Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/0/40/2571758-gbz4.jpg
VS
http://www.geeksofdoom.com/GoD/img/2012/06/2012-06-01-earth2_alan_scott-e1338579929688.jpeg

Alan Scott (earth 2)
VS
The new green lantern

Who wins? Both are in the early parts of their GL career, who would take the other out?

His name is Baz and he loses

Originally posted by xJLxKing
His name is Baz and he loses

Thanks for the name. I was totally drawing a blank there lol.

The Gay Ranger is tagging dat azz

Baz.

Alan Scott rapes. Also he doesn't look like a mexican wrestler.

What has Alan done recently?

His ring is now connected to and powered by The Green. He used it to defeat Grundy, who seems to have gotten a serious upgrade in the New 52.

He seems to be more powerful than Baz at this point, but he really only has the one feat.

Originally posted by Cogito
His ring is now connected to and powered by The Green. He used it to defeat Grundy, who seems to have gotten a serious upgrade in the New 52.

He seems to be more powerful than Baz at this point, but he really only has the one feat.

At least Baz brought someone back from a coma.

I don't know all Baz has to do to win is take Alan off planet. once he gets too high in the stratosphere he looses his connection to the "green"/ Earth and is depowered

Originally posted by beatboks
I don't know all Baz has to do to win is take Alan off planet. once he gets too high in the stratosphere he looses his connection to the "green"/ Earth and is depowered

Unlikely Baz would know anything about Alan's powers

Goddamnit.

What did they do to you and the JSA, Alan?

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Goddamnit.

What did they do to you and the JSA, Alan?

They might as well have made new characters for what they are doing.. It's not 'bad' but given the characters being used it just hurts. Such as There is no way Jay can be anything close to the character i loved to read for so long, to much had been stripped away.. But Im starting to like his new incarnation.. Still it's a pale imitation (as of now)

Earth 2 has been pretty good. Love how they are showing the NG's respect.

Earth 2 has been pretty shit, tbh.

I like it a lot. World building is what James Robinson does best, IMO.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Goddamnit.

What did they do to you and the JSA, Alan?

Completely FUBARED it.

Aside form the power drop for Alan his character (until issue #13 - there is hope) comes across as a stuck up #$%#$. Nothing like the noble honorable character he was before.

Jay goes from being the poster child of self confidence ( to the point where he was the JSA's first Chairman right out of College and their youngest member ATT), to being some naive doubtful man with very little faith in himself what so ever ( Also starting to change but it's a wonder he'd lasted the first 12 issues)

Al Pratt is now a good little soldier who will follow any order no matter how stupid it seems ( OH can you kill or capture the "wonders" trying to save all our lives)

Wes Dodd's is a cold blooded killer

Terry Sloane is psychotic and would destroy any city if it would give him a win of any sort. he'd teh reason E-2 Supes, WW, and bat's were killed in issue 1 5 years ago. To win he blew up the area they were fighting in the resulting explosion put craters of massive heat and lava on several parts of the globe and wiped people by the millions ( but Hey Apokolips' armies were killed - along with 1/8 the planet). When Alan, Jay, Al and Harkgirl were fighting Grundy somewhere in Washingtom (IIRC) he was prepared to nuke it while they were there just to beat grundy

Don't eve MENTION JSA in relation to this book. If the team does get called that I'll be going postal somewhere round 1700 Broadway, 7th Fl. New York, NY

Originally posted by beatboks
Completely FUBARED it.

Aside form the power drop for Alan his character (until issue #13 - there is hope) comes across as a stuck up #$%#$. Nothing like the noble honorable character he was before.

Jay goes from being the poster child of self confidence ( to the point where he was the JSA's first Chairman right out of College and their youngest member ATT), to being some naive doubtful man with very little faith in himself what so ever ( Also starting to change but it's a wonder he'd lasted the first 12 issues)

Al Pratt is now a good little soldier who will follow any order no matter how stupid it seems ( OH can you kill or capture the "wonders" trying to save all our lives)

Wes Dodd's is a cold blooded killer

Terry Sloane is psychotic and would destroy any city if it would give him a win of any sort. he'd teh reason E-2 Supes, WW, and bat's were killed in issue 1 5 years ago. To win he blew up the area they were fighting in the resulting explosion put craters of massive heat and lava on several parts of the globe and wiped people by the millions ( but Hey Apokolips' armies were killed - along with 1/8 the planet). When Alan, Jay, Al and Harkgirl were fighting Grundy somewhere in Washingtom (IIRC) he was prepared to nuke it while they were there just to beat grundy

Don't eve MENTION JSA in relation to this book. If the team does get called that I'll be going postal somewhere round 1700 Broadway, 7th Fl. New York, NY
I had hope they pulled the characters away from what they were to give them something to become. Such as Jay with the confidence issues.. Threw character development make him eventually become the confident but humble man that he was. Same with Al Pratt and Alan eventually becoming something close to what was. Can't just have them all falling into their roles so quickly and competently more so if good stories can be told during the course of them getting there But then we get to something like what they are doing with Terry Sloane And it all seems like crap character assassination.

Alan wins.