Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Pick and order the all-time top 3 comics brawlers. This should be based on consistent brawling feats, not extrapolation, so no Trion Juggernaut and the like please. Also, this is just brawling, so no other powers (blasts, flight, matter manipulation, etc.)

1. Juggernaut
2. Hulk
3. Hercules

hulk, wendigo, manthing

Superman is on any list.

Originally posted by CosmicComet
1. Juggernaut
2. Lobo
3. Hulk

Am amending this to include Lobo.

.

Invincible
Herc
Hulk

.

Difficult list. Not sure I can narrow it down to three when you have so many amazing brawlers like Hulk, Juggernaut, Thor, Superman, Lobo etc.

Originally posted by CosmicComet
1. Juggernaut
2. Hulk
3. Hercules

Juggernaut
Thor
Black Adam

Everyone has named weaksauce characters so far. My list:

1. PC Validus
2. SA Mangog
3. Shaggyman/The General

You guys sleeping on invincible

Invincible doesn't even deserve to be mentioned with some of the names thrown around here.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Invincible doesn't even deserve to be mentioned with some of the names thrown around here.
You kidding?

Invincible has way may heart than anybody mentioned here.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Invincible doesn't even deserve to be mentioned with some of the names thrown around here.

I agree, but he does have some of the most visibly impressive and gruesome fights bar none, but that is largely the art.

.

Originally posted by Verizon Mobile
Lulz. Batman has more heart than invicible. Shit Wonder Woman and Namor can kick his ass. Alright ill give you batman but come one. He is ****ing batman. And Being able to kick his ass has nothing to do with anything.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
I agree, but he does have some of the most visibly impressive and gruesome fights bar none, but that is largely the art.

I agree he is tough, but Gecko is overdoing it.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
I agree he is tough, but Gecko is overdoing it.
but.. but... intestines

just to throw it out there, Man-Thing has out brawled the Hulk before

Originally posted by inimalist
just to throw it out there, Man-Thing has out brawled the Hulk before

Everyone that has been mentioned has been outbrawleed.

Hulk outbrawled Juggy.
Juggy outbrawled Thor.
Grundy outbrawled Superman.
Hulk outbrawled Herc.
Herc outbrawled Thor.

You get the point.

Originally posted by carver9
Everyone that has been mentioned has been outbrawleed.


Not everyone.

.

Originally posted by carver9
Everyone that has been mentioned has been outbrawleed.

Hulk outbrawled Juggy.
Juggy outbrawled Thor.
Grundy outbrawled Superman.
Hulk outbrawled Herc.
Herc outbrawled Thor.

You get the point.

indicating he deserves to be treated among the high end brawlers on this list....

not to mention, his essential immunity to brawling type attacks/insane regeneration gives him a leg up over everyone mentioned in your list, possibly save classic juggernaut

wendigo is a strong enough brawler to take on Alpha Flight and requires high end magic to put down

whether or not you think they top the list, they certainly deserve mention among these other "heavyweights"

EDIT: hulk has also never taken a clear win from Manny

Originally posted by inimalist
indicating he deserves to be treated among the high end brawlers on this list....

not to mention, his essential immunity to brawling type attacks/insane regeneration gives him a leg up over everyone mentioned in your list, possibly save classic juggernaut

wendigo is a strong enough brawler to take on Alpha Flight and requires high end magic to put down

whether or not you think they top the list, they certainly deserve mention among these other "heavyweights"

EDIT: hulk has also never taken a clear win from Manny

In a fist fight, who would you put above Hulk (minus skyfathers)?

man-thing

Originally posted by carver9
In a fist fight, who would you put above Hulk (minus skyfathers)?
Man-thing
Thanos
Validus
Starro
Red knight
SA Mangog
Gold age Captain marvel
Gold age Black adam
Immortal Herc
Beastmode Orion


Thats just off the top of my head

Originally posted by Gecko4lif
Man-thing
Thanos
Validus
Starro
Red knight
SA Mangog
Gold age Captain marvel
Gold age Black adam
Immortal Herc
Beastmode Orion


Thats just off the top of my head

I have always said on this Board that Orion would wreck the Hulk. Even in a fist fight Orion put the Hulk down. This guy goes toe-to-toe with Superman. He can put the Hulk on his back.

EDIT: HUlk would wreck immortal Hercules.

I wasn't counting precrisis stuff, but if counting that Golden Age Captain Marvel definitely ranks high.

Originally posted by carver9
Hulk outbrawled Juggy.

When?

Originally posted by carver9
Juggy outbrawled Thor.

Not without extenuating circumstances.

Originally posted by carver9
Herc outbrawled Thor.

When?

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
When?



Not without extenuating circumstances.



When?

When Hulk grabbed Juggy by the Helmet and spinned his a** like Thor spins mjlonir and tossed him over the mountain. The fight was done.

Thor lost twice to Juggy.

You already know when Herc manhandled Thor. Let's put it like this, if it wasn't for Thor lightning, he would have passed out.

Like Michael Jackson say ... DO YOU REMEMBA?

Originally posted by Hyperion Prime
I have always said on this Board that Orion would wreck the Hulk. Even in a fist fight Orion put the Hulk down. This guy goes toe-to-toe with Superman. He can put the Hulk on his back.

EDIT: HUlk would wreck immortal Hercules.

In your opinion, Jackie Chen can beat Hulk in a fist fight.

Originally posted by Gecko4lif
Man-thing
Thanos
Validus
Starro
Red knight
SA Mangog
Gold age Captain marvel
Gold age Black adam
Immortal Herc
Beastmode Orion


Thats just off the top of my head

A lot of those people are "just your opinion".

Why would you bring up Pre-Crisis characters?

Originally posted by carver9
In your opinion, Jackie Chen can beat Hulk in a fist fight.

No, but Fei Long could

Originally posted by carver9
When Hulk grabbed Juggy by the Helmet and spinned his a** like Thor spins mjlonir and tossed him over the mountain. The fight was done.

Thor lost twice to Juggy.

You already know when Herc manhandled Thor. Let's put it like this, if it wasn't for Thor lightning, he would have passed out.

Like Michael Jackson say ... DO YOU REMEMBA?

What's your definition of a brawl slug fest? Brawling usually involves multiple opponents.

I'm assuming you picture two opponents going toe to toe until one goes down?

I don't want to be presumptuous so I'll wait for your response. I'm kind enough to let you organize your position.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
What's your definition of a brawl slug fest? Brawling usually involves multiple opponents.

I'm assuming you picture two opponents going toe to toe until one goes down?

I don't want to be presumptuous so I'll wait for your response. I'm kind enough to let you organize your position.



Forget you Rage.

I guess we have different definitions of brawling.

Are you afraid of a little question? What's your definition of a slug fest or brawl? It could be wrestling in the mud, a pretty liberal take, but I won't judge.

1.Thanos
2.Tyrant
3.Hulk

1.Invincible
2.Hulk
3.Juggernaut

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Are you afraid of a little question? What's your definition of a slug fest or brawl? It could be wrestling in the mud, a pretty liberal take, but I won't judge.

A brawl is similar to a fist fight imo. It can involve 2 people or more... depends.

Jack Daw
Bigby Wolf
Wonderman

Originally posted by Simbon
Everyone has named weaksauce characters so far. My list:

1. PC Validus
2. SA Mangog
3. Shaggyman/The General

lol, agreed.


Originally posted by Gecko4lif
You kidding?

Invincible has way may heart than anybody mentioned here.

So your list is, what, Invincible, Thing, and Cap? You see the flaw here?

Originally posted by Digi
So your list is, what, Invincible, Thing, and Cap? You see the flaw here?
Thing is a boxer more than a brawler but the case could indeed be made I suppose

And Cap isnt a brawler he is a martial artist

HP Doomsday
SA Mangog
War Hulk

Originally posted by Gecko4lif
Thing is a boxer more than a brawler but the case could indeed be made I suppose

And Cap isnt a brawler he is a martial artist

It was in response to your "heart" comment. Clearly Invincible would get reamed by half the people named on this list.

Originally posted by Digi
It was in response to your "heart" comment. Clearly Invincible would get reamed by half the people named on this list.
true

Originally posted by carver9
Everyone that has been mentioned has been outbrawleed.

Hulk outbrawled Juggy.
Juggy outbrawled Thor.
Grundy outbrawled Superman.
Hulk outbrawled Herc.
Herc outbrawled Thor.

You get the point. hulk's right foot out brawled the eastern seaboard

http://i48.tinypic.com/4ryd8j.gif

Hulk's outbrawling Juggy sounds more like a BFR. mmm

Originally posted by inimalist
you mean the fight where hulk throws him away on the next page? Yes, the same fight Hulk was outbrawl by Juggernaut and Hulk BFR Juggernaut

here read how Juggernaut its outbrawling hulk

http://i246.photobucket.com/albums/gg102/Knowsbleed33/Battle/IH%20172/th_TheIncredibleHulkv2-172-18.jpg]

if thats how you read it...

Originally posted by inimalist
if thats how you read it...

Read it again
http://thumbnails28.imagebam.com/13227/a3bfcd132265104.jpg

Juggernaut definitely had the edge physically in that depiction.

Originally posted by carver9
A brawl is similar to a fist fight imo. It can involve 2 people or more... depends.

Let's limit this discussion to only two individuals. Do you count removing tossing someone from the battle field as "outbrawling" an opponent?

Originally posted by JonyBoy2
Read it again
http://thumbnails28.imagebam.com/13227/a3bfcd132265104.jpg

/ffs

1: Juggernaut
2: Lobo
3: Hercules

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Do you count removing tossing someone from the battle field as "outbrawling" an opponent? Not me, maby Carver?

Originally posted by inimalist
you mean the fight where hulk throws him away on the next page?

I read that comic years ago....lol at the X-Men just being there. I think they were just driving along and saw juggernaut.

I'll give Invincible some props in that department. Not the strongest obviously but as a pure brawler he certainly deserves to be mentioned. Wolverine is up there too.