Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Both have an equal number of warships, men aboard such warships, and fighters that they will operate.
Who is the greater tactician? Battle takes place above Courscant. Both want the opponent's fleet eradicated.

Obviously Thrawn. Revan has no tactician feats like at all.

Thrawn.

Originally posted by Trocity
Thrawn.

Lame.

LOL

These threads never go like Ant wants them to.

*shrugs* Going with Revan.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
LOL

These threads never go like Ant wants them to.

He should start backing better characters. Like Sheev. excellent


Or Agen Kolar. uhuh

The Prodigal Knight's tactician abilities far surpasses Scrotum Face.

@Temp

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
The Prodigal Knight's tactician abilities far surpasses Scrotum Face.

Your anger arouses me.

Becauze Revan have battle meditation XDXDXDXDXDXDXDXDXDXDXDXDXDXDDXD !!!!!
He uze it to zacrifieze iz troopz when necezzary, without downing the moral of hiz troopz.....

Battle meditation might make Revan a more effective battle commander and thus grant him the win {maybe?}, but Ant asked which is the greater tactician and that would indeed be Thrawn.

Meh, I asked who would win the battle. Battle precognition (not mediation, Temp) is included in the tactician faceoff.

No, you didn't.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Both have an equal number of warships, men aboard such warships, and fighters that they will operate.
Who is the greater tactician? Battle takes place above Courscant. Both want the opponent's fleet eradicated.

It's okay, Temp. Revan doesn't have Battle Meditation, and "Battle Precognition" is just tactical foresight.

Revan iz cappable of everything to win... He will peharpz tricking our dear thrawn, living opening with alwayz the zame interval of time...

There iz many category where you can exel if uou r a tactician...
Be a great tactician= inknowledge the technology of your time, know how it'z working and bring your own ivention with it...
If You gave them both Revan era tech both Thrawn Era tech or totaly neutral tech wich iz totaly unknowed with the zame effectif on each zide.... It really change.
WIth the 3rd one it iz the underztanding and adapting capacity wich are in cauz even if thrawn iz a chizz with great obzervation zkill... Revan get the edge on thiz point, and will appropriate the fleet mechanic more quicly...

Originally posted by NewGuy01
It's okay, Temp. Revan doesn't have Battle Meditation, and "Battle Precognition" is just tactical foresight.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Revan doesn't have Battle Meditation

Wow, what a loser.

ikr

sas you should come on tor tbh

But a Revan zpeach have the zame efefct than battle meditation !!!!

Revan zpeach :
You Revan, lizten to me, I will explain to you how to proceed for thiz one, all you have to do iz juzt draw your light zaber az you have done to your precedent zpeach to remember the amazing zpeach thoze word than pozzezz the zoul of your followerz !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You made thiz zpeach when you ztill where fighting the mandalorian, and then you juzt doe the zame thing over and over again...

O.K that'z badly written.. ..

But Revan have hyptonize them !!!!

Revan

Precognition is only worth something if you actually know how to counter tacti s and Revan is no Thrawn by any margin.

Thrawn would have a harder time if he doesn't study Revan's tactics beforehand.

Originally posted by AncientPower
Precognition is only worth something if you actually know how to counter tacti s and Revan is no Thrawn by any margin.

yeah revan dont knoe dem taktics @ all bro

Definitely not a tactician.

Revan iz actually creativ.
More than you can imagine.... That'z mean he iz able to find zolution to the problem.

I don't know how do you tranzlate pince de thrawn etc...

But revan with hiz interdictor ztart to uze zimilar tacticz...

And tacticz change with the technology remember????? That'z why it'z important to zpecified the technology at their dizponzal...

Can Revan uze hiz auro of fear and intimidation???? To bring zhip on hiz command??? (Damn thranw why your zoldier enjoy the honor to zerve you???)

Originally posted by Revanchiste
Revan iz actually creativ.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9C_HReR_McQ&t=2m21s

Thrawn :/

Revans probably a close second though.

Originally posted by Selenial
Thrawn :/

Revans probably a close second though.

Prolly Ackbar.

There iz winning a battle and winning a war Revan focuz more on winning the war...

Thrawn iz creativ too having technology at your dizpozal and be able to make zometing great iz unexpected iz creativity.

The only Revan's brilliance is in either using vast resources of Republic against a single Mandalorian planet or using Star Forge supplying weaponry infinitely against mostly militaryless republic, or using Foundry to make a droid army.

Thiz juzt logic becauz it would be ztupid to uz them !!!! And malachor V where an occazion to end the war.

Revan waz like churchil with the intellency... Remember when you are with the ztar map on Kazhyyyk... Remeber the dialog.

You have a repport than a breach will be zet in the ennemy fleet line protecting the homeworld of your ennemy in ten day. Your intellgency tell you than one ou your baze will be ztrike dow in 5 dayz?? What zhould you do????

We juzt think what he doez iz ztupid but in fact it'z alway geniouz.

When he attack the republic he take care of the republic he take the inztalation not deztroying them to don't weak the republic....
He ztar to convert the Jedi order.

Revan loses the space battle but still manages to board thrawn 's ship and beats him to death worse than he did to mandalore the ultimate.

Thrawn without a doubt. He nay be one of the greatest tacticians in fictional history

And Revan isn't in your opinion?

He is a great tactician but has done nothing to put him amount the greatest. He won a war and became a ledgend for it but thrawn pulls off tactical impossibilities on a regular basis

Nearly destroying both the Republic and Imperial armadas at the same time with only some ships and a handful of pirates?

Revan is like king Leonidas and the battle of Thermopylae. What he did was awesome and brilliant and badass. But Thrawn is like Hannibal if every battle Hannibal fought was the battle of Cannae.

There is a huge difference

King Leonidas would shit stomp Hannibal, the the 300 would *****-slap Carthage with casual ease.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
King Leonidas would shit stomp Hannibal, the the 300 would *****-slap Carthage with casual ease.

What did I ever do to King Leonidas?

Was he a fan of Darth Bane? Is he mad that even his army would stomp Bane?

I mean the city.

Revan wins this through a massive surplus of war experience compared to Thrawn, and an unsurpassed degree of precognition, foresight, and battle meditation.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
King Leonidas would shit stomp Hannibal, the the 300 would *****-slap Carthage with casual ease. Leonidas had mover 6000 men in that battle AND the Athens fighting at sea.

Hannibal pulled off the perfect maneuver and slaughtered two roman armies in an after noon with only a fraction of the men.

Leonidas only lasted as long as he did because he nullified the Persians numbers. Hannibal had no such advantage

Jack, I can't right now. Getting ready to hang with friends.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
King Leonidas would shit stomp Hannibal, the the 300 would *****-slap Carthage with casual ease.

Dude, no. Cannae is a work of ****ing art.

Also Thrawn is more reliant on prep than Revan. Without staring at a painting for a few hours he's not as good as Revan's battle precog.

I have zmall ztory and zource than you will never heard and knowed about Revan tacticz... It'z a pain in the azz to find them, they are reliable but really....

There iz an big ellipze on the mandalorian war... But if you zchearch zchearch zchearch and rezchearch again on the net you can have zamall windowz.. The zame for the war againzt the republic....

If Revan zhow hiz azz on the battle the moral of hiz troopz quazi give him the edge....

Revan have alzo teach how to command at hiz officier (becauz Revan not manage juzt zimple battlez he manage war !!! ANd He cannot have hiz azz everywhere)


"Also Thrawn is more reliant on prep than Revan. Without staring at a painting for a few hours he's not as good as Revan's battle precog."

That'z true if you give them a total unknow technology to fight..... Revan get clearly the edge... Force Knowledge XD He will learn more quicly and anticipate fazter than thrawn....

Originally posted by deathslash
Revan loses the space battle but still manages to board thrawn 's ship and beats him to death worse than he did to mandalore the ultimate.

Yhea becauze thrawn iz the key to the victory.

No matter the zhipz you can replace them !!! Hit the heart and the head !!!

But he will board only if needed, Becoze with mandalore the utimate it waz juzt an invitation...

If he can juzt firing on thrawn zhip.....

Zidiouz never tell to thrawn than he waz he'z bezt amiral zo that'z mean thrawn iz the bezt grand amiral of the imperail fleet.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
King Leonidas would shit stomp Hannibal, the the 300 would *****-slap Carthage with casual ease.

Revan counting on 300 zpartiate iz not iz kind at all....Even mandalore the ultimate and hiz 1 000 000 000 mandalorianz.... angainzt republic 15 000 000 000 zoldierz.....