Smallville Superman vs Routh Superman

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Cryo
End of Series Clark

http://simplysupermanbatman.files.wordpress.com/2011/03/tom_welling_superman.jpg

vs

Routh Superman (Feats from Superman 1, 2 and Returns)

http://comicbook.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/brandon-routh-superman-returns.jpg

They duke it out on earth, both are bloodlusted and everything goes.

Who wins?

steverules_2
Smallville Supes moved a planet...Routh lifted an island with Kryptonite in it....hmmmm...

KingD19
Routh gets beaten with an island full of Kryptonite.

Zack Fair
Not too familiar with Smallville Supes, but from what I've heard he seems superior.

Firefly218
Smallville supes destroys Routh with his pinkey

Supra
Smallville

Impediment
Spite.

Arachnid1
As everyone else has said, Smallville.

Supra
This is actually a pretty good match up with similar feats.

Impediment
No, it's not. Not by a light year.

playa1258
Smallville Supes is stronger,faster, has better combat speed ,combat skills and more firepower.

carver9
Smallville Supes has better fts than DCNU comic Supes. Smallville stomps...even without flight.

Epicurus
Originally posted by carver9
Smallville Supes has better fts than DCNU comic Supes.
Keep dreaming. laughing out loud

carver9
Originally posted by Epicurus
Keep dreaming. laughing out loud

He does.

marwash22
Originally posted by carver9
He does. lolno.

new 52 Superman had him casually benching the equivalent of Earth for days.

Zack Fair
lol wtf Carv.

Arachnid1
Originally posted by marwash22
lolno.

new 52 Superman had him casually benching the equivalent of Earth for days. He still got handled in a fight with NU52 Wonder Woman, Flash, or Darksied. NU52 Supes seems to be much slower than his previous incarnation. Smallville Clarks speed mixed with his strength and his heat vision (which is significantly more powerful than NU52 Supes) would take him out relatively quickly.

Strength is the only think NU52 supes has over Smallville feats wise. Other than that, he's outcassed my a large margin.

Zack Fair
You must have missed Superman traveling from Pluto to Earth in 1 or 2 seconds. Or his reading every single medical text book in a moment.

Current Darkseid is beast. No shame getting beat by him. N52 Supes isn't unbeatable, of course he will lose fights and get low showings. His good stuff is good though. Redundancy be damned.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.