Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

All out

Can the duo defeat him?

The Twins take it. Caedus can amp her through their battle meld, and he is already a peer of Sidious.

Depends on if Sidious can take Jaina out

Other than that Sheev gets his ass kicked

Sidious is a cautious character. I don't think he would dive into a duel right away when facing an enemy he does not know. Especially since he can sense how powerful they are.

A lightning attack by Sidious could keep Caedus back and take out Jaina for a while.

Enough 1on1 time with Caedus and Sidious has the victory. Not saying its a certainty but Sidious definitely has a good chance at winning this imo.

Either twin can win Sidious.

Originally posted by Sinious
Enough 1on1 time with Caedus and Sidious has the victory. Not saying its a certainty but Sidious definitely has a good chance at winning this imo.

No, he really doesn't. At this time, Caedus alone can give him one hell of a fight. Adding Jaina is just too much.

Yeah, Jaina's enough to tip the scales.

10 vs. 9.5 is close enough that any help the 9.5 gets tips it his way.

Jaina and Caedus take it 7-8 out of 10, IMO.

Damn, perhaps DE Sidious would be a better opponent for this team.

Originally posted by ares834
No, he really doesn't. At this time, Caedus alone can give him one hell of a fight. Adding Jaina is just too much.

Sidious is slightly better as a duelist and has enough power to hold the duo back for a while imo.

The outcome of this fight mostly depends on whether he can eliminate Jaina or not.

Sidious closes Jaina's windpipe and proceeds to defeat Caedus in a great fight?

Which would be unlikely unless he can do it with Caedus pounding at him A possibility though, however remote

Not sure how remote it is. Doesn't take long at all to crush a windpipe with telekinesis, lol. Even if we assume that Sidious is incapable of doing it before Caedus closes the distance, all he needs is less than a second of respite - a saber lock, perhaps - to do it.

Caedus > ROTS Sidious

Adding Jaina to Team Caedus makes this an absolute stomp.

Originally posted by carthage
Depends on if Sidious can take Jaina out

Other than that Sheev gets his ass kicked

Originally posted by Sinious

A lightning attack by Sidious could keep Caedus back and take out Jaina for a while.


Jaina can block Caedus's lightning and other force attacks, so she's not likely to be taken out by a quick lightning from Sidious either.



I think both of them are tough enough that even splitting them up is hard. Duo should win this quite solidly IMO.

Originally posted by ILS
Sidious closes Jaina's windpipe and proceeds to defeat Caedus in a great fight

I don't think Caedus will just stand there and let him?

Caedus is already on Sidious's speed/sabers level and arguably approaching him in force power as well, at least RotS Sidious.
Caedus vs. Sidious 1v1 is an extremely close and brutal battle.

It boils down to how good Jaina really is: RotS Kenobi level? SoD Maul level?

Originally posted by Q99
Jaina can block Caedus's lightning and other force attacks, so she's not likely to be taken out by a quick lightning from Sidious either.

A quick lightning attack by Sidious was enough to take out Yoda though.

Originally posted by Stigma
I don't think Caedus will just stand there and let him?

Caedus is already on Sidious's speed/sabers level and arguably approaching him in force power as well, at least RotS Sidious.
Caedus vs. Sidious 1v1 is an extremely close and brutal battle.

It boils down to how good Jaina really is: RotS Kenobi level? SoD Maul level?

Obi-wan Kenobi didn't join Yoda to fight the Emperor for a reason. It'd be like when Yoda had to protect Anakin from Sidious in TCW. He'd do more damage than good. I'm not sure how Jaina would be able to turn the tides when a jedi master like Kenobi is considered to be completely useless.

I believe Caedus has both Battle Mediation and Force Meld, and both of those things work better with a twin sister involved. It's being his twin that lets Caedus adequately support his sister.

He wouldn't be able to support Obi Wan, say, as well, because he's not related to Obi Wan.

It's Jaina whose going to be supporting Caedus here. Caedus is the main force on the team, you do realize this right?

Battle meld was significantly labor intensive for him, at least that's what he said when he was coordinating the GA fleets. It would probably be draining on him in a duel with Sidious

That's coordinating a fleet. Coordinating with just his twin sister has to be a LOT easier.

Their bond was nonexistent when he was a Sith Lord IIRC

Makes it sound like Caedus would've done better as Jacen in Sacrifice before offing Mara. The twin bond is probably enough to make a difference in Jaina's performance if it works.

Originally posted by Sinious
A quick lightning attack by Sidious was enough to take out Yoda though.

Well, Jaina is not Yoda. She will not stay in relaxed posture trying to casually block lightning with bare hands.

Originally posted by carthage
Battle meld was significantly labor intensive for him, at least that's what he said when he was coordinating the GA fleets. It would probably be draining on him in a duel with Sidious
Jacen coordinated Jedi Strike Team of 15 people during YV war.