Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Modified Hunger Game rules. They are placed in an enclosed forest and given 3 days to kill each other till only 1 remains. They each bring their preferred bows but are given only 10 standard arrows each. No explosive arrows or whatever. They are also each given 1 long knife and 1 canteen full of water.

They will need to hunt for food in the forest as well as make any additional arrows on their own. Who wins?

Legolas stomps.

Legolas and Hawkeye could both solo.

So who goes down between Legolas and Hawkeye?

Originally posted by FrothByte
So who goes down between Legolas and Hawkeye?

Legolas, he's definitely either bisexual or outright gay, from what we've seen.

Ha! Legolas is on his home turf, he stomps.

spite, spite and more spite.. Legolas stomps and stomps hard

Originally posted by BruceSkywalker
spite, spite and more spite.. Legolas stomps and stomps hard

THIS.

+

Dudes, he's a frikkin ELF.

Legolas kills them both with the same arrow.

Hawkeye by feats is frankly the more impressive shot.

But in a forest environment, and with hunting as the stip, he is sure to win.

Originally posted by NemeBro
Hawkeye by feats is frankly the more impressive shot.

But in a forest environment, and with hunting as the stip, he is sure to win.

What feats would you suggest are his better ones?

Originally posted by Kaibs
What feats would you suggest are his better ones?

The blind shooting the Chitauri flyer, adjusting perfectly for severe wind turbulance and the shot that shut down the hellicarrier were epic feats of archery.

Legolas has the range advantage though, he made an extremely long shot at a goblin while they were fleeing Moria and then killed the globlin riding the worg from a great distance.

Both have never missed, iirc. With the exception of Legolas not bringing down the berserk Uruk, though that wasn't so much of a miss(he hit the neck twice) as a plot device.

Not that it matters here, as neither is going to miss, so it comes down to who is stealthier, faster on the draw and can possibly dodge an arrow(s). Legolas I'd say.

Legolas also has a tentative millenia or so of experience on the other two, so yeah...

Legolas stomps. Hawkeye is the better shot, but legolas is better everything else.

We should add Oliver Queen to this fight

Oliver Queen would also get stomped. Hawkeye and Legolas >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Oliver at shooting arrows

Funny thing is, Katniss I believe is the only one on this list to actually dodge an arrow or fast moving projectile.

Legolas has made some acrobatic dodges.

Originally posted by NemeBro
Hawkeye by feats is frankly the more impressive shot.

But in a forest environment, and with hunting as the stip, he is sure to win.

Originally posted by Firefly218
Legolas has made some acrobatic dodges.

Has he? I haven't had 16 hours to watch all of the trilogy in years. I know he did some fancy footwork in melee combat, and I think he may have dodged some in Hobbit, but I can't remember for sure.

Legolas here, thanks to the overall scenario. In a pure archery contest, based on feats, I would pick Hawkeye. But in a forest environment, Legolas has all the advantages.