Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Sword battle. Which team wins?

The elves

I think Bor could take Legolas the other two would be closer.

Don't know much about Elrond but if he fights anything like Thranduil then the Elves win this solidly.

Didn't Elrond manage to take out 4-5 of the Ringwraiths during the battle of Dol Guldur? But I think that is the only time we actually see him fight.

Yeah but Aragorn fought them off too 4 or 5 of them

bhzzfXQmv9w

Don't compare Aragorn's fight to Elrond and Saruman's. One is clearly higher than the orher, and Elrond could solo imo.

Elves, pretty comfortably.

Elrond had help and Aragorn didn't unless you want to count the Hobbits.

Originally posted by golem370
Elrond had help and Aragorn didn't unless you want to count the Hobbits.

But Aragorn didn't exactly beat the Wraiths, he seemed to just scare them off. Elrond had a better showing against them.

I guess I see what you are saying but I think Aragorn proved to rather be skilled through out the triliogy so I think he would put up a good fight plus I still think that Bor would beat Legolas so it could become two on one. Elrond didn't actually beat them either the came back with Sauron

Elrond was fighting off Sauron when Gandalf coudlnt in the Hobbit movies.

???

Originally posted by Inhuman
Elrond was fighting off Sauron when Gandalf coudlnt in the Hobbit movies.

He never fought him off though, only his minions. Though he did imply that he could or might be able to.. when he said we need to track him down and kill him. Seemingly he believed he could with the help of others.

Elves take this. Boromir is the weakest link here and he's considerably below Legolas and Elrond.

I just watched that scene. Elrond and Saruman were fighting The Nazgul.
Elrond & Saruman beat the fuq out of all the Nazgul in that scene. Both pulling their weight.


bhzzfXQmv9w

Day late and a dollar short as usual IM

Actually im always on point bro

Not in threads involving Cap it seems, eh Bro?

Well for some outlandish reason you seem to think that Cap and Ozy are equals or close to it so your judgment on Cap related opinions is faulty to say the least.

Bor was a very skilled the second only to Aragorn on the team.

Swordsman

Originally posted by golem370
I think Bor could take Legolas the other two would be closer.

I actually agree.

Dunedains win.

Nah. Legolas dispatches opponents easier and faster than Boromir. Plus Legolas has the feat of actually going h2h with Bolg, which makes me believe he's quite stronger than Boromir.

Legolas is a non-factor, my frosty friend.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Legolas is a non-factor, my frosty friend. Prepare for Kt to have a fanboy meltdown.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Legolas is a non-factor, my frosty friend.

And you consider Boromir so much better because??

Few words from Tolkien himself.

Physically, Boromir was the strongest of the Fellowship.

Legolas was the least useful memeber

Boromir was a tad broader than Aragorn as well by Tolkien's descriptions IIRC

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Few words from Tolkien himself.

Physically, Boromir was the strongest of the Fellowship.

Legolas was the least useful memeber

TBF, Legolas is quite a bit better in the films than he was in the books.

That's true.

But still not good enough to best Gimli in the battle of Helm's Deep

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Few words from Tolkien himself.

Physically, Boromir was the strongest of the Fellowship.

Legolas was the least useful memeber

In the books, Boromir was considered the strongest. But this isn't the books. Legolas was strong enough to go h2h with Bolg, which makes him the strongest among the fellowship.

Keep dreaming, Frosty. Keep dreaming.

Well if Boromir is>Legolas and Legolas beat Bolg then Boromir>Bolg too

Originally posted by StealthRanger
Well if Boromir is>Legolas and Legolas beat Bolg then Boromir>Bolg too There is no evidence that Boromir is stronger than Legolas in the films.

Originally posted by Inhuman
Elrond was fighting off Sauron when Gandalf coudlnt in the Hobbit movies. Um, keep in mind none of the SHIT-TASTIC Hobbit movies count in lore terms. I suppose since this is the movie forums, that we have to use the Made-up Jackson bull shit. But in the books none of that shit happened. Gandalf didn't get imprisoned by Sauron and he certainly didn't need Galadrial to save him. ****ing Hobbit movies were a travesty.


That being said if we go strictly by the movies then it's probably the Elves. In the books however the Humans win handily. Boromir would Shit-stomp Legolas and Then Aragorn and Boromir would double team Elrond.