Going for the kill: All out Hulk vs all out Thor (both current)

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Warlord
ok the both want to kill each other with whatever means possible except bfr....who wins?

Inhuman
Current Thor has a vagina

Cosmic_Beings
Hulk effortlessly curbstomps Thor by accidentally stepping on her

RealPizzaBoy
Female Thor gives Birth and having a green baby.

Warlord
ok, male Thor bitches

DarkSaint85
Lol you guys.

Thor kills.

eaebiakuya
Current Thor going all out = Thor from the battle against Gorr.

Thor kills him.

carver9
Hulk going all out turns to World Breaker. Thor gets stomped.

Estacado
Originally posted by carver9
Hulk going all out turns to World Breaker. Thor gets stomped.
Title says current.ermm

carver9
Originally posted by Estacado
Title says current.ermm

He is still called World Breaker though and we haven't seen the limits of his power yet. With that said, he goes World Breaker. Also, as of right now, Current Hulk has Banner intellect.

celeyhyga17
Originally posted by carver9
He is still called World Breaker though and we haven't seen the limits of his power yet. With that said, he goes World Breaker. Also, as of right now, Current Hulk has Banner intellect.
Willing to kill Hulk has no prayer. Fight would be over in a minute or two.

The Sorrow
Tonys thoughts on Current Hulk: http://www.comicbookresources.com/prev_img.php?pid=22818&pg=1

Will be interesting to see how that beef gets resolved.

An unleashed Hulk is borderline unstoppable, Thor would need to fight out of character to win here as we've seen how an enraged bloodlusted Thor fights and it isn't smart. Hulk is also currently intelligent which could be used to his advantage.

RealPizzaBoy
All out Thor will be using blasts, Storms, Huricans, God Blast...
now the real discussion is, whats an all out hulk? does all out hulk means he is as mad as he can get? because IMO an all out means he is ready to kill. and hulk fought many enemies who he wanted to kill but didnt get enraged further to greater levels. just because hulk wants to kill someone doesnt mean he is getting angrier.

carver9
Originally posted by The Sorrow
Tonys thoughts on Current Hulk: http://www.comicbookresources.com/prev_img.php?pid=22818&pg=1

Will be interesting to see how that beef gets resolved.

An unleashed Hulk is borderline unstoppable, Thor would need to fight out of character to win here as we've seen how an enraged bloodlusted Thor fights and it isn't smart. Hulk is also currently intelligent which could be used to his advantage.

laughing out loud

Juggle suns. Marvel loves Hulk.

carver9
Originally posted by RealPizzaBoy
All out Thor will be using blasts, Storms, Huricans, God Blast...
now the real discussion is, whats an all out hulk? does all out hulk means he is as mad as he can get? because IMO an all out means he is ready to kill. and hulk fought many enemies who he wanted to kill but didnt get enraged further to greater levels. just because hulk wants to kill someone doesnt mean he is getting angrier.

Read Hulk my friend. Seems like you have been missing a lot of info on the character.

krisblaze
Thor aims his hammer.

Bam.

Hulk dead.

carver9
Hulk aims his fist...Bam, Thor's dead.

Estacado
Thor and Tony already whooped Hulk when they teamed up.
Didnt they?

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
Hulk aims his fist...Bam, Thor's dead.
Hulk ain't smart enough to aim his fist.

carver9
Originally posted by Estacado
Thor and Tony already whooped Hulk when they teamed up.
Didnt they?

When? Their latest fight ended in a stalemate. Hell, at one point Hulk was making fun of Thor hits, an enraged Thor.

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
Hulk ain't smart enough to aim his fist.

He has Banner intellect currently.

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
He has Banner intellect currently.
Banner doesn't know how to fight.

I'd break him.

RealPizzaBoy
Originally posted by carver9
Read Hulk my friend. Seems like you have been missing a lot of info on the character.

what does it have to do with anything? i am stating a simple fact, that hulk fought many enemies thruought his caree,r which he wanted to kill. now it didnt mean he suddenly got all mad to WBH mode. hell he even many times was on the losing side and wanted to kill his opponent but didnt get angrier to overpower him. so explain to me why is hulk wanting to kill someone = hulk getting to the peak of his anger?

carver9
Originally posted by RealPizzaBoy
what does it have to do with anything? i am stating a simple fact, that hulk fought many enemies thruought his caree,r which he wanted to kill. now it didnt mean he suddenly got all mad to WBH mode. hell he even many times was on the losing side and wanted to kill his opponent but didnt get angrier to overpower him. so explain to me why is hulk wanting to kill someone = hulk getting to the peak of his anger?

I can tell you still have not been keeping up with the character. It was stated more than once that even while pissed, Hulk holds back. Banner prevent Hulk from killing. In thus scenario...the luxury of Hulk being held back from Banner is gone. You really should keep up with the character, his books are great.

DarkSaint85
All out Thor uses Necro blades doe.

As seen in character when he went all out against Galactus.

Khazra Reborn
Originally posted by carver9
When? Their latest fight ended in a stalemate. Hell, at one point Hulk was making fun of Thor hits, an enraged Thor.

You are legitimately out of your mind. I've never seen anyone, in real life or online been so far up a fictional characters ass that they see things with this level of delusion.

RealPizzaBoy
Originally posted by carver9
I can tell you still have not been keeping up with the character. It was stated more than once that even while pissed, Hulk holds back. Banner prevent Hulk from killing. In thus scenario...the luxury of Hulk being held back from Banner is gone. You really should keep up with the character, his books are great.

i understand that banner keeps him away from killing. but who said killing = him getting to the peak of his anger?

maxivitopowe
Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
You are legitimately out of your mind. I've never seen anyone, in real life or online been so far up a fictional characters ass that they see things with this level of delusion.
Abhi?
H1a8?

Galan007
Originally posted by carver9
He is still called World Breaker because title always equates to power, right?

anyway, thor wins. some of the shit he's pulled in GoT is simply beyond what we've seen from hulk thus far.

DarkOdin
a weakened Thor kill worthy thing and koed worthy wwh hulk, who was stated on panel to be more powerful then the great wwh of carver's universe.

Thor 10/10

Blue Area Vet
All out Thor blows Hulk off the planet to die in space via planetary storm.

Blue Area Vet
Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
You are legitimately out of your mind. I've never seen anyone, in real life or online been so far up a fictional characters ass that they see things with this level of delusion. laughing out loud I do think Ahbi would have words with thee.

Blue Area Vet
Originally posted by DarkOdin
a weakened Thor kill worthy thing and koed worthy wwh hulk, who was stated on panel to be more powerful then the great wwh of carver's universe.

Thor 10/10

HEY! Carver said don't talk about that.

maxivitopowe
No bfr I think this is gonna be an epic fight

Thor edges this 6/10

One_Angry_Scot
An all out Thor will more than likely defeat on all out Hulk. He was doing crazy stuff in GoT in one part of the fight with Gorr he was destroying planets just from the blows of hitting Gorr and if he isn't holding back every single blow will hit Hulk like that. Probably at extreme speeds as well, not combined with the fact that he will utilize Mjolnir to it's full extent including hitting him with lightning of the same kind that he used against Thanos and perhaps even more powerful.

Hulk has no chance in hell against Thor when he is not holding back.

krisblaze
Actually I'm curious.

Is Thor trying to kill the Hulk as quickly as possible, or is he just bloodlusted?

carver9
Originally posted by DarkOdin
a weakened Thor kill worthy thing and koed worthy wwh hulk, who was stated on panel to be more powerful then the great wwh of carver's universe.

Thor 10/10

Nul wasn't koed and Thor admitted he could never beat Hulk (upfront). Glad you brought that fight up.

One_Angry_Scot
Originally posted by carver9
Nul wasn't koed and Thor admitted he could never beat Hulk (upfront). Glad you brought that fight up.

That's where you're wrong, Thor after that said "Do you now" so it isn't true, its clearly a ploy to get Hulk to move closer to attack him.

http://i.imgur.com/szjnpH2l.jpg

carver9
Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
An all out Thor will more than likely defeat on all out Hulk. He was doing crazy stuff in GoT in one part of the fight with Gorr he was destroying planets just from the blows of hitting Gorr and if he isn't holding back every single blow will hit Hulk like that. Probably at extreme speeds as well, not combined with the fact that he will utilize Mjolnir to it's full extent including hitting him with lightning of the same kind that he used against Thanos and perhaps even more powerful.

Hulk has no chance in hell against Thor when he is not holding back.

Hulk is at his highest here as well and he has endured planetary attacks. Also, Hulk is faster than Thor. Hulk has already fought an enraged Thor before. During one point, Thor went Warrior Madness and Hulk still overpowered him. If Thor is enraged in this battle then it hinders him since, well, the guy enjoys getting up close and personal which will more than likely get him killed. Hulk stomps.

carver9
Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
That's where your're wrong, Thor after that said "Do you now" so it isn't true, its clearly a ploy to get Hulk to move closer to attack him.

http://i.imgur.com/szjnpH2l.jpg

Get him to move closer? Where did you get that since right after that scene, Thor is flying to Hulk as well. I guess you are saying Thor thought Nul was going to run?

One_Angry_Scot
Originally posted by carver9
Get him to move closer? Where did you get that since right after that scene, Thor is flying to Hulk as well. I guess you are saying Thor thought Nul was going to run?

Well your guess is wrong. This is what happened in the scan.

Thor is on the ground saying to Nul he knew Hulk could defeat him always, Nul moves closer to attack Thor then Thor instead says "Did you now" which obviously shows it was a ploy.

carver9
Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
You are legitimately out of your mind. I've never seen anyone, in real life or online been so far up a fictional characters ass that they see things with this level of delusion.

Here is the fight. Show me this domination you was talking about.


http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers01_zps487bcb53.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers02_zps78838d4b.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers03_zpsdfec4c64.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers04_zpsb2d0182d.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers05_zps5817497e.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers06_zps1c9aeb23.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers07_zps8cea4ed9.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers08_zpsd4b431dc.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers09_zpsa5fea1fe.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers010_zpscbbab401.jpg

DarkSaint85
Can he tank the necro blade? As BFR is off, Thor is free to leave to go get it, without self BFR

carver9
Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
Well your guess is wrong. This is what happened in the scan.

Thor is on the ground saying to Nul he knew Hulk could defeat him always, Nul moves closer to attack Thor then Thor instead says "Did you now" which obviously shows it was a ploy.

Doesn't sound like a ploy to me and doesn't seem like something Thor would do since, he knew Nul would come at him anyways. Thor took the safe route and bfr'd him. Before that scene Thor threw everything at Hulk and even stated he was going to kill him and Nul tanked it all, which is the reason Thor resorted to bfring him.

carver9
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Can he tank the necro blade? As BFR is off, Thor is free to leave to go get it, without self BFR

No, he can't tank it. With that said, if he does have the blade, it's a stomp. Is that what you want to hear Dark?

celeyhyga17
Why is the Annihiblade even in this thread?

One_Angry_Scot
Originally posted by carver9
Doesn't sound like a ploy to me and doesn't seem like something Thor would do since, he knew Nul would come at him anyways. Thor took the safe route and bfr'd him. Before that scene Thor threw everything at Hulk and even stated he was going to kill him and Nul tanked it all, which is the reason Thor resorted to bfring him.

I'm making the point that you said Thor admitted he could never defeat Hulk when that wasn't the case I am not going to show the scan again or quote what Thor said because the truth is Thor wasn't admitting Hulk could always defeat him, it's just not the case.

deathlife
Thor won't even go for melee with these stips.

He wins this.

carver9
Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
I'm making the point that you said Thor admitted he could never defeat Hulk when that wasn't the case I am not going to show the scan again or quote what Thor said because the truth is Thor wasn't admitting Hulk could always defeat him, it's just not the case.

I just disagree with your stand point on that showing. Agree to disagree i guess.

One_Angry_Scot
Originally posted by carver9
I just disagree with your stand point on that showing. Agree to disagree i guess.

Okay then.

krisblaze
Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
I'm making the point that you said Thor admitted he could never defeat Hulk when that wasn't the case I am not going to show the scan again or quote what Thor said because the truth is Thor wasn't admitting Hulk could always defeat him, it's just not the case.
Carver chooses not to understand.

Funny considering Thor's got a legit K.O on Hulk.

carver9
Originally posted by deathlife
Thor won't even go for melee with these stips.

He wins this.

So a Thor that is going for the kill won't go fist cuff?

http://img9.imageshack.us/img9/4769/thorvshulkandthing5b.jpg

You're always on point. thumb up

DarkOdin
Originally posted by carver9
So a Thor that is going for the kill won't go fist cuff?

http://img9.imageshack.us/img9/4769/thorvshulkandthing5b.jpg

You're always on point. thumb up

and that is weaken Thor putting a whooping melee style on an ampped wwh who was also trying to kill thor.

lol your not helping your point

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
Carver chooses not to understand.

Funny considering Thor's got a legit K.O on Hulk.

Almost 20 yrs ago. Lol...Hulk has been upgraded since then. Also this.

http://i226.photobucket.com/albums/dd124/HulkFights/Vs%20Thor/Fight%205/2.jpg
http://i226.photobucket.com/albums/dd124/HulkFights/Vs%20Thor/Fight%205/3.jpg

That's all it took was 3 hits. I wonder what the 4th Hit would have done?

carver9
Originally posted by DarkOdin
and that is weaken Thor putting a whooping melee style on an ampped wwh who was also trying to kill thor.

lol your not helping your point

And Hulk was turned around looking at Thing when he did that. Also, that weakened Thor has some of the best fts in his career like busting through Galactus head and having an advantage against Surfer. By the way, Hulk tanked Thor assault. A Thor that was trying to kill him. Giving it his all. A weakened Hulk held planets together and tanked bombs with enough power to split planets in half.

Branlor Swift
Originally posted by carver9
A weakened Hulk held planets together and tanked bombs with enough power to split planets in half. You're posting this in response to someone saying a weakened Thor beat up a hugely amped WWH...

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
Almost 20 yrs ago. Lol...Hulk has been upgraded since then. Also this.

http://i226.photobucket.com/albums/dd124/HulkFights/Vs%20Thor/Fight%205/2.jpg
http://i226.photobucket.com/albums/dd124/HulkFights/Vs%20Thor/Fight%205/3.jpg

That's all it took was 3 hits. I wonder what the 4th Hit would have done?

3 hits on a Thor that had already beaten him and was carrying Banner's unconscious body no expression

Why did you omit the preceeding scan? Seems nefarious.

Blue Area Vet
Originally posted by Inhuman
Current Thor has a vagina

Hey, wait, .....oh yeah, he I mean she actually does!

Insane Titan
Thor wins no contest

One_Angry_Scot
Originally posted by krisblaze
3 hits on a Thor that had already beaten him and was carrying Banner's unconscious body no expression

Why did you omit the preceeding scan? Seems nefarious.

Were these the scans you were speaking of?

http://imgur.com/a/FI60T

krisblaze
Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
Were these the scans you were speaking of?

http://imgur.com/a/FI60T
Yes, and this one: http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Fights/ThorvsHulk49.jpg (credit to ODG)

Funny, it's almost as if Thor wasn't ready to fight him!

But surely Carver could not have been trying to falsely construe the situation, and present the scans as if it looked like Thor was being beaten in a fair fight?

Who'd stoop that low?

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
3 hits on a Thor that had already beaten him and was carrying Banner's unconscious body no expression

Why did you omit the preceeding scan? Seems nefarious.

Because there was no need for me to post that scene since it is irrelevant.

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
Yes, and this one: http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Fights/ThorvsHulk49.jpg (credit to ODG)

Funny, it's almost as if Thor wasn't ready to fight him!

But surely Carver could not have been trying to falsely construe the situation, and present the scans as if it looked like Thor was being beaten in a fair fight?

Who'd stoop that low?

Lol...Hulk passed out due to the atmosphere in that scan, not Thor. Hahahahahaha...

The other is a surprise attack. A good surprise attack but...

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
Because there was no need for me to post that scene since it's irrelevant and reminds me of the Avengers showing where Thanos takes control of Hulk mind which leads to him dropping Thor.

Why it's almost like you're trying to bring up another case of Hulk attacking an unaware Thor yet again! Only this time you're going for a slightly for subtle variation!

Ye gods, the debating skills on this kid.

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
Why it's almost like you're trying to bring up another case of Hulk attacking an unaware Thor yet again! Only this time you're going for a slightly for subtle variation!

Ye gods, the debating skills on this kid.

And you bringing up a scene that had nothing to do with Thor...it had more to do with Hulk passing out due to the atmosphere. Yeah gods, the debating skills on this kid.

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
And you bringing up a scene that had nothing to do with Thor...it had more to do with Hulk passing out due to the atmosphere. Yeah gods, the debating skills on this kid.

Yes, but that was the second time the Hulk was knocked out in that issue.

The first time it was from Thor's lightning.

Khazra Reborn
Originally posted by carver9
Here is the fight. Show me this domination you was talking about.


http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers01_zps487bcb53.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers02_zps78838d4b.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers03_zpsdfec4c64.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers04_zpsb2d0182d.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers05_zps5817497e.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers06_zps1c9aeb23.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers07_zps8cea4ed9.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers08_zpsd4b431dc.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers09_zpsa5fea1fe.jpg
http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers010_zpscbbab401.jpg

What the Hell are you on man? I didn't say anything about Thor dominating, YOU said Hulk was mocking Thor in that fight, which he clearly wasn't. That was the exact opposite of what happened. Firstly, Captain America stops Thor from caving Hulk's skull in, then at the end Thor knocks Hulk the phuck out.

So, I have no idea what you're going on about.

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
Yes, but that was the second time the Hulk was knocked out in that issue.

The first time it was from Thor's lightning.

You told me to post what happened before that which was Hulk passing out due to oxygen. Hulk then awakes and 3 punch Thor. You didn't have a point.

Thor surprise attack Hulk is great and all, especially against a weaker Hulk than today's Hulk but he's out for blood this time which means... (we already know how he fights when he wants to see that red).

carver9
Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
What the Hell are you on man? I didn't say anything about Thor dominating, YOU said Hulk was mocking Thor in that fight, which he clearly wasn't. That was the exact opposite of what happened. Firstly, Captain America stops Thor from caving Hulk's skull in, then at the end Thor knocks Hulk the phuck out.

So, I have no idea what you're going on about.

What kind of computer are you using? Wait, are you debating from a flip phone?

What is Hulk saying in this scan? Use a laptop please.

http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers04_zpsb2d0182d.jpg

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
You told me to post what happened before that which was Hulk passing out due to oxygen. Hulk then awakes and 3 punch Thor. You didn't have a point.

Thor surprise attack Hulk is great and all, especially against a weaker Hulk than today's Hulk but he's out for blood this time which means... (we already know how he fights when he wants to see that red).

Of course I had and have a point.

Hulk's 3 hits on Thor were when Thor was not paying attention, because he was carrying banner's unconscious body.

You did not try to present it as such. You tried to lie, and I caught you in that lie.

Khazra Reborn
Originally posted by carver9
What kind of computer are you using? Wait, are you debating from a flip phone?

What is Hulk saying in this scan? Use a laptop please.

http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers04_zpsb2d0182d.jpg

Seriously? laughing out loud

You think Hulk, after being knocked on his ass muttering to himself, is mocking Thor?

Branlor Swift
Originally posted by carver9
What kind of computer are you using? Wait, are you debating from a flip phone?

What is Hulk saying in this scan? Use a laptop please.

http://i1096.photobucket.com/albums/g340/Fernando072295/hulkvsavengers04_zpsb2d0182d.jpg Didn't Thor knock him out with a backhand in that fight?

Khazra Reborn
Wasn't a backhand, but yeah at the end of the fight Thor knocks Hulk out, solidly.

Branlor Swift
Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
Wasn't a backhand, but yeah at the end of the fight Thor knocks Hulk out, solidly. Back hammer then. Takes too much effort to discern between hammer hits and fist hits with Thor.

Khazra Reborn
Originally posted by Branlor Swift
Back hammer then. Takes too much effort to discern between hammer hits and fist hits with Thor.

I guess it was a backhand/hammer, I remembered it as an uppercut for some reason. Lol, backhand is way more embarrassing.

carver9
He was still conscious after that hit, Thor even states it.

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
Of course I had and have a point.

Hulk's 3 hits on Thor were when Thor was not paying attention, because he was carrying banner's unconscious body.

You did not try to present it as such. You tried to lie, and I caught you in that lie.

Thor was looking right at Hulk before that hit.

psycho gundam
Originally posted by The Sorrow
Tonys thoughts on Current Hulk: http://www.comicbookresources.com/prev_img.php?pid=22818&pg=1

Will be interesting to see how that beef gets resolved.

An unleashed Hulk is borderline unstoppable, Thor would need to fight out of character to win here as we've seen how an enraged bloodlusted Thor fights and it isn't smart. Hulk is also currently intelligent which could be used to his advantage. Originally posted by carver9
laughing out loud

Juggle suns. Marvel loves Hulk. "Handfuls of the sun."

ALREADY misquoting and over-blowing and you just read it......

The Sorrow
Neither Thor nor Hulk had clean wins in that annual, tbh all of the fights could be marked with an asterix. Hulk buried Thor under a mountain in their 1st fight. Thor scored a brief ko win in their 2nd fight, and Hulk briefly ko'd Thor in their 3rd.

It can be argued Hulk cheapshotted Thor in the 3rd, but Thor couldn't stop the beatdown Hulk gave him either. It could be seen that Hulk dropped his guard in the instance Thor ko'd him, and the 1st fight can be contested because it was the mountain that did the damage not the Hulk himself. Both guys were still standing at the end ready to go another round.

Khazra Reborn
Originally posted by carver9
He was still conscious after that hit, Thor even states it.

No, he didn't. He say maybe, and then he's interrupted.

Hulk's unconscious body sailing motionless through the air is a helluva lot more reliable an indicator of Hulk being out, than Thor saying "mayhaps", in favor of consciousness.

Warlord
wasn't also Hulk recently taken out by a Mjolnir discharge when they were fighting frost giants? maybe I'm wrong

krisblaze
Originally posted by The Sorrow
Neither Thor nor Hulk had clean wins in that annual, tbh all of the fights could be marked with an asterix. Hulk buried Thor under a mountain in their 1st fight. Thor scored a brief ko win in their 2nd fight, and Hulk briefly ko'd Thor in their 3rd.

It can be argued Hulk cheapshotted Thor in the 3rd, but Thor couldn't stop the beatdown Hulk gave him either. It could be seen that Hulk dropped his guard in the instance Thor ko'd him, and the 1st fight can be contested because it was the mountain that did the damage not the Hulk himself. Both guys were still standing at the end ready to go another round.

In the first fight Thor didn't use his hammer. He even had to PROTECT the hammer so it wouldn't be broken when the enchantment was off. Thor wasn't buried beneath a mountain, and the only reason the Hulk managed to get that throw in is because Thor thought about his 5 minutes which were up!
http://s388.photobucket.com/user/OneDumbG0/media/Thor%20Fights/ThorvsHulk05.jpg.html (ODG)

If we gave Thor 3 free attacks to the Hulk then there wouldn't be anything left.

And Hulk sure as shit didn't drop his guard he was grabbing for Thor when the lightning struck him in the head. Thor even had his back turned!

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
No, he can't tank it. With that said, if he does have the blade, it's a stomp. Is that what you want to hear Dark?

Well, as we know that's what Thor in character does (he was fighting Galactus, then went to go get it because he was pissed off at Galactus), Hulk has no chance.

Warlord
no anihiliblade for this fight

DarkSaint85
You said any means possible...and the thread is already on page 5.

Good to see that Thor needs handicapping though thumb up

Warlord
maybe I missed something but is the necroblade part of his powerset?

DarkSaint85
You DID miss something.

You said no BFR.

Which means Thor can safely leave the battlefield, as it is not a defeat condition.

He did the same thing with Galactus. He went to get the Annihiblade.

The Sorrow
Originally posted by krisblaze
In the first fight Thor didn't use his hammer. He even had to PROTECT the hammer so it wouldn't be broken when the enchantment was off. Thor wasn't buried beneath a mountain, and the only reason the Hulk managed to get that throw in is because Thor thought about his 5 minutes which were up!
http://s388.photobucket.com/user/OneDumbG0/media/Thor%20Fights/ThorvsHulk05.jpg.html (ODG)

If we gave Thor 3 free attacks to the Hulk then there wouldn't be anything left.

And Hulk sure as shit didn't drop his guard he was grabbing for Thor when the lightning struck him in the head. Thor even had his back turned!
If you read my post correctly you would know I was referring to the annual (2001) which they had 3 seperate fights. Thor used his hammer in all 3 fights and actually used his lightning before the one he ko'd Hulk with, but Hulk recovered from that one.

IIRC he was yelling at Thor to turn around and fight after he put the fire out, then as he approached and reached out Thor turned around and zapped him. Thor basically outsmarted him, I doubt Hulk was expecting him to do that.

Warlord
@Saint: ok my bad... I meant to say with whatever means possible within their powerset.
Otherwise Thor has a shitload of options (destroyer, necroblade, casket of eternal winter, norn stones, whatever)

carver9
Originally posted by Warlord
wasn't also Hulk recently taken out by a Mjolnir discharge when they were fighting frost giants? maybe I'm wrong

Thor koed himself using that much power. I've never seen Thor exert that much power. Not a terrible showing based on Thor power showings. Why would you bring that up though? Are you saying Thor stomps?

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
Thor koed himself using that much power. I've never seen Thor exert that much power. Not a terrible showing based on Thor power showings. Why would you bring that up though? Are you saying Thor stomps?

Have you never seen a Godblast before?

Warlord
Originally posted by carver9
Thor koed himself using that much power. I've never seen Thor exert that much power. Not a terrible showing based on Thor power showings. Why would you bring that up though? Are you saying Thor stomps? not stomping but I believe Thor wins this

krisblaze
Originally posted by The Sorrow
If you read my post correctly you would know I was referring to the annual (2001) which they had 3 seperate fights. Thor used his hammer in all 3 fights and actually used his lightning before the one he ko'd Hulk with, but Hulk recovered from that one.

IIRC he was yelling at Thor to turn around and fight after he put the fire out, then as he approached and reached out Thor turned around and zapped him. Thor basically outsmarted him, I doubt Hulk was expecting him to do that.

Sorry, I read it as a reference to their first three fights smile

I still disagree that Thor caught Hulk unaware with the lightning as the Hulk was clearly attacking him.

Hulk's attack on Thor however was a cheapshot considering that Thor was in the process of saving Banner's life..

carver9
Originally posted by Warlord
not stomping but I believe Thor wins this

But he has a sh** load of options. How can Hulk win even one based off your posts which means you made a spite thread, right?

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
Sorry, I read it as a reference to their first three fights smile

I still disagree that Thor caught Hulk unaware with the lightning as the Hulk was clearly attacking him.

Hulk's attack on Thor however was a cheapshot considering that Thor was in the process of saving Banner's life..

Thor was looking right at Hulk.

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
Thor was looking right at Hulk.

Yes.

You can see the surprise on Thor's face.

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
Yes.

You can see the surprise on Thor's face.

Even though he is looking at Hulk before Hulk attacked? You still consider that a surprise attack? Do you know what a surprise attack is?

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
Even though he is looking at Hulk before Hulk attacked? You still consider that a surprise attack? Do you know what a surprise attack is?

Yes.

If I enter a room and three pirates jump at me and beat me that's a surprise attack.

Even if I see them jumping at me when I open the door it would be still be a surprise attack.

Warlord
Originally posted by carver9
But he has a sh** load of options. How can Hulk win even one based off your posts which means you made a spite thread, right?
what are my posts that indicate that Hulk stomps?

Newjak
Originally posted by carver9
Even though he is looking at Hulk before Hulk attacked? You still consider that a surprise attack? Do you know what a surprise attack is? Technically someone can still surprise attack you even if you are looking at them.

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
Even though he is looking at Hulk before Hulk attacked? You still consider that a surprise attack? Do you know what a surprise attack is?

Isn't Hulk a speedster?

eaebiakuya
Originally posted by carver9
I've never seen Thor exert that much power

laughing

You can seen in this month. Original Sin: Thor and Loki.

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
Yes.

If I enter a room and three pirates jump at me and beat me that's a surprise attack.

Even if I see them jumping at me when I open the door it would be still be a surprise attack.

So even though Hulk transformed...say rrrrrrrrrrrrrr, Thor then say by the gods.

http://i226.photobucket.com/albums/dd124/HulkFights/Vs%20Thor/Fight%205/1.jpg

What else should have happened in that scene for it not to be a surprised attack from a guy you've been battle for 2 issues?

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
So even though Hulk transformed...say rrrrrrrrrrrrrr, Thor then say by the gods.

http://i226.photobucket.com/albums/dd124/HulkFights/Vs%20Thor/Fight%205/1.jpg

What else should have happened in that scene for it not to be a surprised attack from a guy you've been battle for 2 issues?

I don't know what Thor 'should' think. I only know that he was surprised.

He was also in the middle of teleporting them...

carver9
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Isn't Hulk a speedster?

Please read above.

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
I don't know what Thor 'should' think. I only know that he was surprised.

He was also in the middle of teleporting them...

So even though Hulk grows in mass, say rrrrrrrrrrrrrr, then Thor look up, then had enough time to say "by the gods" and it's still a surprise attack? You're full of excuses.

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
So even though Hulk grows in mass, say rrrrrrrrrrrrrr, then look up, then had enough time to say "by the gods" and it's still a surprise attack? You're full of excuses.
I'm full of explanations, though you choose not to listen to them.

Thor is carrying Hulk with one arm and teleporting with the other, he should've done what?

He was obviously surprised when the Hulk attacked him.

I don't know or care what you think Thor should be thinking. He was surprised by the attack.

The Sorrow
Originally posted by krisblaze
Sorry, I read it as a reference to their first three fights smile

I still disagree that Thor caught Hulk unaware with the lightning as the Hulk was clearly attacking him.

Hulk's attack on Thor however was a cheapshot considering that Thor was in the process of saving Banner's life..
You're free to disagree I did say it was open to interpretation. If he was really intent on blindsiding Thor I don't think he would be yelling at him to turn around and fight though.

Again this is open to interpretation aswell. They aren't clean wins by any means, however it's the only win Thor has over Hulk, which baffles me as to why people think it's a stomp in his favour.

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
I'm full of explanations, though you choose not to listen to them.

Thor is carrying Hulk with one arm and teleporting with the other, he should've done what?

He was obviously surprised when the Hulk attacked him.

I don't know or care what you think Thor should be thinking. He was surprised by the attack.

Gotcha. So Hulk transforming, leans up, look at Thor, say rrrrrrrrrrrrrr, Thor screams "by the gods" and it's still a surprise attack? Makes a lot of sense.

krisblaze
Yes.

What do you think 'by the gods' mean? Do you think it's an exclamation of surprise? Or...?

Originally posted by The Sorrow
You're free to disagree I did say it was open to interpretation. If he was really intent on blindsiding Thor I don't think he would be yelling at him to turn around and fight though.

Again this is open to interpretation aswell. They aren't clean wins by any means, however it's the only win Thor has over Hulk, which baffles me as to why people think it's a stomp in his favour.
They probably think it's stomp because Thor's been using his fists and not his hammer in half the matches.

And because he's used lightning in 3 out of 12 matches despite having all these other very easy to use powers.

Maybe that and the fact that the last time they fought a dying Thor beat both amped Hulk and Thing.

Newjak
Originally posted by carver9
Gotcha. So Hulk transforming, leans up, look at Thor, say rrrrrrrrrrrrrr, Thor screams "by the gods" and it's still a surprise attack? Makes a lot of sense. It does actually. Clearly Thor was caught off guard by Hulk showing up as he thought banner was unconscious.

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
Yes.

What do you think 'by the gods' mean? Do you think it's an exclamation of surprise? Or...?


They probably think it's stomp because Thor's been using his fists and not his hammer in half the matches.

And because he's used lightning in 3 out of 12 matches despite having all these other very easy to use powers.

Maybe that and the fact that the last time they fought a dying Thor beat both amped Hulk and Thing.

Agree to disagree.

Don't consider bfring as a win but what ever.

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
Agree to disagree.

Don't consider bfring as a win but what ever.
I asked you a question.

What do you think 'by the gods' means? And what emotion do you think Thor was trying to express, if not surprise?

The Sorrow
Originally posted by krisblaze
They probably think it's stomp because Thor's been using his fists and not his hammer in half the matches.

And because he's used lightning in 3 out of 12 matches despite having all these other very easy to use powers.

Maybe that and the fact that the last time they fought a dying Thor beat both amped Hulk and Thing.
Ever since Thor #385 where it was established Hulk > Thor without Mjolnir in h2h he has been using Mjolnir in their fights.

We have actually seen Thor go all out against Hulk using lightning (Hulk #300, IH #440 & Fear Itself #3) and Hulk resisted it each time. He also was able to resist it once during the 2001 Annual. Lightning is his most potent weapon so why wouldn't he fall back on that?

Well he almost killed Thing but he couldn't actually defeat Hulk, he just about removed him from the battlefield with his last attack. Bfr is off in this thread.

Rage.Of.Olympus
Why can't Thor just drain Hulk of his gamma energy?

Originally posted by Warlord
wasn't also Hulk recently taken out by a Mjolnir discharge when they were fighting frost giants? maybe I'm wrong

Yea, apparently Hulk was knocked out just from the lingering energy engulfing Thor's body.

krisblaze
He could, and we've seen that the drain's effects are more or less instantenous.

Thor couldn't do it, however, because....I don't know... some reason!

Originally posted by The Sorrow
Ever since Thor #385 where it was established Hulk > Thor without Mjolnir in h2h he has been using Mjolnir in fights.

We have actually seen Thor go all out against Hulk using lightning (Hulk #300, IH #440 & Fear Itself #3) and Hulk resisted it each time. He also was able to resist it once during the 2001 Annual. Lightning is his most potent weapon so why wouldn't he fall back on that?

Well he almost killed Thing but he couldn't actually defeat Hulk, he just about removed him from the battlefield with his last attack. Bfr is off in this thread.

Why are you responding like I said that Thor never used lightning against Hulk? That's not what I said and I'd like your post to reflect what I wrote, not the argument you've construed in your head. I specifically stated that he had used it 3 times.

300? I see no lightning hitting Hulk. I see lightning striking by them, but from the looks of things its hitting Thor as much as its hitting Hulk, no resisting there.

IH #440 Thor used lightning on him. Hulk was hurt. Thor flew over to him. He resisted it? It's not something he can push against. The lightning hurt him.

Fear itself: Did you not read the exchange between them? -I couldn't defeat you- "I know" -did you now?- Thor knocks him into space. This isn't an concession, it's a taunt. This was also a Thor that had been suffering a fatal injury over a month, and had taken a beaten before he even met Hulk/Thing no expression

You asked why people thought this was a stomp, I replied saying that people probably think it's a stomp because Thor has never used anything beyond lightning against the Hulk, and the times he did use lightning he did it sparingly and only in a few of their many fights.

carver9
Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Why can't Thor just drain Hulk of his gamma energy?



Yea, apparently Hulk was knocked out just from the lingering energy engulfing Thor's body.

Could work. Could you see Thor using it in a kill mindset or Hulk being still enough to allow Thor to use it?

Damborgson
If Thor after a little physical duel goes into the air and lets this loose on Hulk:

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Destroys the landscape with the Hulk and finishes off the Frost Giant army with a huge lightning onslaught:
http://s3d3.turboimagehost.com/t/15970560_Indestructible_Hulk_008-016.jpghttp://s3d3.turboimagehost.com/t/15970561_Indestructible_Hulk_008-017.jpghttp://s3d4.turboimagehost.com/t/15970568_Indestructible_Hulk_008-018.jpg




How does Hulk get a win? Honestly. The feedback, from that, the little stuff that was still clinging to Thor, knocked the Hulk out. How is this even a debate?

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
He could, and we've seen that the drain's effects are more or less instantenous.

Thor couldn't do it, however, because....I don't know... some reason!



Why are you responding like I said that Thor never used lightning against Hulk? That's not what I said and I'd like your post to reflect what I wrote, not the argument you've construed in your head. I specifically stated that he had used it 3 times.

300? I see no lightning hitting Hulk. I see lightning striking by them, but from the looks of things its hitting Thor as much as its hitting Hulk, no resisting there.

IH #440 Thor used lightning on him. Hulk was hurt. Thor flew over to him. He resisted it? It's not something he can push against. The lightning hurt him.

Fear itself: Did you not read the exchange between them? -I couldn't defeat you- "I know" -did you now?- Thor knocks him into space. This isn't an concession, it's a taunt. This was also a Thor that had been suffering a fatal injury over a month, and had taken a beaten before he even met Hulk/Thing no expression

You asked why people thought this was a stomp, I replied saying that people probably think it's a stomp because Thor has never used anything beyond lightning against the Hulk, and the times he did use lightning he did it sparingly and only in a few of their many fights.

What fight did Thor have before facing Thing/Hulk? Also, was it ever stated that Thor wound affected his fighting prowess? Also, Ms. Marvel did better against Nul than Thor did (and Hulk was mind controlled).

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
What fight did Thor have before facing Thing/Hulk? Also, was it ever stated that Thor wound affected his fighting prowess? Also, Ms. Marvel did better against Nul than Thor did (and Hulk was mind controlled).

The serpent. He didn't fight him, he was just punched.

Did anyone ever say 'oh wow, that giant gaping wound in Thor's side sure must've diminished his fighting prowess' ? No. Odin, however, is amazed that Thor was able to keep fighting despite his injury.

Ok.

Damborgson
Originally posted by krisblaze
Did anyone ever say 'oh wow, that giant gaping wound in Thor's side sure must've diminished his fighting prowess' ? No. Odin, however, is amazed that Thor was able to keep fighting despite his injury.




/shrug

Dude, when you have to argue that an oozing stab wound, mystical in nature no less, would lower someone's ability to fight effectively, you know you're not going to reach the person.

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
The serpent. He didn't fight him, he was just punched.

Did anyone ever say 'oh wow, that giant gaping wound in Thor's side sure must've diminished his fighting prowess' ? No. Odin, however, is amazed that Thor was able to keep fighting despite his injury.

Ok.

Lol...so the Serpent punching Thor weakened him?

Thor kept fighting when his liver was turned to glass. Was it ever mentioned that the wound weakened him?

krisblaze
Originally posted by Damborgson
/shrug

Dude, when you have to argue that an oozing stab wound, mystical in nature no less, would lower someone's ability to fight effectively, you know you're not going to reach the person.

I know, but he needs a chance to get his say in before I join half the board in ignoring him.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...so the Serpent punching Thor weakened him?

Thor kept fighting when his liver was turned to glass. Was it ever mentioned that the wound weakened him?


I just answered both of these questions.

Yes the serpent punched him.

Odin was amazed that Thor could fight with the wound.

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
I know, but he needs a chance to get his say in before I join half the board in ignoring him.




I just answered both of these questions.

Yes the serpent punched him.

Odin was amazed that Thor could fight with the wound.

Your answers was terrible. Moving on because neither one of us are changing our opinions.

Hulk wins.

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
Your answers was terrible. Moving on because neither one of us are changing our opinions.
? I said that Thor was bleeding before he fought The Thing and Hulk.

Bleeding because the Serpent punched him before he was teleported to them.

I also said that no one explicitly stated that the wound made Thor worse at fighting, but that Odin expressed amazement that Thor had been able to fight with the wound.

These answer EXACTLY what you asked.

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze
? I said that Thor was bleeding before he fought The Thing and Hulk.

Bleeding because the Serpent punched him before he was teleported to them.

I also said that no one explicitly stated that the wound made Thor worse at fighting, but that Odin expressed amazement that Thor had been able to fight with the wound.

These answer EXACTLY what you asked.

And I basically said Thor didn't show anything during any of his fights that his wound did anything to him.

I guess me and you see Thor differently. I think Thor can handle more than a single hit from Serpent.

Odin underestimated Thor, that's all. I have seen Thor fight at his peak while having his insides chewed up. I don't think he is as weak as you think he is.

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
And I basically said Thor didn't show anything during any of his fights that his wound did anything to him.

I guess me and you see Thor differently. I think Thor can handle more than a single hit from Serpent.

Odin underestimated Thor, that's all. I have seen Thor fight at his peak while having his insides chewed up. I don't think he is as weak as you think he is.

He didn't show anything during his fight with the Surfer either, but later in his chambers he made it clear that the wound was hurting him constantly. That coupled with all-knowing Odin's statement about Thor's wound should be more than enough to indicate that he was in pain.

It doesn't matter what you think or don't think Thor can handle.

He handled the injury obviously, since he fought and beat them. I've never said anything to the contrary.

I said that Thor was injured from the wound in his side and the attack from the Serpent.

I'm sure you've seen plenty from your brief foray into half a respect-thread and the 5 Thor comics you've read.

Branlor Swift
Thor got beat up by Odin. Dropped from the clouds by Odin. Blasted by Serpent and dropped from clouds by him. He was bleeding from the mouth after the latter which immediately preceded a fight between him and Thulk.

carver9
Originally posted by krisblaze

He handled the injury obviously, since he fought and beat them. I've never said anything to the contrary.

I said that Thor was injured from the wound in his side.



thumb up

I agree with this (the rest of your post doesn't matter).

krisblaze
Originally posted by carver9
thumb up

I agree with this (the rest of your post doesn't matter).
An injured Thor fights as well as an uninjured Thor?

You never answered my question.

What do you think 'by the gods' is supposed to express?

celeyhyga17
Originally posted by The Sorrow
Ever since Thor #385 where it was established Hulk > Thor without Mjolnir in h2h he has been using Mjolnir in their fights.

We have actually seen Thor go all out against Hulk using lightning (Hulk #300, IH #440 & Fear Itself #3) and Hulk resisted it each time. He also was able to resist it once during the 2001 Annual. Lightning is his most potent weapon so why wouldn't he fall back on that?

Well he almost killed Thing but he couldn't actually defeat Hulk, he just about removed him from the battlefield with his last attack. Bfr is off in this thread.
He would kill Hulk with Mjolnir if he stopped holding back so much. In this scan, the writer later clarified that it was Hulk who was getting smacked in the face.

Originally posted by ODG
Ultimately, Thor has to use restraint with Mjolnir. Otherwise, things like this happen. Here, Balder councils Thor against Mjolnir's unfettered power when they speak on his nearly killing Rulk in their rematch, from Breaking Into Comics The Marvel Way #2:

http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Stats/th_ThorRestraint09BreakingIntoComics2.jpg

The Sorrow
Originally posted by krisblaze
He could, and we've seen that the drain's effects are more or less instantenous.

Thor couldn't do it, however, because....I don't know... some reason!



Why are you responding like I said that Thor never used lightning against Hulk? That's not what I said and I'd like your post to reflect what I wrote, not the argument you've construed in your head. I specifically stated that he had used it 3 times.

300? I see no lightning hitting Hulk. I see lightning striking by them, but from the looks of things its hitting Thor as much as its hitting Hulk, no resisting there.

IH #440 Thor used lightning on him. Hulk was hurt. Thor flew over to him. He resisted it? It's not something he can push against. The lightning hurt him.

Fear itself: Did you not read the exchange between them? -I couldn't defeat you- "I know" -did you now?- Thor knocks him into space. This isn't an concession, it's a taunt. This was also a Thor that had been suffering a fatal injury over a month, and had taken a beaten before he even met Hulk/Thing no expression

You asked why people thought this was a stomp, I replied saying that people probably think it's a stomp because Thor has never used anything beyond lightning against the Hulk, and the times he did use lightning he did it sparingly and only in a few of their many fights.
You claimed he uses his fists in half of their fights, and that he's used lightning 3 times against Hulk - both of which are inaccurate claims so I corrected you. Its really that simple, no need to get e-motional.

Thor has used Mjolnir in MOST of their fights apart from the very early days, yes most of them are straight melee but we have several instances of Thor using lightning, and while they hurt Hulk he was able to fight on in all bar one showing in which he was ko'd (possibly surprised) by the attack but managed to recovered moments later.

Being the god of Thunder, it should be pretty obvious why Thor is going to be surrounded by lightning, he used hammer shots aswell while not holding back but they didn't seem to affect Hulk much outside of knocking him around (Hulk #300).

Again, if that's the reasoning that Thor stomps then it isn't backed up by facts because their fights tell a different story including the ones Thor HAS used more than melee and HAS gone all out. Besides godblast (which is an absolutely last resort attack) what attacks does he currently have more powerful than lightning?

carver9
Originally posted by celeyhyga17
He would kill Hulk with Mjolnir if he stopped holding back so much. In this scan, the writer later clarified that it was Hulk who was getting smacked in the face.

It wasn't Hulk though.

celeyhyga17
Originally posted by carver9
It wasn't Hulk though.
Did you miss the part where I said it was later clarified by the writer that it was Hulk on those two panels and not Rulk?

Kevin Grevioux in an interview later confirmed that the coloring was off and it was indeed Hulk and not Rulk.

The Sorrow
Originally posted by celeyhyga17
He would kill Hulk with Mjolnir if he stopped holding back so much. In this scan, the writer later clarified that it was Hulk who was getting smacked in the face.
Tbh that's an arguement you could make for both, if Banner went apeshit he could kill Thor if he tried.

Iirc he said it was originally meant to be Hulk but it ended up as the Red Hulk.

carver9
Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Did you miss the part where I said it was later clarified by the writer that it was Hulk on those two panels and not Rulk?

Kevin Grevioux in an interview later confirmed that the coloring was off and it was indeed Hulk and not Rulk.

Just want to make sure you knew it was Red Hulk.

eaebiakuya
It wasnt Red Hulk, and even ODG in the respect thread agreed it was green hulk later on.

Rage.Of.Olympus
Originally posted by carver9
Could work. Could you see Thor using it in a kill mindset or Hulk being still enough to allow Thor to use it?

Would work.

Why wouldn't he?

Hulk doesn't have to allow anything when Thor can fly far faster then he can jump/move and he has powerful long range attacks and the draining starts working instantly.

carver9
Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Would work.

Why wouldn't he?

Hulk doesn't have to allow anything when Thor can fly far faster then he can jump/move and he has powerful long range attacks and the draining starts working instantly.

Do you have any examples of Thor draining abilities?

I think Hulk would be all over Thor as soon as the bell rings.

Rage.Of.Olympus
Originally posted by carver9
Do you have any examples of Thor draining abilities?

I think Hulk would be all over Thor as soon as the bell rings.

no expression

You've been on this board for long enough to know most of them. Heck, I've personally presented a few to you. Anyways, check out ODG's respect thread.

Even if they were already brawling, Thor's strong and powerful enough to give himself breathing room. Not that they would be. Thor flies far faster then Hulk moves and has multiple long range options to make Hulk regretting charging right in.

DarkOdin
Originally posted by Branlor Swift
You're posting this in response to someone saying a weakened Thor beat up a hugely amped WWH... leave it to carver to beat himself in a debate laughing out loud

Stoic
Originally posted by DarkOdin
leave it to carver to beat himself in a debate laughing out loud

If BFR wasn't an option in that scene, I have doubts that Thor even in a fully healthy state would not have won that match.

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
Agree to disagree.

Don't consider bfring as a win but what ever.

Originally posted by Warlord
no anihiliblade for this fight

Originally posted by The Sorrow
Besides godblast (which is an absolutely last resort attack) what attacks does he currently have more powerful than lightning?

Keep the stips coming!!!!

Warlord
hey I made thsi thread.
I own the stips stick out tongue

leonidas
Originally posted by DarkOdin
leave it to carver to beat himself in a debate laughing out loud

he's had a really bad week, even by his own standards.

Stoic
I don't know what the current Hulk is? Is this the intelligent one that's fighting Stark, or is it the one that gets in your face with the hot breath, and snots running out of his nose?

Either way, he seems to be written to the extent that whenever he gets hit hard enough, he reverts to Banner. Stupid writers. Thor beats current fragile Hulk.

Branlor Swift
Banner reverting to Hulk only happens when one of Hickman's original characters (do not steal) hits him.
Sun God
Proxima
And now that I think about it Hyperion when he appeared likely did just hit him so hard he Bannered. At least in Hicktention.

Thor wouldn't do it, but an alt Thor or a new Thor analogue would.

Stoic
Originally posted by Branlor Swift
Banner reverting to Hulk only happens when one of Hickman's original characters (do not steal) hits him.
Sun God
Proxima
And now that I think about it Hyperion when he appeared likely did just hit him so hard he Bannered. At least in Hicktention.

Thor wouldn't do it, but an alt Thor or a new Thor analogue would.

Yeah that's what I'm talking about. It's pretty dumb to write him that way, but it's currently the way the Hulk is portrayed, and since I don't see why Hyperion or the others that you mentioned should be able to hit harder than Thor, I don't know why the same thing wouldn't happen (under Hickman that is).

Badabing
Originally posted by Warlord
ok the both want to kill each other with whatever means possible except bfr....who wins? Hulk would smash Thor, and the entire House of El. b_hulk

leonidas
each going for the kill, thor ends him.

<< THERE IS MORE FROM THIS THREAD HERE >>