Would IM3 be better...

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



SamZED
If they actually went with the comicbook version of Mandarin?

DARTH POWER
Yes 100 times better.

Kazenji
Still keep Aldrich Killian, Just have it so he sells the Extremis to a terrorist group just like the book. Instead have the terrorist group be the Mandarin's.

roughrider
The Mandarin was always going to have to be radically changed for the movies, because he's a Fu Manchu stereotype in the comics. So radically altered we got. And the movie made $1.2 billion. It's over, man.

WhiteWitchKing
Yes, it would have been better all around.

SamZED
What bothers me personally..
1) people say it was done so there'd be a twist.
- they could've done some other twist
- what kind of twist was that anyway seeing how at the very beginning of the movie we see the bad guy all pissed at Tony and Tony's voice saying "we create our own monsters". Some twist...
2) people say that Mandarin is too unrealistic for the IM movies.
- they already had gods and radiactive monsters in the Avengers. How is Mandarin different?
- and he's NOT unrealistic, the way he was portrayed in the trailer... it WORKED. He was scary, badass. They could've just finished this concept and it would've been great. No need for the magical rings even, just make him this brilliant terrorist we thought he was.

Entity
Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Yes 100 times better.

Originally posted by SamZED
What bothers me personally..
1) people say it was done so there'd be a twist.
- they could've done some other twist
- what kind of twist was that anyway seeing how at the very beginning of the movie we see the bad guy all pissed at Tony and Tony's voice saying "we create our own monsters". Some twist...
2) people say that Mandarin is too unrealistic for the IM movies.
- they already had gods and radiactive monsters in the Avengers. How is Mandarin different?
- and he's NOT unrealistic, the way he was portrayed in the trailer... it WORKED. He was scary, badass. They could've just finished this concept and it would've been great. No need for the magical rings even, just make him this brilliant terrorist we thought he was.

thumb up


And IMO lose that piece of shit Mark XLII armor but keep the other 40 they completely wasted for no good reason at the end.

How much money did Tony just essentially burn doing just that in the end? confused

Accel
The problem with the Mandarin isn't that he's too unrealistic; it's that he's one of the most ridiculous racist stereotypes around.

And honestly, if they made him more like the comic book version, the film would still essentially be the same, just having the villain switched out, but having the action set pieces be the same.

If anything, the twist made the story more interesting.

Kazenji
Hasn't anyone seen the Mandarin's recent appearence from Matt Fractions run, He didn't look much like a ridiculous racist stereotypes

Originally posted by Accel

If anything, the twist made the story more interesting.

try telling to the thousands of people who disliked the twist.

Accel
The only ones who seem to really care at all are comic book fans just simply because it wasn't the comic book Mandarin. Most movie goers who don't read the comics didn't mind at all.

JayDaDon
Originally posted by Entity
thumb up


And IMO lose that piece of shit Mark XLII armor but keep the other 40 they completely wasted for no good reason at the end.

How much money did Tony just essentially burn doing just that in the end? confused

I hate watching things like that in movies. Was I aupposed to go "wow! Awesome!" at watching him piss away untold millions of dollars in armors on a whim?

SamZED
There's a "how IM3 should've ended" video on you tube, Avengers kick out Tony since he's useless now and hire Pots instead lol

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.