Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Sabers only

Battle takes place in the Geonosian Arena.

lolMalak

I'm thinking the same thing. Malak takes this.

Marek imo. He beat Vader after all.

Which Marek tho?

Galen.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Marek imo. He beat Vader after all.

Which Marek tho?
They didn't fight a pure sabers duel, and even if they did, Malak > TFU Vader in sabers.

What makes you say that?

And Marek did beat Vader in a lightsaber exchange.

Malak.

I wouldn't go so far as to say Malak is above TFU Vader in sabers, but if Kazdan and Kota can trouble him even moderately, Malak can probably win

Originally posted by Nephthys
What makes you say that?

Eh, all of Vader's "vast improvements" afterwards prevent me from holding him in high esteem in TFU.

Sabers only? I don't recall the duel being such.

Originally posted by FreshestSlice
They didn't fight a pure sabers duel, and even if they did, Malak > TFU Vader in sabers.

Doubt it. Even before his improvements during the OT, he was more or less evenly matched with Maul as a duelist.

The fight was almost entirely a saber match until the very end.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Doubt it. Even before his improvements during the OT, he was more or less evenly matched with Maul as a duelist. Hmm, but you don't consider Malak to be? That statement was about TFU Vader being bellow Malak in sabers, not OT Vader being unskilled with sabers in general.
Originally posted by NewGuy01
The fight was almost entirely a saber match until the very end.
Fair enough.