Ash Nazg
New to this, Ive only read through a few of the more recent posts, so excuse me if this has been done before, but even if it has, I thinks its a good topic to resurect to guage new opinions.
I get the feel that there is a good mixture of people here, some who have read the books many years ago and have been long standing fans, some who have had interest sparked in the books because of the films and those who have not (yet?) read the books.
Im one of the former and have to admit I was dubious and a bit hesitant about seeing what has been my favourite story hit the big screen. Fist viewing, I was dissapointed, but felt I should like it. There were parts that didnt seem right and I found myself probably too over critical. Then I saw it again. The again, and again. Then bought the extended version (which I knew I always would!) and loved it. I now think PJ has done an absoutely superb job. Yes there are part that still dont sit too well (like Faramir in TT) but other changes, like Arwens beefed up role, which I find work well, especially in telling more of the relationship between her and Aragorn, which is covered mainly outside of the books in the apedices and other books.
I think it is superb that the films have now opened a new generations eyes to the story and I hope with all my heart that if you havent read the books, that you will.
All opinions welcome, I lke to see different view points, and I hope anyone who wishes will feel free to chip in on this one, whatever your view.
I get the feel that there is a good mixture of people here, some who have read the books many years ago and have been long standing fans, some who have had interest sparked in the books because of the films and those who have not (yet?) read the books.
Im one of the former and have to admit I was dubious and a bit hesitant about seeing what has been my favourite story hit the big screen. Fist viewing, I was dissapointed, but felt I should like it. There were parts that didnt seem right and I found myself probably too over critical. Then I saw it again. The again, and again. Then bought the extended version (which I knew I always would!) and loved it. I now think PJ has done an absoutely superb job. Yes there are part that still dont sit too well (like Faramir in TT) but other changes, like Arwens beefed up role, which I find work well, especially in telling more of the relationship between her and Aragorn, which is covered mainly outside of the books in the apedices and other books.
I think it is superb that the films have now opened a new generations eyes to the story and I hope with all my heart that if you havent read the books, that you will.
All opinions welcome, I lke to see different view points, and I hope anyone who wishes will feel free to chip in on this one, whatever your view.