Mary Jane vs Gwen Stacy
Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
HulkIsHulk
If Mary Jane from the Spider-Man trilogy movies and Gwen Stacy from the Amazing Spider-Man movie wearing loose-fitting pants and t-shirt had a fist-fight who would win:
Round 1: They accidentally wreck the others science project and drop paint on each other
Round 2: Both believe the other stole something valuable from their house
Round 3: They have to defeat the other or their Peter dies
Round 4: Both think the other killed their Peter
Arachnid1
Gwen, she could actually take care of herself sometimes. I prefer MJ in comics, but Gwen in the movies was perfect. Emma Stone should have played MJ, they'll never get MJ that perfect now.
HulkIsHulk
Originally posted by Arachnid1
Gwen, she could actually take care of herself sometimes. I prefer MJ in comics, but Gwen in the movies was perfect. Emma Stone should have played MJ, they'll never get MJ that perfect now.
Lol when did she do that? The closest to she did something of a fight is with that spray can and lighter against the lizard and it accomplished jack shit. She was lucky he didn't break her neck then and there. And lol, in the school fight she hit him with a wooden case. Apparently there was no metal around. She was actually far less effective in direct combat than Mary Jane if you look a things more closely
Arachnid1
All of that is still more than I remember Mj ever doing. What did MJ ever do to the super villains? I don't remember her ever putting up a fight unlike Aunt May and her umbrella of justice
Robtard
MJ is hotter so she wins
Arachnid1
Originally posted by Robtard
MJ is hotter so she wins Nowhere as hot as Stone!
http://www.media4.hw-static.com/wp-content/uploads/spider-man-movie-still-kirsten-dunst-as-mary-jane-watson-in-spider-man_1107684-400x305.jpeg
https://i.ytimg.com/vi/do-Hw4hHWII/hqdefault.jpg
You're killin me Rob
Robtard
Even with you taking an average pic of Dunst and one of the more flattering pics of Stone, Dunst > Stone.
This is a scientific fact, bruh
Arachnid1
Originally posted by Robtard
Even with you taking an average pic of Dunst and one of the more flattering pics of Stone, Dunst > Stone.
This is a scientific fact, bruh I took stock pics of both from their respective movies. MJ in highschool was the hottest I've ever seen Dunst in any role. Dunst looked her best in SM1, was plain Jane in SM2 went full troll mode by SM3. If I wanted to take an unflattering picture of Dunst, I would have went with this.
http://bbsimg.ngfiles.com/1/16622000/ngbbs485892a9e77cd.jpg
Kirsten Dunst is ugly af, and this is noticed by many. Emma Stone on the other hand, is heaven incarnate. OMFG @ how perfect she is.
http://www.apnatimepass.com/emma-stone-hot-photos-6.jpg
vs
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-EvtAQAv52_Y/TfbqfLghxdI/AAAAAAAAFaI/oXIsPo4F99I/s1600/turktv_kirstendunst.jpg
Even Dunst being half naked in that pic doesn't save her. bored
There's even a thread about her ugliness on these forums. The majority voted her to be average or below as apposed to "cute I guess" or hot.
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=301684
Robtard
Keep arguing against scientific facts
https://i.warosu.org/data/sci/img/0070/46/1422988934432.jpg
Mind you, she can look good. But Dunst is better.
Arachnid1
Come at me brah!
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-BLOOsBUfr98/TkEVZVPEVbI/AAAAAAAAAgU/YM1YusT-oBA/s400/kirsten-dunst-without-makeup-04.jpg
Dunst can barely look passable. Stone looks good even in the unflattering picture you found. You'll have to do better than that!
BruceSkywalker
neither wins... dunst is a crack whore and stone is a horse face
Robtard
Originally posted by Arachnid1
Come at me brah!
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-BLOOsBUfr98/TkEVZVPEVbI/AAAAAAAAAgU/YM1YusT-oBA/s400/kirsten-dunst-without-makeup-04.jpg
Dunst can barely look passable. Stone looks good even in the unflattering picture you found. You'll have to do better than that!
Stone does not look good in that pic, she looks like the ill begotten offspring of Donald Trump and an orangutan, making her 3/4th orangutan.
But I'd rather not, as I said, Stone can look good and I don't think she's necessarily an ugly woman.
KingD19
Back to the topic, Gwen actually showed she could handle herself. And her dad was a cop, so I'm assuming on top of being a tough chick, daddy Stacy taught her some basic hand to hand, maybe some firearm training.
MJ does nothing. Literally nothing in the films but be a damsel in distress. At least Gwen tried to fight against an unstoppable monster. She's got more balls than MJ does.
HulkIsHulk
Here's an ugly emma pic
http://s32.postimg.org/g55l5jba9/0_Gkc_Gnkd3_Wzn.jpg
HulkIsHulk
Originally posted by Arachnid1
All of that is still more than I remember Mj ever doing. What did MJ ever do to the super villains? I don't remember her ever putting up a fight unlike Aunt May and her umbrella of justice
The movies must have been a pretty bad experience for you then.
Here's MJ smacking away one thug with her handbag before kicking the next one in the family jewels:
http://i.imgur.com/Mv0zNoo.gif
Here she tries to do the same thing to Ock as Aunt May but he's prepared for it this time. Decent durability feat for MJ as well:
http://i.imgur.com/KiMrC4T.gif
Here MJ dodges several cinder blocks falling towards her. And they weren't falling that slow either, as shown by them wrecking the car parts they hit:
http://i.imgur.com/u9gSqNj.gif
She then uses one cinder block as a weapon against Venom:
http://i.imgur.com/8TK4TTT.gif
Here she jumps out of the way of a truck falling at her from above
http://i.imgur.com/eO73ICj.gif
Here she takes a hit from a pissed off Peter when she tries to interfere in his fight with her club bouncers. Just before that Pete was oneshotting the bouncers left and right so he wasn't holding back that much either:
http://i.imgur.com/eO73ICj.gif
Gwen was only useful against the villains due her scientific skills. She did not become a damsel in distress because the villains specifically chose not to or did not know about her
The Lizard had her trapped, cornered and he was completely unaffected by her makeshift flamethrower using a spray can and a lighter. He could've killed her then and there but he chose not to and simply took away the chemical which he needed from her
Electro didn't know about her because Pete webbed her to a car and she arrived when the fight was in full bore. Even when she ran him over with the car he still chose to focus on Spider man instead of going after her even when she was in clear sight
When someone finally did, you know what happened. I would agree if someone said Gwen has more balls than MJ, but better feats? Nope, not at all
HulkIsHulk
On hotness, Stone has the better face while Dunst has the better bod. Don't really care about both btw tbh
KingD19
Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
The movies must have been a pretty bad experience for you then.
Here's MJ smacking away one thug with her handbag before kicking the next one in the family jewels:
http://i.imgur.com/Mv0zNoo.gif
Here she tries to do the same thing to Ock as Aunt May but he's prepared for it this time. Decent durability feat for MJ as well:
http://i.imgur.com/KiMrC4T.gif
Here MJ dodges several cinder blocks falling towards her. And they weren't falling that slow either, as shown by them wrecking the car parts they hit:
http://i.imgur.com/u9gSqNj.gif
She then uses one cinder block as a weapon against Venom:
http://i.imgur.com/8TK4TTT.gif
Here she jumps out of the way of a truck falling at her from above
http://i.imgur.com/eO73ICj.gif
Here she takes a hit from a pissed off Peter when she tries to interfere in his fight with her club bouncers. Just before that Pete was oneshotting the bouncers left and right so he wasn't holding back that much either:
http://i.imgur.com/eO73ICj.gif
Gwen was only useful against the villains due her scientific skills. She did not become a damsel in distress because the villains specifically chose not to or did not know about her
The Lizard had her trapped, cornered and he was completely unaffected by her makeshift flamethrower using a spray can and a lighter. He could've killed her then and there but he chose not to and simply took away the chemical which he needed from her
Electro didn't know about her because Pete webbed her to a car and she arrived when the fight was in full bore. Even when she ran him over with the car he still chose to focus on Spider man instead of going after her even when she was in clear sight
When someone finally did, you know what happened. I would agree if someone said Gwen has more balls than MJ, but better feats? Nope, not at all
So MJ being ineffective against villains who could instantly end her life more times than Gwen makes her better? Doc Ock wasn't trying to hurt people. Eddie had a crush on MJ and needed her as a bargaining chip, etc... What do you think would have happened if Ock or Venom really wanted her dead? At least Gwen helped with her intelligence.
StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
On hotness, Stone has the better face while Dunst has the better bod. Don't really care about both btw tbh
This is correct.
Dunst has better boobs, as seen in Melancholia.
tkitna
Mary Jane wins
https://hardtickettohomevideo.files.wordpress.com/2013/05/spider-man.jpg
FrothByte
MJ in SM1 is hotter than Gwen in any ASM movie. That said, Gwen is hotter than MJ in SM3
HulkIsHulk
Another ugly Emma stone pic:
http://s32.postimg.org/w43mzqx29/146235003970217_7278998536.jpg
And another
http://www.worstpreviews.com/images/headlines/headline17859.jpg
And another:
http://s32.postimg.org/4nn21siox/step0002_jpg_1462350106776.jpg
HulkIsHulk
And another:
http://s32.postimg.org/ugwlwjp29/146235003970217_4073464363.jpg
And another:
http://s32.postimg.org/tipiwtfhd/146235003970217_9684277704.jpg
and another:
http://s32.postimg.org/tmowh3kpt/146235003970217_2676836350.jpg
And lol - this edited image gets me every time:
http://s32.postimg.org/ydzr8kbkx/146235003970217_3708313964.jpg

And the thing is only the eyes and mouth are edited there

HulkIsHulk
Originally posted by Arachnid1
Even Dunst being half naked in that pic doesn't save her. bored
threadid=301684
You know the same could be said of this pic of emma
https://i1.sndcdn.com/artworks-000096983133-gml96o-t500x500.jpg
You can't just pick and choose. Either both are attractive or not

HulkIsHulk
Originally posted by tkitna
Mary Jane wins
https://hardtickettohomevideo.files.wordpress.com/2013/05/spider-man.jpg
I've always wondered was Dunst too poor to buy a bra in the 1st and 2nd movies? 'Cause it looked like she never had one on
HulkIsHulk
Originally posted by KingD19
So MJ being ineffective against villains who could instantly end her life more times than Gwen makes her better?
No one said MJ is better or not. I only said she has better feats when it pertains to physical combat. Not to mention you were criticizing her for being a damsel in distress and praising Gwen for not being so. MJ would've been dead several times over in SM3 if not for her own abilities, whether others were trying to kill her or not. Like here. If she had not ducked in time she would've been finished:
http://i.imgur.com/2U1HIxo.gif
Originally posted by KingD19
What do you think would have happened if Ock or Venom really wanted her dead?
As for that - the same as Gwen would've been if Lizard or Electro wanted her dead - deader than dead. Also both Gobby and Venom did want MJ to die. Just not anywhere, they wanted to kill her in front of Pete. Then again, just asking you - what could've Gwen done when Ock, Goblin or Venom attacked her when she was alone and had her by the throat? Other than screaming or crying out insults?
Originally posted by KingD19
At least Gwen helped with her intelligence.
Yes she did. No one said she didn't. But you are the one extrapolating it into being taking care of her self physically based only on personal preference when Gwen has shown no direct combat feats at all. I went back and watched both ASM movies and she never got into a fight ever. She hit someone once and ran away. And I already said Gwen's braver than MJ
but according to you MJ did absolutely nothing in the trilogy, like here while Gwen at least tried Wow.
Originally posted by KingD19
MJ does nothing. Literally nothing in the films but be a damsel in distress. At least Gwen tried to fight against an unstoppable monster.
And posts like these are what I call a load of bullcrap
HulkIsHulk
Its bloody clear that you hated MJ in the original trilogy. I could care less, but don't post such nonsense just to lowball
StiltmanFTW
Not a fan of either, but Dunst at least has a pair of nice boobs to grab while ****ing from behind.
tkitna
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Not a fan of either, but Dunst at least has a pair of nice boobs to grab while ****ing from behind.
Exactly. Its pretty clear cut to me.
cdtm
Gwen Stacy dies.
That's like her superpower. Dying.
BruceSkywalker
Originally posted by cdtm
Gwen Stacy dies.
That's like her superpower. Dying.
don't say that because Zendaya is playing mj or gwen hahaha
HulkIsHulk
Lol at this pic
http://s32.postimg.org/rgm85zgox/vlcsnap_2016_05_08_18h54m22s231.jpg
John Murdoch
Mary Jane via superhuman durability: in SM3, Symbiote Emo Peter backhanded her. She fell down and reacted like a woman being hit by her boyfriend for the first time rather than having her skull caved in, her neck snapped, and dying immediately. Gwen ain't hurting her without weaponry.
Darth Thor
This thread only proves the miracles Hollywood make up artists can achieve.
Surtur
Gwen has a phatter ass than Mary Jane, she wins everything because of that.
HulkIsHulk
Originally posted by Surtur
Gwen has a phatter ass than Mary Jane, she wins everything because of that.
Guess you hate tatas.
HulkIsHulk
Lol this thread was a riot
riv6672
Bryce Dallas Howard as Gwen Stacy for the ROWR.
https://i.ibb.co/d58dZ3K/D14-FD120-A846-4-A75-837-A-0-D39-B0-AD9311.jpg
HulkIsHulk
Yeah that was BDH's prettiest role I've seen
StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by riv6672
Bryce Dallas Howard as Gwen Stacy for the ROWR.
https://i.ibb.co/d58dZ3K/D14-FD120-A846-4-A75-837-A-0-D39-B0-AD9311.jpg
Easily the best.
Zendaya is really hot, but not so much in MCU.
HulkIsHulk
I just googled Zendaya and damn, Stilt is right.
Also she is not looking sexy in MCU is interntional, she's a high schooler in it, so she can't be sexualized plus its in character for her to dress frumpy anyway
riv6672
Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
I just googled Zendaya and damn, Stilt is right.
Also she is not looking sexy in MCU is interntional, she's a high schooler in it, so she can't be sexualized plus its in character for her to dress frumpy anyway
I know the why, but I still want the wow!

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
Copyright 1999-2025 KillerMovies.