Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11119/111190794/5018539-2141976841-47782.jpg

No prep.
No BFR.
Standard (unamped) versions.

http://sciencefiction.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/DrFate.jpg

Fate.

Okay Fate's right hand is turned in a really awkward position.

new 52 fate? he gets raped

Nothing really useable, but thanks for the replies.

Gotta go with Fate. Way more versatile and willing to lay the WHOMP down over the Normally Pacifist Surfer. Unless Surf's "supposed" Super Speed can be factored in.

Whoever gets in the first clean hit, but generally magic beats cosmic.

Kent Nelson fate wins easily. Can do everything Surfer can and LOT LOT more

Straus fate I would say looses in a close fight. No where near the versatility and lacking in experience.

Inza might make a split, purely due to her creativity in teh use of her power.

Hector Should take the win comfortably. He gained enough experience to eventually handle characters above Norrin's paygrade. On averaged feats it's closer.

Kent V goes down hard. He only has like 4 feats anywhere near Norrin.

Nu52 fate get's stomped as Ghostman said. He's a paper lantern who's been stomped by much less.

Now those answers i can work with. Thanks, guys.

Surfer crushes him.

Originally posted by Stoic
Whoever gets in the first clean hit, but generally magic beats cosmic.

Since when?

I'll leave that discussion up to you guys, hopefully, as i've never seen a clear advantage for either.

Magic/cosmic power, at it's highest levels it's all the same.

Thats very Mr. Miyagi of you.

Originally posted by beatboks
Kent Nelson fate wins easily. Can do everything Surfer can and LOT LOT more

Straus fate I would say looses in a close fight. No where near the versatility and lacking in experience.

Inza might make a split, purely due to her creativity in teh use of her power.

Hector Should take the win comfortably. He gained enough experience to eventually handle characters above Norrin's paygrade. On averaged feats it's closer.

Kent V goes down hard. He only has like 4 feats anywhere near Norrin.

Nu52 fate get's stomped as Ghostman said. He's a paper lantern who's been stomped by much less.

The two big ones, Kent and Hector would win with no problem. In September, two Fates (Kent and the newbie) will take on God of Death, Osiris. Also, Nelson will be appearing in Blue Beetle. Glad Kent Nelson is back.

http://i65.tinypic.com/25rfedi.jpg

Which Blue Beetle?

Originally posted by Blue Area Vet
Since when?

http://static1.comicvine.com/uploads/original/10/108342/5201848-screen+shot+2016-05-04+at+5.25.06+pm.png
Surfer can't undo Magik's magic with his power cosmic

http://static7.comicvine.com/uploads/original/10/108342/3256195-3255117-1443860413-24973.jpg
Her demons use the power cosmic

http://static4.comicvine.com/uploads/original/10/108342/5166109-screen+shot+2016-04-22+at+5.45.07+pm.png
Her magic turns PF rachel into a puppet. Rachel only turns back after Nightcrawler burns a book of spells.

So its not magic, but Magik.

Originally posted by riv6672
So its not magic, but Magik.

Yup. Its magik. But if magik and demon pets are capable of doing those things i dont see why fate cant replicate these showings. Im not saying that any two bit mage can beat the surfers power cosmic

Yeah, Fate at his peak is Strange level, maybe higher due to the fact that he had enhanced stats like durability, strength, and speed. Near pre-crisis levels.

Originally posted by nwg202
Yup. Its magik. But if magik and demon pets are capable of doing those things i dont see why fate cant replicate these showings. Im not saying that any two bit mage can beat the surfers power cosmic
That sounded like what you were saying.
In any case, i'm not applying one character's feats to all characters with similar powers across the board, and thats just me.

I think fate might take it 6/10 considering that ss is no pushover and he weilds the power cosmic

^^^Fair enough.

Originally posted by ChukzZ
I think fate might take it 6/10 considering that ss is no pushover and he weilds the power cosmic

You REALLY think that Fate beats Surfer one on one?

Its hardly inconceivable. Magicians are notoriously hard to pin down.