Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Combatants

Thanos - Thanos for this fight is as he was when brought back during the Cancerverse event.


Hulk - Hulk for this fight is as he was during the World War Hulk event, discounting any later revelations or retcons that detracted from his overall performance (such as Black Bolt being revealed as a weaker Super Skrull and Iron Man's S.P.I.N. tech being revealed as a dummy).



Arena

The fight will take place on a planet shaped mass of Primary Adamantium the size of the Earth. It has a normal atmosphere and surrounding the outer edges of said atmosphere is an indestructible and completely elastic energy field that permeates in but not out.


Stipulations

- This fight is solely hand to hand. Thanos can use cosmic energy/magic/etc. to amp himself but he can not use energy blasts, matter manipulation, any tech (discounting any implants that augment his physical prowess), magic or psionics to harm Hulk.
- Both characters start at their base statistics for the purpose of this fight.
- A win is declared if one character is killed or KOed for five minutes straight.
- Thanos' immortality is off for the purpose of this fight but he still possesses the level of durability afforded him.
- BFR is allowed but cannot remove the character from the stated Arena.
- Thanos, as the one who trained her, is assumed to have all the fighting skill and technique of Gamora.
- For the sake of this discussion, and though it's not one of his showcased skills normally, assume Thanos' speed and agility are comparable to Wolverine's or Blade's.
- Please explain and back up/support your choice in this fight. Don't just go "Hulk" or "Thanos" please, it leads to a lackluster discussion devoid of substance.

so Carver vs Quan?

Originally posted by ctsketch
so Carver vs Quan?

Snrk...

That one made me choke.

Originally posted by ctsketch
so Carver vs Quan?

Originally posted by ctsketch
so Carver vs Quan?

Carver is too much for quan .

Originally posted by TheGodKiller
Carver is too much for quan .

Idk.

I've seen Quan trip Carver up too many times.

Ok, enough joshing around at others expense (even if it is a KMC pastime) guys and let's discuss the thread's subject matter.

Originally posted by CosmicComet
Idk.

I've seen Quan trip Carver up too many times.

Seriously , at the end of the day , who cares ? They both provide good entertainment . One purple along with (fake) feathers , the other green along with golden hair .

Originally posted by Mr.Mxyzptlk
Ok, enough joshing around at others expense (even if it is a KMC pastime) guys and let's discuss the thread's subject matter.

If Thanos was indeed upgraded(pre-TI) as Thanos wankers have been going about , then I think this fight could turn out somewhat similar to the Zeus fight .
However , I think Hulk won't go down w/o a fight .
I'll give Thanos a 6.5/10 win in this regard . Just my 2 cents .

Originally posted by Mr.Mxyzptlk
Ok, enough joshing around at others expense (even if it is a KMC pastime) guys and let's discuss the thread's subject matter.

No joshing around at anyone's expense, I like both people, most of the time.

Quanos beats World War Carv though.

Im not touching this with a ten foot pole.

Originally posted by TheMask
Im not touching this with a ten foot pole.

Then why bother to post other than to say you don't want to post about it?

Originally posted by CosmicComet
No joshing around at anyone's expense, I like both people, most of the time.

Quanos beats World War Carv though.

Its the war of the fanboys ! Clearly the purple one with (fake)feathers (that get ruffled too often) wins this .

Well. WWH is stronger for sure. But Thanos energy out put is tricky. Its probably more then Sentry's I think the million exploding sun's crap was retconned. BUT Zom was so bad he had to be delt with by the LT. Also There is the question. Was Strange trying to kill Hulk?

BUT SINCE THIS IS JUST HAND TO HAND

HULK IS THE WINNER

Thanos could probably tear Hulks head off in this WWH form and He'd grow a new one

Originally posted by TheMask
Thanos could probably tear Hulks head off in this WWH form and He'd grow a new one

No Hulk, as far as I'm aware, has ever shown that level of Regeneration except for the Maestro.

And what do you base on Hulk being stronger than Thanos at base?

Two of his best strength feats are potentially destroying a planet through shattering tectonic plates and beating Black Bolt off screen.

Impressive mind you but Thanos has destroyed planets before as collateral damage in 1 on 1 fist fights.

The million exploding suns got retconned?

Also... Quan.

Nothing defeats the glory of:

based on?

Originally posted by Zack Fair
The million exploding suns got retconned?

Also... Quan.

Nothing defeats the glory of:

based on?

Based on ?

This is the strongest Hulk isnt it? Then he just grows a new one. Also the base strength of Thanos has always been 100 tons. Hulk's to strong. Also Hulk when fighting the Sentry just powering up was enough to almost destroy the planet. He could also manipulte tectonic plates as you mentioned. If he wanted to im sure he could destroy planets

Originally posted by TheMask
This is the strongest Hulk isnt it? Then he just grows a new one. Also the base strength of Thanos has always been 100 tons. Hulk's to strong. Also Hulk when fighting the Sentry just powering up was enough to almost destroy the planet. He could also manipulte tectonic plates as you mentioned. If he wanted to im sure he could destroy planets

Thanos can amp his strength with cosmic energy/magic/bionic implants etc . , in this thread .

Originally posted by TheGodKiller
Based on ?

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v629/JohnnyDA/KennyKola-CMPunkLaughGIF.gif

Oh another biased thanos thread? Ok This is why I didnt wanna comment. Cause I don't like commenting on fanboy threads unless this isnt a fanboy thread. Is it?

Originally posted by TheMask
This is the strongest Hulk isnt it?

No, that's WBH or whatever name KMC uses for him since I left.



No Hulk outside of Maestro could do that.



It's "too" and Green Scar Hulk's base strength is 100 tons. Thanos' strength has to be somewhere north of that since he has manhandled 2 v 1s with Class 100s before.



Proof? Because that fight was pretty underwhelming and barely destroyed a city.



Not contesting any of that. Just pointing out Thanos has done it for years.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v629/JohnnyDA/KennyKola-CMPunkLaughGIF.gif

http://i240.photobucket.com/albums/ff32/evildrew81/scary%20stuff/Joker.gif

So you admit this is a biased thread for thanos? Ok thanks.

Originally posted by TheMask
Oh another biased thanos thread? Ok This is why I didnt wanna comment. Cause I don't like commenting on fanboy threads unless this isnt a fanboy thread. Is it?

Seeing as I'm an avid Hulk fan and an avid Thanos fan? No.

I'm just curious how this version of the Hulk would fare against a Thanos who could potentially match him amp for amp in a fist to fist fight.

Ok if this isnt a biased thread. Then tell me how Hulk wins IN YOUR OPINION.

Originally posted by TheMask
Ok if this isnt a biased thread. Then tell me how Hulk wins IN YOUR OPINION.

If Hulk's base durability would allow him time to amp to the point where Thanos could not put him down through strength or martial skill and then it's just a matter of Hulk's strength reaching a point to overcome Thanos' monstrous durability.

But I made this thread to find out if that is a likely outcome.

Originally posted by Mr.Mxyzptlk


Stipulations



- Thanos, as the one who trained her, is assumed to have all the fighting skill and technique of Gamora.
- For the sake of this discussion, and though it's not one of his showcased skills normally, assume Thanos' speed and agility are comparable to Wolverine's or Blade's.


Kind of biased to me, I dunno.

Didnt i tell you that Hulk could win from strength?

Originally posted by Zack Fair
Kind of biased to me, I dunno.

Thanos exclusively trained Gamora, so it implies he was at least equally as skilled as her when she first debuted. The fact that writers choose to not have him use such skill generally because of his overwhelming strength+durability+intellect+energy output+etc. is no fault of mine for wanting to include it.

As for speed, I know handbook ratings are for shit, but I didn't want anyone saying Hulk would wail without impunity on someone who has a Speed of 3 while Wolverine and Blade have 2. Again, it's one of Thanos' powers/skills not normally showcased but that doesn't mean he doesn't have them.

Originally posted by TheMask
Didnt i tell you that Hulk could win from strength?

You weren't very specific how though.

He gets stronger and stronger. I do truly believe he can destroy a planet. Even in weaker incarnations. As for the meastro I believe that at the time of WWH he was at his best healing abilities. Even better then the Meastro, but I guess since they were never on panal they cant be proven? I think that since he servived what he did they technically can be proven.

What im trying to say is. Without Thanos power blasts there is nothing he can do to kill this version of the hulk.

Originally posted by TheMask
He gets stronger and stronger. I do truly believe he can destroy a planet.

And at no point have I, or anyone else in this thread has said otherwise.



Dunno. On-Panel Professor Hulk has better healing feats than Green Scar, but I still digress that only Maestro has regenerated from atomic dust and thus could regrow a head. No other Hulk has shown that kind of ability.

Originally posted by TheMask
What im trying to say is. Without Thanos power blasts there is nothing he can do to kill this version of the hulk.

A KO is also a valid win option.

Thanos easily if he is allow to amp his strength like Zeus did. I remember before Hulk got crush by Zeus people on this panel use to say Hulk strength is infinite and that He will just get madder and surpass people like Odin and Zeus even after the amp and beat them in H2H.
Thank God for IH 621 and 622. That myth was proven to be false.

Thanos.

His default durability is phucking absurd. His strength without amping/augmentation is also pretty high end, though I concede Hulk's would eventually surpass him if given time. I think even while gimped, Thanos has the means to take on WWH (nevermind giving him agility akin to Wolverine or Blade, which is...generous to say the least).

Originally posted by hunbu04
Thanos easily if he is allow to amp his strength like Zeus did. I remember before Hulk got crush by Zeus people on this panel use to say Hulk strength is infinite and that He will just get madder and surpass people like Odin and Zeus even after the amp and beat them in H2H.
Thank God for IH 621 and 622. That myth was proven to be false.

Well, to be fair, Odin and Zeus are also a whole tier over Thanos.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
(nevermind giving him agility akin to Wolverine or Blade, which is...generous to say the least).

Like I said, handbooks are shit but it's a mention part of his powerset. *shrugs*

His agility and speed are supposed to be equal to any of the Earth's Eternals and that's at least flat Enhanced.

Given then stops of the OP, my money's on Thanks l beating Hulk to KO or death. His base strength and durability are much higher and he's much more skilled. Until Hulk can amp a lot, he's out of his league. Amping takes time he doesn't have.

Originally posted by Dream Stuff
Given then stops of the OP, my money's on Thanks l beating Hulk to KO or death. His base strength and durability are much higher and he's much more skilled. Until Hulk can amp a lot, he's out of his league. Amping takes time he doesn't have.

Your first sentence confused me. o.o

So basically, Thanos needs his fighting skill and speed amped in order to have a chance of beating the Hulk?

Originally posted by Silent Master
So basically, Thanos needs his fighting skill and speed amped in order to have a chance of beating the Hulk?

I didn't amp anything. I just logically concluded what he should have or has had mentioned as part of his power set but doesn't generally showcase because the large versatility and brute power of the rest of his power set compensates for lack of use of it.

He trained Gamora to be the assasin she is. Fact.

He has speed comparable to Earth Eternals, which is at least Enhanced if not flat out low Superhuman. Fact.

You gave him skill and agility above what his feats support, so yes.....you did amp him.

Which is fine, as you're the thread starter.

Even barring said speculative amps, he'd still beat Hulk, imo.

Originally posted by Mr.Mxyzptlk

- BFR is allowed but cannot remove the character from the stated Arena.

Originally posted by Silent Master
You gave him skill and agility above what his feats support, so yes.....you did amp him.

Which is fine, as you're the thread starter.

He's not Amped, that's part of his established power set. *sigh*

But that's not really a point worth arguing over.

Originally posted by PillarofOsiris


As in knocking them into the stratosphere or a continent away to get some breathing room and time to recover. That's still BFR but doesn't remove them from the Arena or constitute a win.

This is the most bias thread I have ever seen created by a single individual. Hulk still wins, even if Thanos blasting power wasn't taken from him.

Originally posted by carver9
This is the most bias thread I have ever seen created by a single individual. Hulk still wins, even if Thanos blasting power wasn't taken from him.

Lol, shut up, Carver.

A.) This is by no means the most bias thread ever created or even the most biased thread you've personally seen. C'mon, now.

B.) Don't be all Incredible Carter and assume - wrongly - that WWHulk could take on a fully powered Thanos with all of his powers and abilities and win.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Lol, shut up, Carver.

A.) This is by no means the most bias thread ever created or even the most biased thread you've personally seen. C'mon, now.

B.) Don't be all Incredible Carter and assume - wrongly - that WWHulk could take on a fully powered Thanos with all of his powers and abilities and win.

Jake, this thread is a bias thread. Seem like something Quan himself would make.

Why wouldn't Hulk be able to beat a fully powered Thanos outside of BFRing?

Originally posted by carver9
Jake, this thread is a bias thread. Seem like something Quan himself would make.

Why wouldn't Hulk be able to beat a fully powered Thanos outside of BFRing?

I'm not saying it's not, but don't act like this is the most biased thread you ever came across. We both know it's not and the only reason why you're protesting as much is because it pits Thanos against Hulk. Quan would probably make a thread where Thanos can't use his versatility and still argue Thanos winning in the end.

Because Thanos has freakish durability, the ability to mindrape, potent fire power, matter manipulation, etc.

Thanos would literally have to fight down on Hulk's terms for Hulk to have a chance, which is what this thread entails.

Originally posted by Mr.Mxyzptlk
He's not Amped, that's part of his established power set. *sigh*

But that's not really a point worth arguing over.

Can you show scans of Thanos using Gamora level hth skill or Wolverine/blade level agility?

Originally posted by carver9
Jake, this thread is a bias thread. Seem like something Quan himself would make.

Why wouldn't Hulk be able to beat a fully powered Thanos outside of BFRing? Thanos is stronger than the Hulk. He beats the snot out of him at his own game.

Originally posted by quanchi112
All I want is Thanos zoom zoom in my boom boom.

WTF?

Originally posted by TheMask
WTF? Are you trying to get banned ?

I wont cry over it if I get banned. Ive been baned multiple times. it will give me a rest from seeing your UTTER stupidity on a daily baisis.

Originally posted by TheMask
I wont cry over it if I get banned. Ive been baned multiple times. it will give me a rest from seeing your UTTER stupidity on a daily baisis. Oh a returned sock. Bom voyage. You lose once again.

Ps. Thanos wins.

sock? haha you should have been banned ages ago for your low Iq

Originally posted by Silent Master
Can you show scans of Thanos using Gamora level hth skill or Wolverine/blade level agility?
Good question.

Closing to comply with Bada's recent Thanos hiatus. See the pinned thread for all Thanos-related shenanigans.

Originally posted by carver9
This is the most bias thread I have ever seen created by a single individual. Hulk still wins, even if Thanos blasting power wasn't taken from him.

Really?

Why the f*ck do people make these threads, thanos is and always will be on another lvl. Just because carver is biased enough to debate the other way does not mean this fight is any less of a stomp in the favor of the mad titan.

Hulk wins.

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
Really?

Yes...Hulk is a master of powering though attacks. The fight is happening next month...we will see what happens.

Originally posted by carver9
Hulk wins.

This is literally all you can come up with, you don't have any reason or evidence to support your claim but your fanboyism out weighs logic.

Originally posted by carver9
Yes...Hulk is a master of powering though attacks. The fight is happening next month...we will see what happens.

Which fight has Hulk ever beaten Thanos in?

Carver will put you all on ignore because he can't actually answer you on this topic.

Originally posted by Insane Titan
Carver will put you all on ignore because he can't actually answer you on this topic.


Just like he does not have a retort on captain atom vs hulk, dude is hilarious.

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
Which fight has Hulk ever beaten Thanos in?

Neither has a win over the other so I don't know why this question was asked.

Originally posted by carver9
Neither has a win over the other so I don't know why this question was asked.


Well hulk tried to fight him but got swatted away like a fly.

When?

It is not world war hulk, but you love using scans that don't pertain exactly to the op so here it is.

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11115/111158055/4037569-thanos+vs+hulk.jpg

Originally posted by thingy150
It is not world war hulk, but you love using scans that don't pertain exactly to the op so here it is.

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11115/111158055/4037569-thanos+vs+hulk.jpg

Aaaahhhhh, infinity #6. Let's see what Cap and Thor tells Hulk before facing Thanos and the crew.

http://s1143.photobucket.com/user/carver9/media-full/Hulk/Screenshot_2014-06-18-11-00-15_zps44dbf092.png.html

"Hulk, knock on the door, DISTRACT them, soften them up". From the words of Cap.

"Harness your appetite Hulk. Leave some for the rest of us."

Also, lol, Hulk smiled at the punch Thanos hit him with. It didn't even hurt. So we have a Hulk that was told by his boss and friend to hold back and when Thanos punch him, he smiles at the hit. What else ya got? And I don't mind you using scans like that because again, Hulk is Hulk...everything he does is under his own power. Some are just angrier than others but it's still his power that is achieving said goal.

He was told to distract him because that is literally all he can do, if hulk could take him out they would have told him to. Do you seriously think that hulk could take him out but that they told him not to? Hulk was not even worthy enough to distract thanos.

Oh ya and he was not smiling this is the page after
https://encrypted-tbn3.gstatic.com/images? q=tbn:ANd9GcT5RiCt7cb7yDpVmSRQ7mRwSWUQ8_7p7T4cqRnv
4bb36BtFIX6F
No smile

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/10/105634/3924854-hulk+thanos+3.jpg

last one did not work

Oh wait he is smiling lol...ahahha

still does not change the fact he got slapped away like a fly.....he could not even distract the mad titan.

Originally posted by thingy150
He was told to distract him because that is literally all he can do, if hulk could take him out they would have told him to. Do you seriously think that hulk could take him out but that they told him not to? Hulk was not even worthy enough to distract thanos.

Oh ya and he was not smiling this is the page after
https://encrypted-tbn3.gstatic.com/images? q=tbn:ANd9GcT5RiCt7cb7yDpVmSRQ7mRwSWUQ8_7p7T4cqRnv
4bb36BtFIX6F
No smile

He is clearly smiling in the first panel and again, Cap and Thor told Hulk to hold back. Take that as you will but again, the proof is there for you to ignore yet again. Don't know why Cap told him to pull his power along with Thor but the proof is in the writing. I'm debating this no further. I've provided all the evidence i need.

Originally posted by thingy150
He was told to distract him because that is literally all he can do, if hulk could take him out they would have told him to. Do you seriously think that hulk could take him out but that they told him not to? Hulk was not even worthy enough to distract thanos.

Oh ya and he was not smiling this is the page after
https://encrypted-tbn3.gstatic.com/images? q=tbn:ANd9GcT5RiCt7cb7yDpVmSRQ7mRwSWUQ8_7p7T4cqRnv
4bb36BtFIX6F
No smile did you notice how Hulk did want any of Thanos when got back up after Thanos casually swatted him away.

It's clear Thor was the main guy the avengers fought could fight Thanos

Originally posted by carver9
He is clearly smiling in the first panel and again, Cap and Thor told Hulk to hold back. Take that as you will but again, the proof is there for you to ignore yet again. Don't know why Cap told him to pull his power along with Thor but the proof is in the writing. I'm debating this no further. I've provided all the evidence i need.


Yes i already stated in an earlier post i was wrong about the smile..but what does that do for hulk? He smiled and did nothing after he got swatted away like a b*tch, he could have tried to take on thanos again but he knew his place. Thanos stomps hulk

Why would Cap say something stupid like that?

Originally posted by Insane Titan
did you notice how Hulk did want any of Thanos when got back up after Thanos casually swatted him away.

It's clear Thor was the main guy the avengers fought could fight Thanos

Yup i love that they showed thor was the greatest challenge to the titan, hulk is no match for either of them(he should not be for thor but he has been in past years when written wrong)

Originally posted by Reflassshh
Why would Cap say something stupid like that?


Because hulk is only a distraction, he cannot challenge thanos in an actual fight so he was just there to distract him(which did not even work because he got swatted like a tennis ball)

Originally posted by thingy150
Yes i already stated in an earlier post i was wrong about the smile..but what does that do for hulk? He smiled and did nothing after he got swatted away like a b*tch, he could have tried to take on thanos again but he knew his place. Thanos stomps hulk

Oooooorrrrrr, lol, as shown on panel (SMDH) Thanos backed off from Hulk and had his generals charge Hulk instead.

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/10/105634/3924854-hulk+thanos+3.jpg

In which, after this they hit him with the weight of the sun. Doesn't looked like Hulk backed down...look the other way around.

Originally posted by thingy150
Yup i love that they showed thor was the greatest challenge to the titan, hulk is no match for either of them(he should not be for thor but he has been in past years when written wrong)

Sad that Hickman said Hulk is the most powerful on the Avengers.

Originally posted by carver9
Oooooorrrrrr, lol, as shown on panel (SMDH) Thanos backed off from Hulk and had his generals charge Hulk instead.

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/10/105634/3924854-hulk+thanos+3.jpg

In which, after this they hit him with the weight of the sun. Doesn't looked like Hulk backed down...look the other way around.

Thanos didn't back down.

There's no proof of this. All he did was get his generals to attack Hulk. Nothing more nothing less.

We'd have to ask Hickman before we make such assumptions as this.

Originally posted by thingy150
Because hulk is only a distraction, he cannot challenge thanos in an actual fight so he was just there to distract him(which did not even work because he got swatted like a tennis ball)

Lol...is that what you got from it?

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
Thanos didn't back down.

There's no proof of this. All he did was get his generals to attack Hulk. Nothing more nothing less.

We'd have to ask Hickman before we make such assumptions as this.

Didn't say back down, I said backed off and he did back off and let his generals fight instead.

carver, thanos realized that hulk was literally not worth his time, he swatted him and already knew that hulk was no match for him. Are you really going to try and turn that scan back around on thanos? Thanos literally swatted him like a child.

Hickman may have said hulk is more powerful but he showed who can actually stand toe to toe with thanos(thor)

He did not back off, he stayed in the same spot while his generals took care of the small threats(hulk).

Hulk had his chance and he got served as if he were the ball in a tennis match.

Originally posted by thingy150
carver, thanos realized that hulk was literally not worth his time, he swatted him and already knew that hulk was no match for him. Are you really going to try and turn that scan back around on thanos? Thanos literally swatted him like a child.

Hickman may have said hulk is more powerful but he showed who can actually stand toe to toe with thanos(thor)

So you're making up stuff again? Where was any of that said in the comic? Hulk not being worth his time. Thanos did say "generals, take care of this monster for me". Doesn't indicate anything you've just said.

Originally posted by thingy150
He did not back off, he stayed in the same spot while his generals took care of the small threats(hulk).

Hulk had his chance and he got served as if he were the ball in a tennis match.

"Generals, handle this monster for me". If I just witness someone smiling at my punch, I wouldn't fight them either. Him calling in someone to fight for him is backing off from a fight. He didn't do that against anyone there except Hulk.

HAHHAH hulk was long gone, he did not even get to see him smile because hulk flew away as soon as thanos touched him. He let his generals do the work for him because the people fighting him were below him, so he got his underlings to take care of the small threats.

Are you seriously trying to use a scan of thanos swatting hulk as evidence for hulk winning, is that how desperate you are?

Originally posted by carver9
Didn't say back down, I said backed off and he did back off and let his generals fight instead.

Fair enough, I was just going on what you said on the bottom, but fairplay.

If he let his generals attack Hulk that would be odd right? I mean why send people most likely to be vastly inferior to you in power. He'd be dooming them to certain death otherwise.

I disagree with you, I don't think he was backing down/off. I just don't think he would send people less powerful than him to take down a supposed threat that you presume merits something powerful to defeat.

He knew Proxima among others could quickly finish Hulk so he sent them. He had things on his mind. He was a bit busy with other things.

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
Fair enough, I was just going on what you said on the bottom, but fairplay.

If he let his generals attack Hulk that would be odd right? I mean why send people most likely to be vastly inferior to you in power. He'd be dooming them to certain death otherwise.

I disagree with you, I don't think he was backing down/off. I just don't think he would send people less powerful than him to take down a supposed threat that you presume merits something powerful to defeat.

Or he realized they had a plot weapon that would temp stop Hulk in which it did. It's obvious Hickman didn't want Hulk involved in the battle which is the reason he was taken out via plot. What more can they do than what Thanos punch did (which was nothing)? Let's not forget, thanos DID attack Hulk and it did absolutely nothing to him whereas Proxima spear did far more damage.

Originally posted by carver9
He is clearly smiling in the first panel and again, Cap and Thor told Hulk to hold back. Take that as you will but again, the proof is there for you to ignore yet again. Don't know why Cap told him to pull his power along with Thor but the proof is in the writing. I'm debating this no further. I've provided all the evidence i need.

I don't understand this. Thanos slapped him around and because Hulk had a smirk on his face, the feat is invalid to you?

Originally posted by carver9
Or he realized they had a plot weapon that would temp stop Hulk in which it did. It's obvious Hickman didn't want Hulk involved in the battle which is the reason he was taken out via plot. What more can they do than what Thanos punch did (which was nothing)? Let's not forget, thanos DID attack Hulk and it did absolutely nothing to him whereas Proxima spear did far more damage.

Like I said.

"He knew Proxima among others could quickly finish Hulk so he sent them."

Thanos could have punched him repeatedly and much harder. But like I said above happened.

Proxima's spear specifically drained Hulk so again it was a foil to Hulk.

It doesn't mean just because of what I have said that Thanos couldn't beat him. It just means that for Hickman's reasons Thanos told the generals to attack him after Hulk swatted him away.

Thanos had a whole bunch of heroes to contend with.

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
I don't understand this. Thanos slapped him around and because Hulk had a smirk on his face, the feat is invalid to you?

Fanboy logic is not real logic, do you see his avatar, he hates thanos because he knows deep down that thanos is better in every way, this scares him because he rides hulk so hard.

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
Like I said.

"He knew Proxima among others could quickly finish Hulk so he sent them."

Thanos could have punched him repeatedly and much harder. But like I said above happened.

Proxima's spear specifically drained Hulk so again it was a foil to Hulk.

It doesn't mean just because of what I have said that Thanos couldn't beat him. It just means that for Hickman's reasons Thanos told the generals to attack him after Hulk swatted him away.

Thanos had a whole bunch of heroes to contend with.

So Thanos didn't punch him at his hardest during that hit? Prove it with scans.

Also, prove that Thanos could of repeatedly punched Hulk. If it was that easy, he wouldn't have sent in his generals.

Also, he didn't swat him away. Look at the scans. Swatting and punching are two different things.

Oh my god. I might be getting off today. Can't take this making up stuff anymore.

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
I don't understand this. Thanos slapped him around and because Hulk had a smirk on his face, the feat is invalid to you?

Slapped him around? He PUNCHED him ONCE.

Originally posted by carver9
"Generals, handle this monster for me". If I just witness someone smiling at my punch, I wouldn't fight them either. Him calling in someone to fight for him is backing off from a fight. He didn't do that against anyone there except Hulk.

I get my underlings to fetch my coffee too.

Originally posted by carver9
So Thanos didn't punch him at his hardest during that hit? Prove it with scans.

Also, prove that Thanos could of repeatedly punched Hulk. If it was that easy, he wouldn't have sent in his generals.

Also, he didn't swat him away. Look at the scans. Swatting and punching are two different things.

Oh my god. I might be getting off today. Can't take this making up stuff anymore.

You have to prove it was his "hardest" punch then. I didn't say it was his weakest.

He would have ran over to Hulk or teleported and repeatedly kept punching him. Like I said he had other things to do than contend with Hulk, which is why he sent his generals.

I used the term loosely. He punched/swatted him whatever you want to say. He wasn't using his full power.

If you want to go that's up to you. I am just being honest and saying what happened. I'll tweet Hickman now and ask him.

I have tweeted him now. H emay not answer but I done what I thought was right.

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
You have to prove it was his "hardest" punch then. I didn't say it was his weakest.

He would have ran over to Hulk or teleported and repeatedly kept punching him. Like I said he had other things to do than contend with Hulk, which is why he sent his generals.

I used the term loosely. He punched/swatted him whatever you want to say. He wasn't using his full power.

If you want to go that's up to you. I am just being honest and saying what happened. I'll tweet Hickman now and ask him.

I have tweeted him now. H emay not answer but I done what I thought was right.

You're the one making assumptions that he held back. Prove it.

Aaaahhhh, so Hulk was going to sit there and let Thanks punch on him? Makes sense. Ya know, the same guy who smiled at his first blow.

There's a difference between swatting and punching. No proof that be swatted, especially since we clearly see a punch.

No insult coming from me but this post seems like nothing but a dream of something that didn't happen.

Originally posted by carver9
You're the one making assumptions that he held back. Prove it.

Aaaahhhh, so Hulk was going to sit there and let Thanks punch on him? Makes sense. Ya know, the same guy who smiled at his first blow.

There's a difference between swatting and punching. No proof that be swatted, especially since we clearly see a punch.

No insult coming from me but this post seems like nothing but a dream of something that didn't happen.

You're making assumptions he didn't hold back. Prove that.

Never said that, don't be silly.

I already answered that.

Thanks for your input here. Your opinion doesn't mean it was a dream.
I haven't got much else to say really. I am busy making a new respect thread so I hope you enjoy the rest of the debate with everyone else.

I'll never get this done otherwise.

I love that carver inevitably contradicts himself multiple times when he debates

What ignores is that fact Thanos makes it clear Thor was the main guy to contend with and Hulk was only a distraction.

Hulk could have easily gone after Thanos , plus Thanos didn't even have to energy change his punch to swat Hulk away.

Thanos of easily reverted Hulk back to banner just like Proxima did. He did a similar thing to Captain Marvell whilst he(Thanos) was in his weakest incarnation.

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
You're making assumptions he didn't hold back. Prove that.

Never said that, don't be silly.

I already answered that.

Thanks for your input here. Your opinion doesn't mean it was a dream.
I haven't got much else to say really. I am busy making a new respect thread so I hope you enjoy the rest of the debate with everyone else.

I'll never get this done otherwise.

Show me Thanos ever holding back and provide scans. Thanos is a villain, why would he hold back. I want some scans of this along with proof of your assumptions on him holding back.

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
You're making assumptions he didn't hold back. Prove that.

Never said that, don't be silly.

I already answered that.

Thanks for your input here. Your opinion doesn't mean it was a dream.
I haven't got much else to say really. I am busy making a new respect thread so I hope you enjoy the rest of the debate with everyone else.

I'll never get this done otherwise. in his first ongoing by Starlin Thanos admits he doesn't needlessly kill. So he probably held back against Hulk

Originally posted by carver9
Show me Thanos ever holding back and provide scans. Thanos is a villain, why would he hold back. I want some scans of this along with proof of your assumptions on him holding back.

Show me proof that he wasn't holding back.

Again you're assuming he wasn't. I cannot answer this any other way. I am busy making a respect thread.

Thanos also held back when he had the Infinity Gauntlet. Cut himself off from the power etcetc or whatever the dialogue was.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Thanos also held back when he had the Infinity Gauntlet. Cut himself off from the power etcetc or whatever the dialogue was.

Why did he cut himself from the full power?

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
Show me proof that he wasn't holding back.

Again you're assuming he wasn't. I cannot answer this any other way. I am busy making a respect thread.

You're the one that said he held back, so the proof is on you. Also, show me Thanos ever holding back without context.

Originally posted by carver9
You're the one that said he held back, so the proof is on you. Also, show me Thanos ever holding back without context.

I can't answer in another way.

I am busy making a respect thread.

While I am gone, here are all of my posts. Quote me where I specifically said he held back.

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
Thanos didn't back down.

There's no proof of this. All he did was get his generals to attack Hulk. Nothing more nothing less.

We'd have to ask Hickman before we make such assumptions as this.

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
Fair enough, I was just going on what you said on the bottom, but fairplay.

If he let his generals attack Hulk that would be odd right? I mean why send people most likely to be vastly inferior to you in power. He'd be dooming them to certain death otherwise.

I disagree with you, I don't think he was backing down/off. I just don't think he would send people less powerful than him to take down a supposed threat that you presume merits something powerful to defeat.

He knew Proxima among others could quickly finish Hulk so he sent them. He had things on his mind. He was a bit busy with other things.

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
Like I said.

"He knew Proxima among others could quickly finish Hulk so he sent them."

Thanos could have punched him repeatedly and much harder. But like I said above happened.

Proxima's spear specifically drained Hulk so again it was a foil to Hulk.

It doesn't mean just because of what I have said that Thanos couldn't beat him. It just means that for Hickman's reasons Thanos told the generals to attack him after Hulk swatted him away.

Thanos had a whole bunch of heroes to contend with.

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
You have to prove it was his "hardest" punch then. I didn't say it was his weakest.

He would have ran over to Hulk or teleported and repeatedly kept punching him. Like I said he had other things to do than contend with Hulk, which is why he sent his generals.

I used the term loosely. He punched/swatted him whatever you want to say. He wasn't using his full power.

If you want to go that's up to you. I am just being honest and saying what happened. I'll tweet Hickman now and ask him.

I have tweeted him now. H emay not answer but I done what I thought was right.

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
You're making assumptions he didn't hold back. Prove that.

Never said that, don't be silly.

I already answered that.

Thanks for your input here. Your opinion doesn't mean it was a dream.
I haven't got much else to say really. I am busy making a new respect thread so I hope you enjoy the rest of the debate with everyone else.

I'll never get this done otherwise.

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
Show me proof that he wasn't holding back.

Again you're assuming he wasn't. I cannot answer this any other way. I am busy making a respect thread.

Which I didn't. We know evidence of Thanos's power when he actually is using it. This wasn't a time. So don't start another debate with me Carver as I am busy.

If you answer asking me to prove something I haven't stated again.I will send you an exact copy of this post.

Carver the proof was on you when you had to prove that thanos was amped against tyrant, he is making an assumption off of the scans just like you did.

Good job contradicting yourself buddy.

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
I can't answer in another way.

I am busy making a respect thread.

While I am gone, here are all of my posts. Quote me where I specifically said he held back.

"Thanos could have punched him repeatedly and much harder".

Originally posted by carver9
"Thanos could have punched him repeatedly and much harder".

Does that mean that I said he held back?

No, it just means I said he could have hit him harder. I didn't say he was holding back did I.

Why didn't he use a punches that could near beat Surfer to death? Why didn't he attack him with ferocity like he did with Odin or Galactus. We wont ever know.

I never implied anything else.

Originally posted by carver9
You're the one that said he held back, so the proof is on you. Also, show me Thanos ever holding back without context.

Moving the goalposts, when it suits you, I see!

I'm losing count of the times I owned you just today

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
Does that mean that I said he held back?

No, it just means I said he could have hit him harder. I didn't say he was holding back did I.

Why didn't he use a punches that could near beat Surfer to death? Why didn't he attack him with ferocity like he did with Odin or Galactus. We wont ever know.

I never implied anything else. you're proof is that fact Thanos didn't energy charge his fists why he punched Hulk

Originally posted by carver9
Slapped him around? He PUNCHED him ONCE.

He didn't even punch him bro, he back handed him and sent him flying. Hulk never came back to question who was stronger again.

He knew. Hence the smirk on his face.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Moving the goalposts, when it suits you, I see!

I'm losing count of the times I owned you just today

Lol...you didn't own me today though.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...you didn't own me today though.

I believe we have all bent you over with Hulk and had our way with you two lovable jimmie rustlers.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...you didn't own me today though.


I owned you today, when you said that hulk would beat cap atom by dispersing his energy and i destroyed your pitiful theory in 3 different ways

luv ya

Originally posted by carver9
So Thanos didn't punch him at his hardest during that hit? Prove it with scans.

Oh my god. I might be getting off today. Can't take this making up stuff anymore. \

It was casual backhand.

Don't get rustled,

http://img2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20120309043943/gyropedia/images/9/91/1327974741374.png

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
He didn't even punch him bro, he back handed him and sent him flying. Hulk never came back to question who was stronger again.

He knew. Hence the smirk on his face.



So this is a backhand?

LHM

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/15/150339/3926424-2913700827-ff0a2.jpg

Originally posted by carver9


So this is a backhand?

LHM

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/15/150339/3926424-2913700827-ff0a2.jpg

Nah its just a inferior being flying away after he gets hit

Originally posted by thingy150
Nah its just a inferior being flying away after he gets hit

We will see on Dec 3rd.

Originally posted by carver9
We will see on Dec 3rd.


Oh shit thats the day after my birthday....NICE

So carver your life really depends on the outcome of this fight lol, if thanos wins will you even come back to the forum lol

Originally posted by thingy150
So carver your life really depends on the outcome of this fight lol, if thanos wins will you even come back to the forum lol

Never said who would win the fight between the two but everyone here better hope the fight is a massacre on Thanos part, because if not...

Also, this is a 6 comic showdown. Six. Starlin himself said that Thanos is weary of facing Hulk so if this fight turns out to be anything like Starlin is making it out to be, then there are going to be a lot of unhappy Thanos fans along with a lot of face down people on KMC who under rates Hulk.

Originally posted by carver9
Never said who would win the fight between the two but everyone here better hope the fight is a massacre on Thanos part, because if not...

Also, this is a 6 comic showdown. Six. Starlin himself said that Thanos is weary of facing Hulk so if this fight turns out to be anything like Starlin is making it out to be, then there are going to be a lot of unhappy Thanos fans along with a lot of face down people on KMC who under rates Hulk.

It's 4 I think.

Plus like I said before I think it's gonna be close. Because what would be the point of making the comic then Thanos brings out some deus ex machina force and beats him.

I think because of there being no point otherwise Hulk will fight Thanos and Thanos will credit Hulk somehow and he either puts him down in some way or the fight is interrupted by one of the other villains in the story.

Originally posted by carver9
Never said who would win the fight between the two but everyone here better hope the fight is a massacre on Thanos part, because if not...

Also, this is a 6 comic showdown. Six. Starlin himself said that Thanos is weary of facing Hulk so if this fight turns out to be anything like Starlin is making it out to be, then there are going to be a lot of unhappy Thanos fans along with a lot of face down people on KMC who under rates Hulk.

Starlin is literally the only person who thinks hulk stands a chance against thanos, any other writer would have thanos crush hulk so it does not matter.

Thanos is just better, he has better feats, he has a better power set, he has a better name, he is just BETTER.

Hulk standing toe to toe with thanos is all PIS, starlin is going to write a PIS filled fight, who cares.

Originally posted by thingy150
Starlin is literally the only person who thinks hulk stands a chance against thanos, any other writer would have thanos crush hulk so it does not matter.

Thanos is just better, he has better feats, he has a better power set, he has a better name, he is just BETTER.

Lol...Pak said nothing short of Galactus could stop Hulk. Hickman said Hulk is the most powerful being on the Avengers and the team consists of High Herald and trans tiers. Waid said no one could beat Hulk. Starlin thinks of Hulk as unbeatable. The list goes on and on and on. A lot of writers put Hulk as one of the most powerful being in Marvel. Sorry you didn't know that.

You might want to look at Hulk fts...Ya know, the character you know little of. Then Holla at me.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...Pak said nothing short of Galactus could stop Hulk. Hickman said Hulk is the most powerful being on the Avengers and the team consists of High Herald and trans tiers. Waid said no one could beat Hulk. Starlin thinks of Hulk as unbeatable. The list goes on and on and on. A lot of writers put Hulk as one of the most powerful being in Marvel. Sorry you didn't know that.

You might want to look at Hulk fts...Ya know, the character you know little of. Then Holla at me.

Hulk is not even close to one of the most powerful beings in marvel, he is not on that level, look at me seriously and tell me that he is on the level of actual top tier characters like galactus, beyonder, franklin richards, TOAA, tyrant, odin, zeus, LT, dormammu...etc.

The list of the people who could stomp hulk goes on and on. Hulk is not even close to as powerful as you think he is and i have read a good amount of hulk.

Before commenting on any thread with hulk in it actually do some research on the character he is fighting. When you dont know about the character you tend to get embarrassed(like in atom vs hulk)

Originally posted by thingy150
Hulk is not even close to one of the most powerful beings in marvel, he is not on that level, look at me seriously and tell me that he is on the level of actual top tier characters like galactus, beyonder, franklin richards, TOAA, tyrant, odin, zeus, LT, dormammu...etc.

The list of the people who could stomp hulk goes on and on. Hulk is not even close to as powerful as you think he is and i have read a good amount of hulk.

Before commenting on any thread with hulk in it actually do some research on the character he is fighting. When you dont know about the character you tend to get embarrassed(like in atom vs hulk)


You said writers don't think of Hulk as Starlin does, I posted what I've read from writers themselves...interviews from writers that has been shared with the forum. I don't think of Hulk as being on their level but Marvel view of the character is extremely high.

Hulk is pretty much on the power scale that I think he is on based off fts. The guy nearly overpowered a freaking abstract not too long ago.

Atom sucks.

Originally posted by carver9
You said writers don't think of Hulk as Starlin does, I posted what I've read from writers themselves...interviews from writers that has been shared with the forum. I don't think of Hulk as being on their level but Marvel view of the character is extremely high.

Hulk is pretty much on the power scale that I think he is on based off fts. The guy nearly overpowered a freaking abstract not too long ago.

Atom sucks.

Lol Cap Atom wrecks him and you are still salty from when i wrecked you in that thread. You provided no links or anything to prove those writers said that and even then writers say some dumb sh*t. I saw some writers say that movie predator would beat comic wolverine...they say dumb sh*t.

Originally posted by thingy150
So carver your life really depends on the outcome of this fight lol, if thanos wins will you even come back to the forum lol


Oh, he'll be back but I'm sure he'll have some kind of BS lame excuse ready for Hulk getting his *** kicked.

Carver, I formally ask you to show me on the doll where they rustled your Jimmies.

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
Carver, I formally ask you to show me on the doll where they rustled your Jimmies.




I spit coke all over my comp i laughed so hard

Originally posted by thingy150


I spit coke all over my comp i laughed so hard

Originally posted by carver9
Hulk wins. I will give you one post to recant this awful post.

People are joking when they say Thanus wins......right?

Originally posted by Raisen
People are joking when they say Thanus wins......right?


LOL. That's a joke, right?

Originally posted by Raisen
People are joking when they say Thanus wins......right?


If you aren't trolling you need to read some thanos my friend.

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11115/111158055/4037569-thanos+vs+hulk.jpg

Thanos did this to hulk, punted him like a foam football

Originally posted by Star428
LOL. That's a joke, right?


Lol ikr, he must be new to comics if its not a joke, only people who have not read comics think that hulk is the "strongest there is".

Originally posted by thingy150
If you aren't trolling you need to read some thanos my friend.

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11115/111158055/4037569-thanos+vs+hulk.jpg

Thanos did this to hulk, punted him like a foam football

Are you impressed by that?

Originally posted by carver9
Are you impressed by that?

Yes i am impressed by hulk trying to blitz thanos and being casually hit away like a 3 year old kid with brittle bone disease.

Originally posted by Raisen
People are joking when they say Thanus wins......right? Thanos, 10/10.