Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Manhattan has grown tired of his existence. He seeks a way to end himself, once and for all. He seeks out two groups. Group A is Voldemort, Dumbledore and the death eaters. Group B is every Jedi/Sith shown in every SW movie.

Manhattan tells them to end him for good. He holds his arms at his sides, nods, and closes his eyes.


The Jedi/Sith go first, with their most powerful force attacks. The Wizards go second, with their most powerful spells.


Who destroys Manhattan?

Not the Wizards. Doc Manhattan already destroyed Hogwarts and beat Harry to death with his one eyed trouser snake 'cause the Wizards were powerless against him, obviously.....but I think it'd take something like the force itself intervening some how or something for the SWers to stop Manhattan.

But if science and tech has the answer, then SW will beat the wizards to that post too.

Nah. Force attacks would fail miserably.


The wizards are all alive, doofus. There is no Wizard/Jedi matchup in this thread.

Snape steps up, Avada Kedavra. Ding dong, the Doc is dead!!!



It would seem HPmagic is more powerful.




Thanks for playing

Its seems that it is more powerful to you, cause of the wizzjizz crust in your eyes.

Show me a feat in HP that has blown up a planet... (A feat that is insignificant next to the power of the force, BTW.)

Oh thats right. There nothing even remotely comparable cause Wizards are small time when compared to a unified energy field that penetrates and binds an entire galaxy/universe together.

Or even a mere SW technological invention like the Death Star..

No... I don't think that would work either. It would take some heavy shit to kill him I think on either side. If we could use Luke past the movies then he would get it done, since he had so much control of the force he could change the universe. Other than him, I honestly have no idea. Maybe a super charged death star blast would do the trick. I dont think the HP magic would work though. It's not absolute like you might think it is.

This isn't a versus fight.

Can a mod close this?

Why does it matter? You could just choose to not even bother with the thread.

BECUASE TEH INTERNET IS SEREOUS BUSSINESS!

Originally posted by Nephthys
BECUASE TEH INTERNET IS SEREOUS BUSSINESS!


haha. PREACH IT BROTHA!

Hey RJ if Manhattan wanted to die a death spell would do the trick!
As long as he didn't clone himself he dies simple.

Originally posted by the ninjak
Hey RJ if Manhattan wanted to die a death spell would do the trick!
As long as he didn't clone himself he dies simple. Because HP magic is more powerful than the Force.





And sadako doesn't like it, hence his little one liners.

Doctor Manhattan wants to die? Yes, by 3 spells.

One will do. Avada Kedavra.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
One will do. Avada Kedavra.

Pretty much.

He admitted himself in the film when Ozymodius killed him that he was a fool not to realise that he made clones of himself.

Dead, 100% dead, there's nothing to regen from. This is why Avada Kedavra would kill Superman and Hancock (again, IF it hit them), and the Hulk. Wolverine too.

any actual proof from the movies and not blindly fanboyism that a magic spell will destroy a being of pure energy?

any actual proof a magic spell can kill a God?

Avada Kedavra is a life ender. It kills, it removes life from the victim. If Mnahattan is literally 100% dead, no amount of regen in the universe brings him back.

Apparantly it strikes the soul directly. If thats true (and provable) I guess Manhatten would die if hit, as I assume he still has a soul. The problem with that is I don't think that was actually stated on-screen, so whatever.

And while he's made of pure energy he still touches things and is solid, so I assume it'll still hit him normally.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Apparantly it strikes the soul directly. If thats true (and provable) I guess Manhatten would die if hit, as I assume he still has a soul. The problem with that is I don't think that was actually stated on-screen, so whatever.

And while he's made of pure energy he still touches things and is solid, so I assume it'll still hit him normally. It's not like a wizard can take him in combat, all I'm saying is IF it hits him.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Because HP magic is more powerful than the Force.





And sadako doesn't like it, hence his little one liners.

Yet it constantly is shown in the threads, the movies, in fandom debates, that The force is the greater and more powerful.

But back to your fantasies you can go, just dont try to present them as fact in the face of massive contrary evidence.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Yet it constantly is shown in the threads, the movies, in fandom debates, that The force is the greater and more powerful.

But back to your fantasies you can go, just dont try to present them as fact in the face of massive contrary evidence. Sure, and all you have to offer in said threads is "The wizards were dead a long time ago."

Weak, dude.

Its all I HAVE to say, cause the outcomes I refer to are all in the beginning pages of those threads.

Ergo: Backed up statements.

Oh it's surely all you have to say, you've made that painfully obvious. I LOL every time I call you out and you slytherin back inside your little spite shell.

More bullshit mischaracterisation...?

Nice that youre virtually admitting that you can't admit defeat.

I'm right here, ready to bury anything you throw at me.



Bring it.

In this thread. You seriously want me to bring over six threads into this one... Nope. Cant turn this into a shit fest.

Just go back into threads you speak of, and read say the 1st pages of all of them. You will see them there.
And although all this macho "Burying" BS, is your pose right now, you couldnt do so in like 35+ pages subsequent to the killings.
Everyone has discredited your countering arguments there.

Dodge.


And no, they haven't. Borbarad is currently tearing you a new orifice. He's saying alot of the same things I have.

No he puts his stuff together better than you.
My orignal orafice count remains intact though.

The particle machine that killed the beast in "No Such Thing" might kill Doctor Manhattan.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
No he puts his stuff together better than you.
My orignal orafice count remains intact though. Same shit is being said, in a more presentable fashion, by a different person. I've been preaching that shit since page one in all HP threads.

It really amazes me that you can go on ignoring the difference in power sets.

Everytime RJ makes a versus thread which causes an argument between him and Sadako...a fairy dies

That's why we do it. Fairies suck.

Happens a lot, you make a thread that pisses him off and then you two argue about it...but without you two arguing this place may not be so fun

Wizards have the power to Kill Manhattan. Jedi do not. The argument as to who is more powerful is now over.


And he doesn't like it.

Well considering Manhattan is letting himself be killed then yeah they probs could...if he were fighting back...manhattan would clearly win...but thats not the case here

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Wizards have the power to Kill Manhattan. Jedi do not. The argument as to who is more powerful is now over.


And he doesn't like it.

By KMC Forum rules, Jedi don't have the feats to kill Manhattan, but if Manhattan existed in the SW universe they would. The Force is the totality of everything that exists, and if Mahatten existed then ergo Jedi would be able to to atomize people/things like Doc does.

Mhm, funny that was never shown onscreen.

Oh the jedi could kill Manhatten. Just saber him a few dozen times. Manhattan's nigh unkillable becuase he can just regen or reconfigure or whatever his molecules back together. If he's actively trying to die, he just doesn't do that and dies.

No, they couldn't. Ozy disintegrated him and he still regenned. It didn't kill him, he was able to regen.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Mhm, funny that was never shown onscreen.

Just speculating, dude. Movie Jedi couldn't do squat to Manhattan. I'm just saying that The Force isn't a bag of random tricks like magic is. It's the essense of everything that is.

He regenned becuase he wanted to. Here he does not. Simple.

Originally posted by Nephthys
He regenned becuase he wanted to. Here he does not. Simple. Wizard versus Manhattan, during the Watchmen movie, when Manhattan cannot see the future, is an epic curbstomp in favor of the wizard. Avada Kedavra ends life instantly, if Manhattan is literally dead, he cannot regen.

It's not rocket science, dude.

Originally posted by dadudemon
Death spell separates the soul from the body. So, no matter what, it would kills DM. It's magic, not science.

However, I do not see how any wizard could ever land a single spell on him. Ever.

See?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Wizard versus Manhattan, during the Watchmen movie, when Manhattan cannot see the future, is an epic curbstomp in favor of the wizard. Avada Kedavra ends life instantly, if Manhattan is literally dead, he cannot regen.

It's not rocket science, dude.

That literally has nothing to do with what I said.

Originally posted by Nephthys
That literally has nothing to do with what I said.

It removes the soul from the body. This is shown onscreen.

That still doesn't have anything to do with why the Jedi will be able to kill him, which is what I was talking about. We've already established that the death spell would be lethal to him. I'm not challenging that.

Also, huh? When was that shown on-screen?

Originally posted by Nephthys
That still doesn't have anything to do with why the Jedi will be able to kill him, which is what I was talking about. We've already established that the death spell would be lethal to him. I'm not challenging that.

Also, huh? When was that shown on-screen? Ministry battle. FF to 2:19.

pZWtt1oAPCM

Or not, kinda hard to tell.

Originally posted by the ninjak


He admitted himself in the film when Ozymodius killed him that he was a fool not to realise that he made clones of himself.

Um, what?

I'm pretty sure that never happened.

Nice too see that no matter how much time goes by, RJ will always stroke Harry's wand faithfully.

Aw, lookit the big boy!!!

Originally posted by Blinky
Nice too see that no matter how much time goes by, RJ will always stroke Harry's wand faithfully.

+20

http://i698.photobucket.com/albums/vv341/jedibeastie2/vader-voldemort-chart-555-1-1.jpg

http://i.telegraph.co.uk/telegraph/multimedia/archive/01763/potter_1763593c.jpg

I bet you are.

How so? It's finally proven that HP wizards possess power far greater than the SW Force.

Why would this upset me?

Because that fantasy of yours in particular hasn't happened at all.

The wizards were all killed before you could have you way with them.
Thats why you cry.... endlessly.

There it is again, the sweet smell of your concession

Except that wasn't proven. Both teams can kill him. So the thread is a draw.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Except that wasn't proven. Both teams can kill him. So the thread is a draw. haermm No, they can't.

Let's go with this: Takes place during the Watchmen movie. Manhattan does not want to die. He cannot see the future because of Ozy's scheme.

The wizards end him with avada kedavra. The spell removes the soul. He is literally dead, ended, nothing left to regen from.

The Jedi have nothing that would literally kill him.

Pretty simple.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
There it is again, the sweet smell of your concession

'Tis the new fragrance of your arguments freshly cleaned clock.

Star-win.

"The Wizards were all killed long ago", first of all, lame comeback. Second of all, the wizards are not in danger here.

Pay attention.

They are in danger of being judged as being far weaker than the SW forces...which is true, of course.

Now who's changing the thread?

Pwned

Originally posted by Nephthys
Now who's changing the thread? Changing the thread how? I was simply asking a question.

And your answer was perfect.

So this is Dr Manhattan who can teleport to anywhere in the universe pretty much instantly....Can create and destroy life at will...Can manipulate matter at the sub atomic level...Perceives time in a non linear fashion and thus, barring the use of tachyons, can see anything that is going to happen. This is a being that can walk on the surface of the sun. He can phase through solid object...Can create multiple copies of himself (unknown how many)

It's also stated that during a potential conflict during the cold war he would be able to destroy 99% of all incoming soviet missles while simultaneously destroying large areas of the Soviet Union.

This is a being that pretty much single handedly won the Vietnam war.

Is this actually a serious debate?...

Originally posted by jaden101
So this is Dr Manhattan who can teleport to anywhere in the universe pretty much instantly....Can create and destroy life at will...Can manipulate matter at the sub atomic level...Perceives time in a non linear fashion and thus, barring the use of tachyons, can see anything that is going to happen. This is a being that can walk on the surface of the sun. He can phase through solid object...Can create multiple copies of himself (unknown how many)

It's also stated that during a potential conflict during the cold war he would be able to destroy 99% of all incoming soviet missles while simultaneously destroying large areas of the Soviet Union.

This is a being that pretty much single handedly won the Vietnam war.

Is this actually a serious debate?...

QFT

Originally posted by jaden101
So this is Dr Manhattan who can teleport to anywhere in the universe pretty much instantly....Can create and destroy life at will...Can manipulate matter at the sub atomic level...Perceives time in a non linear fashion and thus, barring the use of tachyons, can see anything that is going to happen. This is a being that can walk on the surface of the sun. He can phase through solid object...Can create multiple copies of himself (unknown how many)

It's also stated that during a potential conflict during the cold war he would be able to destroy 99% of all incoming soviet missles while simultaneously destroying large areas of the Soviet Union.

This is a being that pretty much single handedly won the Vietnam war.

Is this actually a serious debate?...

Nah its a butthurt fest on account of the fact that RJ didnt like the outcome of Doc Manhattan vs Hogwarts, which literally concluded with Hogwarts destroyed, all wizards dead, and Harry Potter himself humiliatingly beaten to death with Manhattan's blue-bus-like trouser snake, blended perfectly with a hint of "SW beats HP and he doesnt like it" angst. Delicious.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Nah its a butthurt fest on account of the fact that RJ didnt like the outcome of Doc Manhattan vs Hogwarts, which literally concluded with Hogwarts destroyed, all wizards dead, and Harry Potter himself humiliatingly beaten to death with Manhattan's blue-bus-like trouser snake, blended perfectly with a hint of "SW beats HP and he doesnt like it" angst. Delicious.

Aaahhh...One of those again?

Originally posted by jaden101
So this is Dr Manhattan who can teleport to anywhere in the universe pretty much instantly....Can create and destroy life at will...Can manipulate matter at the sub atomic level...Perceives time in a non linear fashion and thus, barring the use of tachyons, can see anything that is going to happen. This is a being that can walk on the surface of the sun. He can phase through solid object...Can create multiple copies of himself (unknown how many)

It's also stated that during a potential conflict during the cold war he would be able to destroy 99% of all incoming soviet missles while simultaneously destroying large areas of the Soviet Union.

This is a being that pretty much single handedly won the Vietnam war.

Is this actually a serious debate?... Did you even read the thread?

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Nah its a butthurt fest on account of the fact that RJ didnt like the outcome of Doc Manhattan vs Hogwarts, which literally concluded with Hogwarts destroyed, all wizards dead, and Harry Potter himself humiliatingly beaten to death with Manhattan's blue-bus-like trouser snake, blended perfectly with a hint of "SW beats HP and he doesnt like it" angst. Delicious.


Originally posted by jaden101
Aaahhh...One of those again?

Sadly so.

Well hello Mr. Pot!!!! Sup?

RJ, thats the mirror....we're over here.

Just following your act, babe. Funny how Jaden accused me of doing the same thing you've been doing for days now.

Nah... Youve been like that for welllllllll over a year.

I post a few threads where your wizard friends are roasted (As they are in your HP love threads), and you cry and shit yerself.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Just following your act, babe. Funny how Jaden accused me of doing the same thing you've been doing for days now.

I've accused somebody something?

News to me.

Still...If the shoe fits.

Originally posted by Placidity
Um, what?

I'm pretty sure that never happened.

DM says it when he is huge and attacks Ozy through the roof.

He said he made clones of himself.

No he didn't:

TmVgEdBVWOQ&feature=related

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Nah... Youve been like that for welllllllll over a year.

I post a few threads where your wizard friends are roasted (As they are in your HP love threads), and you cry and shit yerself. Actually there's only one where they are likely roasted. The rest I turned back on the owner.

Erm. No. You didn't own them.