Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

PH Hulk vs SD Doomsday


Battle on a deserted planet. Who takes it?

Doomsday

Planet Hulk was the better animation, which is rare, as DC generally has superior animated flicks to Marvel.

But Doomsday likely takes this from what I remember of the film. It took a Superman-slam from orbital heights to take out DD. Hulk in PH was also gimped for the majority of the film, so his feats suffer here.

Hulk was able to put up a decent fight against BRB, and Bill was pretty powerful in the film, so there is that.

IIRC, he was suffering from travelling-through-the-portal weakness as well, why he was enslaved. ie he was also gimped.

In the comic, Doomsday killed Superman and Doomsday revived more powerful than ever

Doomsday, easy.

Doomsday was definitely the more durable of the two.

Based off fts, Hulk wins. Survived a nuke while weakened. Better punching power showings. Lift a boulder that almost covered a mountain. Healing factor. He's overall more powerful. Doomsday dies.

Doomsday.

Originally posted by carver9
Based off fts, Hulk wins. Survived a nuke while weakened. Better punching power showings. Lift a boulder that almost covered a mountain. Healing factor. He's overall more powerful. Doomsday dies. So what feats does Doomsday have that outmatch the ones carver has mentioned everyone?

Originally posted by NemeBro
So what feats does Doomsday have that outmatch the ones carver has mentioned everyone?

Nothing DD did outmatches Carver's version of Hulk from PH that I recall.

Reality:

Hulk didn't "survive a nuke", it was a firebomb designed to burn the infected Sakaarans. The buildings and such were left standing as the fire swept through the town.

The boulder Hulk lifted didn't "almost cover a mountain", it was very large and Hulk used it to cover the mouth of a cave in said mountain.

Originally posted by Robtard
Nothing DD did outmatches Carver's version of Hulk from PH that I recall.

Reality:

Hulk didn't "survive a nuke", it was a firebomb designed to burn the infected Sakaarans. The buildings and such were left standing as the fire swept through the town.

The boulder Hulk lifted didn't "almost cover a mountain", it was very large and Hulk used it to cover the mouth of a cave in said mountain. Lol thats a pretty massive drop from what was previously described. Someone went a little overboard...

Originally posted by Robtard
Nothing DD did outmatches Carver's version of Hulk from PH that I recall.

Reality:

Hulk didn't "survive a nuke", it was a firebomb designed to burn the infected Sakaarans. The buildings and such were left standing as the fire swept through the town.

The boulder Hulk lifted didn't "almost cover a mountain", it was very large and Hulk used it to cover the mouth of a cave in said mountain.

Where was it stated that the bomb was designed to kill the infected?

Originally posted by carver9
Where was it stated that the bomb was designed to kill the infected?

Really, that silly tactic?

Anyhow, it was a firebomb, the buildings were left largely intact after the explosion as the fire swept through the streets.

gonna go with the hulk

Carter pls.

N6hqC5Z9was

@ 3:00.

Superman had to slam DD from orbit for a KO.

Hulk was knocked out by far, far less.

Doomsday easily.
Unless you are carter.

What koed Hulk and Doomsday died during that scene.

LoL, really? The firebomb KO'd the Hulk in PH.

Originally posted by Robtard
LoL, really? The firebomb KO'd the Hulk in PH.

Lol...really? After being injected by spikes, numerous of spike...heavily damaged and you think only the fire bomb had play in that? Get out of here. What else koed him?

Doomsday

I would go with Doomsday myself.

Don't know why when Hulk fts are better.

Doomsday took a orbital power slam to beat while Hulk was downed by far less.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...really? After being injected by spikes, numerous of spike...heavily damaged and you think only the fire bomb had play in that? Get out of here. What else koed him?

You asked "what koed Hulk?". If you can't handle the answer because the Hulk was KO'd in PH, that's your problem.

Proof the spikes caused Hulk's KO? IIRC The spikes don't KO; they infect beings and turn them into mindless killing machines.

Originally posted by Robtard
You asked "what koed Hulk?". If you can't handle the answer because the Hulk was KO'd in PH, that's your problem.

Proof the spikes caused Hulk's KO? IIRC The spikes don't KO; they infect beings and turn them into mindless killing machines.

Do I honestly need to provide proof that the spikes was damaging him? That's a retarded question. Circumstances was involved which goes against your claims of HULK being koed. By the way, Red King hits on Hulk>>>>> the licks Superman was dishing out on Doomsday.

Carter are you ok?

Who is Carter?

Id pick either Superman or Doomsday to beat Hulk, though Hulk would make DD work for it.

Doomsday

Doomsday all day, Hulk is a brute but this is the guy who killed Superman were talking about here that is the ultimate feat in and of itself

Originally posted by carver9
Do I honestly need to provide proof that the spikes was damaging him? That's a retarded question.

Circumstances was involved which goes against your claims of HULK being koed.

By the way, Red King hits on Hulk>>>>> the licks Superman was dishing out on Doomsday.

The spikes don't "damage" iirc, they infect people and turn them into nigh-mindless killing machines. Post proof if you have of the spikes causing damage.

Except Hulk was KO'd in Planet Hulk, which puts a stop on your initial implication that the Hulk was never KO'd.

LoL, no.

Originally posted by Robtard
The spikes don't "damage" iirc, they infect people and turn them into nigh-mindless killing machines. Post proof if you have of the spikes causing damage.

Except Hulk was KO'd in Planet Hulk, which puts a stop on your initial implication that the Hulk was never KO'd.

LoL, no.

Hulk was never koed but Hulk with Spikes and plot was koed. Showings like that don't count against the character when context is involved. You've been here long enough to know that. Now again, HULK has not been koed.

Originally posted by carver9
Hulk was never koed but Hulk with Spikes and plot was koed. Showings like that don't count against the character when context is involved. You've been here long enough to know that. Now again, HULK has not been koed.

If you want to prove that the spikes weakened the Hulk, go on. There's nothing that indicates someone becomes weaker after they're infected with spikes. The opposite, actually.

Being infected gives the host "enhanced agility and strength" Proof: marvelanimated.wikia.com/wiki/Spikes_(Planet_Hulk)

So what we have is an infected Hulk who gained a boost in power and was still KO'd.

Originally posted by Robtard
If you want to prove that the spikes weakened the Hulk, go on. There's nothing that indicates someone becomes weaker after they're infected with spikes. The opposite, actually.

Being infected gives the host "enhanced agility and strength" Proof: marvelanimated.wikia.com/wiki/Spikes_(Planet_Hulk)

So what we have is an infected Hulk who gained a boost in power and was still KO'd.

Are you really comparing the comic to the movie...lol, we can go there. This version of Hulk really stomps. The guy held a planet twice the size of Earth while weakened.

Context during that scene...extreme context. You have no proof at all on if the Hulk was damaged or not...NONE. We see him screaming in pain, we see him trying to fight off the infection. That ft isn't an approval on Hulk being koed at all. Now if I said Hulk with Spikes wasn't koed, then you'll have an argument but I didnt. So what else do you have?

Originally posted by carver9
Are you really comparing the comic to the movie...lol, we can go there. This version of Hulk really stomps. The guy held a planet twice the size of Earth while weakened.

Context during that scene...extreme context. You have no proof at all on if the Hulk was damaged or not...NONE. We see him screaming in pain, we see him trying to fight off the infection. That ft isn't an approval on Hulk being koed at all. Now if I said Hulk with Spikes wasn't koed, then you'll have an argument but I didnt. So what else do you have?

Did you even click the link? It's for the Animated film, not the comic. So no, I am not bringing in comic feats.

LolZ. WTF. You're the one that is saying Hulk was "heavily damaged" during that scene, but now you're saying there's no proof either way:

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...really? After being injected by spikes, numerous of spike...heavily damaged and you think only the fire bomb had play in that? Get out of here. What else koed him?

So what we have in that scene is a powered up Hulk (due to the nature of the spikes) being KO'd by a firebomb (you said it was a nuke). It's obvious you can't deal with it and why you're all over the place in your claims and accusations.

Originally posted by Robtard
If you want to prove that the spikes weakened the Hulk, go on. There's nothing that indicates someone becomes weaker after they're infected with spikes. The opposite, actually.

Being infected gives the host "enhanced agility and strength" Proof: marvelanimated.wikia.com/wiki/Spikes_(Planet_Hulk)

So what we have is an infected Hulk who gained a boost in power and was still KO'd.

his hf was fighting off infection bro. he was weakened.

doomsday prolly still wins tho

Originally posted by Raisen
his hf was fighting off infection bro. he was weakened.

doomsday prolly still wins tho

If you click the link to the animated film, the spikes make those infected physically more powerful; not weaker.

Fair enough; agreed.

the spikes make you stronger once they take over, sure.
but hulk was fighting off the infection when this bombing occurred. I may be wrong but that's the way I remember it

Originally posted by Robtard
If you click the link to the animated film, the spikes make those infected physically more powerful; not weaker.

Fair enough; agreed.

The ft isn't valid for the Hulk because it's questionable and it has context. Move on.

Originally posted by carver9
The ft isn't valid for the Hulk because it's questionable and it has context. Move on.

You're funny when it comes to anything Hulk. It's in the film, ergo it is valid. I might as well argue that Superman killing Doomsday with the orbital slam just "doesn't count."

Okay Hulk isn't as strong as Carv initially said, though no one's given anything about this Doomsday. The final fight gave nothing.