Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Fight takes place on flat/neutral terrain. Who wins?

Team 2 Bane with Orbalisk armor still sucks and still gets beaten around by TK from Malgus and or The Emperor can fry the loser with lightning.

Caedus can take out Malgus, but Bane dies to Sidious and Caedus loses to the Emperor (with difficulty)

Loser's not the right word for Bane, but I agree.

Caedus IMO reached or got very close to Palpatine's power, but I think Bane is a little superior to Malgus.

Can Caedus hold his own against Sidious ROTS? I think so, he was adequately fighting GM Luke in a lightsaber duel, the same Luke that when he was far less powerful and less refined was beating DE Sids in a duel.

In Force power I would like to think that Caedus would be able to hold his own as well, so they would probably go at it for a long time.

Long enough for Bane to take down Malgus and then possibly tip the balance enough to take down ROTS Sids.

Sidious will defeat Caedus with difficulty or oneshot Bane easily

Malgus on the other hand has dominated HoT/Barsen Wrath/Nox with TK, either of those users collectively are more powerful than himself

Malgus is also far superior duelist to Bane, and can dominate him with TK as he did with HoT and Barsen long enough for Sidious to defeat Caedus.

Even if Caedus beat Malgus, Sidious would SLAUGHTERHOUSE Bane and then finish Caedus off. Malgus can hold off Bane either way.

Sorry but your 'absence of evidence is evidence of absence' logic doesn't sit well with me, Bane was a master duelist and a very very powerful Force User... you know considering he is the ****ing Sith'Ari.

Anyway, your opinion is just fine but i don't agree with it.

Bane is an inferior duelist to Malgus

Bane fought evenly/gradually was overcoming Zannah (who only has beaten Set Harth) and Sarro Xaj (only due to the ineptitude of Johun Othone), beat a featless trainee Sirak, beat a featless Trainee Fohargh, and only beat Kas'im due to drawing on a nexus.

Malgus has beaten Kao Cen Darach, beaten Satele Shan twice, beaten Aryn Leneer, beaten a Zabrak master that toppled buildings on him, beaten Ven Zallow, beaten Lord Adras, and dominated two of the most powerful Jedi/Sith of the era with Telekinesis.

The only difference between DOE Bane and Orbalisk Bane, is Bane is protected by armor and is amped to a high degree. Bane is inferior in skill, power, and dueling feats to Malgus and there is nothing in Bane's showings off nexus with Orbalisks to suggest he doesn't get smashed around by Malgus's TK.

Team 1. Malgus doesn't belong here and causes Sidious' fall.

Team 1.

bump

Team 2. Malgus is stronger than Bane imo.

The teams are pretty even.

Originally posted by Lord Stark
Team 2. Malgus is stronger than Bane imo.

You think so? I would think the advantages of body-covering lightsaber-proof armor that provides passive dark side healing, and noticeably greater speed would provide something of an advantage on Bane's part, even if Malgus were as powerful as he.

Originally posted by Sinious
Team 1. Malgus doesn't belong here and causes Sidious' fall.

LOL I sooo take this back.

Team 2 in a good fight.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
You think so? I would think the advantages of body-covering lightsaber-proof armor that provides passive dark side healing, and noticeably greater speed would provide something of an advantage on Bane's part, even if Malgus were as powerful as he.
Problem with Darth Bane (Orbalisks) is his vulnerability to Force powers such as Force Lightning. Darth Malgus happens to be extremely proficient in the use of Force Lightning.

In addition, Malgus have Force Maelstrom. A powerful multi-tasking Force ability should be good enough to overwhelm most opponents.

Noticeably greater speed? Malgus is extremely fast. He have successfully contended with foes who are stated to be unbelievably fast even by Jedi standards.

Also, if I am not wrong, Orbalisks slowed Bane down.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
Team 2 in a good fight.


Problem with Darth Bane (Orbalisks) is his vulnerability to Force powers such as Force Lightning. Darth Malgus happens to be extremely proficient in the use of Force Lightning.

In addition, Malgus have Force Maelstrom. A powerful multi-tasking Force ability should be good enough to overwhelm most opponents.

He is vulnerable, though hardly much moreso than anyone else I'd wager, but he does have a lightsaber.

Caedus could probably kill Malgus via force storm tbh, he's actually demonstrated the power unlike him




-NJO Traitor