Luke Skywalker Vs Darth Caedus & Darth Sidious

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Board Walker
This is all out fight to the death.

Stigma
lol spite

Q99
That's too much even for Luke.

carthage
Luke goes down

FreshestSlice
Team can take anyone in the mythos.

Board Walker
Lets say this is LOTF Luke, and DE Sidious.

carthage
Caedus proved he could hold his own against his Uncle well enough, even with a few discrepancies due to bad writing. With Sidious Luke just gets overwhelmed

Board Walker
Could Caedus have defeated Luke if plot wasn't involved? As in Caedus knew Luke was coming, wasn't ambushed, and Ben wasn't in the room.

carthage
Probably not Luke still has better force and dueling feats across the board, but Caedus would likely have fought and pressed him until he was cut to pieces. He was literally dismembered when he fought him, lol

NewGuy01
Sidious may solo. With Jacen as support this is a stomp.

Nalaniel
Team.

Kalen Sykes
Originally posted by NewGuy01
Sidious may solo. With Jacen as support this is a stomp.


LOTF Luke? Sidious wouldn't solo. In fact, I could see Luke winning with mild difficulty, against him. This is a version of Luke who has an added 30 years of training, experience, and improvement over his DE version. Adding Caedus into the mix, though, moves the team into the Win column.

Board Walker
With no plot interference, and if Caedus was not injured prior to his fight with Luke how close would they be in terms of power compared to one another?

Would Luke have walked out of there alive still? Would it be a double kill, I'm just very curious how a no plot weakened Caedus ranks up to Luke.

Emperordmb
Try no plot weakened Luke. Earlier in the series, Luke pinned Caedus to a chair and he was unable to move. Or when Luke made Caedus flip shit with his illusions.

NewGuy01
Earlier in the series? It was the same book he fought him in.

Emperordmb
Originally posted by NewGuy01
Earlier in the series? It was the same book he fought him in.
That was all in the same book?

truejedi
Originally posted by Board Walker
With no plot interference, and if Caedus was not injured prior to his fight with Luke how close would they be in terms of power compared to one another?

Would Luke have walked out of there alive still? Would it be a double kill, I'm just very curious how a no plot weakened Caedus ranks up to Luke.

Not close. In the other encounter between the two, Jacen was expecting Luke to confront him, was prepared to fight him, and use booby-traps he had in place, and Luke still picked Jacen up, threw him across the room and kept him from moving a muscle throughout their conversation, and after Luke had left the room. It was impressive.

In their second encounter, Jacen was verbally warned (stupid Ben) that Luke was right behind him, and just didn't turn around. His own stupidity. Luke also had him trapped and was about to kill him BEFORE taking all the damage that Jacen dealt him in that duel, but his fear that Ben was about to fall to the dark-side delayed his final attack until Jacen broke free, leading to renewed hostilities.

Jacen's most impressive win was against Mara Jade. In his encounter with her, he was beaten, struggling, underneath her and losing, until he surprised her with his third hand and stabbed her with a dart. Jacen was powerful, but not at the Luke/Sidious level. His main claim to fame is his ability to take a lot of damage and just keep coming.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.