Broly v.s. Thanos

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



ScreamPaste
Because seriously, let's see this thread happen. Even if I do personally believe it is one sided and spitey.

The fight takes place on DBZ Earth while all the heroes are napping, and they will not wake up. There are no BFRs. Howzzitgo?

Effect Veiler
Broly destroys the Earth and the Galaxy. Thanos floats around unconscious in space because of his immortality, Broly eventually dies of old age.

Nice thread, fanboy.

ScreamPaste
Already with the insults.

ares834
Thanos stomps.

Effect Veiler
You made this spite thread because you got mad of the outcome of the other thread.

An immortal character and no BFR? This thread should be closed and you should get a ban.

ScreamPaste
Originally posted by Effect Veiler
You made this spite thread because you got mad of the outcome of the other thread.

An immortal character and no BFR? This thread should be closed and you should get a ban. KO's are still possible.

I should get a ban for making a thread you don't like? Touchy. haermm Also, I don't care about the other thread, I just like calling people on things.

Effect Veiler
Originally posted by ScreamPaste
KO's are still possible.
OK. Show me Thanos talking a Galaxy buster to the face and remaining conscious.

Until then, Broly wins.

Yamcha
Dammit ;~;...I love Broly I really do, I wish he was stronger...if I had it my way DBZ characters would be on Living Tribunal level and destroy Universes without realizing it as a side effect just through sparring....alas I do not T^T

That being said...I don't see how a guy who can endure things so easily like this
http://i48.tinypic.com/mkdi0l.jpg
http://i50.tinypic.com/2qcngut.jpg

Or do things like this
http://i50.tinypic.com/27zf7sz.jpg
(I know Galactus wasn't down for the count but later Galactus is even impressed by Thanos's shields and that's saying something coming from Big G)

Is really gonna have trouble with the Legendary Saiyan ;~;....I wish he could go SS3 :c...I mean Thanos has faced Odin, someone who I can see utterly curbing Broly the way Zeus did to Hulk </3

Also taking in the fact Thanos is leagues smarter than Broly :/

I honestly see the fight eventually ending up like this

http://i47.tinypic.com/309ua9y.jpg

Effect Veiler
I'm still waiting to see Thanos retaining consciousness after being hit by a galaxy-buster.

NemeBro
Originally posted by Effect Veiler
Attack potency =/= collateral damage.

Effect Veiler
I'm still waiting to see Thanos tank a blast with the Attack Potency of the level of a Galaxy buster.

NemeBro
An enraged Odin attacked him.

Effect Veiler
Originally posted by NemeBro
An enraged Odin attacked him.
OK. Show me that said blast had the Attack Potency of a Galaxy Buster.

Because Odin didn't even have enough power to scourge the Earth in the Galactus Seed arc.

NemeBro
Show me that the blast that killed Broly had the attack potency of a galaxy buster.

Effect Veiler
Why? Broly's durability isn't in question.

Broly is faster than Thanos. Thanos won't hit Broly unless Broly allows him to get a free hit in. Which isn't going to happen.

Broly will obviously survive his own galaxy buster because he survived it when he destroyed the South Galaxy, if that's what you meant.

NemeBro
Thanos has tagged Silver Surfer, who is faster than Broly.

Prove Broly was in the South Galaxy when he destroyed it.

Effect Veiler
Originally posted by NemeBro
Thanos has tagged Silver Surfer, who is faster than Broly.
Silver Surfer's combat speed...

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/13/134112/2596351-2359944-mexicans_own_surfer.jpg

I'm also inclined to post the fight between Wolverine and Thanos, as well as the myraid of other people who have to superspeed yet kept up with Surfer and Thanos.

Broly wins.

Yamcha
You asked for a galactic feat so I looked into one durability feat I recall that may come closest to what you're looking for, it was Thanos surviving a black hole collapsing on him, now this alone seems impressive but there was a formula someone did to show how impressive this actually is..hang on let me find it...

Voila! Here we go, an actually this comes from Endless Mike so all credit goes to him (scans as well) he's super knowledgable about these things too,
---------------------
http://i48.tinypic.com/2n1sy7o.jpg
"Such a collapse would release the total mass-energy content of the black hole in one huge burst, meaning that to survive this, Thanos would have needed to tank all of that energy.

Schwarzchild radius formula:

We need to solve this for mass.

First of all, 2 light-years = 1.89210568e16 m.

Multiplying that by the speed of light squared, we get 1.700539779e33. Divided by 2, we end up with 8.502698893e32. Dividing this by the gravitational constant, we arrive at a mass of 1.274033973e43 kg. This is more mass than the entire local group of galaxies. <------

Now we simply need to apply e=mc^2.

We get a yield of 1.145044631e60 joules, or 273,672,235,100,000,000,000,000,000
yottatons.

And what was the result to Thanos after tanking this, you ask?
http://i48.tinypic.com/jkgfoh.jpg
---------------------

Like I said I'm not math guy but I remember that blowing my mind, hopefully it'll help a shed some light on how durable Thanos truly is.

Whew after all that I feel like this lmao

http://i45.tinypic.com/166wro0.jpg

NemeBro
Originally posted by Effect Veiler
Silver Surfer's combat speed...

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/13/134112/2596351-2359944-mexicans_own_surfer.jpg

I'm also inclined to post the fight between Wolverine and Thanos, as well as the myraid of other people who have to superspeed yet kept up with Surfer and Thanos.

Broly wins.

Wolverine is far faster than Broly.

That's a nice low showing you've got there that everyone has seen, but Silver Surfer is still faster.

Anyway, Thanos telepathically makes Broly bite his tongue off and drown on his blood.

Effect Veiler
Endless Mike lol?

Read the scan. It's not the SC radius that's 2 light years, it's the reach of the gravitational pull of the artificial singularity.

abhilegend
Originally posted by Effect Veiler
Silver Surfer's combat speed...

http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/13/134112/2596351-2359944-mexicans_own_surfer.jpg

I'm also inclined to post the fight between Wolverine and Thanos, as well as the myraid of other people who have to superspeed yet kept up with Surfer and Thanos.

Broly wins.
That's non-canon.

Chozone
Broly's instance of vaporizing a galaxy is vague at the very best, we see it pix-elated away and then we see Goku travel there a bit later and it's in tact

Outside of that we saw Broly vaporize a planet but his durability sucks, against energy attack it's ok but against physical force it isn't, he had to use a shield to protect himself from lava

Telepathy might not work against him because of his rage but Thanos could potentially one shot him via energy blast or fist to the face

Damborgson
It depends how Thanos approaches the fight. He could very well have a new mind slave, but if he toys around, he could also be left floating in space since Broly's psychotic enough to dust the planet once he saw that he wasn't getting past Broly's shields. Thanos would work him in hand to hand also, but be at a disadvantage if he tried to blast it out with him. His best bet is to catch him with some high powered energy blasts or mental attacks before Broly goes all "KAKKAROT!!!!!!!1!" And starts pouring on the power. Broly's dangerous and its best to take someone who dusts planets with backhand blasts seriously. His durability is just against heat though.

Oh and lol @ Effect Veiler trying to lowball surfer by using a non canon comic that proves...nothing.

Chozone
Originally posted by abhilegend
That's non-canon. What comic is that scan from and how is it non canon?

CosmicComet
Thanos' durability is far beyond Broly's output. The guy never destroyed a galaxy. It was still completely in-tact, as the crew goes there and there are still countless stars in the sky on New Vegeta, it was simply being attacked, as was said in the narrative. That visual was simply representative of the future.

Broly is still faster however, as simply hitting someone with immense speed in comics does not mean your speed is on par with their own, not unless there is specific mention of it. Its a comic, speedsters get tagged all the time due to PIS/CIS etc. (And yes, make no mistake, Surfer is immensely faster than anyone in DBZ due to at least having a couple of a nanosecond level reaction feats--on such a scale, a full second would feel like a few decades. Literally. No one in DBZ has a perception speed anywhere near this fast, since 30 minutes is still considered a fairly short time for them via fusions.)

Broly's durability is immensely shit compared to Thanos, as being blasted into the sun was able to kill him for good, and that same blast did not remotely damage the sun despite the size of the explosion.

Broly's physical strength compared to Thanos is also such that an ant compares better to a top notch powerlifter than he does to Thanos. Literally.


Broly will eventually tire, as the ki fluctuations in his body takes a toll on him. Thanos can mindrape him or clothesline his head off when the opening presents itself.

abhilegend
Originally posted by Chozone
What comic is that scan from and how is it non canon?
Silver Surfer: Ultimate Cosmic Experience. It depicts surfer leaving with galactus upon his first visit to earth, which contradicts the canon.

TheHulk
Lol effect is literally ignoring everything..and i think Thanos can take it..but Brolly has a chance too.

Epicurus
Bump
Originally posted by Effect Veiler
Because Odin didn't even have enough power to scourge the Earth in the Galactus Seed arc.
Complete and utter bullshit.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.