is least embarrassing for your boy.

You've just embarrassed yourself by showing that all you know from Shuma is the wiki page you browsed through. Crom never battled Shuma, neither did the Shaman. They used Shuma's plot-device weapon.




And speaking of hyperbole, you got scans of Gorath destroying a planet, let alone a galaxy?

It's already shown that when Strange tries to leave the dimension a huge explosion happens and Kaluu realizes what would happen should Strange leave with Shuma's energy still inside him, which is the destruction of galaxies.

Secondly, yea, I saw Shuma-Gorath non-chalantly attack the entire earth instantaneously while taunting Doctor Strange.

Add to the fact that Strange even acknowledged that he'd never felt such power when Shuma showed up as a manifestation within the Ancient One's mind. It's spelled all over the plot that Shuma-Gorath is Doctor Strange's most powerful enemy at the time. What would the point be in Shuma being weaker? Oh, here comes this big new villain we've been waiting issues to see, but oh it turns out he's actually weaker than what Strange has fought before! Oh yea, sure makes for an exciting story :/

Prep-Man
Shuma.

Horrificus
Originally posted by CortSether
Actually, he does. Nowhere is it said Eternity needed help, ever. It's not even said they actually battled. But we do know that Dormammu put Zom in the Chains of Living Bondage without Eternity, and then Eternity imprisoned him. It had nothing to do with how powerful Zom was or that Eternity couldn't defeat him. Why did he decide to imprison Zom instead of destroy him? Who knows, possibly for the same reason the Living Tribunal decided to banish Zom instead of just destroy him right there on the spot like we all know he could.

Or are you now going to start saying that he's able to rival the Living Tribunal? big grin

Zom's hands were shackled by Dormammu with the Chains of Living Bondage, no one knows how.

The fact that Dormammu was able to shackle Zom at all speaks volumes that he's not near Shuma-Gorath in power.

The LT shows up and annihilates Zom, but Zom lives in diminished form and can reach full power should he ever gain enough mystic energy.

And this is special in some way? Shuma-Gorath was apparently destroyed and reassembled just fine. It's also stated in the Thanos Imperative #6 that Shuma-Gorath along with the rest of the Many-Angled Ones cannot die.

Gorath's list of enemies : Dr. Strange, Ancient One, nameless caveman shaman, forgotten Stone Age God Crom

You're forgetting: The Vishanti and Sise-Neg, the former who failed to defeat Shuma-Gorath and the latter who outright stated he didn't want to attempt to destroy it (wasn't even sure if he could), and this is when he was almost at the completion of his journey in absorbing everything in Marvel.

Again you're bringing up "nameless Shaman"? Wow. You're just choosing to ignore things. He used the 'Iron Bound Books of Shuma-Gorath' to banish Shuma. It was Shuma's own personal plot-device, which AGAIN I'll tell you is not a low showing if you're defeated by your own plot device. Or shall we say that Mad Jim Jaspers is a weakling because his own plot-device, The Fury, was able to defeat him? Or now Superman is a weak pos because of his Kryptonite weakness? Or Spectre because of the Spear of Destiny? And in the case of Crom, he's never even battled Shuma, just used the plot-device weapon to banish him.

{B]I'll repeat this till it sinks in so you understand Cort :

That's fine, but you just look like an ass because you've clearly only skimmed through wiki pages and not even read any of Shuma's appearances.


Strange NEVER beat Zom. Strange with Ancient One's power never beat Zom.

The fact that Zom couldn't even kill a regular Doctor Strange even before the Ancient One imbued him with his power shows he's nowhere near Eternity's level.

Strange beat Gorath and his "all powerful" lieutenant in their own realms where they were supposedly omnipotent.

As already said, it's only you who cannot smell the plot device with Arioch. In his realm Arioch was as powerful as he could conceive, Strange didn't disagree which is why he forced the merging. But when before or after has Strange ever forced a merging with those significantly more powerful than him, or significantly weaker? Never. That's why it's PIS, because Strange has never displayed that ability before or after that point. And it wasn't a normal Doctor Strange that defeated Shuma-Gorath. It was Strange/Arioch who had turned into Shuma-Gorath in the realm. It was basically Shuma-Gorath defeating itself. Not "Strange". Keep lying, it's fun telling you you're wrong every time.

Strange beat Gorath on Earth at Stonehenge

You mean, a severly weakened and hungry Shuma who was collapsing over itself almost killed Doctor Strange. And that was just in Strange leading the battle to Stonehenge to use the historical site's powers to open a dimensional warp. That encounter was not even comparable. Or should I say the time Doctor Strange downed a starving Galactus with the Images of Ikkon equates to Galactus being a weakling in all instances?

Crom, a stone age God, beat Gorath OR (depending on source) unnamed neanderthal shaman beat Gorath. Pick whichever is least embarrassing for your boy.

You've just embarrassed yourself by showing that all you know from Shuma is the wiki page you browsed through. Crom never battled Shuma, neither did the Shaman. They used Shuma's plot-device weapon.




And speaking of hyperbole, you got scans of Gorath destroying a planet, let alone a galaxy?

It's already shown that when Strange tries to leave the dimension a huge explosion happens and Kaluu realizes what would happen should Strange leave with Shuma's energy still inside him, which is the destruction of galaxies.

Secondly, yea, I saw Shuma-Gorath non-chalantly attack the entire earth instantaneously while taunting Doctor Strange.

Add to the fact that Strange even acknowledged that he'd never felt such power when Shuma showed up as a manifestation within the Ancient One's mind. It's spelled all over the plot that Shuma-Gorath is Doctor Strange's most powerful enemy at the time. What would the point be in Shuma being weaker? Oh, here comes this big new villain we've been waiting issues to see, but oh it turns out he's actually weaker than what Strange has fought before! Oh yea, sure makes for an exciting story :/ Jeeeez!
Ladies and gentlemen, THIS is how it's done!
starwars
"Impressive. Most impressive."

Glorificus
Shuma is a bit more lacking in big feats than Zom. So I'd have to go with Zom for the win. Also, the most recent incarnation of Shuma wasn't all that impressive...

Horrificus
Originally posted by Glorificus
Shuma is a bit more lacking in big feats than Zom. So I'd have to go with Zom for the win. Also, the most recent incarnation of Shuma wasn't all that impressive... The thing is, Shuma is the mystical ruler of an entire dimension.
That, in itself, should assure him a top of the pyramid level seat. Along with the usual statements made by characters to the effect of his omnipotence.

Think about all of the abstracts that hardly have any, if any feats at all, yet their power levels are usually assumed.

I'm trying to recall any of Eternity's combat feats, but drawing a blank.

Sr J-Bieb
Shuma Gorath is below Death if that counts as a feat...

zopzop
Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
Shuma Gorath is below Death if that counts as a feat...

And Death is below Thanos. naughty All hail Thanos!

Horrificus
Originally posted by zopzop
And Death is below Thanos. naughty All hail Thanos! Only when there is "Sweet Lovin'" goin on. wink

CortSether
I've boned death before.

Or at least it smelled like death...

guy222
zom wins

CortSether
Originally posted by guy222
zom loses

Fixed.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.