Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Prime Yoda at the age of between 600-700 faces off against three variations of Sidious:

Round 1: Darth Sidious (Revenge of the Sith)

Round 2: Darth Sidious (Return of the Jedi)

Round 3: Darth Sidious (Dark Empire)


Settings:

Round 1: Senate Chamber

Round 2: Death Star II Throne Room

Round 3: Eclipse Throne Room

Rules:

Yoda gets full rest and a day of prep for each round.
Sidious is caught off-guard each round with no prep.
In the interest of fairness Sidious ROTJ gets his lightsaber.
DE Sids can't Essence Transfer.

Hard to call.

But he probably clears.

Pure speculation tbh. But... it's fun.

Prime Yoda was supposedly more powerful than his RotS self, but hard to tell by how much.

Im gonna say he clears Round 1 with very high difficulty. Not sure about round 2. With these stipulations probably Yoda. Round 3 goes to DE Sidious, perhaps.

Prime Yoda is ridiculously overrated. He wins the first solely out of having the first strike, and the second one he might win but he could also be flat-out overpowered Force-wise.

And he won't be winning the last one for a majority.

Originally posted by Stigma

Im gonna say he clears Round 1 with very high difficulty. Not sure about round 2. With these stipulations probably Yoda. Round 3 goes to DE Sidious, perhaps.

I agree. Sidious getting caught off guard when Yoda prime has prep is probably too much for ROTJ Sidious. DE Sidious will still win though.

Yoda wins 1, 2 is pretty much 50 50, but even Prime Yoda can't compete with the Emperor Reborn.

Originally posted by Stigma
Pure speculation tbh. But... it's fun.

Prime Yoda was supposedly more powerful than his RotS self, but hard to tell by how much.

Im gonna say he clears Round 1 with very high difficulty. Not sure about round 2. With these stipulations probably Yoda. Round 3 goes to DE Sidious, perhaps.

Actually, no we know approximately how much more powerful Yoda is.

Pre-700 he could lift 6 of the Muntuur stones, post-700 he could lift 6. Doing the math if you take 20% of 5/7ths and add it to 5/7ths you get 6/7ths. So...yeah ROTS Yoda's TK is 80% of Prime Yoda. In other words the difference between Vader and Sidious is the difference between Prime Yoda and ROTS Yoda. +Mace even said that he's lost a step in dueling. Also throw in that it no longer hurts to fight because you know Yoda has arthritis


prime!Yoda clears with prep



No he's not. The dude has debilitating arthritis that for the most part confines him to a bloody hoverchair mostly. He practices the most exhausting form of lightsaber combat, after just 30 seconds of combat with Dooku he was tired. prime!Yoda would have no such restrictions. + Would have way better TK.

Prime Yoda isn't clearing the Reborn Emperor. It's a MASSIVE upgrade for Sidious.

Just like Prime Yoda isn't clearing GM Luke either.

Originally posted by Angelalex242
Prime Yoda isn't clearing the Reborn Emperor. It's a MASSIVE upgrade for Sidious.

Just like Prime Yoda isn't clearing GM Luke either.

A ridiculous comparison considering GM Luke is far above the Reborn Emperor.

Wins round 1 by the skin of his teeth.

Round 2 is a toss up.

Loses round 3.

He doesn't beat two

Yeah 2 is drawish. I'd give it 5/10.

How is 2 a draw? He has prep and the element of surprise?

Originally posted by Lord Stark
A ridiculous comparison considering GM Luke is far above the Reborn Emperor.

Not really, no.

Round 1. Prime yoda

Round 2. Could go either way

Round 3. Sidious stomps

Originally posted by ares834
Wins round 1 by the skin of his teeth.

Round 2 is a toss up.

Loses round 3.

Originally posted by Lord Stark



No he's not. The dude has debilitating arthritis that for the most part confines him to a bloody hoverchair mostly. He practices the most exhausting form of lightsaber combat, after just 30 seconds of combat with Dooku he was tired. prime!Yoda would have no such restrictions. + Would have way better TK.

LMAO. What arthritis? His Force Valor can compensate, and he had a longer fight with Palpatine without tiring mid-duel.

His speed was reduced slightly, and his telekinesis went down, but that's all. And it's not "way better", or at least, not utterly game-changing.

Yoda doesn't clear DE Palpatine either, that's ridiculous.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Not really, no.

Luke should be 110% of Sidious' Power, considering that Full-Potential Anakin is 120% his power.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Luke should be 110% of Sidious' Power, considering that Full-Potential Anakin is 120% his power.

Full potential Anakin is 200% of Sidious. And Luke is stated to be what Anakin should have been so he should be at least 140-150% of Sidious.


Originally posted by SunRazer
LMAO. What arthritis? His Force Valor can compensate, and he had a longer fight with Palpatine without tiring mid-duel.

Fightsaber: Jedi Lightsaber combat says Yoda has arthritis. Just because he can duel for longer periods of time doesn't mean it's not exhausting for him. His force valor is obviously taxing.



Nigga do you read? His TK went down by 20% that's the difference between Palpatine and Vader.



Yeah he does, with prep and an ambush.




Via word of god, yes he is. GL basically states Luke is 200% of Sidious. Now I think 150% makes more sense, but the quote is there.

Originally posted by Lord Stark
Nigga do you read? https://33.media.tumblr.com/68112c120f830e59c7c138af060bfe33/tumblr_inline_no7zn5YEEm1r4tgin_500.gif