Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
I don't understand the logic here by some... some say well Sids beat yoda already... WHEN did this happen?
Agreed.
Originally posted by Ascendancy
Sids has already beaten Yoda, so going to have to go with that the majority of the time.
The fight itself was a stalemate.
Originally posted by Ascendancy
Argued for Bane against Mace whether with or without orbs, and Bane won by a margin in the thread debating that specific match up.
This is classic argumentum ad populum, and as such has no real merit.
Not to mention, some of us are still not convinced if DoE Bane can take Mace (I deliberately leave RoT Bane vs Mace for some other time)
Originally posted by Ascendancy
We know that Obi can take Sith Anakin, so that leave Obi vs Sids & Bane, either of whom is more than his match in both sabers and Force, especially arcane techniques
IMHO:
Yoda >= Sids
Windu>= DoE Bane
Kenobi > Sith Anakin
Jedi team has a slight edge, and they edge out the victory: 6/10.