Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Brotherhood:
Magneto(Old)
Sabertooth
Toad
Mystique
Pyro
Callisto

vs.

Hellfire Club:
Sebastion Shaw
Emma Frost
Riptide
Angel
Azazel

Fight is inside the Statue of Liberty (X-men 1)
Who wins?

I'm afraid this is the Hellfire Club. Every member with the exception of Angel is a certified powerhouse.

Magneto is the only major threat on the Brotherhood side. As soon as Azazel teleports his helmet away from his head this fight is over. Emma mindrapes Erik(and everyone for that matter), Riptide is clearly more powerful than Pyro, Azazel is a beast, etc.

Sebastion Shaw was portrayed as being rediculously powerful, bulletproof, explosion proof, etc.

Realistically, Azazel should be able to take most of these guys out in a few seconds.

xavier was able to F with Shaws mind. and Emma was powerful enough to block xaviers telepathy earlier in the film. that showing how powerful she is, she could put the brotherhood into a comma. except for magneto if he has his helmet