Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Both are in their prime; both Legends and Canon feats available.

Battle takes place on Yavin IV.

Lord Scourge solidly

He became a master swordsman long before his prime. He also have advantage in the aspects of strength, Force powers and experience. During his tenure as the Emperor's Wrath, he significantly grew in power and acquired new talents (including Shatterpoint). He have over a thousand (Jedi and Sith) kills under his belt, a testament to his considerable combat prowess.

Scourge solidly.

Ventress wins

Ventress. I've never been impressed by Scrouge, honestly.

Scourge

Scourge pretty handily. Taking into consideration his ability to draw on his opponents emotions (especially anger, fear, and hatred), which Ventress is full of and tends to have poor control over, he'd have a massive amp from that.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Scourge

Battle takes place on Yavin IV? Scourge gorges on Kun's anger.

guess also Sadic > Plo Koon and Nefarid > Corran Horn

Stop pretending Sadic and Nefarid are in the same multiverse as Scourge

Originally posted by JKBart
guess also Sadic > Plo Koon

Rofl.

Scourge getting tooled by Factory droids in the Revan novel >>> any of Ventress's feats tbh

Originally posted by AncientPower
Scourge solidly.

Originally posted by carthage
Scourge getting tooled by Factory droids in the Revan novel >>> any of Ventress's feats tbh

That was literally decades before his prime. So, yeah, not seeing how that is relevant.



I'm leaning towards Ventress.

Originally posted by Col. Valerian
That was literally centuries before his prime. So, yeah, not seeing how that is relevant.

Right, but we don't exactly know at which point during those years did he reach his peak. Could've been decades for all we know, but then again, could've been centuries.

Doesn't matter. The point is the Revan novel is far before his peak.

Ventress.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Doesn't matter. The point is the Revan novel is far before his peak.

I know it doesn't, I was agreeing with that notion.

Yeah, Scourge is heavily underrated on KMC.

Did you read the same first page I did?

Yes, I was inspired by it enough to share what's usually the case in most threads.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
acquired new talents (including Shatterpoint).

This probably doesn't impact the battle a whole lot, but I'm curious; where is this stated?

Originally posted by NewGuy01
This probably doesn't impact the battle a whole lot, but I'm curious; where is this stated? It isn't.

Still beats Asajj, though.

Ventress.

Originally posted by Geistalt
It isn't.

Still beats Asajj, though.

Ventress, killing 3 nameless Sith a year doesn't compare to challenging some of the most powerful Jedi in history.

You say that like it isn't a hundred times as much experience as Ventress has and like Scourge couldn't do that as well.

Having hundreds of times more experience and training as your opponent when you're already a prodigy and possessing massive amounts of actualised power on top of 3 seperate amps is actually a big deal, bro.

Ventress slaps him into a coma.

Originally posted by Nephthys
You say that like it isn't a hundred times as much experience as Ventress has and like Scourge couldn't do that as well.

Having hundreds of times more experience and training as your opponent when you're already a prodigy and possessing massive amounts of actualised power on top of 3 seperate amps is actually a big deal, bro. And yet he was beaten by a Jedi who had what, 2-3 years of combat experience? Right, nah don't think I'm going to buy in to your hyperbole.

And I wonder what's prodigal about struggling to beat droids or getting obliterated by Nyriss. mmm

Lol @ comparing Ventress to the Hero of Tython. Pretty sure the guy who beat Vitiate was a special case, just guessing here.

The droids thing was a very specific problem that he got over and get this, Nyriss was actually just incredibly strong? Scourge was comparable to the Exile who shat her way through Malachor's legions of Sith, Sion and Traya in one sitting.

That guy who beat Vitiate... Along with 3 other people on or above his level, a Vitiate-killing holocron, and only by exploiting the fact that Vitiate was trapped in his mental space, and possibly his kamikaze-daddy issues as well. He did this several years after he fought Scourge, during which he obtained the bulk of his battle experience and a number of sizeable amps... But no, it should be fine to equate Scourge in any way to the Emperor whose cock he sucked for 300 f*cking years.

i was talking about the first time lol

its ok the hero beats vitiate a LOT

Originally posted by Nephthys
Lol @ comparing Ventress to the Hero of Tython. Pretty sure the guy who beat Vitiate was a special case, just guessing here.

The droids thing was a very specific problem that he got over and get this, Nyriss was actually just incredibly strong? Scourge was comparable to the Exile who shat her way through Malachor's legions of Sith, Sion and Traya in one sitting. Ah yes, heaven forbid I compare Ventress to the guy who defeated the mighty Darth Angral and a severely weakened Shitiate. Though regardless you are just guessing. So feel free to prove the HoT is an exception, not the rule, despite Scourge having defeated nobody else in the game. mmm

And sure excuses, I also remember when Scourge compared to Meetra that time never.

Yeah, still running with Ventress, who proved a match for Kenobi & Anakin even in an injured state, and forced Windu to use all his skills to defeat her, before her prime mind you, whereas in DD she's holding off a bloodlusted Vos and driving back Count Dooku.

Originally posted by Azronger
Ventress slaps him into a coma.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Scourge was comparable to the Exile

If by 'comparable' you mean getting outclassed by her twice on a Dark Side Nexus after her sojourn on a three century more potent Nathema than the one that was f*cking with the Outlander, Vaylin and Lana.

Sure.

Scourge

Originally posted by Beniboybling
EVURY1 FROM TOR ERA IS SHIT except 4 Valkorion.

Asajj made Mace Windu use "all his skills" in combat. Mace 10 years prior is better than Ulic who is the only Sith practitioner that can challenge Exar Kun, implying substantial superiority to Novel Vitiate.

So Mace > Asajj ~ Ulic > Novel Vitiate >> Screwrge.

@Geistalt, that guy sounds smart. However, Valkorion is shit too.

Don't even need any of this "new scaling" to award Ventress the decisive win in this one.