Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

1st Normal fight
2nd Who is a better Spider-Man?
3rd Who's fighting style is better?

Why don't we wait till Garfield gets two more movies before comparing them in versus?

I had actually wanted to make this thread XD

Though I agree, we should let Garfield get at least one more movie. Two would take too long.

Originally posted by Estacado
1st Normal fight
2nd Who is a better Spider-Man?
3rd Who's fighting style is better?


if we limit Tobey to his first film, I would say maybe even but i have to rewatch the first Spidey to be sure..

Tobey was better Spidey

limiting Tobey to first film, Garfield slightly better

ASM's punches wouldn't do much damage to SM, if any.

Tobey Peter would school Garfield Peter, no contest. Superior spider-sense, superior strength and durability. Only thing Garfield might have on Peter is speed.

Originally posted by Tzeentch._
Tobey Peter would school Garfield Peter, no contest. Superior spider-sense, superior strength and durability. Only thing Garfield might have on Peter is speed.

What's up with the stupid screen-name, brah?

There is a good point there, Tobey Spidey was tanking hits that would have put Garfield Spidey down for a month.

Garfield was just a teen still but Tobey Spiderman was not the real Spiderman where his webs comes out through his skin. Garfield for the win cus he was a lot funnier.

Originally posted by lilshogun
Garfield was just a teen still but Tobey Spiderman was not the real Spiderman where his webs comes out through his skin. Garfield for the win cus he was a lot funnier.

Biological web-shooters were had in the comics too.

Maguire stomps. Even if we just go by his performance in the first movie, he is still way better. Garfield kept running around shooting webs instead of actually fighting.Originally posted by Pwned
There is a good point there, Tobey Spidey was tanking hits that would have put Garfield Spidey down for a month. This. GG beat the crap out of him and he still came back as strong as ever.

Originally posted by Robtard
What's up with the stupid screen-name, brah?

What's up with the stupid thread topic? Jeeeeesus H christ this shit is dumb... *massive facepalm*

Originally posted by Patient_Leech
What's up with the stupid thread topic? Jeeeeesus H christ this shit is dumb... *massive facepalm*

You just don't get the point of a vs do you.....

1.Maguire has more feats.
2.Garfield
3.Garfield

Garfield will tell Maguire he just banged MJ. Maguire will burst into tears. Garfield will pound on him.

Garfield wins cause he's smart and cocky whilst Maguire was a complete wuss bag.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Garfield will tell Maguire he just banged MJ. Maguire will burst into tears. Garfield will pound on him.

Garfield wins cause he's smart and cocky whilst Maguire was a complete wuss bag.

Maguire will beat Garfield like he did MJ.

Originally posted by the ninjak
Maguire will beat Garfield like he did MJ.
That was only because of the black suit though without it Tobey is a pussy...

Originally posted by Estacado
That was only because of the black suit though without it Tobey is a pussy...

What's your point?

Tobey's a pussy without the blacksuit, or it took a black suit to beat MJ like SpideyMags will beat SpideyGarf?

Because both points are heavily wrong.

Still haven't seen the Amazing Spider-man, but did Garfield-Man do anything as awesome as stopping a train or tanking a grenade with his face?

Maguire Spider-Man wins as of now. He has much better strength and durability feats.

Originally posted by Psychotron
Still haven't seen the Amazing Spider-man, but did Garfield-Man do anything as awesome as stopping a train or tanking a grenade with his face? No.