Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Has the canon evolved Darth Vader into a top tier combatant in the mythos?

Composite ROTJ Vader vs Composite ROTS Yoda

Setting: Dagobah Swamps.

All-out, no amps.

Still Yoda

Yoda. Vader is slow Yoda is not.

Yoda, but it's probably not terribly one-sided given that morals are on.

I'll have to see how Vader Down and Rebels goes, but probably still Yoda for a majority.

Vader is still probably not on Yoda's level, but close.

Vader goes to a swamp down in Dagobah, where he doesn't come back from a giant carbonated soda...S O D A soda....

Yoda wins.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Yoda, but it's probably not terribly one-sided given that morals are on.

Vader rapes with a mechanic dildo.

Nothing has changed for Vader in terms of lightsaber abilities, which was always the field he was rather lacking in.

Yoda converts him back to the light side.

Lmfao @ Yoda stomping Vader

Originally posted by carthage
Lmfao @ Yoda stomping Vader ??

Yoda with mid difficulty, Disney Vader isn't any stronger

Force wise they're still around even in canon. Yoda may be more powerful though since though he was over matched by Sidious, Vader also was in Lords of the Sith and it is hinted that Sidious wasn't using his full power.

Skill wise Yoda is still Vader's better by feats.

Speed wise I'm not sure. Vader has created 13 afterimages with blade whilst blocking omnidirectional fire.

Strength and endurance is debatable.

Durability goes to Vader.

Yoda is obvious more knowledgeable/versatile in the force and Darth Vader's mobility is hampered by his suit.

Probably still Yoda but a good fight nonetheless.

Welcome back man

Originally posted by carthage
Welcome back man

Thanks man. It's good to be back.

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_super/11116/111165168/4932890-6044953366-5537-.jpg

Yoda still wins. People overlooking Vader's lack of maneuverability and exaggerating Vader's force powers to the nth degree.

Originally posted by carthage
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_super/11116/111165168/4932890-6044953366-5537-.jpg I remember getting that in a 5th grade book fair

Vader should win that encounter if Yoda's that nearing his deathbed.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Vader should win that encounter if Yoda's that nearing his deathbed.

Originally posted by carthage
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_super/11116/111165168/4932890-6044953366-5537-.jpg
It says "see who wins on page 64", I wonder what it says there

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Star_Wars:_Head-to-Head

Originally posted by Rebel95
http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Star_Wars:_Head-to-Head
It says the winner is Darth Vader.

Originally posted by Rebel95
It says the winner is Darth Vader.


It also has Fisto beating Maul, so clearly not reliable in terms of the results.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
It also has Fisto beating Maul, so clearly not reliable in terms of the results. Unlike you I don't take any of these opinions as factual but you clearly pick and choose indicating an inconsistency and strong bias.

Doesn't it also have Grievous beating Sidious?

Yeah those things are bullshit

Plo Koon beating Talzin as well. Oh, and apparently the Nightsisters that fought Dooku with Ventress could beat Luminara and Gallia.

And guess who wrote the book? Pablo Hidalgo, lmfao.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Plo Koon beating Talzin as well. Oh, and apparently the Nightsisters that fought Dooku with Ventress could beat Luminara and Gallia. Luminara's tactically retarded and underestimates everyone she fights, dude.

Originally posted by |King Joker|
And guess who wrote the book? Pablo Hidalgo, lmfao.




Oh jeez no.

Well I'm hoping he was just being a fanboy 5 years ago, but has a much more in depth knowledge of combatant's abilities, now that he's you know.. Head of Canon.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Unlike you I don't take any of these opinions as factual but you clearly pick and choose indicating an inconsistency and strong bias.
I never said that I agreed with it. I was just sharing.

Originally posted by Rebel95
I never said that I agreed with it. I was just sharing. I quoted Darth Thor. Is this a Darth Thor alt ? Kinda slipped up there, eh ?

Originally posted by quanchi112
I quoted Darth Thor. Is this a Darth Thor alt ? Kinda slipped up there, eh ?


My b. Your post looked like it was directed towards me. You said he took it as factual when he said that it wasn't so it didn't really make any sense.

Originally posted by Rebel95
It says the winner is Darth Vader.

Yes, I'm pretty sure a 900 year old Yoda, knocking on death's door, broken morale, and potentially disarmed would indeed lose to Vader.

Does it say it's the OT version of Yoda?