Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Bruce is having a seriously bad day. He's sick, one broken leg and a massive concussion. In short, he can't fight. So Captain America has taken his place to retake Gotham. Everything goes and there are no rules.

Uh, is Cap fighting Bane 1 on 1 or is he trying to take down Bane and his entire army while they have Gotham hostage?

If it's 1 on 1, Cap beats the shit out of Bane, and he doesn't even need his shield to do it.

Against an entrenched Bane and his army, Cap doesn't have the technology and resources of Batman. He might still pull it off but he'd need help from Gordon and the locals.

Yea...HTH only is basically spite against Bane....not sure about retaking Gotham as it depends on what intel and resources Cap is given.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Yea...HTH only is basically spite against Bane....not sure about retaking Gotham as it depends on what intel and resources Cap is given.

Cap was holding his own against an alien invasion. He'll be able to fight a group of common criminals with guns. They don't have anything that Cap's shield hasn't tanked. He'll beat Bane, capture Talia, and turn her into the US Army, who, along with GCPD, will find the bomb, which Lucius will dismantle.

I don't see movie Cap having the ability to retake Gotham from Bane. A dude with a shield? He gets shot in the back, two days tops.

Originally posted by COG Veteran
I don't see movie Cap having the ability to retake Gotham from Bane. A dude with a shield? He gets shot in the back, two days tops.

Plus he's wearing bright colors. He'll need to wear all black and make his voice into a growl for him to go undercover.

Yea...a German sniper tried that, didn't work.

Truthfully, I didn't even see that sniper, and the camera was pointed at him.

Cap can take Gotham faster than batman minus the bat stuff. One shield throw turns banes mask to crap and Talia wouldn't get far. With the added time with how fast cap would deal with this they have time to spare to find the bomb. cap can inspire cops in a sewer and civilians alot better than demonized batman.

If some two bit cops could do it, a WW2 general definitely can. He's got the healing factor too, so he's not staying down no matter what.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Yea...a German sniper tried that, didn't work.

We're talking about league of shadows snipers with ninja training and all that. Those guys would trump a nazi sniper.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Yea...a German sniper tried that, didn't work.

He forgot to use the growling voice.

Originally posted by COG Veteran
We're talking about league of shadows snipers with ninja training and all that. Those guys would trump a nazi sniper.

By all means, show feats of these league of shadow snipers managing to shoot someone on Cap's skill level.

Originally posted by Silent Master
By all means, show feats of these league of shadow snipers managing to shoot someone on Cap's skill level.

Well, show Cap being able to trounce everyone in those sewers and sneak around, with that bright suit and HIGHLY REFLECTIVE shield. He isn't gonna be using the darkness as well as batman.

Did you miss the part where he sneaks onto the Red Skull's base and releases the POWs?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Did you miss the part where he sneaks onto the Red Skull's base and releases the POWs?

He also got captured at some point too. Movie woulda ended had those flamethrower guys just pointed their guns at him and held the trigger.

That was later in the movie and getting caught was part of the plan, remember he was acting as a distraction so that the rest of the attack force could get into position.

Originally posted by Silent Master
That was later in the movie and getting caught was part of the plan, remember he was acting as a distraction so that the rest of the attack force could get into position.

Ok, its been a while since i've seen the movie, got timeline mixed up. But still he would died had Red Skull said "kill Cap A on sight". Than plan coulda gone to hell badly.

Originally posted by COG Veteran
Ok, its been a while since i've seen the movie, got timeline mixed up. But still he would died had Red Skull said "kill Cap A on sight". Than plan coulda gone to hell badly.

lol you are seriously underestimating Cap in this.

First of all The League of shadows are said to be the best fighters but have no on screen feats to say that they can even compete with cap. All the fighting scenes were as follows....Punch, Block, repeat.

Cap was able to......

Jump an 8 foot fence as if it were a hurdle, Punch through a Submarines glass while under water, Hold a motorcycle over his head, Sneak/fight onto a red skull base and release the POW men...by himself, He sensed and took out a sniper that was hidden in a tree behind him, Took out a group of enemies that had surrounded him all armed with insta kill weapons, and was able to throw his shield with perfect accuracy and timing so that it banked off that tank took out a bad guy and flew right on course to where he was so he could catch it.....not to mention that was done on the fly.

That was only just in his own movie. Lets talk Avengers where he showed....

A sort of tactical genius that that kept the Aliens within a contained area of the city, Not only was he maneuvering and fighting on a flying landing pad that was having a system failure but he was doing it at that altitude without an oxygen mask, He fought and killed 3 attacking Aliens (that were crushing car beneath their feet) by himself with ease, and im sure im forgetting some other things to.

Truth is Cap would destroy ANYONE h2h in the Nolan batman movies and Im pretty sure he could make his way to Bane fighting through Banes soldiers.

Originally posted by COG Veteran
He also got captured at some point too. Movie woulda ended had those flamethrower guys just pointed their guns at him and held the trigger. Cap took a shot that disintegrated regular ppl, iirc.

He did.

Cap would beat the ****ing shit out of Bane with contemptuous ease.

A single Chitauri trooper would beat the shit out of Bane.

Cap can probably also stop Bane's plans.

Against Bane in a H2H confrontation, obviously Cap would have the upper hand but I don't think Cap is intelligent enough nor does he possess the resources to thwart Bane's operation.

Cap would dominate Bane and his fodder. Bane is completely out of his league (pun intended).

Originally posted by Odekahn
Cap would dominate Bane and his fodder. Bane is completely out of his league (pun intended).

Agreed