Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who would win in this duel?

Wow, good matchup!

Hey man! Welcome to KMC! As a heads up, there's actually a sub division on this forum that's made exclusively for threads like this! It's labeled the "movie versus forum."

They've got all kinds of cinematic throw downs, so head on over and check it out.

The section you posted this thread on is just discussing movies on general. Don't worry, it happens a lot. The mods will probably move this over for you. It helps keep the site clean and organized.

Also, totally Indy

I would think the one that gets into gunfights constantly, fights monsters, animals, armed criminals including trained mercenaries, etc., and usually carries a pair of pistols and is really good with them. Plus does frankly superhuman physical stunts. Johns may have fought a lot of Nazis, but mostly just fist fights.

Indiana may have come first, but let's be serious- this is an action video game protagonist. The carnage she's inflicted is massive.

Depends on the conditions. Lara wins a gunfight, Indy wins a fist/melee fight.

Nah, Lara still wins in fist/melee. Indiana is your regular tough guy but he's not shown as this super skilled h2h fighter. Lara has been portrayed as a pretty great h2h fighter.

Originally posted by FrothByte
Nah, Lara still wins in fist/melee. Indiana is your regular tough guy but he's not shown as this super skilled h2h fighter. Lara has been portrayed as a pretty great h2h fighter.

If theres guns, Lara wins. Otherwise, Indy wins

In a gun fight Lara wins. But Indy has stupid levels of damage soak. In Temple of Doom he takes a beating while getting Voodoo Doll'd, so it'd be hard for Lara to put him down in a h2h fight.

Indiana sexes up Lara ftw.

Indy and easily (mostly because men are simply better than woman)

Originally posted by Psychotron
Indiana sexes up Lara ftw.

I'd watch that porn.

Originally posted by Q99
I would think the one that gets into gunfights constantly,


That would be both of them honestly

Originally posted by Q99

fights monsters, animals, armed criminals including trained mercenaries, etc.,


Trained Mercs you say. Indy goes head to head with the SS and Spetsnaz. He's also faced a few animals.

No he hasn't faced monsters, but he has faced magic users. You know like guys who can reach into his chest and pulled out his still beating heart with out breaking the skin.

Originally posted by Q99

and usually carries a pair of pistols and is really good with them.


Actually Indy has been known to carry to pistols as well and is rather adept with them.

Originally posted by Q99

Plus does frankly superhuman physical stunts.


Again that would be both of them.

Originally posted by Q99

Johns may have fought a lot of Nazis, but mostly just fist fights.


Not only does he rather routinely engage in gun battles, but often those Nazi's he faces are SS teams as in military special forces.

Originally posted by Q99

Indiana may have come first, but let's be serious- this is an action video game protagonist. The carnage she's inflicted is massive.

And he's and action movie protagonist. So the amount of carnage he's inflicted is massive.

Originally posted by FrothByte
Nah, Lara still wins in fist/melee. Indiana is your regular tough guy but he's not shown as this super skilled h2h fighter. Lara has been portrayed as a pretty great h2h fighter. She ever KO 3 guys with one punch?