Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Just for shits and giggles, I want to rate every single film incarnation of the Hulk, live action and animated, and settle the debate once and for all.

Which Hulk is strongest? Why?


Bana Hulk
Norton Hulk
Ruffalo Hulk
Ferrigno Hulk
Planet Hulk
Ultimate Avengers Hulk
Hulk from "Hulk vs Wolverine"
Hulk from "Hulk vs. Thor"
Hulk from Iron Man & Hulk: Heroes United
Hulk from Avengers Confidential: Black Widow & Punisher

Hulk vs Thor is the strongest one by an extremely large margin.

Hulk Hogan and its not even close

Originally posted by KingD19
Hulk vs Thor is the strongest one by an extremely large margin.

Guess that's another thing we agree on. Hulk vs. Thor was almost too overpowered.

I haven't seen it, so for me I guess it's Bana hulk, he survived a nuke so...

Ultimate Avengers Hulk did wreck the whole team, lift Mjolnir, and one-shot Thor. He's probably at the top.

1. Hulk from "Hulk Vs" (Wolverine and Thor)
2. Ultimate Avengers Hulk
3. Planet Hulk
4. Hulk from Iron Man & Hulk: Heroes United
5. Hulk from Avengers Confidential: Black Widow & Punisher
6. Ruffalo Hulk
7. Norton Hulk
8. Bana Hulk
9. Ferrigno Hulk

Originally posted by Supermutant
1. Hulk from "Hulk Vs" (Wolverine and Thor)
2. Ultimate Avengers Hulk
3. Planet Hulk
4. Hulk from Iron Man & Hulk: Heroes United
5. Hulk from Avengers Confidential: Black Widow & Punisher
6. Ruffalo Hulk
7. Norton Hulk
8. Bana Hulk
9. Ferrigno Hulk

I agree with this list, except I'd swap 6 and 8.

Originally posted by Impediment
I agree with this list, except I'd swap 6 and 8.

Why? Ruffalo Hulk was overpowering Thor, one shotted a Chitauri armored Leviathan, and pounded Loki senseless with one hand.

Bana Hulk was having a hard time with gamma dogs.

Why is that a low feat if they're powered by the same shit he is?

Originally posted by Psychotron
Why is that a low feat if they're powered by the same shit he is?

Its not a low feat for Bana Hulk, but Ruffalo Hulk has much better feats.

He didn't tank a nuke, though.

I also have to question why Bana Hulk would be below Norton's. His is really only the same as Ruffalo's in name only.

Bana Hulk tanked a nuke.

Ruffalo Hulk was being pinned down by Chitauri laser fire as Iron Man flew the nuke into the portal..

Wasn't it a gamma bomb?

Originally posted by KingD19
Wasn't it a gamma bomb?

I don't remember anymore, but what difference would that make? Wouldn't it just be more powerful?

Originally posted by Psychotron
I don't remember anymore, but what difference would that make? Wouldn't it just be more powerful?

Gamma energy is what fuels him.

It's like saying a guy who is fireproof and absorbs fire gets hit with an incendiary bomb and he tanks it imo. It's a nice feat, but he's designed to handle stuff like that.

Originally posted by KingD19
Gamma energy is what fuels him.

It's like saying a guy who is fireproof and absorbs fire gets hit with an incendiary bomb and he tanks it imo. It's a nice feat, but he's designed to handle stuff like that.

Okay, but radiation isn't the big problem here, it's the force of the shokwave and the heat. If Bana Hulk survived that then he's way above Avengers Hulk.

Originally posted by Psychotron
Okay, but radiation isn't the big problem here, it's the force of the shokwave and the heat. If Bana Hulk survived that then he's way above Avengers Hulk.

The gamma energy would amp him at the same time as the actual explosion making it more likely for him to survive it.

Didn't Bana Hulk also survive a near atmospheric drop? He also has a visibly functional healing factor and actually gets more powerful with anger: he got bigger so reason.

Originally posted by KingD19
The gamma energy would amp him at the same time as the actual explosion making it more likely for him to survive it.

Speculation. We have no idea if gamma radiation powers him up. Also, the heat and force at the center of the explosion would be far greater than any potential amp.

Just look at the jumping. Bana Hulk could jump much higher/farther than any other live action movie Hulk.

Ferigno Hulk couldn't even pick up a car.

Originally posted by Supermutant
Bana Hulk was having a hard time with gamma dogs. Their bite strength must have been enormous

Bana Hulk agility was above any other, damage soak was of the scale, strength might not be the tip top but he would certainly be the toughest live action hulk.