Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

ABSTRACT SUPREME BEING OMEGA SHENRON TIER

Ash Williams/Bruce Cambell (2), Fi (The Master Sword) ( ∞ ), Genie (1), James with a lead pipe (1), Kirby (2), Mario (2), Master Chief (1), Tommy Oliver (5)

Abstract

Arceus (2), Elder God (Demonbane) (2), Nyarlythotep (Demonbane) (2), Lucifer (Shin Megami Tensei) (2), Sheogorath (1), Zeed-Millenniummon (1)

Cube Being

Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann (1), Unicron (1)

Skyfather

Amaterasu (1), The Golden Goddesses (Zelda) (2), Q (Star Trek) (2), Solaris (1)

Transcendant

Discord (MLP:FiM) (1)

Herald

High

Asura (3), KOS-MOS (1), Magnus the Red (2),

Mid

Clark Kent (Smallville) (1), Princess Celestia (1), Princess Luna (1), Hyper Knuckles (2), Super Scourge (2), Super Shadow (2), Super Silver the Hedgehog (2), Super Sonic (2),

Low

Aku (2), Dante (DMC2) (4), Ganondorf (4), Hideyoshi Toyotomi (1), Kratos (God of War) (1), Lenneth (Valkyrie Profile) (1), Lucifer (Super Natural) (1), Magnus The Red (1), Mew (2) MewTwo (4), Powerpuff Girls (5), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (1), Tabuu (1)

Metahuman

High

Angron (1), Castiel (1), Dante (DMC1&4) (2), Dante (DMC2) (3), Doomsday (DCAU) (1), Guyver (1), Hideyoshi Toyotomi (Sengoku Basara) (2), Ichigo (1), Invincible (1), Kenshiro (3), Kojuro Katakura (Sengoku Basara) (1), Kratos (God of War) (1), Lemen Russ (1), Lorgar (1), Luffy (1), Luke Skywalker (2), Masamune Date (Sengoku Basara) (2), Master Asia (3), Megaman X (2), Mew (1), Naruto (1), Comic!Rainbow Dash (1), Raoh (2), Riku (Kingdom Hearts (2), Saitama (1), Sanguinius (1), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (1), Sora (2), Tetsuo Shima (Akira) (3), Yukimura Sanada (Sengoku Basara) (2) Zero (2), Zero Superman (DCAU) (1),

Mid

Alex Mercer (4), Alita (Battle Angel Alita/Last Order) (1), Alucard (Hellsing) (3), Ben Tennyson (Composite) (1), Blade Liger (1), Captain Planet (1), Cloverfield Monster (1), Evil!Cole McGrath (InFamous) (4), Dante (DmC) (2), Death (Darksiders) (3), Donkey Kong (2), Fingolfin (1), Flame Princess (1), Hancock (1), Hayato Furinji (HSD) (2), Ice King (1), Jackie Chan (Talismans) (1), Jin Kazama (1), Kaiju's (PR) (1), Kain the Vampire (3), Ken (Street Fighter) (2), Kirby (3), Kharn The Betrayer (1), Knuckles (2), Kojuro Katakura (Sengoku Basara) (1), Liger Zero (1), Link, Hero of Legend (6), Link, Hero of Light (6), Link, Hero of Time (6), Link, Hero of Winds (6), Mario (2), Mega Man (4), Megaman X (2), Merry Dreameater (1), Natsu (Fairy Tail) (1), Optimus Prime (1), Pride (1),Cyborg!Raiden (MGS) (1), Rainbow Dash (1), Raziel (3), Ryu (Street Fighter) (2), Samurai Jack (4), Samus Aran (2), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (2), Scourge The Hedgehog (2), Seras (Hellsing) (1), Silver the Hedgehog (2), Shadow (2), Sonic (2), Sora (Kingdom Hearts) (1), Titus, Second Captain of the Ultramarines (4), Twilight Sparkle (1), Vergil (DmC) (2), Yoh Asakura (1)

Low

Aang (Avatar) (2), Albert Wesker (Resident Evil Games) (6), Andrew Detmer (2), Big MacIntosh (1), Billith (1), Good!Cole McGrath (3), Cloud (FF7) (2), Commander Shepherd (4), Corvo Attano (1), Eddie Riggs (2), Edward (Twilight) (1), Envy (1), Eren Jager (Attack on Titan) (1), Fluttershy (1), Gluttony (1), Greed (1), Guts (Berserk) (1), Haseo (DotHack) (1), Hellboy (1), Jack (Mass Effect) (2), Jak (1), Kain the Vampire (2), Kenichi (2), Lelith Hesperax (1), Lu Bu (3), Lust (1), Master Chief (Halo) (9), Metabee (1), Pride (1), Ratchet (3), Raziel (2), Russell Edgington (2), Ryu Hayabusa (1), Samara (Mass Effect) (2), Sam Gideon (ARS) (2), Shining Armour (1), Shizuo Heiwajima (Durarara) (2), Sloth (1), Sylar (2), Thorkell (Vinland Saga) (1), Voldemort (1), War (Darksiders) (3), Warlow (True Blood) (2), Wrath (1)

Street

High

Adam Jensen (1), Afro Samurai (2), AppleJack (1), Brock Samson (2), Chris Redfield (3), Dexter (Dexter's Laboratory) (1), Edward Elric (2), Finn the Human (2), Fluttershy (2), Geralt of Rivia (The Witcher) (2), Isaac Clark (1), Jackie Chan (JCA) (1), Kazuma Kiryu (2), Marth (2), Miyamoto Musashi (Vagabond) (1), Pinkie (1), The Prince (Sands of Time) (3), Rarity (1), Solid Snake (2), Riddick (2), Voldemort (2)

Mid

Achilles (Troy) (3), Aragorn (4), Captain Falcon (2), Falco Lombardi (2), Fox McCloud (2), Gregor Clegane (3), Jackie Chan (2), James Bond (2), Joanna Dark (1), John Marston (2), Krystal the Fox (1), Marcus Fenix (4), Undertaker (2), Wolf O'Donnell (2), Xin (Kingdom) (2)

Low

Ash Williams (1), Fluttershy (1), Huey Freeman (2), Nathan Drake (2), Riley Freeman (2), Roger Smith (Big O) (1), Sly Cooper (2), Stewie Griffin (3), Turanga Leela (2)



List is imperfect and subject to change.

Tier list is a work in progress, please share any disagreements to improve the list.

__________________________________

(Credits to Emi~Kiro for starting this)

(Major props to ScreamPaste for organizing and compiling this list! More edits to follow, I'm sure. -Impediment)

They already have a cross genre tier list thread somewhere in comic v.s.

They do?

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
They already have a cross genre tier list thread somewhere in comic v.s.

I have no idea where to find it, or if it's even still alive.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=460164

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=460164
That list looks a little hurt and bare bones don't you think? I see no better place to sort this stuff out than here in the 'foreign cinema' arena.

I think this is an awesome idea.

Originally posted by SevenShackles
That list looks a little hurt and bare bones don't you think? I see no better place to sort this stuff out than here in the 'foreign cinema' arena.

I think this is an awesome idea.
IIRC there's an updated list on a later page, but sure, let's work one out. We'd need a mod willing to update the first page, though.

Originally posted by SevenShackles
That list looks a little hurt and bare bones don't you think? I see no better place to sort this stuff out than here in the 'foreign cinema' arena.

I think this is an awesome idea.

That was basically the idea.


Originally posted by ScreamPaste
IIRC there's an updated list on a later page, but sure, let's work one out. We'd need a mod willing to update the first page, though.

As I said, I was hoping to make an official thread to sort this out.

So are we using the list constructed in the comics vs as a template/start here? The characters already on the list can be re disputed as need be but it's at least a start.

Before we start we'll need a mod willing to update the OP, lol.

Originally posted by SevenShackles
So are we using the list constructed in the comics vs as a template/start here? The characters already on the list can be re disputed as need be but it's at least a start.

I'd prefer starting over so we have more to discuss. I'd hate to use a pre-existing template and have needless amount of dispute about raising or lowering characters. I think it's better to let everyone decide that early on.


Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Before we start we'll need a mod willing to update the OP, lol.

Impediment is the only one over 'Foreign Cinema', so that kinda narrows it down. Lol. Unless other mods are allowed to have a say in it.

Want me to PM him?

I would myself, but you know way more about this than I do. You'll more likely pick up a response sooner than I as well. Refer him to the thread, and see where he wants to go with it. We could have a collective discussion about how we want to do this.

I pm'd him, let's see what he says.

Why don't we begin building one before we create the thread?

I curious how mass effect characters like Samara, Wrex, Harbinger, Jax and thane would rank on the scale. biotics seemed rather potent nevermind reapers like Harbinger.

DBZ characters should be fun to figure out. Despite what anyone has to say I can't accept yamcha being in a ranking above Krillin. It's simply blasphemy.

Couldn't agree more. Yamcha needs at least two tiers above krillin.

I've always found biotics to be overrated. As soon as a battle thread starts it's usually "biotics, gg."

Never mind in the entire trilogy that there's no biotic that's even close to being like that with the exception of Samara. Hell for the "ownage' you can do with biotics, it sure wasn't easy for Liara against two random Cerberus troopers at the beginning of ME3.

It's a weaker version of the force yet the hype is much greater.

^ Yep.

Originally posted by SevenShackles
I curious how mass effect characters like Samara, Wrex, Harbinger, Jax and thane would rank on the scale. biotics seemed rather potent nevermind reapers like Harbinger.

Not high at all. Biotics are never used the way some poster believe they are.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Couldn't agree more. Yamcha needs at least two tiers above krillin.
http://i1278.photobucket.com/albums/y508/YamchaKMC/image_zpsac66e5a4.jpg

Originally posted by Based
I've always found biotics to be overrated. As soon as a battle thread starts it's usually "biotics, gg."

Never mind in the entire trilogy that there's no biotic that's even close to being like that with the exception of Samara. Hell for the "ownage' you can do with biotics, it sure wasn't easy for Liara against two random Cerberus troopers at the beginning of ME3.

It's a weaker version of the force yet the hype is much greater.

Umm.... Liara wtf pwned those guys once she stepped out of the vents. She couldn't levitate them inside the crawlspace.

Originally posted by Based
I've always found biotics to be overrated. As soon as a battle thread starts it's usually "biotics, gg."

Never mind in the entire trilogy that there's no biotic that's even close to being like that with the exception of Samara. Hell for the "ownage' you can do with biotics, it sure wasn't easy for Liara against two random Cerberus troopers at the beginning of ME3.

It's a weaker version of the force yet the hype is much greater.
Going off cut scenes Samara and Jack come across as a lot more powerful than their ingame selves but I always figured that just game balancing. The history of both, Samaras fight with her daughter and Jack tearing threw those robots on the prison ship were pretty impressive. (The ship part made me think jack would had super biotic powers but she just had normal powers, what a let down)

I agree with the person who said it is a weaker version of the force.
I always figured they would fall into the 'meta' category of ranking maybe Samara and Jack falling into 'high meta' or 'mid meta' while the other biotics fall lower.
Not sure where the Krogan go. I'm super biased with the Krogan because I like them so much.

Samara and other biotic users are mid-meta at best.

Krogans should be street level.

Samara should not be mentioned in the same breath as characters like Storm.

Mid meta? **** that shit yo, **** it with a rusty spoon.

Sorry for being tardy. Work and shit like that.

I just saw the PMs and this seems like a cool idea.

Go ahead and make a list and I'll update as soon as I can get around to doing it today.

In anime, games and live action we're going to end up with a couple dozens above Herald, with hundreds below that. That fully speaks for mainstream series.



Something like this? Could throw some characters on there as examples.

So are we keeping track of votes or is this working some other way?

I'll just throw out some suggestions to just get the ball rolling..
Mew two / low herald
Mew/ low herald
roger Smith (big O)/low street level
Samara/ low Meta
jack/low meta
Afro samurai/ elite street level
KOS-MOS full power (xenosaga)/ high herald (elite? Higher? I know I don't remember everything about her but that she could be a beast)
Ultraman /low herald
Guyver/ high meta
Brock Samson (venture brothers)/elite street level
Seras (helsing) /mid meta

Share your opinions and lets get some stuff moving!

Originally posted by NemeBro
Samara should not be mentioned in the same breath as characters like Storm.

Mid meta? **** that shit yo, **** it with a rusty spoon.
I see you have a strong opinion on this yo.
When you compare her to ppl like storm I can see how she can be bumped down a peg or two.

Kirby for abstract supreme being omega shenron tier.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Kirby for abstract supreme being omega shenron tier. I think you made this exact post in the thread for this in comic versus.

Hero of Time Link for mid-meta.

Originally posted by BloodRain
In anime, games and live action we're going to end up with a couple dozens above Herald, with hundreds below that. That fully speaks for mainstream series.



Something like this? Could throw some characters on there as examples.

I'd drop elite. Just go high/mid/low works best, plus that how KMC comic ranks go. Might as well keep it consistent.

I probably did, I love Kirby more than any other character. He is the only one that makes me smile.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
I probably did, I love Kirby more than any other character. He is the only one that makes me smile. Even Luigi?

What tier would you put Kenshiro in?

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
I probably did, I love Kirby more than any other character. He is the only one that makes me smile.

You know that the super smash bros games are rigged for Kirby to win right?

Kenshiro is hard to place, mid-high meta. Anyone with range would have an advantage over him. He can dodge bullets easily, he could crush Iron Man's armor, but Tony would still win most fights due to his range and attacks. He's a tankbuster like Wolverine, he's had some up and down durability showings, mainly low piercing/bladed durability. He's had rocks that weighed tons smashed over his head without flinching but an arrow has no problem piercing his skin, not going in deep, but it has penetrated his skin. He has insane speed and reflexes along with strength. One of the most skilled fighters in anime.

Originally posted by COG Veteran
You know that the super smash bros games are rigged for Kirby to win right?

As it should be

Originally posted by COG Veteran
You know that the super smash bros games are rigged for Kirby to win right? Originally posted by juggerman
As it should be

Juggerman you're the coolest member of KMC.

I'm curious as to where the Undefeated of the East would rank

IAizwLfZbUA

Originally posted by juggerman
As it should be

So out of all of the Super smash characters, who ranks as the highest (and at what level) and who is the lowest?

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Juggerman you're the coolest member of KMC.



Kirby is the man! That's my main SSB character

Originally posted by COG Veteran
So out of all of the Super smash characters, who ranks as the highest (and at what level) and who is the lowest?

Weakest is probably Olimar and strongest is, of course, Captain Falcon.

Originally posted by COG Veteran
So out of all of the Super smash characters, who ranks as the highest (and at what level) and who is the lowest? Ness would be highest, IIRC, MewTwo and Ganondorf fit in a few tiers down, prolly Low Herald. Most sit in the meta range. Olimar would be bottom tier because he's like an inch tall.

I was leaning toward Ganon as the strongest. Prolly followed up by Samus.

Depends.

Real selves: Mewtwo, Rayquaza, Ness and (super) Sonic, followed by Ganondorf, Samus and Ridley are the strongest.

Smash selves: Taboo, Ganondorf, Bowser and Sonic.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Ness would be highest, IIRC, MewTwo and Ganondorf fit in a few tiers down, prolly Low Herald. Most sit in the meta range. Olimar would be bottom tier because he's like an inch tall.

Been awhile but what did Ness do that was so impressive? I assume you are talking about his battle with Giygas but Giygas wasn't even harmed by Ness.

Originally posted by COG Veteran
I was leaning toward Ganon as the strongest. Prolly followed up by Samus.
Ness defeated something capable of busting a universe, IIRC. Ganondorf has no feats on that level. Ganondorf and MewTwo form the tier between Ness and the others, being the only other beings I can think of in smash above Meta (depending how much of Mario/Luigi's history is being counted... They could be stronger than Ness.) Depending on how you count it Donkey Kong tops the meta tiers because he can punch a moon out of orbit, but that moon behaved a bit strangely so it's up for debate.

Under DK Link and Samus are the next strongest.

Originally posted by ares834
Been awhile but what did Ness do that was so impressive? I assume you are talking about his battle with Giygas but Giygas wasn't even harmed by Ness.
Didn't he? I haven't actually played Earthbound so I'm going off what I've been told.

I'd put Ganondorf above Mewtwo.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Didn't he? I haven't actually played Earthbound so I'm going off what I've been told. I don't think any of your attacks have any effect, you have to pray to beat him if I recall correctly.

Originally posted by juggerman
I'd put Ganondorf above Mewtwo.

I wouldn't.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Didn't he? I haven't actually played Earthbound so I'm going off what I've been told.

IIRC he is defeated through prayer or something like that.

Originally posted by juggerman
I'd put Ganondorf above Mewtwo.
That's arguable, and depends what'd being counted as power. MewTwo has a far greater showing of destructive capability than Ganondorf has, he could casually maintain a powerful storm that would've killed all pokemon (I guess sub legendary, anyway) on Earth. Your typical hurrican releases the energy of a nuclear bomb every second, so yeah.

Ganondorf stopped the passing of night to day permanently with most of his power sealed though. How he actually did it is unknown but permanent night is a planetary feat, but not necessarily a destructive one. His greatest 'destructive' feat is merging two dimensions across the scape of an entire country using only a fraction of his power, though he's also flash frozen Zora's domain twice, and shattered an island.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
That's arguable, and depends what'd being counted as power. MewTwo has a far greater showing of destructive capability than Ganondorf has, he could casually maintain a powerful storm that would've killed all pokemon (I guess sub legendary, anyway) on Earth. Your typical hurrican releases the energy of a nuclear bomb every second, so yeah.

Ganondorf stopped the passing of night to day permanently with most of his power sealed though. How he actually did it is unknown but permanent night is a planetary feat, but not necessarily a destructive one. His greatest destructive feat is merging two dimensions across the scape of an entire country using only a fraction of his power, though he's also flash frozen Zora's domain twice, and shattered an island.

Who'd win in a fight? Guess that's the best way to decide who's above whom yes?

Originally posted by juggerman
Who'd win in a fight? Guess that's the best way to decide who's above whom yes? Not necessarily, I can name many people 'above' Ganondorf in power who he could defeat due to sheer haxness of powers. He is not more powerful than they are, so who would win isn't really relevant to a tier list.

Ganon is, imho, low herald, no higher. MewTwo also fits nicely into that category, I believe, but in overall power is higher than Ganondorf.

Originally posted by juggerman
Who'd win in a fight? Guess that's the best way to decide who's above whom yes?

Not necessarily, they could still end up in the same tier.

Not necessarily.

Edit: lol, third

Originally posted by ares834
Not necessarily.

Edit: lol, third Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Not necessarily, they could still end up in the same tier.
Jinx...?

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Not necessarily, I can name many people 'above' Ganondorf in power who he could defeat due to sheer haxness of powers. He is not more powerful than they are, so who would win isn't really relevant to a tier list.

Ganon is, imho, low herald, no higher. MewTwo also fits nicely into that category, I believe, but in overall power is higher than Ganondorf.

Gotcha

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Not necessarily, they could still end up in the same tier.

I meant higher between them

Originally posted by ares834
Not necessarily.

Edit: lol, third

Well.... shut up

Celestia and Luna for mid herald.

Comicbook Rainbow Dash for high meta.

Rainbow Dash, Shining Armour, and Twilight Sparkle for mid meta.

Big MacIntosh for low meta

Pinkie, AppleJack, Rarity, and Fluttershy for high street.

Yes, I had to be that guy.

Fluttershy at low street. Very low.

So, how are we going to rank all these characters?

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Fluttershy at low street. Very low.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WYA7t5Wx56Y



Originally posted by ares834
So, how are we going to rank all these characters?
By vote, I assume.

The stare doesn't have any actual power behind it...

Kenshiro should be at least high meta where People like Magneto and Iron Man is. EoS he I believe he as a assortment of abilities such Intangibility and the likes that will make him able to compete with the two.

Did goku's new god mode bump him up?

Originally posted by Phanteros
Kenshiro should be at least high meta where People like Magneto and Iron Man is. EoS he I believe he as a assortment of abilities such Intangibility and the likes that will make him able to compete with the two.

Magneto and Iron Man would both crush him. Iron Man due to range and artillery, Magneto because he is Magneto.

I'll tally the votes so far.
OMEGA SHENRON TIER

Kirby (2, lol)

Herald

High

KOS-MOS (1)

Mid

Celestia (1), Luna (1)

Low

MewTwo (2), Mew (1), Ultraman (1), Ganondorf (1)

Metahuman

High

Guyver (1), Comic!Rainbow Dash (1), Kenshiro (1)

Mid

Seras (Helsing) (1), Kirby (1), Hero of Time Link (1), Rainbow Dash (1), Twilight Sparkle (1), Kenshiro (1)

Low

Samara (Mass Effect) (1), Jack (Mass Effect) (1), Big MacInTosh (1), Shining Armour (1),

Street

High

Afro Samurai (1), Brock Samson (2), Pinkie (1), AppleJack (1), Rarity (1), Fluttershy (1)

Mid

Low

Roger Smith (Big O) (1), Fluttershy (1),

Originally posted by juggerman
I'd put Ganondorf above Mewtwo.
To clarify, are you voting for Ganondorf & MewTwo to be low-herald as well? I haven't counted this post.

I have factored my own votes into this.

Movie hasn't been quantified yet.

So should we just do those characters listed so far then? Figure out where they belong and then go from there.

Originally posted by ares834
So should we just do those characters listed so far then? Figure out where they belong and then go from there.
I think that would be best. Got a vote to cast?

I personally think Mew should be moved down to High Meta, he could fight MewTwo, but did not display MewTwo's higher feats like the massive storm he maintained casually during said fight.

Originally posted by SevenShackles
So are we keeping track of votes or is this working some other way?

I'll just throw out some suggestions to just get the ball rolling..
Mew two / low herald
Mew/ low herald
roger Smith (big O)/low street level
Samara/ low Meta
jack/low meta
Afro samurai/ elite street level
KOS-MOS full power (xenosaga)/ high herald (elite? Higher? I know I don't remember everything about her but that she could be a beast)
Ultraman /low herald
Guyver/ high meta
Brock Samson (venture brothers)/elite street level
Seras (helsing) /mid meta

Share your opinions and lets get some stuff moving!


I see you have a strong opinion on this yo.
When you compare her to ppl like storm I can see how she can be bumped down a peg or two.
http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_meg7grYvyb1ryx6or.gif
I'll take the lack of reply as confirmation that I'm awesome, cool and correct in my assesments.

Originally posted by SevenShackles
http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_meg7grYvyb1ryx6or.gif
I'll take the lack of reply as confirmation that I'm awesome, cool and correct in my assesments.
I counted every vote in that reply.

Ok, with my votes.

OMEGA SHENRON TIER

Kirby (2, lol)

Herald

High

KOS-MOS (1)

Mid

Celestia (1), Luna (1)

Low

MewTwo (3), Mew (2), Ultraman (1), Ganondorf (2)

Metahuman

High

Guyver (1), Comic!Rainbow Dash (1), Kenshiro (1)

Mid

Seras (Helsing) (1), Kirby (2), Hero of Time Link (2), Rainbow Dash (1), Twilight Sparkle (1), Kenshiro (2)

Low

Samara (Mass Effect) (2), Jack (Mass Effect) (2), Big MacInTosh (1), Shining Armour (1),

Street

High

Afro Samurai (1), Brock Samson (2), Pinkie (1), AppleJack (1), Rarity (1), Fluttershy (1)

Mid

Afro Samurai (1)

Low

Roger Smith (Big O) (1), Fluttershy (1),

Originally posted by COG Veteran
Umm.... Liara wtf pwned those guys once she stepped out of the vents. She couldn't levitate them inside the crawlspace.

Then why did she have to go int the vents in the first place? Since biotics = god there she should have soloed Cerberus forces that invaded Mars. Biotic users are ridiculously overhyped in other mediums.

How do votes even work with this?

Edit: And how many per verse are we mentioning?

Originally posted by BloodRain
How do votes even work with this?

Edit: And how many per verse are we mentioning?
You vote, the vote is added to the votes already on the board, majority rules.

So right now it looks like MewTwo is solid low herald, since it would take more than three votes to move him, or some people who voted for him would need to change their votes.

I see no limitation requirement, but we might wanna place the ones already mentioned first.

Most of the strong sonic characters would be around mid meta, right?

Hm, where would Ness rank

Warlow(trueblood) for loser low meta tier.

OMEGA SHENRON TIER

Kirby (2, lol)

Herald

High

KOS-MOS (1)

Mid

Celestia (1), Luna (1)

Low

MewTwo (3), Mew (2), Ultraman (1), Ganondorf (2)

Metahuman

High

Guyver (1), Comic!Rainbow Dash (1), Kenshiro (1), Mew (1)

Mid

Seras (Helsing) (1), Kirby (2), Hero of Time Link (2), Rainbow Dash (1), Twilight Sparkle (1), Kenshiro (2)

Low

Samara (Mass Effect) (2), Jack (Mass Effect) (2), Big MacInTosh (1), Shining Armour (1), Warlow (True Blood) (1)

Street

High

Afro Samurai (1), Brock Samson (2), Pinkie (1), AppleJack (1), Rarity (1), Fluttershy (1)

Mid

Afro Samurai (1)

Low

Roger Smith (Big O) (1), Fluttershy (1),

I'm going to request people be very clear about whether or not they are voting so the tally doesn't get confusing. If you are voting, from now on please indicate it with

for

Separated from the rest of your message as above. >_> Just makes my job easier.

Sonic, shadow, knuckles, and silver for mid meta.

Master Chief, mid meta.
Luke Skywalker, high meta.
Queen of Blades (Starcraft), low Herald.

OMEGA SHENRON TIER

Kirby (2, lol)

Herald

High

KOS-MOS (1)

Mid

Celestia (1), Luna (1)

Low

MewTwo (3), Mew (2), Ultraman (1), Ganondorf (2), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (1)

Metahuman

High

Guyver (1), Comic!Rainbow Dash (1), Kenshiro (1), Mew (1), Luke Skywalker (1), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (1)


Mid

Seras (Helsing) (1), Kirby (2), Hero of Time Link (2), Rainbow Dash (1), Twilight Sparkle (1), Kenshiro (2), Sonic (1), Shadow (1), Knuckles (1), Silver (1), Master Chief (Halo) (1)

Low

Samara (Mass Effect) (2), Jack (Mass Effect) (2), Big MacInTosh (1), Shining Armour (1), Warlow (True Blood) (1), Master Chief (Halo) (1)

Street

High

Afro Samurai (1), Brock Samson (2), Pinkie (1), AppleJack (1), Rarity (1), Fluttershy (1)

Mid

Afro Samurai (1)

Low

Roger Smith (Big O) (1), Fluttershy (1),

Queen of Blades for high meta
Master Chief for low meta

(Votes already included)

Maybe it's just me, but I definitely think we should get the current characters finalized before we begin listing others. Otherwise, it could just end up as a mess.

Originally posted by Phanteros
Warlow(trueblood) for loser low meta tier.
Russell, Warlow and Billith for Low Meta.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Most of the strong sonic characters would be around mid meta, right?
Sonic etc for Mid Meta
Super Sonic etc for Mid Herald
Solaris for High Skyfather O.o



Now Scream you ass, where would a character go who defeats someone who is above their tier? Eg Super Sonic. He and two other Mid Heralds defeated a High Skyfather. What does that say about them?

Guess this is a question on powerscaling too.

Originally posted by ares834
Maybe it's just me, but I definitely think we should get the current characters finalized before we begin listing others. Otherwise, it could just end up as a mess. Agreed. Have votes to cast?

Master Chief for low meta.
Luke Skywalker for high meta.
Queen of Blades (Starcraft) for high meta.

OMEGA SHENRON TIER

Kirby (2, lol)

Skyfather

Solaris (1)

Herald

High

KOS-MOS (1)

Mid

Celestia (1), Luna (1), Super Sonic (1), Super Shadow (1), Hyper Knuckles (1), Super Silver (1)

Low

MewTwo (3), Mew (2), Ultraman (1), Ganondorf (2), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (1)

Metahuman

High

Guyver (1), Comic!Rainbow Dash (1), Kenshiro (1), Mew (1), Luke Skywalker (2), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (2)


Mid

Seras (Helsing) (1), Kirby (2), Hero of Time Link (2), Rainbow Dash (1), Twilight Sparkle (1), Kenshiro (2), Sonic (2), Shadow (2), Knuckles (2), Silver (2), Master Chief (Halo) (1)

Low

Samara (Mass Effect) (2), Jack (Mass Effect) (2), Big MacInTosh (1), Shining Armour (1), Warlow (True Blood) (2), Russell Edgington (1), Billith (1), Master Chief (Halo) (2)

Street

High

Afro Samurai (1), Brock Samson (2), Pinkie (1), AppleJack (1), Rarity (1), Fluttershy (1)

Mid

Afro Samurai (1)

Low

Roger Smith (Big O) (1), Fluttershy (1),

Edit: Now with Ares' votes included.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Most of the strong sonic characters would be around mid meta, right?
(Sonic, knuckles, shadow, silver, metal sonic, scourge etc) Sounds about right. I'm more interested in where super sonic, enrjak and hyper knuckles would fall.
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/12/123441/2475991-super_sonic_vs_hyper_knuckles_showdown_8.jpg
Super sonic and hyper knuckles collide and destroy a zone. Makes me question what overall tier they should be in.

Originally posted by BloodRain
Now Scream you ass, where would a character go who defeats someone who is above their tier? Eg Super Sonic. He and two other Mid Heralds defeated a High Skyfather. What does that say about them?

Guess this is a question on powerscaling too.

Happens all the time. Superman and Thor, for example, have defeated Skyfather+ beings before.

Originally posted by ares834
Happens all the time. Superman and Thor, for example, have defeated Skyfather+ beings before. Link does this with Ganondorf, most Final Fantasy games have this happen, Dante did it with Mundus (131) etc.

so yeah, not necessarily a factor in tier placement, though good for feats.

Originally posted by SevenShackles
(Sonic, knuckles, shadow, silver, metal sonic, scourge etc) Sounds about right. I'm more interested in where super sonic, enrjak and hyper knuckles would fall.
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/12/123441/2475991-super_sonic_vs_hyper_knuckles_showdown_8.jpg
Super sonic and hyper knuckles collide and destroy a zone. Makes me question what overall tier they should be in.
BR seems to feel mid herald.

Originally posted by SevenShackles
(Sonic, knuckles, shadow, silver, metal sonic, scourge etc) Sounds about right. I'm more interested in where super sonic, enrjak and hyper knuckles would fall.
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/12/123441/2475991-super_sonic_vs_hyper_knuckles_showdown_8.jpg
Super sonic and hyper knuckles collide and destroy a zone. Makes me question what overall tier they should be in.
Low-mid Herald?

I agree with Kirby being mid meta.


Mid herald sounds right.

Originally posted by SevenShackles
I agree with Kirby being mid meta.


Mid herald sounds right.
Counting those as votes, updating:

OMEGA SHENRON TIER

Kirby (2, lol)

Skyfather

Solaris (1)

Herald

High

KOS-MOS (1)

Mid

Celestia (1), Luna (1), Super Sonic (2), Super Shadow (2), Hyper Knuckles (2), Super Silver (2)

Low

MewTwo (3), Mew (2), Ultraman (1), Ganondorf (2), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (1)

Metahuman

High

Guyver (1), Comic!Rainbow Dash (1), Kenshiro (1), Mew (1), Luke Skywalker (2), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (2)

Mid

Seras (Helsing) (1), Kirby (3), Hero of Time Link (2), Rainbow Dash (1), Twilight Sparkle (1), Kenshiro (2), Sonic (2), Shadow (2), Knuckles (2), Silver (2), Master Chief (Halo) (1)

Low

Samara (Mass Effect) (2), Jack (Mass Effect) (2), Big MacInTosh (1), Shining Armour (1), Warlow (True Blood) (2), Russell Edgington (1), Billith (1), Master Chief (Halo) (2)

Street

High

Afro Samurai (1), Brock Samson (2), Pinkie (1), AppleJack (1), Rarity (1), Fluttershy (1)

Mid

Afro Samurai (1)

Low

Roger Smith (Big O) (1), Fluttershy (1),

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Low-mid Herald?
Not sure if vote, did not count.

Well what if by feats Thorman was a Herald and defeated a character whose feats are Skyfather, but we see that Thorman is a lot stronger but lacks certain powers?

Like Kratos. By their feats Zeus should be above, what with his powers, but Kratos would overpower him.

Kratos is probably low herald, but we can cross that bridge when we get to it. We'll just judge by displayed power.

Now agree with Ganondorf and OoT Link's placement. uhuh

Originally posted by BloodRain
Well what if by feats Thorman was a Herald and defeated a character whose feats are Skyfather, but we see that Thorman is a lot stronger but lacks certain powers?

It really depends. For example, if Thorman struggled with other far weaker characters or struggled to perform herald level feats then his placement should be about that level. But if he breezed through those and beat then shit out of a Skyfather, well, then I'd argue he should be at least a Skyfather.

O.o I was going to put my Kratos vote to the High Meta tier.

Agreed on Ganondorf and OoT Link's placement :T

Cole Macgrath for Low Meta

Cole!Beast for Mid Meta

Alex Mercer for Mid Meta

Kain for Low Meta

Arceus for Skyfather??

Dante for Low Herald

Sora for Mid Meta+

Wesker for High Street

Master Chief for High Street

Cloud for Low Meta

Raiden for Mid Meta

Voldemort for High Street

Aang for Low Meta

Castiel for High Meta

Lucifer (SN) for Low Herald

Lucifer (SMT) for whatevers the rank right below Supreme being

Sylar for Low Meta

Kaiju's (PR) for Mid Meta+

Alucard (Hellsing) for Mid Meta

Hellboy for Low Meta

RISE OF THE METAS!!!

Originally posted by ares834
It really depends. For example, if Thorman struggled with other far weaker characters or struggled to perform herald level feats then his placement should be about that level. But if he breezed through those and beat then shit out of a Skyfather, well, then I'd argue he should be at least a Skyfather.
Now I know why people find difficulty with tier lists

Originally posted by BloodRain
O.o I was going to put my Kratos vote to the High Meta tier.

Agreed on Ganondorf and OoT Link's placement :T

Cole Macgrath for Low Meta

Cole!Beast for Mid Meta

Alex Mercer for Mid Meta

Kain for Low Meta

Arceus for Skyfather??

Dante for Low Herald

Sora for Mid Meta+

Wesker for High Street

Master Chief for High Street

Cloud for Low Meta

Raiden for Mid Meta

Voldemort for High Street

Aang for Low Meta

Castiel for High Meta

Lucifer (SN) for Low Herald

Lucifer (SMT) for whatevers the rank right below Supreme being

Sylar for Low Meta

Kaiju's (PR) for Mid Meta+

Alucard (Hellsing) for Mid Meta

Hellboy for Low Meta

RISE OF THE METAS!!!


Now I know why people find difficulty with tier lists
Tallying.... Please wait.
http://0-media-cdn.foolz.us/ffuuka/board/q/image/1369/15/1369153725815.jpg

Only did 4, then remembered you didnt answer my question.. call that my master revenge plan ahah

Originally posted by BloodRain
Arceus for Skyfather??


Been awhile, but wasn't Dialga/Palkia creating a universe in Diamond/Pearl. That should put them and Arceus well above Skyfather assuming we ignore the Arceus movie...

I'm a little shakey on my tier terms (bad luck for Scream when I likely change me mind on something), but I don't think the pair were doing so, just had powers on that level.

Guess those two would be High Skyfather, above that for Arceus.

OMEGA SHENRON TIER

Kirby (2, lol)

Abstract

Lucifer (Shin Megami Tensei) (1)

Skyfather

Solaris (1), Arceus (1),

Herald

High

KOS-MOS (1)

Mid

Celestia (1), Luna (1), Super Sonic (2), Super Shadow (2), Hyper Knuckles (2), Super Silver (2)

Low

MewTwo (3), Mew (2), Ultraman (1), Ganondorf (3), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (1), Dante (DMC1-4) (1), Lucifer (Super Natural)

Metahuman

High

Guyver (1), Comic!Rainbow Dash (1), Kenshiro (1), Mew (1), Luke Skywalker (2), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (2), Castiel (1)

Mid

Seras (Hellsing) (1), Kirby (3), Link (Hero of Time) (3), Rainbow Dash (1), Twilight Sparkle (1), Kenshiro (2), Sonic (2), Shadow (2), Knuckles (2), Silver (2), Master Chief (Halo) (1), Beast!Cole (InFamous) (1), Alex Mercer (1), Sora (Kingdom Hearts) (1), Cyborg!Raiden (MGS) (1), Kaiju's (PR) (1), Alucard (Hellsing) (1)

Low

Samara (Mass Effect) (2), Jack (Mass Effect) (2), Big MacInTosh (1), Shining Armour (1), Warlow (True Blood) (2), Russell Edgington (1), Billith (1), Master Chief (Halo) (2), Cole McGrath (InFamous) (1), Kain the Vampire (1), Cloud (FF7) (1), Aang (Avatar) (1), Sylar (1), Hellboy (1)

Street

High

Afro Samurai (1), Brock Samson (2), Pinkie (1), AppleJack (1), Rarity (1), Fluttershy (1), Albert Wesker (Resident Evil Games) (1), Master Chief (Halo) (1), Voldemort (1)

Mid

Afro Samurai (1)

Low

Roger Smith (Big O) (1), Fluttershy (1),

Edit: I'll be slowly adding links to OBD profiles to the list.

Originally posted by BloodRain
Only did 4, then remembered you didnt answer my question.. call that my master revenge plan ahah
I'm high on pain killers, clarification needed.

Originally posted by ares834
Been awhile, but wasn't Dialga/Palkia creating a universe in Diamond/Pearl. That should put them and Arceus well above Skyfather assuming we ignore the Arceus movie...
The movies/anime and games are separate. We should note them separately in the tier list.

For organization you guys should pick a character, list their feats and whatnot along with vulnerabilities and weaknesses if needed and then everyone votes on where they should be. Everyone can't vote on every character without knowledge of the character in question. Could start at the street level and work up.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
For organization you guys should pick a character, list their feats and whatnot along with vulnerabilities and weaknesses if needed and then everyone votes on where they should be. Everyone can't vote on every character without knowledge of the character in question. Could start at the street level and work up.
This is part of why I'm linking profiles from OBD. Also, not everyone needs to vote on every character, if they don't know enough then the ones who do should be able to place that character where they like. Your way would be very thorough, but also fairly slow. Would we create new threads for that? If it's in a separate thread then that sounds like a great idea.

Yeah a tier discussion thread.. or this could be the discussion thread.


Was only going to do 4 characters :T btw on your next edit its DMC2 Dante that I'm talking about. DMC 1&4 Dante would be a rank below.

Originally posted by BloodRain
Yeah a tier discussion thread.. or this could be the discussion thread.


Was only going to do 4 characters :T btw on your next edit its DMC2 Dante that I'm talking about. DMC 1&4 Dante would be a rank below.
Nah, a new thread for each character to keep it organized, but we'd keep the numbers of characters being discussed low at any given time.

It says 1-4, not 1+4, I think. Anyway, will differentiate. Get on Skype.

Originally posted by BloodRain
O.o I was going to put my Kratos vote to the High Meta tier.

Agreed on Ganondorf and OoT Link's placement :T

Cole Macgrath for Low Meta

Cole!Beast for Mid Meta

Alex Mercer for Mid Meta

Kain for Low Meta

Arceus for Skyfather??

Dante for Low Herald

Sora for Mid Meta+

Wesker for High Street

Master Chief for High Street

Cloud for Low Meta

Raiden for Mid Meta

Voldemort for High Street

Aang for Low Meta

Castiel for High Meta

Lucifer (SN) for Low Herald

Lucifer (SMT) for whatevers the rank right below Supreme being

Sylar for Low Meta

Kaiju's (PR) for Mid Meta+

Alucard (Hellsing) for Mid Meta

Hellboy for Low Meta

RISE OF THE METAS!!!


Now I know why people find difficulty with tier lists
Raiden as in metal gear solid Raiden or mortal kombat Raiden? I think clarification needs to be made in some instances.

OMEGA SHENRON TIER

Kirby (2, lol)

Abstract

Lucifer (Shin Megami Tensei) (1)

Skyfather

Solaris (1), Arceus (1),

Transcendant

Discord (MLP:FiM) (1)

Herald

High

KOS-MOS (1)

Mid

Princess Celestia (1), Princess Luna (1), Super Sonic (2), Super Shadow (2), Hyper Knuckles (2), Super Silver the Hedgehog (2),

Low

MewTwo (3), Mew (2), Ultraman (1), Ganondorf (3), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (1), Dante (DMC2) (1), Lucifer (Super Natural)

Metahuman

High

Guyver (1), Comic!Rainbow Dash (1), Kenshiro (1), Mew (1), Luke Skywalker (2), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (2), Castiel (1), Dante (DMC1&4) (1)

Mid

Seras (Hellsing) (1), Kirby (3), Link (Hero of Time) (3), Samus Aran (1), Rainbow Dash (1), Twilight Sparkle (1), Kenshiro (2), Sonic (2), Shadow (2), Knuckles (2), Silver the Hedgehog (2), Master Chief (Halo) (1), Beast!Cole (InFamous) (1), Alex Mercer (1), Sora (Kingdom Hearts) (1), Cyborg!Raiden (MGS) (1), Kaiju's (PR) (1), Alucard (Hellsing) (1)

Low

Samara (Mass Effect) (2), Jack (Mass Effect) (2), Big MacInTosh (1), Shining Armour (1), Warlow (True Blood) (2), Russell Edgington (1), Billith (1), Master Chief (Halo) (2), Cole McGrath (InFamous) (1), Kain the Vampire (1), Cloud (FF7) (1), Aang (Avatar) (1), Sylar (1), Hellboy (1)

Street

High

Afro Samurai (1), Brock Samson (2), Pinkie (1), AppleJack (1), Rarity (1), Fluttershy (1), Albert Wesker (Resident Evil Games) (1), Master Chief (Halo) (1), Voldemort (1)

Mid

Afro Samurai (1)

Low

Roger Smith (Big O) (1), Fluttershy (1),

Samus Aran for mid meta. (Already counted)

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
This is part of why I'm linking profiles from OBD. Also, not everyone needs to vote on every character, if they don't know enough then the ones who do should be able to place that character where they like. Your way would be very thorough, but also fairly slow. Would we create new threads for that? If it's in a separate thread then that sounds like a great idea.

No, you don't need a new thread for each character. You can briefly discuss them all here or in another thread.

Example: I think Mr. Bubbles should be mid street, he can fight off a group of armed thugs wielding knives, skilled enough to fight with his eyesight impaired and he has some good damage soak.

Someone comes in who agrees after hearing what they can do can put their vote towards it as well or they can disagree.

I think he's more of a low meta because of whatever reason and whoever chooses to vote can vote either way or give an entirely different opinion. Everyone voting on characters they know and like is just going to be a bad idea I think. I feel as if we should all get some general knowledge and see why they are being placed in their respective position.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
No, you don't need a new thread for each character. You can briefly discuss them all here or in another thread.

Example: I think Mr. Bubbles should be mid street, he can fight off a group of armed thugs wielding knives, skilled enough to fight with his eyesight impaired and he has some good damage soak.

Someone comes in who agrees after hearing what they can do can put their vote towards it as well or they can disagree.

I think he's more of a low meta because of whatever reason and whoever chooses to vote can vote either way or give an entirely different opinion. Everyone voting on characters they know and like is just going to be a bad idea I think. I feel as if we should all get some general knowledge and see why they are being placed in their respective position. All right, fair enough. I think we should use a different thread, though.

Would you start it, please? So far the characters that have been voted for in multiple tiers are:

Sarah Kerrigan (QoB)
Master Chief (Halo)
Kenshiro, I know you're interested in that one, so we can do it first

Originally posted by BloodRain
O.o I was going to put my Kratos vote to the High Meta tier.

Agreed on Ganondorf and OoT Link's placement :T

Cole Macgrath for Low Meta

Cole!Beast for Mid Meta

Alex Mercer for Mid Meta

Kain for Low Meta

Arceus for Skyfather??

Dante for Low Herald

Sora for Mid Meta+

Wesker for High Street

Master Chief for High Street

Cloud for Low Meta

Raiden for Mid Meta

Voldemort for High Street

Aang for Low Meta

Castiel for High Meta

Lucifer (SN) for Low Herald

Lucifer (SMT) for whatevers the rank right below Supreme being

Sylar for Low Meta

Kaiju's (PR) for Mid Meta+

Alucard (Hellsing) for Mid Meta

Hellboy for Low Meta

RISE OF THE METAS!!!


Now I know why people find difficulty with tier lists

If that's legacy of Kain, Kain then he's at least mid, and MAster Chief as well as Wesker would be low Meta, I'm assuming that Chief in the suit.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
If that's legacy of Kain, Kain then he's at least mid, and MAster Chief as well as Wesker would be low Meta, I'm assuming that Chief in the suit.
Should I count those as votes?

Voldemort seems more low meta to me.
Also, power puff girls for mid-ish meta (or low)

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
If that's legacy of Kain, Kain then he's at least mid, and MAster Chief as well as Wesker would be low Meta, I'm assuming that Chief in the suit.
Just abouts down doing that same list with reasons.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Voldemort seems more low meta to me.
Also, power puff girls for mid-ish meta (or low)
Counting these, then I say we switch to Wei's format from here on in, now that we have a fairly established list.

Sound good to everyone?

OMEGA SHENRON TIER

Kirby (2, lol)

Abstract

Lucifer (Shin Megami Tensei) (1)

Skyfather

Solaris (1), Arceus (1),

Transcendant

Discord (MLP:FiM) (1)

Herald

High

KOS-MOS (1)

Mid

Princess Celestia (1), Princess Luna (1), Super Sonic (2), Super Shadow (2), Hyper Knuckles (2), Super Silver the Hedgehog (2),

Low

MewTwo (3), Mew (2), Ultraman (1), Ganondorf (3), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (1), Dante (DMC2) (1), Lucifer (Super Natural)

Metahuman

High

Guyver (1), Comic!Rainbow Dash (1), Kenshiro (1), Mew (1), Luke Skywalker (2), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (2), Castiel (1), Dante (DMC1&4) (1)

Mid

Seras (Hellsing) (1), Kirby (3), Link (Hero of Time) (3), Samus Aran (1), Rainbow Dash (1), Twilight Sparkle (1), Kenshiro (2), Sonic (2), Shadow (2), Knuckles (2), Silver the Hedgehog (2), Master Chief (Halo) (1), Beast!Cole (InFamous) (1), Alex Mercer (1), Sora (Kingdom Hearts) (1), Cyborg!Raiden (MGS) (1), Kaiju's (PR) (1), Alucard (Hellsing) (1), Power Puff Girls (1), Kain the Vampire (1),

Low

Samara (Mass Effect) (2), Jack (Mass Effect) (2), Big MacInTosh (1), Shining Armour (1), Warlow (True Blood) (2), Russell Edgington (1), Billith (1), Master Chief (Halo) (3), Cole McGrath (InFamous) (1), Kain the Vampire (1), Cloud (FF7) (1), Aang (Avatar) (1), Sylar (1), Hellboy (1), Albert Wesker (Resident Evil Games) (1)

Street

High

Afro Samurai (1), Brock Samson (2), Pinkie (1), AppleJack (1), Rarity (1), Fluttershy (1), Albert Wesker (Resident Evil Games) (1), Master Chief (Halo), Voldemort (1)

Mid

Afro Samurai (1)

Low

Roger Smith (Big O) (1), Fluttershy (1),

Quick question, is the sun Celestia lifting basically a real star or is a more mythological one? If it's the former she should be well above mid herald IMO.

As a giant pony needs to move it, i'll guess its mythological.

I personally think Cole would be around Mid Meta, but I'm not 100% sure how that's classified. Still, Cole McGrath for Mid Meta.

Also, should composites of characters be considered as well? (i.e. Link, Samus, etc.)

Originally posted by ares834
Quick question, is the sun Celestia lifting basically a real star or is a more mythological one? If it's the former she should be well above mid herald IMO.
It's a real one as far as I can tell, Nightmare Moon imprisoned her inside of it, and you can't really do that with mythological stars, and telescopes and shit exist in FiM.

All right, I tallied up Wei's votes,
Originally posted by Sacred 117
I personally think Cole would be around Mid Meta, but I'm not 100% sure how that's classified. Still, Cole McGrath for Mid Meta.

Also, should composites of characters be considered as well? (i.e. Link, Samus, etc.)
Will save these for later. It's hard to concentrate right now. Going to move on to more detailed ranking.

Characters who have been voted into multiple tiers should be sorted first. So Master Chief, Kenshiro, etc.

Master Chief would be easy Low Meta. He has enhancements and various weapons and equipment, but nothing really beyond that.

I don't know Kenshiro. Lol.

-Asura(EoG)(Asura's wrath) for high Herald.
-Plutonian(Irredeemable) for mid herald
-Kain and Raziel for mid Metahuman
-Invincible(Comic of the same name) for high meta
-The Prince(SoT): high street level
-Lenneth(Valkyrie Profile) low herald

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
For organization you guys should pick a character, list their feats and whatnot along with vulnerabilities and weaknesses if needed and then everyone votes on where they should be. Everyone can't vote on every character without knowledge of the character in question. Could start at the street level and work up.
Originally posted by BloodRain
Kratos for High Meta tier
Hypersonic, Town level strength, soul pulling weapons, element manip.

Cole Macgrath for Low Meta / Cole!Beast for Mid Meta
Low superhuman body strongest attacks being wall+, element manip. Beast is building level with molecule regeneration.

Alex Mercer for Mid Meta
Blitzing humans, throwing tanks for cityblocks, tanks buildings exploding and with great regen.

Kain for Mid Meta
Low superhuman speed, small building strength, can slow time by 1/5th, soul attacking weapons, telekinesis, teleportation, element manip, defensive logia forms

Arceus for Skyfather/Abstract
Created the Pokemon universe

DMC2 Dante for Low Herald
High Hypersonic, High Multi-city block strength, good regeneration, teleportation, low telikenisis, can slow time by 1/3000th, time stop, element manip, clone, hyper sharp sword, strong barrier, BFR. Curbedstomped three wipers.

Sora for Mid Meta+
Hypersonic+, Multi-city block strength, Magnet/attraction spell, element manip, strong barrier

Wesker for High Street
Supersonic, wall level strength, good regen.

Master Chief for High Street
Peak+ speed, can flip tanks(?), strong laser weapons.

Cloud for Low Meta
Hypersonic, Building strength, element manip

Raiden for Mid Meta
Hypersonic, Multi-City block strength, some regen, hyper sharp sword

Voldemort for High Street
Peak human, small building magical strength, teleporting, telikenisis, killing/pain curse.

Aang for Low Meta
Supersonic, superhuman strength, elemental manipulation

Castiel for High Meta
Hypersonic+, low superhuman strength, high regeneration (can keep coming back unless special magic comes into play), mind rape, telekinesis, time travel, invisibility, possible Town/City level attack, fire manipulation, teleportation

Lucifer (SN) for Low Herald
Everything Castiel has but far more powerful. Can create time loops and reality warp, life wiper.

Lucifer (SMT) for whatevers the rank right below Supreme being
Magnitudes stronger than High FTL beings who could create,wipe out and recreate billions of universes instantly

Sylar for Low Meta
Telekinesis, electric manip, sound manip, regeneration, low disintegration

Kaiju's (PR) for Mid Meta+
Takes nukes to defeat them, building strength, some have EMP attacks

Alucard (Hellsing) for Mid Meta
Supersonic+, Superhuman strength, great regeneration, teleport, low telekinesis

Hellboy for Low Meta
Superhuman strength and durability, fire resistance

Sonic for Mid Meta
Hypesonic, can kick around large robots, time manip

Super Sonic for Mid Herald
Lightspeed, time manip, can teleport multi-city block sized objects

High tier TB vamps for Low Meta
Supersonic, superhuman strength, some regen. One vamp has concussion blasts, another has low telekinesis

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=583944

I'm seeing a lot of categories that are new to me like Skyfather, etc.

Just out of wild curiosity, how would comic book characters like Odin, Galactus, The Living Tribunal, and The One Above All be placed?

TOAA is Supreme Being, Tribunal is high Abstract, low Abstract for Galactus, Odin for high Skyfather.

I'm pretty sure all the ones you just mentioned would be considered Skyfathers. In fact, I think the term Skyfather comes from a comic Odin showing...or maybe it's from the new gods in DC. Can't quite remember.

Also, what's with this nonsense of Fluttershy at low street? She's at least low meta. Talks down dragons and can break petrification with a look.

Is there a reference chart I can study? I need to familiarize myself with these categories if I want to be of any help.

I'm not saying for EVERY category, rather just the ones I have never been too familiar with.

Skyfather would stop at Universal.

Originally posted by Impediment
Is there a reference chart I can study? I need to familiarize myself with these categories if I want to be of any help.

I'm not saying for EVERY category, rather just the ones I have never been too familiar with.
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t577922.html

Originally posted by XanatosForever
I'm pretty sure all the ones you just mentioned would be considered Skyfathers. In fact, I think the term Skyfather comes from a comic Odin showing...or maybe it's from the new gods in DC. Can't quite remember.

Nah, Galactus, TOAA, and LT are all well above Skyfather.

So do they get a tier of their own, or are they just acknowledged as above tiers in general? Is there an Abstract tier or something?

Originally posted by XanatosForever
So do they get a tier of their own, or are they just acknowledged as above tiers in general? Is there an Abstract tier or something? There is an abstract tier, yes.

Cool beans.

Fluttershy for Low Meta.

Noted, Fluttershy will need to be discussed soon, she's in three tiers now.

Originally posted by Sacred 117
I personally think Cole would be around Mid Meta, but I'm not 100% sure how that's classified. Still, Cole McGrath for Mid Meta.

Also, should composites of characters be considered as well? (i.e. Link, Samus, etc.)
Yes, they should, but we'll hold off on that.

alphabetizing the tier list, before it gets too big.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Should I count those as votes?

Yes

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Noted, Fluttershy will need to be discussed soon, she's in three tiers now.

Honestly, I'm willing to accept her at High Street, since she'll at least match AJ and Rarity, but I think there's a decent argument for Low Meta.

Originally posted by XanatosForever
Honestly, I'm willing to accept her at High Street, since she'll at least match AJ and Rarity, but I think there's a decent argument for Low Meta. her greatest power is making people feel uncomfortable?

Not sure it's her greatest, but she has been shown imposing her will on creatures clearly larger, more dangerous, and outright more powerful than her. That, and animals adore her.

I'm gonna go off-topic for a second to hand ScreamPaste the props he deserves for doing all this muthaluvin' work tallying the tiers. Props to you, man. I'd buy you a six pack (or something, lol) if I were old enough and lived in Canada (IIRC).

Originally posted by XanatosForever
Not sure it's her greatest, but she has been shown imposing her will on creatures clearly larger, more dangerous, and outright more powerful than her. That, and animals adore her. She's like Aquaman with beavers instead of sharks. Also much cuter.

Originally posted by Sacred 117
I'm gonna go off-topic for a second to hand ScreamPaste the props he deserves for doing all this muthaluvin' work tallying the tiers. Props to you, man. I'd buy you a six pack (or something, lol) if I were old enough and lived in Canada (IIRC).
Much appreciated. Anything but Molson, hahaha.

I also vote for Cole McGrath and Alex mercer to be in mid meta. And Kenshiro for high Meta.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Much appreciated. Anything but Molson, hahaha.

Unless drinking laws are different there, it'll have to wait two years, I'm afraid. Lol. Rest assured, I'll follow through.

OMEGA SHENRON TIER

Kirby (2, lol)

Abstract

Lucifer (Shin Megami Tensei) (1)

Skyfather

Arceus (1), Solaris (1),

Transcendant

Discord (MLP:FiM) (1)

Herald

High

KOS-MOS (1)

Mid

Princess Celestia (1), Princess Luna (1), Hyper Knuckles (2), Super Shadow (2), Super Silver the Hedgehog (2), Super Sonic (2),

Low

Dante (DMC2) (1),Ganondorf (3), Lucifer (Super Natural), Mew (2) MewTwo (3), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (1), Ultraman (1)

Metahuman

High

Castiel (1), Dante (DMC1&4) (1), Guyver (1), Kenshiro (2), Luke Skywalker (2), Mew (1), Comic!Rainbow Dash (1), Sarah Kerrigan (Queen of Blades) (2)

Mid

Alucard (Hellsing) (1), Alex Mercer (2), Beast!Cole (InFamous) (1), Cole McGrath (InFamous) (2), Kaiju's (PR) (1), Kain the Vampire (1), Kenshiro (2), Kirby (3), Knuckles (2), Link (Hero of Time) (3), Master Chief (Halo) (1), Power Puff Girls (1), Cyborg!Raiden (MGS) (1), Rainbow Dash (1), Samus Aran (1), Seras (Hellsing) (1),Silver the Hedgehog (2), Shadow (2), Sonic (2), Sora (Kingdom Hearts) (1), Twilight Sparkle (1),

Low

Aang (Avatar) (1), Billith (1), Cloud (FF7) (1), Cole McGrath (InFamous) (1), Albert Wesker (Resident Evil Games) (1), Big MacInTosh (1), Fluttershy (1), Hellboy (1), Jack (Mass Effect) (2), Kain the Vampire (1), Master Chief (Halo) (8), Russell Edgington (1), Samara (Mass Effect) (2), Shining Armour (1), Sylar (1), Warlow (True Blood) (2)

Street

High

Afro Samurai (1), Albert Wesker (Resident Evil Games) (1), AppleJack (1), Brock Samson (2), Fluttershy (1), Master Chief (1), Pinkie (1), Rarity (1), Voldemort (1)

Mid

Afro Samurai (1)

Low

Fluttershy (1), Roger Smith (Big O) (1),

Now in alphabetical order! And up to date with all votes so far made.

Originally posted by Sacred 117
Unless drinking laws are different there, it'll have to wait two years, I'm afraid. Lol. Rest assured, I'll follow through.
Only need to be 19 here.