Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

This is RotS Obi-Wan for clarity's sake, and all others during their respective PT peaks.

The setting is a Force neutral planet, made of boring flat rock for as far as the eye can see.

Qui Gon is dead weight for the Jedi team, and ROTS Kenobi has been demonstrated to only adequately defend and take a minor offense never defeat. Qui Gon isn't going to beat either one, he lacks the endurance required and they're both young and in prime physical condition. Qui Gonn goes down and the two dark siders finish off Kenobi

Well technically Qui-Gon's peak during the PT era would have been Qui-Gon's Spirit form

I'd take Ventress over Qui-gon, and ObiMaul is close, so team 1 wins.