Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Plain and simple who wins.

Sabers

Force

All out

Hmmm this is a good fight. Ki Adi did force Ventress into retreat on Coruscant, and Plo managed to push her with one arm broken.

Probably Plo in a decent fight.

Plo Koon Plowns him.

Originally posted by Lord Stark
Hmmm this is a good fight. Ki Adi did force Ventress into retreat on Coruscant, and Plo managed to push her with one arm broken. Mundi did no such thing.

Even with out that Mundi holding out against Grevious for as long as he did is more than impressive imo. I'm going with Mundi.

Moons showing against Ventress is more impressive. Koon wins

Mundi and Ventress literally exchanged only two blows before the gunship fired on her forcing her to retreat.

Plo Koon 8-9/10

Originally posted by |King Joker|
Mundi did no such thing.

Yeah he did. Ventress elected to not engage him and let precious information pass onto Mundi rather than engage him even after the clones died.

2:30
gvR1J1o5qsU

No, she didn't let him get the information knowingly. She already slashed the dude across the chest but he survived long enough to tell Mundi the information.

In the actual duel he didn't force her to do anything, the gunships fired at her causing her to retreat.

Originally posted by |King Joker|
No, she didn't let him get the information knowingly. She already slashed the dude across the chest but he survived long enough to tell Mundi the information.

In the actual duel he didn't force her to do anything, the gunships fired at her causing her to retreat.

Bro do you not understand comic book medium? It lasted longer than two blows. + in every panel Ventress was on the retreat BEFORE the gunship opened fire.

Um, no she wasn't. And how long do you really think the fight lasted? At most it would've been like 10 seconds.

It varies from comic to comic. Do you honestly think the SoD duels were only a few seconds long?

Considering the circumstances of Mundi's duel with Ventress it clearly wasn't meant to be portrayed as anything but a very brief duel.

Sure, but you were trying to pass off that they only exchanged two blows. Ten seconds is reasonable, but the possibility that the fight was longer is there. Either way, he handled himself solidly and has other feats to lean back on anyway.

Of course, but I was just responding to the "Mundi pushed Ventress back" nonsense when we only see an exchange of two blows where no advantage is apparent.

Originally posted by |King Joker|
Um, no she wasn't. And how long do you really think the fight lasted? At most it would've been like 10 seconds.

Yeah she was, in both scenes she's defending. Fight probably lasted around 20-30 seconds. And anyway the fact that Ventress opted to retreat even after Mundi was buried beneath rubble and the Clones were dead speaks a lot, as does Mundi's confidence in his ability to defeat her.

Also considering exhausted Mundi dueled Grievous for hours...yeah it is in keeping with his other feats.

Originally posted by Lord Stark
Yeah she was, in both scenes she's defending. Fight probably lasted around 20-30 seconds. And anyway the fact that Ventress opted to retreat even after Mundi was buried beneath rubble and the Clones were dead speaks a lot, as does Mundi's confidence in his ability to defeat her.

Also considering exhausted Mundi dueled Grievous for hours...yeah it is in keeping with his other feats. No, the first panel they duel he's defending (kind of, but Ventress definitely isn't defending, either), and in the second she is. 20-30 seconds is ridiculous, honestly. The gunship just hovered there for that amount of time while they dueled?

And whether or not it's within his capabilities is not what we're discussing. We're discussing your claim that Mundi forced Ventress into a retreat, which he didn't. Seeing as how Mundi and his forces followed the senator dude, he would have likely had reinforcements nearby, so Ventress trying to engage him again would have been pointless and risky seeing as how the possibly of capture was there. Ventress' "retreat" and unwillingness to engage Mundi is more of a logical decision in my view.

Originally posted by |King Joker|
No, the first panel they duel he's defending (kind of, but Ventress definitely isn't defending, either), and in the second she is. 20-30 seconds is ridiculous, honestly. The gunship just hovered there for that amount of time while they dueled?

Why is this hard to believe? A battalion of Stormtroopers watched for hours and Darth Vader and Kenobi dueled. What do you think this is Order 66?



Yes, she weighed her tactical options and opted for the retreat. Thus Mundi literally forced her into retreat. I don't see how this is any different than Yoda and Dooku dueling briefly and Dooku weighing his options and retreating. No one debates that Dooku was forced into retreat.