Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Captain Jack gets his hat and sword
Indiana gets his hat and whip
No pis
Fight is on empty Black Pearl

Round one: Jack is bloodlusted
Round two: Both Jack and Indy are bloodlusted

I've gotta say that Indy wins these. He just has more focus, and I don't think that we've ever seen Jack "bloodlusted." I mean, he just literally drops into situations where he has to surrender or fight, and his fights are based on luck - that's the Jack Sparrow we all know and love.

Plus there's the fact that Sparrow isn't exactly careful with artifacts - where Indy would be "THAT BELONGS IN A MUSEUM!!! RAWR!!"

Indy's fought on ships before, quite a few times actually. I definitely think he's got this.

Sword beats whip.

Cap Jack absolutely rapes indy. Jack is a pirate and plays dirty, not to mention his talent with the sword

Indy whips Jacks sword out of his hand and throws it in a museum. Done.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Sword beats whip.

Or the whip disarms the sword bearer. Indy is clearly the better h2h fighter, so if he disarms Jack he can beat him

Jack is a man who has fought mortal men, zombies, and sea monsters. Indy is a man who who rapes Nazis for a living.

Could go either way.

Originally posted by IceBreaker2000
Cap Jack absolutely rapes indy. Jack is a pirate and plays dirty, not to mention his talent with the sword

As if Indy doesn't fight dirty. My money's on him.

Indy sneaks a gun in. He wins.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Indy sneaks a gun in. He wins.

So does that mean Jack snuck in 2 guns and a bomb?

Considering Jack's guns are inferior, I'd say sure.

They are inferior but he's made some pretty good shots with them. And even a glancing hit from one of those guns would literally tear a chunk out of Indy.

If they're sitting in each others' lap, sure. But older guns are not that accurate, and modern pistols outstrip them in everywhere. So in a quick draw, Indy wins more often than not.

NO GUNS PEOPLE

Jack has better fighting feats against more dangerous opponents

ftw

Jack wins.

Jack is a drunk with luck. Indy isn't a drunk and he doesn't need luck. Although there always seems to be a rabbits' foot abound in his field of four leaf clovers as well. At the end of the day jack is just another guy with a sword and Indy doesn't even have time for guys like that.

Originally posted by jinXed by JaNx
just another guy with a sword

Who actually knows how to use the sword

whip Whip isnt gonna help Indy here

Jack fought pretty evenly with a centuries old pirate lord, and is probably one of the most skilled combatants in the Pirates verse. Considering he's fought on even terms with and beaten the biggest and best fighters that universe has to offer.

Barbosa, Blackbeard, Will Turner, Davy Jones, etc...

Jack's also much more in tune with his environment. Seemingly to a Jackie Chang-esque level where he can not only use it to his advantage, but to his opponents detriment.

Indy opens up Jack's face with the whip and then disarms him before going into Harrison Ford drunken boxing mode.

Indy for the win.

http://stream1.gifsoup.com/view/329121/indiana-jones-vs-sword-o.gif

Yeah. Let's use an example of a guy with no shown feats showing off like a dumbass, vs a guy with 3 movies worth of kicking everybodies ass.

Also Indy doesn't have his gun in this.

Sense of humor isn't your strong suit, I take it.

I'm on pain pills right now. So it's probably dulled. Is that Lando in your avi?

Originally posted by KingD19
I'm on pain pills right now. So it's probably dulled. Is that Lando in your avi?

I am as well. Stupid migraine. But I definitely understand where you're coming from.

Nope, it's Andrew Ryan. Stylized portrait.

I wish all it was was a migraine. I got kicked in the bicep in a sparring match.

That sounds very unfun. Recovery time?

I'd prefer Jones myself. Jacks too dirty and smelly. Dr Jones though.... meow.

Edit: Oh wait thats not what the threads about.

Also I already commented. Huh.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
That sounds very unfun. Recovery time?

It wasn't too bad. It's one of those "feels worse than it actually is" injuries. So a few days tops. But it does hurt like a b*tch.

Originally posted by KingD19
It wasn't too bad. It's one of those "feels worse than it actually is" injuries. So a few days tops. But it does hurt like a b*tch.

Speedy recovery then.

Jones still wins.

Originally posted by Nephthys
I'd prefer Jones myself. Jacks too dirty and smelly. Dr Jones though.... meow.

Edit: Oh wait thats not what the threads about.

Also I already commented. Huh.

Totally pegged you for a Depp fanboyl.

More of a Han fan.

Han and Indy shoot first. You'll never be satisfied.

Originally posted by Firefly218
Who actually knows how to use the sword

whip Whip isnt gonna help Indy here

Indy always finds a way. It's not the tool that makes the man deadly. It's the man who uses the tool that makes it deadly. Indy would see right through, Jack. The moment Jack loses his sword is the moment he loses all chance of beating, Indy. I don't see, Indy having any problem in divorcing Jack from his sword.

Who did Indy fight who was as skilled as Jack? And Jack's reflexes are pretty damn sharp. I doubt he'd fall victim to a slow whipcrack.

Indy fistfought Nazis, Thugees, and Commies and won, which is as hard as you can be without being born to a Viking family or made of diamond.

It's just who he fought but the things he did and how he did them. I'm not arguing that Jack is a skilled swordsman but without that sword I don't see him being any kind of a threat to Indy and I think it would be all to easy for Indy to separate that sword from jack.

Plus with a whip you can really maintain distance. Just ask Dracula.

No one has brought this up - Since the fight takes place on the Black Pearl, Jack could have the advantage of knowing his surrounding better. If Jack gets unarmed, he runs into some secret passage in the ship and surprise attacks Indy.

Originally posted by Firefly218
No one has brought this up - Since the fight takes place on the Black Pearl, Jack could have the advantage of knowing his surrounding better. If Jack gets unarmed, he runs into some secret passage in the ship and surprise attacks Indy.
So in that scenario, while Jacks hiding, Indy torches the boat, takes one of the lifeboats/canoes and rows back to land while Jack burns alive. Jack should fight, not run away. Which he does very often, run.

So the question becomes: can Indy arm himself from the boarding parties' collection of weapons? Does he own a lighter? How long can Jack dangle on the foretopmainmast before Indy waits him out?

Also, the rum is all in the hold.

Cap Jack kills him no probs.

Didn't read anything before.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Plus with a whip you can really maintain distance. Just ask Dracula.

Nicely, done, sir.

Originally posted by COG Veteran
So in that scenario, while Jacks hiding, Indy torches the boat, takes one of the lifeboats/canoes and rows back to land while Jack burns alive. Jack should fight, not run away. Which he does very often, run.

Yeah, Indy and Jack are not unalike. The only difference is one thinks faster than the other. Good point, Indy wouldn't wait around if Jack retreated (which he always does ).