Did you cry when Dobby died?

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Dobby the elf
I did sad

ares834
I laughed.

Dobby the elf
Originally posted by ares834
I laughed.

That's mean.

Rogue Jedi
nope.

~Bun Bun~
Book: Yes.
Movie: Not so much.

GeekyGirl
Originally posted by ~Bun Bun~
Book: Yes.
Movie: Not so much.

Agreed

damsel-distress
Oh this is a very moving scene, poor Dobby!

siriuswriter
In the movie, Dobby had maybe three seconds to give us his parting words. His burial was much, much more moving.

In books, you can have twelve chapters in which to cover three seconds, if you want. Much much more sentimental in the books, the burial gave me tingly eyes.

juggerman
I couldnt wait for that ugly little thing to croak

BlackZero30x
Originally posted by ares834
I laughed.

thumb up me too....

The Rover
Yes.

maham
Originally posted by juggerman
I couldnt wait for that ugly little thing to croak
laughing

the ninjak
Originally posted by Dobby the elf
I did sad

How did you cry when you're dead?....... why am I responding to a dead elf?

Patient_Leech
I didn't cry, but I was saddened. sad

Cyborg vader
No. I didn't really feel emotionally attached to dobby.

david.miller
Not so much smile

Bazyli
I shocked when he died. In the movie when you see the situation you feel it like reality. Its natural phenomena after some time I feel better.

Bazyli
Originally posted by Bazyli
I shocked when he died. In the movie when you see the situation you feel it like reality. Its natural phenomena after some time I feel better.

Any comments?

aged care homes queensland

Vensai
So this is a yes or no thread? Sure you don't want a poll instead?
Anyway, I didn't cry in the theater since, well, everyone knew it was coming.

quanchi112
Originally posted by ares834
I laughed. You are sick.

sarrydoter123
i feel very sad, when dobby died.its so emotional. sad

Soundgun99
Yes.

Originally posted by Dobby the elf
I did sad

Cat Lady
I sure did.

Cinemaholic
I'm not much in the whole HP scene so I didn't get upset and cry when Dobby died.

The Doctor Who?
In the theater people yelled Dobby! My friend started laughing so I said pretty
loud YOU HEARTLESS BASTARD!!! Got a pretty good laugh out of everybody

Azzikhan
This king of scene should not be added in movie. And the movie like harry potter.

forestlaw
I got upset but thats all :P Im not too emotional, besides its HP which is not my favs.

Surtur
I didn't cry exactly, but it did hit me hard. To be fair I was on vicodin at t he time(just had spinal fusion surgery).

hezza555
I shed a tear or two

sorrowmovie
Yes, I did. I am very shocked when he died.

EmperorSidious2
Originally posted by Patient_Leech
I didn't cry, but I was saddened. sad

Yea

Darth Abonis
Naw

Scottie
Spoilers sad

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.