Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

*Obi-Wan in his RotS version
*Luke in his RotJ version
*Takes place on Kashyyyk
*Fight is all-out

Who wins?

Could go ether way.

Luke goes down hard. A few lessons with Yoda isn't enough.

Hard? He is an equal to Vader in terms of skill.

Originally posted by Intrepid37
Hard? He is an equal to Vader in terms of skill.
Luke won thanks to a TPM rage boost. Before that, he was at best being forced back by Vader and Luke claimed that Vader didn't want to destroy him since, you know, Luke is the only family Vader has left.

Luke was never forced back, and Vader only held power back, not skill.

Kenobi.

Originally posted by Intrepid37
Luke was never forced back, and Vader only held power back, not skill.
You miss the part when Vader threw his lightsaber at Luke?
Considering that TPM Maul was beating Vader, Luke is not on the level of one of the leading Jedi Council members.

He has matching feats to RotS Obi wan

Originally posted by Vensai
You miss the part when Vader threw his lightsaber at Luke?
Considering that TPM Maul was beating Vader, Luke is not on the level of one of the leading Jedi Council members.
Considering that Maul beat Vader before ANH, and that canon sources has told us Vader grew as a swordsman between ANH and ESB and that he grew in power between ESB and RotJ, yes, Luke is on that level.

What is this, Obi-Wan stomps him into the ground.

Don't be ignorant on purpose. Kenobi is not stomping this.

Originally posted by Intrepid37
Don't be ignorant on purpose. Kenobi is not stomping this.


If he gets two sabers he does excellent

http://r19.imgfast.net/users/1916/39/10/06/smiles/2860309752.gif