Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

1. JQ Anakin
2. AOTC Anakin
3. CW Anakin
4. Rots Anakin
Bonus: Rots Vader

Stops at CW Anakin

I think he has a chance against CW anakin but he definitely loses to ROTS anakin.

Not getting past 4, definitely clears 1-2. 3 is the one I'm unsure on.

Stops at 3 imo

Stops at 3.

Bonus < 3. And yaeh, he probably stops at 3.

I could see RotJ Luke defeating the bonus tbh.

RotJ could beat the bonus.

Probably TCW Anakin assuming he isn't jobbing, if not than he dies to 4

Stops at TCW Anakin, where it can go either way if it's early in TCW, but will probably get beaten if it's late in TCW.

I don't see ROTJ taking out Pre-Suit Vader. I don't think Luke could keep his defenses going for that long. Kenobi, who's...well, Kenobi, was pushed to his limits.

RotJ Luke could beat Kenobi. :P

If RotJ Luke can take on RotJ Vader, he should be able to deal with a weaker and more insane version of him. Especially given all the feats canon has given him.

And should be able to take on RotS Anakin as well. mmm

He clears tbh.

lolno

People really have no respect for Luke around here.

>tfw losing to Anakin means someone has no respect for them. What a Neph-tier comment.

Lol I'm referring to your dismissal he has any chance of winning.

That didn't change my point in the slightest. If anything it reinforced it.

Originally posted by FreshestSlice
That didn't change my point in the slightest. If anything it reinforced it. Ditto tbh. And naturally you're not going to agree...

Originally posted by Syndicate
RotJ Luke could beat Kenobi. :P I doubt it. Kenobi matches Luke in speed and surpasses him in durability and endurance. Luke isn't getting past Kenobi's Soresu defense and lacks any combative Force showings besides a Force choke on Jabba's gaurds. Yes, Kenobi has a passable Force wall, but I doubt ROTJ Luke mind you, would feel so stressed to attempt a Force choke. Luke's defenses are quite good, but I think it'd come down to Luke being cut down by Kenobi either by a Shii-Cho and Ataru onslaught or Kenobi outlasting him.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Ditto tbh. And naturally you're not going to agree...
Beni, no one sane, rational, or not-****tarded would agree with you on most things.

Honestly the only advantage Luke has over his father is control.

Luke has a chance of winning. Just not a good one. xD

Originally posted by Kurk
Honestly the only advantage Luke has over his father is control. Or the fact Luke bested him badly as soon as he got angry and fought back.

As soon as he got angry...

That's exactly what Luke does NOT want to do against Kenobi. Angry Luke is more like his dad and therefore Kenobi is more familiar with it. Sane Luke has a jedi's calm discipline and decision making skills. That's probably harder for Kenobi to deal with.

Hard stop at 3.