Rucka's Punisher

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



srankmissingnin
What did you guys think of the first issue of the new Punisher run? I thought it was fantastic! The art, the writing, the panel layout, the perspective of the narrative, this is a really, really creepy, and even scary, issue. The rare parts where Frank shows up are almost a horror story, he is written as this almost ethereal specter of death, he only comes out of the shadows to doll out murder. Frank has no dialogue, and no narration in this issue, and it works. He comes off like a unstoppable monster from a classic horror movie.

Galan007
I definitely wouldn't call myself a 'hardcore' Punisher fan. That is to say, I've only consistently followed his respective MAX runs (which, imo, are very well done.) So basing my opinion primarily on that, Rucka hit it out of the park.

Your analogy of Frank being portrayed as an "ethereal specter of death" is spot on. This issue was creepy (in a good way) and Frank's non-existent dialogue fit that 'style' very well... He let his guns/malice do the talking- and that's exactly what I wanted to see. It was the perfect Punisher issue, imho.

JakeTheBank
Hmmm. That certainly sounds really cool for a take on Punisher. I was wondering how Rucka, who handled Batman and co. for a good while when he worked in DC, would approach Punisher.

BeyondTheGrave
Yeah, I really liked the first issue a lot. seeing him through the eyes of other characters is an interesting take on it and I can't wait to see how it goes because the best way to look at Frank is to look at him through the eyes of someone who's either against him, not like him or completely scared shitless of him. All issues in Punisher's comics that show him from someone else's point of view are awesome. this was no exception.

Can't wait to see how the next issues are.

P.S. speaking of which, when is PunisherMAX 16 coming out? confused

Deadline
Oh shit is Pun gonna go after Doom?

http://www.comicbookresources.com/news/preview2.php?image=solicits/marvelcomics/201111/Punisher-5-50thA.jpg

BruceSkywalker
read and liked the first issue..

Kazenji
Is that Jigsaw?

so much for him dying in the flaming building at the end of 'In The Blood'

SamZED
They never stay dead. I personally liked War journal better but guess its too early to tell.

BeyondTheGrave
you liked it more than In The Blood or this?

I didn't hate war journal 2 but i found it incongruous at times (going from shooting buzzsaw guns at aliens to fighting Captain America themed neo nazis). oh and the art sucked so much balls it could easily spit them on a BLT and call it Meatball Marrinara. I also hated how Matt Fraction teased the "doesn't kill Jigsaw cuz he reminds him of himself" angle and how he can't even remember his wife's face....but then the whole thing was dropped in favor of him fighting skrulls in the middle of new york -_-

even In The Blood was a massive letdown. Remender had a commendable run on Punisher at the start but he needs to be EGWF by Kazuya Mishima for FrankenCastle. DORYA!!

BeyondTheGrave
anyone know when issue 2 is coming out? confused

BackFire
Comes out tomorrow.

I enjoyed the first issue, have always enjoyed the things I've read of The Punisher. I'm excited that there's a new and accessible jumping on point like this just as I'm getting into comics.

BeyondTheGrave
hmm...so it looks like there will be supervillains after all.
honestly, i think this is the most badass artwork seen on any Punisher arc to date. even Frank's skull looks like he just jizzed on himself after looking at himself in the mirror

Deadline
Originally posted by BeyondTheGrave
hmm...so it looks like there will be supervillains after all.
honestly, i think this is the most badass artwork seen on any Punisher arc to date. even Frank's skull looks like he just jizzed on himself after looking at himself in the mirror

I think the idea is it's supposed to look ghostly and ethearel. You're just perverse. Got no problems with supervillains just having him hunt mobsters is boring and pigeon holes him.

BeyondTheGrave
I like jizz-skull of doom better laughing

SamZED
Fight against Vulture 2.0 in the next one. Just hope they wont have it last for the whole issue. The art really does kick ass.

Kazenji
Originally posted by BeyondTheGrave
even In The Blood was a massive letdown. Remender had a commendable run on Punisher at the start but he needs to be EGWF by Kazuya Mishima for FrankenCastle. DORYA!!

Each to their own i suppose......

i liked the Frankencastle story.

BackFire
This week's Punisher was freaking awesome.

Deadline
GOD DAYYMMMM!!!

srankmissingnin
Originally posted by Deadline
GOD DAYYMMMM!!!

Take heart. At least Punisher will beat Thor before Rucka rides off into the sunset.

Deadline
Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Take heart. At least Punisher will beat Thor before Rucka rides off into the sunset.

Im refering to what happened in this months issue. I was waiting for things to heat up and boy did they heat up.

From what Rucka said Thor is one of those Avengers who wouldn't really have a serious problem with Punisher. Rucka stated that The Avengers are going to have different opinions on how to deal with him eg Wolverine, Thor and Black Widow may not have a problem with him at all.

Kazenji
Originally posted by Deadline
Im refering to what happened in this months issue. I was waiting for things to heat up and boy did they heat up.


See....good things come to those who wait.

-Pr-
Rucka's leaving the book, sadly. And he's not too happy about Marvel's treatment of him either.

Shame, really.

Kazenji
http://robot6.comicbookresources.com/2012/09/quote-of-the-day-ive-reached-the-end-of-my-work-for-hire-rope/

-Pr-
Yup.

Wasn't a surprise tbh.

roughrider
Originally posted by Kazenji
http://robot6.comicbookresources.com/2012/09/quote-of-the-day-ive-reached-the-end-of-my-work-for-hire-rope/

Alan Moore is getting company on his island, it seems.

Some people are going to write for the big two, because they are the most high profile houses to go to. Is it going to be a constant cycle of indie writer gets attention, is recruited and becomes a name writing for the big two, only to walk away angry after several years because they don't own the characters and all that copyright arguing that goes back decades etc.?

Kazenji
PUNISHER: WAR ZONE #3 (of 5)

http://imageshack.us/a/img268/6830/54800010151179343803917.jpg

Kazenji
Preview for War Zone

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=preview&id=13971

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by Kazenji
PUNISHER: WAR ZONE #3 (of 5)

http://imageshack.us/a/img268/6830/54800010151179343803917.jpg

Awesome cover. Thor's gonna get that hammer shoved in his ass soon, I hope laughing out loud

Originally posted by Kazenji
Preview for War Zone

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=preview&id=13971

sad

If Parker doesn't get his ribs broken on the following page, then I'll be pissed uhuh

Kazenji
http://imageshack.us/a/img22/9164/29710410151207813843917.jpg

StiltmanFTW
laughing out loud

That's just beatiful. Thor got eaten, Iron Man lies there in his newest armor... it should be posted in the ownage thread big grin

StiltmanFTW
So Punisher's "punishment" will be forcing him to join the new Thunderbolts/Code Red? Just guessing.

abhilegend
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
laughing out loud

That's just beatiful. Thor got eaten, Iron Man lies there in his newest armor... it should be posted in the ownage thread big grin
I don't see thor in that cover though.

StiltmanFTW
Exactly.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Thor got eaten

psycho gundam
Originally posted by Kazenji
http://imageshack.us/a/img22/9164/29710410151207813843917.jpg iron man's suit is still on. i find that peculiar

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.