Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Shrek

http://www.dan-dare.org/FreeFun/Images/CartoonsMoviesTV/ShrekWallpaper800.jpg

vs.

Sully

http://kineraptor.files.wordpress.com/2013/07/m-1315-sully-lets-out-a-roar.jpg

Round 1: h2h combat
Round 2: Scaring children contest

CIS, PIS off

Sully's only h2h combat feats involve getting his ass beaten by Randall and Waternoose.

Shrek probably wins.

In a scare off, Sully though, I'd have to imagine.

1) Shrek

2) Probably Shrek again, even though Sully is a pro 'scary guy', Shrek made entire villages shit their knickers with just going "Rawrr".

Sully made armed with guns police officers scream so loudly and run with such terror that it destroyed the entire scaring lab in Monsters University. Grown men and women with guns and shit.

The villagers had torches, pitchforks and clubs.

So does your face.

Robtards face is scarier than both of them put together.

in Monsters U as a teen he managed to generate enough scare energy from ADULTS that it opened a closed trans-dimensional from the human side and blew out an entire room of those scare battery things

Originally posted by Nephthys
Robtards face is scarier than both of them put together.

You forget the apostrophe.

Shrek

Sully, he's a monster who's scary on his own. Shrek is an Ogre and they have reputation in the Shrek world that is scarier then he actually is.

Originally posted by NemeBro
Sully made armed with guns police officers scream so loudly and run with such terror that it destroyed the entire scaring lab in Monsters University. Grown men and women with guns and shit. Originally posted by maxivitopowe
in Monsters U as a teen he managed to generate enough scare energy from ADULTS that it opened a closed trans-dimensional from the human side and blew out an entire room of those scare battery things

An impressive feat, but even James admitted that he never could have pulled it off without the expertise of Mike Wazowski and his use of scare ambience to set up Sullivan's attempt. That was such a well done scene, too.

In hand to hand, I imagine Sully's, at base, within Shrek's ballpark of strength, but without the feats to back it up, round one goes to the onion.

Round two is squarely in Sully's corner though. Both pack a good pair of lungs, but Shrek only really uses it to keep himself in comfortable solitude, and between Monsters University and Monsters Inc., we see that Sully and other Pixar Monsters are literally raised for scaring. It's not just something to do, it's what keeps their entire society functioning comfortably.

Originally posted by NemeBro
Sully's only h2h combat feats involve getting his ass beaten by Randall and Waternoose.

Shrek probably wins.

In a scare off, Sully though, I'd have to imagine.
Randall used active camouflage. Waternoose was straight up bigger than Sully.

Shrek was humbled by a woman and a runt by ogre standards in that alternate universe as well.