Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

In what order would you rank the council members of the PT era?

I'll start by saying Coleman Trebor is the worst.

Is this power based?

Sorry I should have made it more clear, just in terms of 1v1 combat. Sort of an overall assessment of their combative skills.

As of ROTS:

1. Yoda
2. Windu
3. Anakin
4. Obi-wan
5. Plo Koon
6. Ki-Adi-Mundi
7. Shaak Ti
8. Kit Fisto
9. Saesee Tiin
10. Agen Kolar
11. Stass Allie
12. Coleman Kcaj

Originally posted by Emperordmb
As of ROTS:

1. Yoda
2. Windu
3. Anakin
4. Obi-wan
5. Plo Koon
6. Ki-Adi-Mundi
7. Shaak Ti
8. Kit Fisto
9. Saesee Tiin
10. Agen Kolar
11. Stass Allie
12. Coleman Kcaj

I'd place Shaak Ti above Mundi(not that i'm saying you're wrong or anything), but yeah aside from that dmb's list is the same as mine. pretty solid list dmb

Fisto >> anyone after number 4.

1. Yoda
2. Anakin
3. Mace
4. Kenobi
5-10: Kit, Plo, Shaak, Tiin, Kolar, Mundi (All on the same general level)
11. Stass Allie
12. Coleman Kcaj

1_2 - Yoda & Windu
3- Obi-Wan
4- Kit Fisto
5- Plo Koon
6- Saesee Tiin
7- Agen Kolar
8- Eeth Koth
9- Yaddle
10- Oppo Rancisis
11- Even Piell
12- Depa Billaba
13- Ki Adi Mundi
14- Shaak Ti
15- Adi Gallia
16- Stass Allie
17- Coleman Trebor
18- Coleman Kcaj
19- Yarael Poof

Originally posted by NewGuy01
1. Yoda
2. Anakin
3. Mace
4. Kenobi
5-10: Kit, Plo, Shaak, Tiin, Kolar, Mundi (All on the same general level)
11. Stass Allie
12. Coleman Kcaj

1. Yoda
2. Mace
3.Anakin
4. Kenobi
5. Plo
6. Fisto

and so on

Originally posted by Marco1907
1_2 - Yoda & Windu
3- Obi-Wan
4- Kit Fisto
5- Plo Koon
6- Saesee Tiin
7- Agen Kolar
8- Eeth Koth
9- Yaddle
10- Oppo Rancisis
11- Even Piell
12- Depa Billaba
13- Ki Adi Mundi
14- Shaak Ti
15- Adi Gallia
16- Stass Allie
17- Coleman Trebor
18- Coleman Kcaj
19- Yarael Poof

Huh? I don't get that order, why's Even Piell so high? And Shaak/Mundi/Depa so low? And Yarael below the Colemans?

The first four were easy, it seems like Plo is generally considered the fifth best?

Originally posted by Trocity
The first four were easy, it seems like Plo is generally considered the fifth best?

Generally, yes.

Originally posted by Q99
Huh? I don't get that order, why's Even Piell so high? And Shaak/Mundi/Depa so low? And Yarael below the Colemans?

Because I said so

My list
1-2-3 Yoda, Mace and Anakin are all number 1 in different situations; scenarios
4. Obi-wan
5. Kit Fisto
6. Plo Koon
7.Shaak Ti
8.Ki-Adi Mundi
9. Saesee Tiin
10. Agen Kolar
11. Stass Allie
12. Coleman Kcaj

Anakin ?

I never considered him as a council member, since he become a council member without being ''a jedi master'' ... It was like a joke and probably jedi council never accept him as one.

Nice to see everyone's placing Kenobi above everyone except the Big 3.

Btw, I am not too sure about Kit Fisto & Plo Koon, their ranks can be change. Kit is very fast, and very good at destroying creatures, droids and has great advantage in underwater. On the other hand, Plo Koon has better dueling skill, durability and has better force powers, and much better pilot and a leader.

1_2 - Yoda & Windu
3 - Obi-Wan
4_5 - Kit Fisto & Plo Koon
6 - Saesee Tiin
7 - Agen Kolar
8 - Eeth Koth
9 - Yaddle
10 - Oppo Rancisis
11 - Even Piell
12 - Depa Billaba
13 - Ki Adi Mundi
14 - Shaak Ti
15 - Adi Gallia
16 - Stass Allie
17 - Coleman Trebor
18 - Coleman Kcaj
19 - Yarael Poof

Originally posted by Emperordmb
As of ROTS:

1. Yoda
2. Windu
3. Anakin
4. Obi-wan
5. Plo Koon
6. Ki-Adi-Mundi
7. Shaak Ti
8. Kit Fisto
9. Saesee Tiin
10. Agen Kolar
11. Stass Allie
12. Coleman Kcaj

My exact rankings.

Originally posted by Marco1907
Anakin ?

I never considered him as a council member, since he become a council member without being ''a jedi master'' ... It was like a joke and probably jedi council never accept him as one.

True but he still held a seat on the Council and so he was "technically" a member even if he was never truly accepted.

Originally posted by Marco1907
Btw, I am not too sure about Kit Fisto & Plo Koon, their ranks can be change. Kit is very fast, and very good at destroying creatures, droids and has great advantage in underwater. On the other hand, Plo Koon has better dueling skill, durability and has better force powers, and much better pilot and a leader.

Fair comment but Trocity clearly stated that the criteria was how they ranked in "1v1 combat" specifically. In that regard Plo is definitely better (as you yourself acknowledged).

1. Yoda
2. Windu
3. Anakin
4. Obi-wan
5. Shaak Ti/Plo Koon
7. Ki-Adi-Mundi/ Kit Fisto
9. Agen Kolar
10. Saesee Tiin
11. Stass Allie
12. Coleman Kcaj

Originally posted by Emperordmb
As of ROTS:

1. Yoda
2. Windu
3. Anakin
4. Obi-wan
5. Plo Koon


I think this is pretty concrete.

Originally posted by Sinious
I think this is pretty concrete.

If Saesee Tiin is above Shaak Ti.... My army of underrated characters will tackle you down to the ground and force you to admit Bane > Vitiate http://r28.imgfast.net/users/2811/36/97/52/smiles/78415965.gif

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
If Saesee Tiin is above Shaak Ti.... My army of underrated characters will tackle you down to the ground and force you to admit Bane > Vitiate http://r28.imgfast.net/users/2811/36/97/52/smiles/78415965.gif

You couldnt even get Drew to say Bane>Vitiate

Nobody can get Drew to say anything in that regard. Technically, neither character was created by Drew.

Originally posted by Sinious
You couldnt even get Drew to say Bane>Vitiate

My powah has it's limits lord sinious, much like Vitiate i am nothing without the most stupid argument of all time

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Nobody can get Drew to say anything in that regard. Technically, neither character was created by Drew.

Yes, they were. Their names may have come up before Drew put them on paper, but he created the character's personalities and personally established their capabilities.

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
My powah has it's limits lord sinious,

We should kidnap him

Originally posted by Sinious
We should kidnap him

I just recently replayed Mass Effect and i bashed through some collectors on the highest difficulty and i've played black ops and got the highest K/D ratio. i've been trained for this.



Whoops, i made it so my phone does that whenever i text a friend about the .... Well you know

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
I just recently replayed Mass Effect and i bashed through some collectors on the highest difficulty and i've played black ops and got the highest K/D ratio. i've been trained for this.


I've played a lot of Red Dead Redemption so I can hogtie him. It should be fine



Yeah yeah no need to explain.

1. Yoda
--------------------------
2. Mace Windu
3. Anakin Skywalker
--------------------------
4. Obi-Wan Kenobi
--------------------------
5. Plo Koon
6. Agen Kolar
7. Saesee Tiin
8. Kit Fisto
9. Shaak Ti
10. Depa Billaba
--------------------------
11. Ki-Adi Mundi
12. Oppo Rancisis
13. Eeth Koth
14. Adi Gallia
15. Yaddle
16. Even Piell
--------------------------
17. Yarael Poof
18. Stass Allie
19. Coleman Kcaj
20. Coleman Trebor

um if we're counting people before ROTS, shouldn't Adi Gallia also have a mention on these lists?

Originally posted by Emperordmb
As of ROTS:

1. Yoda
2. Windu
3. Anakin
4. Obi-wan
5. Plo Koon
6. Ki-Adi-Mundi
7. Shaak Ti
8. Kit Fisto
9. Saesee Tiin
10. Agen Kolar
11. Stass Allie
12. Coleman Kcaj

Episode 1
12: Even Piell
11: Eeth Koth
10: Adi Gallia
9: Saesee Tiin
8: Yarael Poof
7: Depa Billaba
6: Ki Adi Mundi
5: Oppo Rancisis
4: Yaddle
3: Plo Koon
2: Mace Windu
1: Yoda
Episode 2
12: Coleman Trebor
11: Even Piell
10: Eeth Koth
9: Adi Gallia
8: Saesee Tiin
7epa Billaba
6: Ki Adi Mundi
5: Shaak Ti
4: Oppo Rancisis
3: Plo Koon
2: Mace Windu
1: Yoda
Episode 3
12: Coleman Kcaj
11: Stass Allie
10: Saesee Tiin
9: Ki Adi Mundi
8: Shaak Ti
7: Agen Kolar
6: Kit Fisto
5: Plo Koon
4: Obi Wan Kenobi
3: Anakin Skywalker
2: Mace Windu
1: Yoda