Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Not sure how good of a fight this is either way, but I'm surprised I couldn't find it on google. Here it is.

*Emperor Malgus

Malgus.

Malgus

HoT.

gets ragdolled and killed

Stop talking to me.

Let's hear* some reasons gents

More powerful, he already sent him flying, dominated him with TK, whereas, HoT only ragdolled a weakened Vitiate. Malgus beat him and Barsen down, and if it weren't for Barsen and the strike team he would've killed HoT in that fight imo.

He is stronger, and more durable, and maybe a little more skilled as a duelist.

Originally posted by ILS
Let's here some reasons gents

Malgus can't overpower him with TK or lightning, the Hero is more powerful and a better swordsman.

Malgus, close fight.

And what do you mean Malgus can't overpower him w/TK? Weren't you making the argument that Malgus could ragdoll the HoT and Barsen'thor at the same time?

Originally posted by Nephthys
Malgus can't overpower him with TK or lightning, the Hero is more powerful and a better swordsman.

We all know how good Scourge was killing fodder guards Malgus already threw him around, and his best feat is collapsing a ceiling which is inferior to Malgus ragdolling him and Barsen and blasting away tons of rubble. Who has HoT beaten that is above him thrashing Zallow, Satele, and Aryn before his prime? Even if he is more skilled (which I doubt) it isn't by much considering he's beaten featless opponents primarily as well.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Malgus, close fight.

And what do you mean Malgus can't overpower him w/TK? Weren't you making the argument that Malgus could ragdoll the HoT and Barsen'thor at the same time?

Uh, no?

Malgus isn't overpowering him if Vitiate couldn't, even in a state where he could collapse the Dark Temple.

You've tried to pass Malgus choking 3 of the party members as canon, and mentioned the Force users exclusively, including the Hero.

Except that he already has sent him flying and dominated him with his force abilities. Vitiate was also weakened and if he had full power/prep/and his nexus would've wiped the floor with him.

Malgus has already proven he is more powerful than HoT, and this was before Revan knocked him down as well

Originally posted by NewGuy01
You've tried to pass Malgus choking 3 of the party members as canon, and mentioned the Force users exclusively, including the Hero.

And the strike team has 4 members....

Strike Team could have been the Imperials though. And he could have been choking out two of the non-Force users.

Malgus.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Strike Team could have been the Imperials though. And he could have been choking out two of the non-Force users.

It probably was the Imperials, and I don't think he could ragdoll the HoT. I'm saying Neph has definitely made the argument several times in the past, though still somehow retains that HoT>Malgus.

#doublestandards

Originally posted by NewGuy01
It probably was the Imperials, and I don't think he could ragdoll the HoT. I'm saying Neph has definitely made the argument several times in the past, though still somehow retains that HoT>Malgus.

I've always maintained that the choke would only be against the 2 non-force users and the weaker Jedi/Sith. So no, I've never argued Malgus could choke the HoT.

Malguz HoT.

Originally posted by Revanchiste
Malguz HoT. Agreed

He's easy on the eyes, I'll admit.

Malgus wins this one.