Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Before we begin and I make my list, I must note that I am not a comic book fan, and thus judge these films purely on their own merit. With that, let's begin:

1) Sin City
2) The Dark Knight
3) 300
4) The Avengers
5) Watchmen

What are yours?

Avengers
Batman 89
Superman 2 (Donner cut)
Blade 2
Iron Man

In order:

Sin City
The Avengers
The Dark Knight
X-Men 2
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

Watchmen
The Dark Knight
Kickass
Avengers
Man of Steel estahuh

The Dark Knight

Iron Man

Batman Begins/The Avengers

Captain America: The First Avenger

300/Sin City/Batman '89

The Dark Knight

Iron Man

The Avengers

Superman: The Movie

Kick-Ass

The Dark Knight

Sin City

Superman (original)

Spiderman 2

Iron Man

Avengers
The Dark Knight
Thor the Dark World
Iron Man
Watchmen

#1 Superman (1978)

#2 The Avengers (2012)

#3 The Dark Knight (2008)

#4 Hancock (2008)

#5 Sky High (2005)

Originally posted by Nuke Nixon
#1 Superman (1978)

#2 The Avengers (2012)

#3 The Dark Knight (2008)

#4 Hancock (2008)

#5 Sky High (2005)

I'm pretty sure Hancock or Sky High weren't based off comics

01. Watchmen
02. The Avengers
03. Batman
04. The Dark Knight
05. Akira

In no order


Avengers

The Dark Knight Rises

Sin City

Iron Man

Akira.

Hellboy
Constantine
Man of Steel
Dark Knight
Crow

Scrap the Rises bit on my list.

TDKR would be on my Top 10.

Cant decide on an order but these are my top 5:

X-Men: First Class
Avengers
The Dark Knight
Batman Begins
Superman 2

Was difficult deciding between Superman 2 and Iron Man for which one makes it to the top 5 and which one is no.6.

I forgot Akira was a comic book film.

My new ranking:

1. Akira
2. Sin City
3. The Dark Knight
4. 300
5. The Avengers

Spawn (as a kid sometimes I watched 2 times a day saw it like 70 times at least)
Avengers
Man Of Steel
Iron Man
Dark Knight

Spiderman 2
The Dark Knight
Avengers
Kick-Ass
Watchmen

Spiderman 2 is for sure my top spot. The others can fight over 2-5. I also want to throw Constantine in there somewhere.

Originally posted by Kazenji
Scrap the Rises bit on my list.

Why's that? Rises was awesome. It's a great end to a great trilogy. It has it's problems but that's one of the things that's so great about it. If I look back on my list I suppose I would just add Watchmen to my list as an interchangeable number one. I loved the movie adaptation. I thought it nailed the spirit of the pages, just like rest of the movies I mentioned. Most all of the movies listed here are really good at that. I guess it's what it means to you, right?

Originally posted by jinXed by JaNx
Why's that? Rises was awesome. It's a great end to a great trilogy. It has it's problems but that's one of the things that's so great about it.

I prefer The Dark Knight more and it's got nothing to do with Heath Ledger dying .

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Cant decide on an order but these are my top 5:

X-Men: First Class
Avengers
The Dark Knight
Batman Begins
Superman 2

Was difficult deciding between Superman 2 and Iron Man for which one makes it to the top 5 and which one is no.6.

Originally posted by Kazenji
I prefer The Dark Knight more and it's got nothing to do with Heath Ledger dying .

Oh, right on. Yeah, he was certainly a world class actor.

1. The Avengers
2. The Dark Knight
3. Spider-man 2
4. Iron Man 3
5. X-Men

1.Watchmen
2.The Dark Knight
3.The Dark Knight Rises
4.Avengers/Man of Steel
5.Man of Steel/Avengers

Honorable Mentions: V For Vendetta, X-Men: First Class, Spider-Man 2, Iron Man, Batman Begins, and Blade II.

I consider all of those great films with Watchmen and The Dark Knight being modern masterpieces.