Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

RotS version of Anakin, Kenobi, and Dooku
SoD version of Maul

Anakin can tap into the dark side to fight Dooku.
Anakin can become emotional against Kenobi.
Maul is angry at both Dooku and Kenobi.

Battle takes place on Mustafar

Team 1

Originally posted by Sinious
Team 1

Originally posted by Sinious
Team 1

Originally posted by FreshestSlice
Team 1

Team 1.

I am leaning towards Team 2

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
I am leaning towards Team 2


Both Anakin and Maul are above Dooku who is above Kenobi.

Erm...it is confirmed Dooku>SoD Maul.

It is?

Wouldn't that indicate parity, "by sheer force of will"?

We are discussing power, not stubbornness.

No we're discussing combat ability.

Then how is stubbornness a factor of combat ability?
The fact he is deceiving himself by thinking he can contend with Dooku means nothing.

He did stalemate Vader didn't he? And Vader could only kill him by piercing through himself.

Erm...that was Vader from ANH, and in which was confirmed to be weaker then ESB Vader.

Well is ROTS Anakin > ANH Vader?

ROTJ?

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
ROTJ?

Edited

That's up to you. Personally, ROTS Anakin looks like the superior.
Though some children's books do state ANH Vader>ROTS Anakin.

Did people really need a quote to confirm Dooku's and Vader's superiority over Maul?

That wasn't the real Maul I thought, and the statement about the current Maul wouldn't affect him either way.

I would go with Anakin but it seems really close, almost equal to me. Since we are talking about the Anakin before he turned to the dark side.

So if ANH Vader is almost equal to ROTS Anakin, who defeated Dooku; its fair to say Maul is probably equal to Dooku and since Anakin>Kenobi, team 1 still has a better chance here.

Originally posted by Giant Anteater
Did people really need a quote to confirm Dooku's and Vader's superiority over Maul?

Yes.

No. But I'd like it anyway.

I would like one for Dooku. Vader is obviously more powerful.

Originally posted by Sinious
I would like one for Dooku. Vader is obviously more powerful.
Dooku's feats are better than Maul's.

Perhaps. Still though, stalemating ANH Vader is impressive enough to assume he also has a chance against Dooku.

Originally posted by Sinious
Perhaps. Still though, stalemating ANH Vader is impressive enough to assume he also has a chance against Dooku.
Maul beat Vader rather conclusively.

I don't remember using the word "beat".

Originally posted by Sinious
I don't remember using the word "beat".
What?

Team 1 in a good fight.

So Giant Anteater was PT?

Who cares.

Just observing the lesser beings in nature.