Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who wins, no bfr!

Kurse

Originally posted by h1a8
Kurse

Thanos is quite strong you know!

Thanos would win after a really good fight

Originally posted by golem370
Thanos would win after a really good fight

I think it's to close to call 50:50 split...

Thanos has shown taking on Thor when he either had the power gem or was in beserker mode which has been said he beserker made he is 10 times stronger then normal. Plus since the damage that Tyrant and Odin did to Thanos couldn't keep him down I dount Kurse could either oh and the Maker

Originally posted by golem370
Thanos has shown taking on Thor when he either had the power gem or was in beserker mode which has been said he beserker made he is 10 times stronger then normal. Plus since the damage that Tyrant and Odin did to Thanos couldn't keep him down I dount Kurse could either oh and the Maker

Persuasive arguments Golem 370

Warrior madness is supposed to amp Thor by 10x, however Thor wasn't in WM when he fought Thanos.

Kurse=4x stronger than Thor. I doubt that equals Thor with warrior madness+ power gem. Thanos win. At first Thanos makes him work for it, but eventually he wears Kurse down.

Thanos has never fought Thor w/WM and power gem.

Originally posted by Zenophobe
Thanos is quite strong you know!

I wouldn't give him being more than twice as strong as Thor. There is no evidence to support the contrary.

Originally posted by golem370
Thanos has shown taking on Thor when he either had the power gem or was in beserker mode which has been said he beserker made he is 10 times stronger then normal. Plus since the damage that Tyrant and Odin did to Thanos couldn't keep him down I dount Kurse could either oh and the Maker

Thanos never fought a 10x Thor. Energy blast durability isn't the same as blunt force durability. A normal Thor can and has rocked Thanos with Mjolnir.

^He can rock most opponents with mjolnir...!

Alright here is a website with the story line

Thor- http://marvel.com/comic_books/collection/36073/thor_blood_thunder_trade_paperback

It wasn't true WM, Thor had a mental break due to Odin's history of messing with his mind, this was stated near the end of the arc.

You just read the story line he was in beserker mode

" When the God of Thunder goes berserk"

Thanos.

Ignore everything what h1a8 says.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Thanos has never fought Thor w/WM and power gem.

Sorry, but I disagree.

Thanos is very strong and WM Thor only bloodied his nose, wow!

Thanos .

Originally posted by Zenophobe
Thanos is very strong and WM Thor only bloodied his nose, wow!

Thanos never fought a WM Thor.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Thanos never fought a WM Thor.

Surely he fought Thor in Blood and Thunder, the story about a "Warrior Madness" Thor..... Where Thor had "Warrior Madness"..amirite?

It wasn't true WM, this was stated in the book just after Thanos trapped him in the force block. Thor's insanity was caused by Odin tampering with Thor's mind so many times.

Originally posted by Silent Master
It wasn't true WM, this was stated in the book just after Thanos trapped him in the force block. Thor's insanity was caused by Odin tampering with Thor's mind so many times.

So the arc where everyone kept saying how much stronger Thor was and how he had Warrior Madness and a Power Gem wasn't about that at all?

Originally posted by Zenophobe
So the arc where everyone kept saying how much stronger Thor was and how he had Warrior Madness and a Power Gem wasn't about that at all?

He had WM.

Originally posted by Hyperion Prime
He had WM.

I think so also, as that was the story's plot!

Originally posted by Hyperion Prime
He had WM.

Try reading the story, it wasn't true WM.

Originally posted by Hyperion Prime
He had WM.

No he didn't. WM has no cure. Thor was suffering from madness but not a 10x increase in strength thats for sure. He wasn't holding back is all.

It doesn't matter if it was TRUE WM or not... It was made CLEAR Thor was fighting at a higher level than usual... Many people mention this fact and people who know Thor... Examples being Sif and Warlock and BRB.. They all commented one way or another that it was WM or that he was fighting at a higher level. So it doesn't matter if it was TRUE WM or just not holding back and going all out... In either case Thanos took on a Thor not holding back WITH the PG.

Before the gem, Thor was only fighting at the level that he's at when he doesn't pull his punches. No external amp. Odin's word trumps anyone else' word anyway.

Yeah good showing by Thanos.

Yea....Thanos knew even he couldn't beat that Thor, which is why he left to retrieve the force-block gun.

The experimental anti-Thor gun

The best part is that Thanos admitted that once Thor was strong enough to break out of the block, they wouldn't have a chance of stopping him.

Then in the next issue Odin easily breaks out of the block. IOW, by Thanos' on words, he didn't have a chance in hell of beating Odin. and his words were proven accurate during the fight, as Odin beat him down.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Yea....Thanos knew even he couldn't beat that Thor, which is why he left to retrieve the force-block gun.

Please prove Thanos couldn't beat Thor.. i would like to see the narration proving this "fact" cause what WAS SAID BY THANOS on panel was that he was simply over the fight... NOTHING about him knowing he was going to lose. Provide proof for that stance.

With the power gem, Thor steam rolled through Silver Surfer, Adam Warlock, Doctor Strange, Dumb Drax, and the rest of the Infinity Watch. Yet Thanos was stalemating Thor with the PG by himself. Regular Thor without the PG would get stomped by that team. So the question is how much stronger does regular Thor have to be to stomp Surfer, Warlock, Strange + the rest of the Infinity Watch like he did with the PG?

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
It doesn't matter if it was TRUE WM or not... It was made CLEAR Thor was fighting at a higher level than usual... Many people mention this fact and people who know Thor... Examples being Sif and Warlock and BRB.. They all commented one way or another that it was WM or that he was fighting at a higher level. So it doesn't matter if it was TRUE WM or just not holding back and going all out... In either case Thanos took on a Thor not holding back WITH the PG.

Originally posted by Hyperion Prime


again!

It wasn't true Warrior's Madness. This was stated and shown in the comics. Don't see how anyone can disagree with blatant on-panel proof, but okay.

It was abundantly clear that it was a deranged and bloodlusted Thor, though.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
It wasn't true Warrior's Madness. This was stated and shown in the comics. Don't see how anyone can disagree with blatant on-panel proof, but okay.

It was abundantly clear that it was a deranged and bloodlusted Thor, though.

I don't think any of them actually read the books.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
It wasn't true Warrior's Madness. This was stated and shown in the comics. Don't see how anyone can disagree with blatant on-panel proof, but okay.

It was abundantly clear that it was a deranged and bloodlusted Thor, though.

It was also stated throughout the arc he had WARRIOR MADNESS10111

Originally posted by Zenophobe
It was also stated throughout the arc he had WARRIOR MADNESS10111

They thought it was Warrior's Madness.

Odin revealed it was not and rather just a mental breakdown.

Originally posted by Zenophobe
It was also stated throughout the arc he had WARRIOR MADNESS10111

No, it was stated that they believed it was WM, however it was found out to be due to Odin tampering with Thor's mind and not true WM.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
They thought it was Warrior's Madness.

Odin revealed it was not and rather just a mental breakdown.

Or they were right and Odin wanted to save Thor the stigma attached to mental health issues as any kind Father would!

Originally posted by Zenophobe
Or they were right and Odin wanted to save Thor the stigma attached to mental health issues as any kind Father would!

The story made it clear that it wasn't true WM.

Originally posted by Zenophobe
So the arc where everyone kept saying how much stronger Thor was and how he had Warrior Madness and a Power Gem wasn't about that at all?

The next comic SAID it wasn't WM. That's the highest proof possible that he wasn't in WM.

Exactly, it was just a mentally unstable Thor with the power gem.

That's horrible saying Thor is mental!!!!!