Robin, Robin, Red Hood, Nightwing Vs Spider-man

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



riv6672
Pre DCnu Tim Drake, Damian Wayne, Jason Todd and Dick Grayson in a no prep battle with Spider-man in mid town Manhattan. Start distance 1 city block.

DTM
Spider-Man wins.

riv6672
Scans or it didnt happen.

Stock reply stalemate!

DTM
Scans or it didnt happen? Scans of what, SpiderMan fighting 4 Robins? Good luck with that (not to mention a fairly rude reply for what is your threads only vote).

iceman24567
I see Spidey winning hometurf and decent starting distance

h1a8
Spidey

Mindset
Depends on how good their teamwork is.

I could see them pulling a majority unless they don't have weapons/gadgets.

pym-ftw
Spidey via blitz. Maybe fighting kids might make spidey go easy but honestly he can web their toys to their hands if he needs to.

beatboks
Spidey. no one should even be able to lay a glove on him or hit him with a weapon with spider sense and speed/agility.

krisblaze
Maybe if it was Dickbat they'd stand a better chance.

The Robins/Nightwings always seem to have such crap gear compared to Batman.

This team almost killed Talia's monster-clone though, and that guy was crazy strong.

riv6672
Originally posted by DTM
Scans or it didnt happen? Scans of what, SpiderMan fighting 4 Robins? Good luck with that (not to mention a fairly rude reply for what is your threads only vote).
Guess humor is deprndant on using smilies, as i was j/k. Ah well!

riv6672
Originally posted by krisblaze
Maybe if it was Dickbat they'd stand a better chance.

The Robins/Nightwings always seem to have such crap gear compared to Batman.

This team almost killed Talia's monster-clone though, and that guy was crazy strong.
What kind of monster?

krisblaze
Originally posted by riv6672
What kind of monster?
The heretic, the one who killed Damien Wayne.

riv6672
Ah, i've seen it. Cool. thumb up

maxivitopowe
Spidey easily

krisblaze
Originally posted by maxivitopowe
Spidey easily

I don't think I've ever seen Spidey beat any team like this easily.

SamZED
Unless some major CIS happens Pete should win pretty handily.

riv6672
I think its a good fight. Not hyped on one particular outcome, was just hoping for some good points for either.

maxivitopowe
Originally posted by krisblaze
I don't think I've ever seen Spidey beat any team like this easily.
Yes he's beaten better

CadenceV2
Originally posted by beatboks
Spidey. no one should even be able to lay a glove on him or hit him with a weapon with spider sense and speed/agility.

This. So this.

pym-ftw
Originally posted by krisblaze
I don't think I've ever seen Spidey beat any team like this easily. If only spidey fought a sinister team of villians... a team who would wtfpawn this one.

shifty

riv6672
Originally posted by beatboks
Spidey. no one should even be able to lay a glove on him or hit him with a weapon with spider sense and speed/agility.

Originally posted by CadenceV2
This. So this.

See, when people make blanket statements like this, i find it silly.
The simple fact is, Spider-man's been hit by people of all tiers since he was created.
If his powers were that absolute, he'd never be beaten.

So. Whether or not i agree with a particular outcome, those blanket " character cant lose because his power is 200% effective 100% of the time" make me go bleh.

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by pym-ftw
If only spidey fought a sinister team of villians... a team who would wtfpawn this one.

shifty

On paper, sure. But the Sinister 6 are riddled with CIS, what with Shocker and Rhino forming a third of their number.

I mean, the Bat Family are textbook examples of PIS working in their favour. On papaer, for example, Killer Croc should pwn them. Stronger, fastesr, home advantage, more durable, etc etc. But he goes down.

These guys are top tacticians. They'll gripe, sure, but they'll defer to Nightwing for leadership.

They have killers with projectile weapons, who won't hesitate to use force if necessary and more importantly, are well-trained and focussed, unlike 90% of Spidey's thugs. They won't stop to gloat over their enemy, or monologue like a Doc Ock or Green Goblin, or get distracted by killing innocent bystanders like a Carnage.

They also have one of the smartest people in the DCU, Tim, who, IIRC, is still one of the only people to have deduced Batman was Bruce.

In effect, you have an upgraded Batman. Better fighters, smarter, more agile and a better leader. But, crucially, spread over 4 bodies who can operate as one (if anybody knows how to fight in a team, it's a team made up of Batman's sidekicks). Plus their toys.


In conclusion: Spidey still wins, but I give his chances as 6 or 7/10.

riv6672
Now that's an answer i can respect. big grin

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.