Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Due to a time/space anomaly several alternate versions of Clark Kent find themselves in the ruins of what was once the Kent farm in Smallville Kansas with no memory of how they arrived. Each blames the others for the destruction of their home town and they fight.

Superman(Cavill)
Superman(Reeve-1,2,3,4)
Superman(Routh-1,2, Returns)
Clark Kent(Smallville series minus the planet launching feat)

Bonus Round: Same deal except Smallville Clark keeps his planet tossing power and is trying to kill the others. The other Supermen are working together now.

Smallville Clark likely beats the shit out of all of them, that guy was so fast it wasn't even funny.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Smallville Clark likely beats the shit out of all of them, that guy was so fast it wasn't even funny.

I think Reeve and Routh have him in speed

Me too.

Routh Superman was light speed.

Reeve Superman circled the earth like 30 times in a second.

Strength-wise end game Smallville Supes has the best feat, but Reeve Superman can most likely do the same.


Edit Lets try and quantify how was Cavillman was.

Anyone?

Originally posted by Zack Fair
Me too.

Routh Superman was light speed.

Reeve Superman circled the earth like 30 times in a second.

Strength-wise end game Smallville Supes has the best feat, but Reeve Superman can most likely do the same.


Edit Lets try and quantify how was Cavillman was.

Anyone?

He was at least supersonic but nowhere near light imo. Smallville Clark was probably faster than Cavill

Moved per request.

FYI, Dean Caine Superman pwns all.

Originally posted by Impediment
Moved per request.

FYI, Dean Caine Superman pwns all.

Thanks for the move

DAMMIT HOW COULD I FORGET ABOUT DEAN!!!????

Sucks that Cavill is probably the weakest of the Supermen even though he had the best fights outof all of them

Smallville Supes would beat the others silly though an argument could be made for Reeve's Superman.

reeve and routh are the same superman as per film canon.

stupid, i know. but fact none the less.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
Me too.

Routh Superman was light speed.

Reeve Superman circled the earth like 30 times in a second.

Strength-wise end game Smallville Supes has the best feat, but Reeve Superman can most likely do the same.


Edit Lets try and quantify how was Cavillman was.

Anyone?

From how it looked like in MOS, it seemed like the Kryptonians could only move in bursts of speed. Like once they move, they end up in their destination with extreme speed, but they don't seem to be capable of other superspeed movements. Like you don't see them delivering super fast punches or dodging around bullets like Matrix Agents. Once moving in superspeed, you don't see them correcting their course and zig zagging in super speed.

I remember reading a book, I think it was a book with Drizzt Do'urden, wherein he wore these speed bracers that made his hands (and swords) extremely fast. Problem was his mind couldn't keep up so he could swing a sword very fast but once committed to the action he couldn't alter the course of the swing or adjust the blow. My theory is that it's the same with the kyptonians. They commit to a movement, use superspeed in making that movement, then if they have to change movements they stop and make the other movement. Kinda like Faora went through those soldiers. She didn't just zip through them and knocked them all out without them seeing her. She'd zip to one, punch him out, zip to another, punch him out, etc.

Originally posted by focus4chumps
reeve and routh are the same superman as per film canon.

stupid, i know. but fact none the less.

The split occurs with Superman III and Superman Returns which is why i clarified in the OP. Both can use feats from 1 and 2 but only Routh has feats from Returns and Reeve has feats from III and IV

Reeve and by extension Routh, have on-demand powers; that's a bonus in a fight.

Cavill is the lowest here.

How fast do you have to be to go from metropolis to space and back in a few seconds?

Originally posted by Zack Fair
How fast do you have to be to go from metropolis to space and back in a few seconds?

Really depends how far out. The Exosphere which is the last layer of atmosphere starts at about 400 miles out and ends at about 62,000 miles.

Smallville Clark was lightspeed.

Cavill has one major advantage though: He's willing to kill.

He'll be koed before he gets a chance.

Originally posted by FrothByte
Cavill has one major advantage though: He's willing to kill.

Not really.

Cavill's Superman will kill when he's put in an extreme position of 'kill someone or risk them butt-raping humanity'.

Reeve's Superman will kill someone that's no longer a threat while mocking them like a total dick.

Originally posted by Robtard
Not really.

Cavill's Superman will kill when he's put in a position of 'kill someone, or risk then butt-raping humanity'.

Reeve's Superman will kill someone that's no longer a threat while mocking them like a total dick. Reeve's Superman was the best.

Originally posted by Mindset
Reeve's Superman was the best.

He's got the biggest dick of all them too:

V4YL0W5kvyw

Dean Caine put his dick in Teri Hatcher.

Win.

Originally posted by Robtard
Not really.

Cavill's Superman will kill when he's put in an extreme position of 'kill someone or risk them butt-raping humanity'.

Reeve's Superman will kill someone that's no longer a threat while mocking them like a total dick. Superdickery at its finest.

Reeve Superman really embodied PC Superman.

Routh was a total monster though, too bad he was a creeper, too.

Cavill supes victory flies into space and leaves the shattered, smoldering remains of the others behind...

Uh....sorry but Cavill is actually the weakest of the Supermen despite how much I wanted him to be better than Routh in this fight.

Though I think its between Reeve's and Welling and I'm leaning towards Welling for now.

Originally posted by juggerman
The split occurs with Superman III and Superman Returns which is why i clarified in the OP. Both can use feats from 1 and 2 but only Routh has feats from Returns and Reeve has feats from III and IV

i cant think of any feats from 3 or 4 which put reeve any higher in abilities. would anyone care to sacrifice 4 hours of precious life to watch those turds again and confirm? i sure as shit won't.

Originally posted by focus4chumps
i cant think of any feats from 3 or 4 which put reeve any higher in abilities. would anyone care to sacrifice 4 hours of precious life to watch those turds again and confirm? i sure as shit won't.

All i remember was his super vision that repaired walls during his fight with Nuke-Man

Superman 4, Superman can talk in space. He's got reality warping powers.

Humans in Superman 4 surived in space too.

Best.movie.Ever.

LoL@Critics claiming they would rather watch with joy Superman 4 over Man of Steel. What a bunch of assholes.

Originally posted by Zack Fair


LoL@Critics claiming they would rather watch with joy Superman 4 over Man of Steel. What a bunch of assholes.

If anyone actually said that, they're just hating on MoS to rasie the 'I hate MoS' bar.

Someone did, yeah.

reeve's superman 1-4 is probably the most powerful since he has on-demand powers.. routh is probably the second only because his powers got scaled back in returns.. then cavill, though he is the best iteration, he is also the weakest, as of now, at least.. i bet he's gonna be more powerful in the sequel, more feats.. let's revisit this thread after man of steel 2..

i never watched smallville so i can't really say..

So Reeve is the top guy here then?

What if the three others teamed up? Could they beat him?

not with reeve throwing around that big ass plastic "s" shield..

Why is Reeve above Smallville?

Didn't Smallville Clark move an entire planet out of Earth's orbit in the series finale?

Originally posted by BloodRain
Why is Reeve above Smallville?

Reeve Superman is a pretty cool guy. He kills Zod with a smile and doesn't afraid of anything.Originally posted by Lestov16
Didn't Smallville Clark move an entire planet out of Earth's orbit in the series finale? Yeah. Reeve Superman moved the moon though. I don't see the apokolips feat beyond Reeve.

Originally posted by juggerman
I think Reeve and Routh have him in speed

They can fly at lightspeeds but they've never actually moved or reacted to things at any kind of speed. Smallville Clark regularly runs around at mach 500 blitzing everything to death like the cheap superdick that he is.

Also I seem to recall one bit where he picks Chloe up and runs to the North Pole from Smallville nigh on instantly.

Originally posted by Nephthys
They can fly at lightspeeds but they've never actually moved or reacted to things at any kind of speed. Smallville Clark regularly runs around at mach 500 blitzing everything to death like the cheap superdick that he is. Catching bullets ain't reacting to things at any kind of speed?

Originally posted by Zack Fair
Reeve Superman is a pretty cool guy. He kills Zod with a smile and doesn't afraid of anything. Yeah. Reeve Superman moved the moon though. I don't see the apokolips feat beyond Reeve.

Reeve was defying the space-time continuum and rewinding time, so he's definitely the most powerful, but I would rank SV Clark second.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
Reeve Superman is a pretty cool guy. He kills Zod with a smile and doesn't afraid of anything. Yeah. Reeve Superman moved the moon though. I don't see the apokolips feat beyond Reeve. Easily pushing a saturn sized planet out of earth's orbit >>> moving the moon.

Originally posted by Mindset
Easily pushing a saturn sized planet out of earth's orbit >>> moving the moon. It is. I wouldn't put it past Reeve is all I'm saying. Not saying he would either. Just...**** OFF Dickset uhuh

Originally posted by Zack Fair
Catching bullets ain't reacting to things at any kind of speed?

Er.....

My memory is spotty on the early Superman movies, ok? >:[

Don't worry, they both oneshot MoS Supes with ease.

Its cool. Should watch them some time whenever you're bored. For the laughs and nostalgia.

Originally posted by Mindset
Don't worry, they both oneshot MoS Supes with ease. That they do.

But then again I remember people arguing Reeve Superman could not defeat the Avengers because he was a lousy fighter. So I'mma go with that.

Watching the Smallville ep with Amy Adams.

Lulz

Originally posted by Zack Fair
That they do.

But then again I remember people arguing Reeve Superman could not defeat the Avengers because he was a lousy fighter. So I'mma go with that. Then Smallville Clark wins.

Ugh...that episode is a travesty. Ruined tight pants Adams for me. over

Originally posted by Mindset
Watching the Smallville ep with Amy Adams.

Lulz

Is that the one where Pete is diggin the fatty?

Black guy digging a fat white girl, no, that's no cliche' at all.

Originally posted by Robtard
Black guy digging a fat white girl, no, that's no cliche' at all. He didn't like her until she lost weight.

Give him some credit.

Originally posted by Robtard
Black guy digging a fat white girl, no, that's no cliche' at all.

That's cuz black guys are smart. Show the chubby some love and she'll do anything for ya.... ANYTHING!

Originally posted by Impediment
FYI, Dean Caine Superman pwns all. Not quite.

http://cdn.fd.uproxx.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/georgereeves.jpg

Watched a video of Reeves Superman destroying walls lol. Apparently he didn't know how to open doors.

Phuck doors.

Originally posted by Mindship
Not quite.

http://cdn.fd.uproxx.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/georgereeves.jpg

JL TAS Season 1 Superman would beat George, lol.