Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Captain Marvel- Classic

VS

Beta Ray Bill

Hero or horse-face?

Korbinite

Could go either way, but if I were a betting man I'd put my $$$ on Billy.

Captain Marvel.

Cap wins.

Cap dropkicks Beta into a vat of boiling chemicals.

Billy Batson has a new pony.

Bill

What weapon does Bill have?

Stormbreaker is his only weapon.

Bill wins then.

How?

...what other weapons would he have? Skuttlebut?

Cap Marvel wins.

pretty close to a split, imo. had it been decided whether new billy>old billy yet? i'd give bill a 6/10 advantage in this, using classic cm.

Originally posted by KingD19
How?

Cause he has the Stormbreaker

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
...what other weapons would he have? Skuttlebut?

Cap Marvel wins.

Shazzam aint getting him outa this one man. Sorry, stormbreaker would ruin his day.

I hate arguing DC since the reboot is so recent..

There should be some kind of bare minimum time rule between reboots, so they can build up some feats before putting in a debate..

Pre-Reboot Cap would definitely win.

I don't know exactly what DcNU Cap's deal is, but he seems to be a pretty damn strong mage.

And Captain Marvel is a superman level character. Capable of the same type of crazy feats Black Adam pulled off, and he's got a few of his own.

Bill is not winning more than a few.

Could go either way, split.

Originally posted by Supra
Shazzam aint getting him outa this one man. Sorry, stormbreaker would ruin his day. Here's the official tier list for every hero in comics:

1) Iron Fist

2) Captain Billiam Marvelton the 1st, Batman, Daredevil, Captain America, Hawkeye, Optimus Prime, Space Punisher (added in the most recent edition)

The third tier and so on is too large to list, but the first two are complete.

I don't see Beta on Billy's tier, do you?

This is how the fight goes:
mLDidwx7Yfs

Originally posted by Supra
Bill wins then.

What is Stormbreaker going to do that stops Captain Marvel?

Originally posted by LordofBrooklyn
What is Stormbreaker going to do that stops Captain Marvel?

Stormbreaker has enough juice to put down Captain Marvel, either via brute force or EP. That's a dumb question.

Originally posted by Dampyre
Stormbreaker has enough juice to put down Captain Marvel, either via brute force or EP. That's a dumb question.

Given Marvel's level of invulnerability and speed it would be dumb to presume he can't withstand it.

Stormbreaker can certainly affect Captain Marvel but ultimately, this is an uphill battle for Beta Ray Bill.

Cap is used to taking on Black Adam, who is basically Beta Ray Bill on stereoids. Good fight, but Bill edges him out, noticeably.

Captain Marvel

Originally posted by LordofBrooklyn
Given Marvel's level of invulnerability and speed it would be dumb to presume he can't withstand it.

Captain Marvel isn't the Destroyer. He can and will be hurt if Stormbreaker connects. It's absurd to think that a character on that level will simply no-sell a weapon that is basically equal to Thor's hammer.

But it's absurd to think that it'll do him in just like that when he's more or less Superman's equal with no heat vision and stuff, but he does have magical powers.

Magical invulnerability, no less!

Originally posted by KingD19
But it's absurd to think that it'll do him in just like that when he's more or less Superman's equal with no heat vision and stuff, but he does have magical powers.

Storbreaker has hurt folks more durable than Captain Marvel. Superman isn't Captain Marvel. He's Marvel's superior, IMO. I guess we have a difference of opinion.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Magical invulnerability, no less!

And? Magic is just another power source that can be overcome with enough power.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Magical invulnerability, no less!

and....? adam is magical. do HIS punches affect cm? of course they do. the hammer would do likewise--only the hammer hits harder than adam's fists imo. this would be really close, no doubt about it, but i think bill has a greater variety of attacks and would accumulate enough damage to take him out for a slight majority.

True.

I'm just saying, it SEEMS to be operating on a diff level to what we would call 'science based' invulnerability, at least, according to Cap:

http://i1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/Delta1938/Untitled-Scanned-06.jpg

Btw, Superman was also there....

*waits for the House of El to show up*

But I just put that there because I was adding my original post on to KingD's.

Bill wins.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Billy wins.

Correct

Originally posted by CosmicComet
Correct I am always correct. Beta Ray Billy wins.

Captain "Beta Ray Billy" Marvel?

Since when did Billy take on such a stupid nickname? He's a cool kid, has a reputation to uphold.

Originally posted by CosmicComet
Captain "Beta Ray Billy" Marvel?

Since when did Billy take on such a stupid nickname? He's a cool kid, has a reputation to uphold. No, it's captain I am just a stupid little kid Marvel but not from the superior marvel universe. It's a long nickname granted which is why you don't hear it that often.

The original Captain Marvel > some cat that died of cancer.

Though he was a cool cancer patient.

Originally posted by CosmicComet
The original Captain Marvel > some cat that died of cancer.

Though he was a cool cancer patient. That guy had swag. This poster is just some idiotic sixth grader who is Superman's peer. Disgraceful.

I hate both of you so much right now

Captain Marvel (DC) wins after a tough fight.

Beta Ray wins after a good fight.

^ CM still rapes Hulk and Gladiator, though.

Some people are F^ckin Retarded.

Captain Marvel Wins

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
Some people are F^ckin Retarded.

Captain Marvel Wins

You're being too hard on yourself.

Originally posted by Silent Master
You're being too hard on yourself. what are u talking about

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
what are u talking about

I giggled...

vin

lol

Edit: double post....window froze

[.

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
Go F Yourself Originally posted by psycho gundam
lol

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
^ CM still rapes Hulk and Gladiator, though.




I agree...he does beat Gladiator and stop trolling me.

Everyone beats Gladiator.

Dude, I haven't even started.

People need to leap off Carvers fleshy pouch where balls should be.

He may not be the smartest, or a good person, but...










K got it, but at least he's better than the primates like big c.

DCnU Marvel seems to be the same badass cap without all the "Gosh! Golly!" hokey stuff.

New Billy has attitude.

He mounts a horse head over his mantle after beating down Bill.

Good fight though.